Tarwala v Amirbeaggi as trustee for bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tarwala v Amirbeaggi as trustee for bankruptcy [2022] FCA 1593

File number: VID 590 of 2021
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2022
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY - application for annulment of bankruptcy under s 153B of Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) - relevant principles for annulment of a bankruptcy arising from a debtor’s petition – where the evidence does not show that the debtor’s petition ought not to have been presented or ought not to have been accepted – where the evidence does not show that the debtor was solvent at the time of lodging the petition, nor at the time of hearing -where there is no proposal by the debtor to meet her debt to a substantial creditor nor to discharge the costs of the administration of the debtor’s estate – annulment not in the public interest or the interest of the creditor – application refused.
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 5, 55, 153B

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 95A

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2015 r 63.56

Cases cited:

Bank of Australasia v Hall (1907) 4 CLR 1514

Big River Group Pty Ltd v Visnic [2010] FMCA 276

Boles v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2001) 183 ALR 239

Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 18

Hall v Poolman [2007] NSWSC 1330; 65 ACSR 123

Keith Smith East West Transport Pty Ltd (in liq) v Australian Taxation Office [2002] NSWCA 264; 42 ACSR 501

Kitay, in the matter of Frigger (No 2) [2018] FCA 1032

Lewis v Doran (2004) 184 FLR 454

Lewis v Doran (2005) 219 ALR 555

New Cap Reinsurance Corp Ltd (in liq) v Westpac Banking Corp (No 9) [2008] NSWSC 1015; 68 ACSR 176

Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1200; 87 FCR 371

Ramsay Health Care Australia Pty Ltd v Compton (2017) 261 CLR 132

Re Abbas [1995] FCA 337; 57 FCR 140

Re Almassy [1999] FCA 1004; 92 FCR 597

Re Coote (1993) 47 FCR 522

ReCoyle, A.G. & Anor [1993] FCA 244; 42 FCR 72

Re Cube Footwear Pty Ltd [2013] 2 QSC 398; 2 Qd R 501

Re Newark Pty Ltd (in liq) [1993] 1 Qd R 409; 6 ACSR 255

Re Papps; Ex parte Tapp (1997) 78 FCR 524

Re Whittall(unreported, Federal Court of Australia, Kiefel J, QG 7598 of 1997, 7 August 1998)

Registrar of Titles (WA) v Franzon (1975) 132 CLR 611

Sayer-Jones v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2022] FCA 1199

Southern Cross Interiors Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2001] NSWSC 621; 53 NSWLR 213

Thredgold v Fyfe Pty Ltd [2013 FCA 1363

Williams (in liq) v Scholz [2008] QCA 094

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 85
Date of hearing: 26 April 2022
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant was self-represented
Counsel…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tarwala v Amirbeaggi as trustee for bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1593
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Tarwala sought to annul her bankruptcy under section 153B of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The Trustee for bankruptcy, Amirbeaggi, opposed the application. The primary issue before the court was whether the application for annulment met the criteria set out in the relevant provisions of the Act. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the evidence demonstrated that the debtor's petition should not have been presented or accepted, and whether the debtor was solvent at the relevant times. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether it was in the public interest or the interest of creditors to annul the bankruptcy.

The court examined the evidence presented and concluded that Ms Tarwala's petition should not be annulled. Firstly, the court found that the evidence did not show that the petition ought not to have been presented or accepted. The court also found that Ms Tarwala was not solvent at the time of lodging the petition or at the time of the hearing. Furthermore, there was no proposal by Ms Tarwala to meet her debt to a substantial creditor or to discharge the costs of the administration of her estate. The court held that annulment was not in the public interest or the interest of the creditor, and therefore, the application for annulment was refused.

