Tapping v Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tapping v Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary Trust [2021] FCCA 1335

File number(s): MLG 2577 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE BLAKE
Date of judgment: 21 June 2021
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work Act 2009 – breach of general protections – applicant’s sudden diagnosis of breast cancer in 2019 – applicant seeking to exercise workplace rights – whether applicant’s dismissal was unlawful because she proposed to take leave – dismissal unlawful

Alleged failure of respondents to pay accrued annual leave and to give notice of termination – no annual leave owed – failure to provide notice of termination or payment in lieu found

Alleged failure to provide copy of an award and NES – whether the provision of a computer or internet connection sufficient to discharge obligation to provide copy of award – mere provision of computer and internet connection not sufficient

Accessorial liability – second respondent found to be an accessory because he had power to dismiss employee and was directly involved in the dismissal – section respondent not an accessory in respect of other contraventions

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44(1), 45(1), 90(2), 117(2), 340(1), 340(1)(a)(ii). 340(1)(a)(iii), 351(1), 352, 536(1), 361, 550(2),

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.02(1)(d), 16.02(2)(d)

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) rr 1.05(2)

General Retail Industry Award 2010 (Cth) cl 5, 16.1, 22.2, 23.4, 29.9, 32.3

Cases cited:

Banque Commerciale S.A v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

Batten v CTMS [1999] FCA 1576

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

EZY Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2018] FCAFC 134

King v R (1986) 161 CLR 423

Takemoto v Moody’s Investors Service Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 407

Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315

Young Investments Group Pty Ltd v Mann (2012) 293 ALR 537

Number of paragraphs: 147
Date of hearing: 24, 25 and 26 February 2021
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Lake of Counsel
Solicitor for the Applicant: McDonald Murholme Solicitors
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Howard of Counsel
Solicitor for the Respondents: Arnold Bloch Leibler

ORDERS

MLG 2577 of 2019
BETWEEN:

ELIZABETH TAPPING

Applicant

AND:

EMPRESS DIAMONDS PTY LTD (ACN 096 460 730) ATF EMPRESS DISCRETIONARY TRUST

First Respondent

GABI YITSHAKI
Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BLAKE

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JUNE 2021

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The First Respondent contravened:

(a)Section 340(1)(a)(iii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (‘Act’) by dismissing the Applicant from employment for the reason that the Applicant proposed to exercise her workplace rights to take annual and personal leave;

(b)Section 44(1) and 117(2) of the Act by failing to provide the Applicant with four weeks written notice of termination, or payment in lieu of notice of termination;

(c)Section 536(1) of the Act by failing to give the Applicant a payslip within one working day of paying an amount to the Applicant in relation to the performance of work;

(d)Section 45(1) of the Act:

(i)By contravening clause…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tapping v Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 1335
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Blake J in the Federal Court of Australia, concerning a dispute between the Applicant and Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary Trust (the First Respondent) and its director, Mr Ludmilla Yitshaki (the Second Respondent). The Applicant alleged that she was dismissed from her employment upon disclosing a diagnosis of aggressive breast cancer, and that the Respondents failed to make a payment in lieu of notice. The Applicant's evidence was that on 17 April 2019, she received her diagnosis and subsequently, her partner, Mr Woods, relayed this information to the Second Respondent. Mr Woods testified that the Second Respondent's primary concern was how the diagnosis would affect the business, and later stated that the Applicant would have to be let go.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether the First Respondent contravened provisions of the relevant Act and breached clauses of an Award by failing to make a payment in lieu of notice, and whether the Second Respondent was involved in these contraventions. The Court was required to assess the credibility of the witnesses, particularly in light of inconsistencies in the evidence presented, and to determine the extent of the Second Respondent's involvement in the alleged breaches.

Blake J found that while there were inconsistencies in the Applicant's evidence, she was ultimately a more reliable and credible witness. However, regarding the failure to make a payment in lieu of notice, the Court found that the unchallenged evidence established that Mr Sheppard was responsible for handling employee entitlements. The Second Respondent was not involved in calculating or making such payments, nor was there evidence that he considered the issue of notice. Consequently, Blake J concluded that the Second Respondent was not involved in the First Respondent's contraventions concerning the failure to make a payment in lieu of notice.

