Taylor v Southern Queensland Parole Board

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Taylor v Southern Queensland Parole Board [2016] QSC 26

PARTIES:

DARREN RODNEY TAYLOR

(applicant)

v
SOUTHERN QUEENSLAND REGIONAL PAROLE BOARD

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Brisbane No BS10447 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Applicant for Statutory Order of Review

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 February 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 February 2016

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1. The application for a statutory order of review filed 19 October 2015 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GENERALLY – where applicant convicted of sexual offences against children – where applicant sought parole pursuant to Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) – where application for parole refused – where applicant seeks judicial review of decision of parole board.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – ERROR OF LAW – where applicant refused parole – where at time of sentencing parole eligibility date set by trial judge – where applicant submits that there was no new information before the parole board – whether operation of s192 of Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) means that parole board is not bound by the parole eligibility date set by trial judge.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – RELEVANT CONSIDERATION – where at time of sentencing parole eligibility date set by trial judge – where applicant submits that parole eligibility date is a relevant consideration – whether parole board failed to have regard to relevant consideration.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – FETTERING DISCRETION – where parole board required psychological assessment for the purposes of determination – where applicant refused psychological assessment – whether parole board fettered its discretion by applying a rule or policy without having regard to the merits of the case.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – UNREASONABLENESS – where applicant submits that parole board decision to refuse application was unreasonable – whether parole board’s decision to refuse application was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could make such a decision.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS – GENERALLY – where applicant submits that there was a breach of natural justice – where applicant refused to provide consent to release medical forms to psychologist – where parole board indicated it would defer determination of application until psychological assessment undertaken – whether parole board failed to afford applicant procedural fairness.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – IRRELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS – where applicant had been previously been convicted of two counts of serious assault – where parole board decision makes reference to previous convictions for serious assault – where guidelines require parole board to have regard to relevant factors – where guidelines specify prior criminal history as relevant factor – whether the parole board had regard to irrelevant considerations.

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – BAD…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taylor v Southern Queensland Parole Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Taylor v Southern Queensland Parole Board involved the applicant, who was serving a sentence for sexual offences against children, challenging the decision of the Southern Queensland Regional Parole Board to refuse his parole application. The applicant sought judicial review of the decision made on 10 June 2015, under s 20 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld). The applicant argued that the parole board had made several errors in deciding to refuse his parole application, including failing to consider relevant information, applying a policy or rule without regard to the merits of his case, making an unreasonable decision, breaching natural justice, considering irrelevant factors, and acting in bad faith.

The legal issues the court needed to decide were whether the parole board had failed to take into account a relevant consideration, whether it had fettered its discretion, whether its decision was unreasonable, whether it had breached natural justice, whether it had taken into account irrelevant considerations, and whether it had exercised its discretion in bad faith. The court examined the operation of s 192 of the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld), which states that the parole board is not bound by the parole eligibility date set by the court if it receives new information about the applicant and considers that the applicant is not suitable for parole at the time fixed by the court.

