Tapp v LawCover Insurance Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tapp v LawCover Insurance Pty Ltd

[2013] FCA 35

Citation: Tapp v LawCover Insurance Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 35
Parties: KEITH TAPP and PETER TAPP v LAWCOVER INSURANCE PTY LTD, ROGER WINCHESTER GRAY and OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY
File number: NSD 1985 of 2012
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 4 January 2013
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – when bankrupt’s right to indemnity under insurance contract for outstanding judgment debt vests in Trustee in bankruptcy – where creditor had sole beneficial interest in proceeds of any right to indemnity held by the bankrupt under a contract of insurance vested in trustee under s 117 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – whether preferential right to proceeds of right to indemnity imposed duty on the trustee to pursue proceedings against insurer or assign to preferred creditor right of action under policy vested in trustee by s 117 – where the creditor requested that the Official Trustee take proceedings to recover indemnity from the insurer – where the Official Trustee refused to commence proceedings or assign right to do so to creditor and suggested that preferred creditor commence separate proceedings against the insurer for declarations on the questions – whether insurer was liable to indemnify bankrupt’s estate and whether trustee should assign right to indemnity to creditor

BANKRUPTCY – effect on the estate of discharge of bankrupt under s 153 Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – whether the estate or the assets of the bankrupt vested in the trustee affected by a bankrupt’s discharge under the Act

TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – DUTIES OF TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY – duties of trustee in bankruptcy exercise powers and performance functions to recover property for the estate, pursue its efficient administration and in commercially sound manner created by s 19(1)(f), (j), (k) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – where trustee in breach of its duties – where failure to ascertain trust assets and recover trust property – where failure to have regard to interest of statutorily preferred creditors – considerations relevant to whether trustee should assign rights to indemnity

Held: the estate is not released when the bankrupt is discharged – discharge does not affect the creditors’ rights to have the trustee realise and distribute assets of the bankrupt vested in the trustee – discharge of bankrupt had no effect on trustee’s rights to realise for the benefit of the estate any property of the bankrupt vested in the trustee by ss 58 or 117 – no reason for trustee at any time to fail or refuse to assign to preferred creditor bankrupt’s rights to seek indemnity from insurer vested in trustee by s 117 – Official Trustee in Bankruptcy failed to fulfil its obligations under s 19(1)(f), (j) and (k) or apply to the Court for directions – failure by the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy to co-operate with the applicants or seek directions caused unnecessary cost and expense in litigation

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 19(1), 58(1), 58(3), 117, 134, 149D, 153,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tapp v LawCover Insurance Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tapp v LawCover Insurance Pty Ltd involved the applicants seeking to recover indemnity for a judgment debt from the trustee under the rights held for their benefit under s 117 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth). The trustee, who had been appointed to manage the bankrupt's estate, had not cooperated with the applicants in their efforts to recover the debt, leading to significant litigation costs. The legal issues before the court included whether the trustee had acted in the best interests of the applicants, whether the trustee had fulfilled its obligations under s 19(1) of the Bankruptcy Act, and who should bear the costs of the litigation.

The court found that the trustee had a duty to act in the best interests of the applicants, particularly in light of their offers to indemnify and assist. The trustee's failure to cooperate with the applicants and the court in resolving the issues surrounding the discharge of the bankrupt led to significant costs being incurred. The court held that the trustee's conduct was the primary cause of the difficulties in the proceedings. The court concluded that the trustee should bear the costs of the litigation and not seek to recover them from the estate of the bankrupt.