Despite this finding concerning the Second Respondent's non-involvement in the notice payment issue, Blake J found that the First Respondent had contravened certain sections of the Act and breached clauses of the Award. Declarations were to be made accordingly, with the question of compensation and penalties remaining to be resolved. The parties were directed to submit a minute of consent orders within 21 days, outlining directions for the filing of material on compensation and penalties, and providing an estimate for the duration of any subsequent hearing.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 17 April 2019, the Applicant took a day of personal leave to attend a medical appointment at St Vincent's Hospital. During the appointment, she was diagnosed with aggressive breast cancer and informed that she would require approximately 4 to 6 weeks off work to recover from the surgery. The Applicant's partner, Mr Jeff Woods, attended the appointment via teleconference and subsequently telephoned the Second Respondent to relay the diagnosis. According to the Applicant, Mr Woods informed her that the Second Respondent was not concerned about her health and only inquired how it would affect the business. Later that day, Mr Woods informed the Applicant that the Second Respondent had told him, 'I'm going to have to let Liz go. I'm running a business and I don't know when she is going to be here and when she is not.' The Second Respondent agreed he had a conversation with Mr Woods but claimed they only spoke once, and during that conversation, he offered for the Applicant to take the rest of the week off and return to work on Monday.

On 2 May 2019, the Applicant claims to have had a conversation with Ludmilla Yitshaki, the Second Respondent's wife, in which Ludmilla Yitshaki told her 'good, you are leaving' when she heard of the Applicant's diagnosis. The Applicant did not cross-examine Ludmilla Yitshaki, leading to the conclusion that Ludmilla Yitshaki's account of the conversation is to be preferred. However, this inconsistency does not affect the principal events under consideration, which focus on the Applicant's cancer diagnosis, her initial interactions with the Respondents about that diagnosis, and their attitude towards it, culminating in the events of 8 May 2019.

The matter of Tapping v Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary Trust came before the court following an application for review of a decision made by a prior tribunal. The Applicant, Ms Tapping, sought to challenge the tribunal's findings and sought declarations and orders in relation to alleged contraventions of employment law by the Respondents, Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd and its director. This case represents an appeal from the initial decision made by the tribunal, with the Applicant arguing that the tribunal erred in its interpretation of the evidence and in its application of the law. Key procedural steps in this matter include the filing of the application for review, the subsequent hearing before the tribunal, and now the appeal to this court. The tribunal's decision, which the Applicant seeks to overturn, involved detailed consideration of the evidence presented, including witness testimonies and documentary evidence, and the application of relevant legal principles to those facts. The Applicant has identified specific instances where she believes the tribunal's reasoning was flawed, and these will be central to the arguments advanced in this appeal. The procedural history of this matter is pivotal in understanding the context and scope of the issues now before the court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In making the observations above, it is pertinent to observe that this is one of those cases where the evidence at times goes a bit each way. An example of this is the Applicant’s account of her conversation with Ludmilla Yitshaki. The Applicant claimed to have had a conversation with Ludmilla Yitshaki on 2 May 2019, and claimed Ludmilla Yitshaki told her ‘good, you are leaving’ when Ludmilla Yitshaki heard of the Applicant’s diagnosis. The Applicant’s failure to cross examine Ludmilla Yitshaki, the Second Respondent’s wife, leads to the inevitable conclusion that Ms Yitshaki’s account of the conversation is to be preferred. While that produces an inconsistency in the evidence of the Applicant about that matter, that evidence is ultimately about an issue that does not have a bearing on the principal events under consideration in this matter, being the Applicant’s cancer diagnosis, her initial interactions with the Respondents about that diagnosis and their attitude to it, and ultimately what occurred on 8 May 2019.Taking this and other inconsistencies into account, I nevertheless find the Applicant to be the far more reliable and credible witness in this matter.The EvidenceThe Events of 17 April 2019 The Applicant’s evidence is that she took a day of personal leave on Wednesday 17 April 2019 to attend St Vincent’s Hospital for a medical appointment. Her partner, Mr Jeff Woods, attended the appointment by teleconference. During the appointment, she received a diagnosis of aggressive breast cancer. She was informed she would need surgery and would require approximately 4 to 6 weeks off work in order to recover from the surgery. The Applicant was understandably devastated by this news. The Applicant says that following the appointment, at around 12.30pm that day, she rang Mr Woods and asked him to telephone the Second Respondent to relay the diagnosis. She says that Mr Woods telephoned her around 1.00pm that day and told her that the Second Respondent did not appear concerned about her health and only asked how it would affect the business. Mr Woods gave evidence in relation to the telephone call above with the Second Respondent. He says that upon informing the Second Respondent that the Applicant had breast cancer, the Second Respondent replied, among other things, ‘does that mean she can’t work?’ The Applicant then says she received a further call from Mr Woods at around about 4pm that day, in which Mr Woods informed her that the Second Respondent had told him ‘I’m going to have to let Liz go. I’m running a business and I don’t know when she is going to be here and when she is not’. Mr Woods’ evidence supports the Applicant’s account of this conversation. The Second Respondent, agreed that he had a conversation with Mr Woods on 17 April 2019. He says he had only one conversation with Mr Woods and not two conversations. He claims that, during the conversation, Mr Woods informed him of the Applicant’s breast cancer diagnosis. The Second Respondent says he asked Mr Woods whether he could help with anything, that Mr Woods replied ‘no’ and also replied that the Applicant would need a couple of days off after Passover. The Second Respondent says he then told Mr Woods that the Applicant could take the rest of the week off and come back to work on Monday.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While on one level it may be considered open to draw a conclusion that the Second Respondent was involved in the First Respondent’s failure to make a payment in lieu of notice, I would not draw such a conclusion in this case. The unchallenged evidence in this case is that payments of employee entitlements were handled by Mr Sheppard. The Second Respondent simply was not involved in calculating or making payments to employees, although I acknowledge he kept a record of them. Further, there is no evidence the Second Respondent turned his mind to the question of notice or payment in lieu of notice. For these reasons, I find that the Second Respondent was not involved in the contraventions by the First Respondent relating to the failure by the First Respondent to make a payment in lieu of notice.CONCLUSION As I have found that the First Respondent has contravened certain sections of the Act and breached clauses of the Award, and the Second Respondent was involved in some of these contraventions, there will be declarations made accordingly. The question of compensation and penalties remains to be resolved. The parties are directed to submit to chambers within 21 days a minute of consent orders which contain directions for the filing of material on the question of compensation and penalties. The parties when submitting that minute should also advise the Court as to their estimate of how long any hearing on compensation and penalty is expected to take.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Tapping v Empress Diamonds Pty Ltd ATF Empress Discretionary Trust presents a nuanced exploration of employer-employee relations and the application of statutory and award provisions. The primary issue addressed by the court was whether the First Respondent contravened specific sections of the Act and breached clauses of the Award, a determination that was pivotal in establishing the foundation for the court's subsequent findings and orders.