The court found that the parole board had not erred in law by failing to take into account a relevant consideration or by fettering its discretion. It also found that the decision to refuse the parole application was not unreasonable, that there was no breach of natural justice, that the parole board had not taken into account irrelevant considerations, and that it had not exercised its discretion in bad faith. The court dismissed the application for a statutory order of review and directed the parties to discuss the costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for a statutory order of review filed 19 October 2015 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant seeks judicial review of the decision of the Southern Queensland Regional Parole Board made 10 June 2015 refusing the applicant’s parole application. The application for review is brought pursuant to s 20 of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld) (JR Act). For reasons which follow, the application for statutory order of review should be dismissed. Background The applicant is serving seven years imprisonment for a number of offences. On 14 November 2012 in the District Court he was sentenced to six years imprisonment for each of three rape offences concerning a child of approximately four years of age. He also received a sentence of four years imprisonment for indecent treatment of the child. Those sentences were ordered to be served concurrently. He was also sentenced to imprisonment for one year for the possession of child exploitation material. That sentence was ordered to be served cumulatively on the six year term, making a total of seven years imprisonment. The sentencing Judge ordered that the applicant be eligible for release on parole after serving two and a half years. Her Honour observed:“As I say, that will be dependent upon you completing appropriate rehabilitative programs and it will be up to the parole authorities. On my calculation that brings the date for eligibility to apply for parole to 11th of May 2015.”[1][1] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-29, p.86 (CD8). In sentencing the applicant her Honour accepted that the applicant suffers from paedophilia. Her Honour further noted:“… clearly it is important for both you and the community that whilst you are in custody appropriate programs and counselling are offered to you, and you are unlikely to receive parole until you have completed those sorts of programs. So I do urge you to take them seriously and to embrace whatever is offered to you in that regard.”[2][2] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-29, p.85. On 12 November 2014 the applicant applied for a parole order.[3] Ms Balzer, a Senior Advisor of the Parole Board Secretariat, who affirmed an affidavit in these proceedings, has exhibited the applicant’s application for a parole order. In paragraph 6 of her affidavit, affirmed 3 December 2016, Ms Balzer implicitly asserts that a document entitled “Getting Started: Preparatory Program (GSPP) Completion Report” constitutes part of the parole application. The applicant, in his written submissions,[4] states that the Completion Report post-dates the parole application by 40 days. The applicant therefore submits that the Completion Report was not lodged by him as part of his parole application. The Board accepts that the Completion Report was not lodged as part of the application for parole.[5] Both parties accept that the Completion Report was a document that was before the Board for the purposes of it determining the parole application. The Completion Report notes that during the applicant’s participation in this course he maintained a stance of categorical denial in relation to the offences.[6] The Completion Report states the following recommendation:“Based on his current stance of categorical denial in relation to the current offences, it is considered that prisoner Taylor is not suitable for participation in future treatment programs. He is recommended to contact Program Delivery Officers should his stance change in the future.”[7][3] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-1, p.1.[4] Applicant’s Outline of Argument, [3].[5] The Board undertook to file an affidavit correcting this factual error: T1-13 to T1-15.[6] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-1, p.18 (CD8).[7] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-1, p.19.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Sections 193(1) and (5) of the CS Act provide:“193 Decision of parole board(1) A parole board required to consider a prisoner’s application for a parole order must decide—(a) to grant the application; or(b) to refuse to grant the application.…(5) If the parole board refuses to grant the application, the board must—(a) give the prisoner written reasons for the refusal; and(b)if the application is for a parole order other than an exceptional circumstances parole order—decide a period of time, of not more than 6 months after the refusal, within which a further application for a parole order (other than an exceptional circumstances parole order) by the prisoner must not be made without the board’s consent.” Section 227(1) provides:227 GuidelinesThe Minister may make guidelines about the policy to be followed by the Queensland board when performing its function.” The Queensland Parole Board Guidelines to the Queensland Regional Parole Board (Guidelines) state:[22][22] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-22, pp.52-60.“1.2 When considering whether a prisoner should be granted a parole order, the highest priority for the Regional Parole Board (‘the Regional Board’) should always be the safety of the community.…2.1 When deciding the level of risk that a prisoner may pose to the community, the Regional Board should have regard to all relevant factors, including, but not limited to:(a)the prisoner’s prior criminal history and any patterns of offending;(b)the likelihood of the prisoner committing further offences;…(e)the recommendation for parole, parole eligibility date, or any recommendation or comments of the sentencing court;…(k)recommended rehabilitation programs or interventions, and the prisoner’s progress in addressing the recommendations.”Ground 1: the Board failed to take into account a relevant consideration In his application for a statutory order of review the applicant identifies this ground as constituting an error of law relying on section 20(2)(f) of the JR Act. In paragraph 3 of his affidavit sworn in support of the application, the applicant also relies on sections 20(2)(e) and 23(d) alleging that the Board failed to take into account a relevant consideration, namely the “recommendation of the sentencing court in setting an eligibility date”. In paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of his outline of argument the applicant sought to expand this ground to include a submission that the Board failed to take into account the operation of section 192 of the CS Act. I have quoted section 192 above. The effect of section 192 is that when deciding whether to grant a parole order the Board is not bound by the parole eligibility date fixed by the court if the Board receives information about the applicant that was not before the court at the time of sentencing and after considering the information considers that the applicant is not suitable for parole at the time fixed by the court. The applicant submits that there was no information before the Board that was not otherwise before the sentencing judge. Irrespective of how this ground is articulated, it has no substance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Queensland Parole Board Guidelines to the Queensland Regional Parole Board (Guidelines) state:[22][22] Affidavit of Angela Balzer filed 3 December 2015, AB-22, pp.52-60.“1.2 When considering whether a prisoner should be granted a parole order, the highest priority for the Regional Parole Board (‘the Regional Board’) should always be the safety of the community.…2.1 When deciding the level of risk that a prisoner may pose to the community, the Regional Board should have regard to all relevant factors, including, but not limited to:(a)the prisoner’s prior criminal history and any patterns of offending;(b)the likelihood of the prisoner committing further offences;…(e)the recommendation for parole, parole eligibility date, or any recommendation or comments of the sentencing court;…(k)recommended rehabilitation programs or interventions, and the prisoner’s progress in addressing the recommendations.”Ground 1: the Board failed to take into account a relevant consideration In his application for a statutory order of review the applicant identifies this ground as constituting an error of law relying on section 20(2)(f) of the JR Act. In paragraph 3 of his affidavit sworn in support of the application, the applicant also relies on sections 20(2)(e) and 23(d) alleging that the Board failed to take into account a relevant consideration, namely the “recommendation of the sentencing court in setting an eligibility date”. In paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of his outline of argument the applicant sought to expand this ground to include a submission that the Board failed to take into account the operation of section 192 of the CS Act. I have quoted section 192 above. The effect of section 192 is that when deciding whether to grant a parole order the Board is not bound by the parole eligibility date fixed by the court if the Board receives information about the applicant that was not before the court at the time of sentencing and after considering the information considers that the applicant is not suitable for parole at the time fixed by the court. The applicant submits that there was no information before the Board that was not otherwise before the sentencing judge. Irrespective of how this ground is articulated, it has no substance. The Statement of Reasons lists all the material that was before the Board and considered by the Board. The parole eligibility date is not expressly referred to in the Statement of Reasons. The material before the Board and considered by the Board, however, includes a number of documents which specifically refer to the applicant’s parole eligibility date of 11 May 2015 such as the sentencing remarks dated 14 November 2012, the Parole Board Report dated 23 December 2014 and the Verdict and Judgment Record dated 14 November 2012. The sentencing judge made it clear that the applicant was unlikely to receive parole until he had completed appropriate programs whilst in custody. The Board, in its Statement of Reasons, identified that the applicant’s “innocence stances” in the Getting Started program had precluded him from completing any further sexual offending assessment and/or programs. This shows that the sentencing remarks were not only before the Board but were considered by the Board in determining whether the parole application should be granted. The sentencing remarks included the parole eligibility date set by the sentencing judge.