In light of the above findings, the court dismissed the application for annulment. The court emphasised that the decision was based on the specific circumstances of the case, and the absence of evidence supporting the grounds for annulment. The court's decision underscored the importance of the principles governing the annulment of bankruptcy, and the need for applicants to demonstrate the appropriate criteria to justify such a relief.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for annulment be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Trustee relied on the affidavit of Shabnam Amirbeaggi affirmed 25 March 2022. Ms Amirbeaggi was not cross-examined. THE FACTS The presentation and acceptance of the debtor's petition The Bankruptcy Form was accepted by the Official Receiver on 9 September 2021. The evidence does not disclose the date upon which Ms Tarwala lodged that form. Given that Ms Tarwala completed and lodged the Bankruptcy Form online, I infer that she lodged the form that day. A few days after she lodged the Bankruptcy Form Ms Tarwala indicated to the Official Receiver that wished to withdraw it. On 14 October 2021, she filed the application to annul her bankruptcy.The reason(s) Ms Tarwala presented the debtor’s petition In March 2017, Ms Tarwala commenced a proceeding in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria against her brother and sister-in-law, John and Elizabeth Keating, seeking damages in detinue and conversion for taking into possession and selling her motor vehicle. On 18 July 2018, Ms Tarwala lost that case on the basis that it was time barred, and was ordered to pay Mr and Mrs Keating’s costs of the proceeding in the amount of $44,000. Ms Tarwala was legally represented in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding by a solicitor, Mr James McConvill. One would hope that she was advised against commencing the proceeding if the claim was plainly statute barred, however there is no information as to that. On 21 August 2018, Ms Tarwala filed an appeal against the Magistrates’ Court judgment in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. Again, if the claim was plainly statute barred, one would hope that she was advised against commencing an appeal, but there is no information as to that. On 3 July 2019, the solicitors for Mr and Mrs Keating, Patten Robins Lawyers, filed a summons seeking summary judgment of the appeal on the basis that it had no real prospect of success. On 22 November 2019, the Supreme Court granted summary judgment against Ms Tarwala and ordered her to pay the costs of the appeal on a party-party basis, to be taxed if not agreed. In answer to Question (Q)34 in the Bankruptcy Form Ms Tarwala said that she was indebted to Mr and Mrs Keating in the sum of $55,000 for their legal costs arising from the unsuccessful appeal. She said the following (at Q56):Following my unsuccessful claim in the Magistrates Court, Melbourne, for replacement value of my car when my brother took possession of it, I appealed this Decision in the Court of Appeal with legal representation. John Keating took separate action in the same court to have my Appeal dismissed, which it was. Under duress, I agreed to pay $50,000 but knew I had no way of satisfying this demand.In other evidence Ms Tarwala said that the $50,000 debt had “crept up” to $55,000 “without explanation.” She described the cause or causes of her bankruptcy as “legal action”, and said (at Q18) that “[t]he cause(s) of her insolvency” were: Erosion of my financial assets through legal action I took in 2017 and lost, and action taken against me by the same party, family members, in 2019. Excessive costs claimed by the other side and undue pressure from other side to make a commitment I could not meet in December 2020, plus my own legal expenses. Further, financial support of my daughter who has had cancer and now suffers from chronic illness, and her daughter (age 15).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A preponderance of assets over liabilities may not be material to the question of a person’s solvency. While a person’s balance-sheet position may be a useful indicator of solvency, the balance sheet test is only useful as a “rule of thumb”: Quick v Stoland Pty Ltd [1998] FCA 1200; 87 FCR 371 at 380.THE EVIDENCE In support of her application, Ms Tarwala relied on affidavits sworn 4 October 2021, 4 November 2021, 2 March 2022, 22 March 2022 and 6 April 2022, with numerous annexures (the first, second, third, fourth and fifth Tarwala affidavits). The Trustee objected to the admissibility of various parts of the fourth and fifth Tarwala affidavits and their annexures. I accept that some parts of those affidavits are objectionable, including because they are hearsay, have little relevance to the application or are in reality submissions. But having regard to the fact that Ms Tarwala is self-represented, and does not understand the rules of evidence, I took the view that the course most consistent with the overarching obligation under s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) was to rule on the most egregious examples and otherwise allow the evidence, subject to weight. Ms Tarwala was not cross-examined. The Trustee relied on the affidavit of Shabnam Amirbeaggi affirmed 25 March 2022. Ms Amirbeaggi was not cross-examined. THE FACTS The presentation and acceptance of the debtor's petition The Bankruptcy Form was accepted by the Official Receiver on 9 September 2021. The evidence does not disclose the date upon which Ms Tarwala lodged that form. Given that Ms Tarwala completed and lodged the Bankruptcy Form online, I infer that she lodged the form that day. A few days after she lodged the Bankruptcy Form Ms Tarwala indicated to the Official Receiver that wished to withdraw it. On 14 October 2021, she filed the application to annul her bankruptcy.The reason(s) Ms Tarwala presented the debtor’s petition In March 2017, Ms Tarwala commenced a proceeding in the Magistrates’ Court of Victoria against her brother and sister-in-law, John and Elizabeth Keating, seeking damages in detinue and conversion for taking into possession and selling her motor vehicle. On 18 July 2018, Ms Tarwala lost that case on the basis that it was time barred, and was ordered to pay Mr and Mrs Keating’s costs of the proceeding in the amount of $44,000. Ms Tarwala was legally represented in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding by a solicitor, Mr James McConvill. One would hope that she was advised against commencing the proceeding if the claim was plainly statute barred, however there is no information as to that. On 21 August 2018, Ms Tarwala filed an appeal against the Magistrates’ Court judgment in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. Again, if the claim was plainly statute barred, one would hope that she was advised against commencing an appeal, but there is no information as to that. On 3 July 2019, the solicitors for Mr and Mrs Keating, Patten Robins Lawyers, filed a summons seeking summary judgment of the appeal on the basis that it had no real prospect of success. On 22 November 2019, the Supreme Court granted summary judgment against Ms Tarwala and ordered her to pay the costs of the appeal on a party-party basis, to be taxed if not agreed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.