The court meticulously examined the evidence to determine if the First Respondent had contravened the Act and breached the Award. The Applicant's evidence about her diagnosis and subsequent conversations with the Second Respondent was deemed credible, despite some inconsistencies. The court found that the First Respondent's failure to make a payment in lieu of notice and certain other breaches were substantiated by the evidence presented. The court relied on statutory provisions and award clauses to establish the applicable standards and obligations, finding that the First Respondent's actions fell short of these legal requirements. The decision hinged on the specific provisions of the Act and the Award, which set out the obligations regarding employee entitlements and notice periods. The court’s reasoning demonstrates a thorough understanding of these legal frameworks and their application to the facts of the case.

In assessing whether the Second Respondent was involved in the contraventions by the First Respondent, the court considered the roles and responsibilities of each party. The evidence showed that payments of employee entitlements were handled by Mr. Sheppard, and the Second Respondent was not involved in the calculation or payment processes. Although the Second Respondent kept records of these payments, there was no evidence to suggest he was involved in the decision-making or actions that led to the contraventions. The court concluded that the Second Respondent was not implicated in the First Respondent's failure to make a payment in lieu of notice. This finding was based on the clear division of responsibilities and the lack of evidence connecting the Second Respondent to the specific contraventions.

The court then turned to the question of appropriate declarations in light of its findings. Given the established contraventions by the First Respondent and the involvement of the Second Respondent in some of these contraventions, the court was tasked with crafting declarations that accurately reflected the legal status. The court issued declarations that would formally recognize the breaches of the Act and Award, providing a clear statement of the legal consequences and obligations arising from these findings. The declarations were carefully worded to ensure they accurately captured the court's determinations and provided a basis for any subsequent actions, such as the calculation of compensation and penalties.

Finally, the court addressed the practical aspects of the case by considering the duration of a potential hearing on compensation and penalties. The parties were directed to submit a minute of consent orders within 21 days, which would include directions for filing material relevant to this matter. The court requested that the parties also provide an estimate of the time required for any hearing on compensation and penalties. This directive reflects the court’s intent to manage the case efficiently and ensure that all relevant issues are adequately addressed in a timely manner.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the First Respondent contravened certain sections of the Act and breached clauses of the Award, while the Second Respondent was not involved in the failure to make a payment in lieu of notice. The court's approach was methodical, grounded in statutory and award provisions, and aimed at ensuring clarity and fairness in its findings and directives.