In the final orders, the court made declarations in the form agreed by the parties, assigning the trustee's rights to indemnity under the policy to the applicants. The court also ordered that the trustee bear the costs of the litigation, and that the applicants and the trustee each bear their own costs. The court found that the trustee's failure to act in accordance with the overarching purpose of the civil procedure provisions of the Act and the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) was the real reason for the parties having to bear substantial expenses in the litigation. The court emphasized that the trustee's conduct had caused significant difficulties in the proceedings and had led to the wastage of resources.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given that the applicants were seeking to recover indemnity for a judgment debt of about $600,000 under the right the trustee held for their benefit under s 117, the trustee had a duty to act in their best interests. The applicants made all appropriate offers to indemnify and assist the trustee. They received no cooperation.Conclusion For these reasons, I will make declarations in the form agreed by the parties. The trustee informed the Court after I delivered the above reasons orally that it will assign its rights to indemnity under the policy to the applicants subject to any reasonable payment of costs. LawCover has sought that its costs of the interlocutory application be paid by the applicants and/or the trustee. The applicants and the trustee have reached an agreement that each bear their own costs. In my opinion, the difficulties in these proceedings to date have been largely occasioned because of the failure of the trustee to carry out its duties under s 19(1) of the Act for the reasons that I have given. When I required submissions to be made by the trustee on 24 December 2012, I drew attention to Pt VB of the Federal Court of Australia Act. Belatedly, the trustee, which has been a party to this litigation from its inception, only this morning recognised its obligation to act in a way that confirms with the overarching purpose of the civil procedure provisions of the Act and the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). In my opinion, the real reason for parties to have borne their substantial expenses in this litigation up to today has been due to the trustee’s conduct. While the parties seem to have had some doubt as to what, in my opinion, was pellucid about the situation after the discharge of Mr Gray from bankruptcy, the trustee offered no assistance to them or the Court on a question that is fundamental to its functions under the Act. Hence, the utility in the declarations that I will make. I am of opinion that the appropriate order in the circumstances of this case is that the trustee bear, and not to seek to recover from the estate of the bankrupt, the costs thrown away by reason of the proceedings before the docket judge and before me to date. It is also appropriate to order that the trustee pay LawCover’s costs so thrown away.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The docket judge received no appropriate assistance from the parties, and particularly from the trustee, being the statutory office holder who might have been expected to use its years of experience to assist on the question of whether the anticipated discharge of Mr Gray raised any issue at all that was worth litigating. Later on 21 December 2012, her Honour set down the separate question for hearing before me as duty judge this week. On 24 December 2012, I directed that the trustee, who had sought to be excused from the litigious catastrophe that it had created for the other parties, to file and serve an affidavit and submissions as to why it had not assigned to the applicants the right to sue LawCover, particularly having regard to the provisions of Pt VB of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Yesterday afternoon, the parties informed me that they had agreed to the terms of declarations that I shall make to resolve the issues arising in relation to the forthcoming discharge of the bankrupt.The relevant operation of the Bankruptcy Act In general terms, s 58(1) of the Act vests the property of the bankrupt forthwith, at the time the debtor becomes bankrupt, in the Official Trustee or, if applicable, the registered trustee (I will refer to these as simply as the trustee). That provision also vests in the trustee after-acquired property of the bankrupt as soon as it is acquired by, or devolves on, the bankrupt. Ordinarily, the right of a bankrupt to make claims upon, and to receive, indemnity from a liability insurer could be expected to vest in the trustee under s 58(1). But, the Act makes specific provision in s 117 for what is to happen to a particular right of a bankrupt to indemnity under a contract of insurance against liabilities to third parties where the bankrupt incurred such a liability either before or after becoming bankrupt. Relevantly, s 117 provides that the bankrupt’s right of indemnity for such a liability vests in the trustee and creates a duty of the trustee to use any amount the trustee receives from the insurer to pay the claim of the particular creditor in respect of which the liability policy responds. The section provides:(1) Where:(a)a bankrupt is or was insured under a contract of insurance against liabilities to third parties; and(b)a liability against which he or she is or was so insured has been incurred (whether before or after he or she became a bankrupt);the right of the bankrupt to indemnity under the policy vests in the trustee and any amount received by the trustee from the insurer under the policy in respect of the liability shall, if the liability has not already been satisfied, be paid in full forthwith to the third party to whom it has been incurred.(2)Subsection (1) does not limit the rights of the third party in respect of any balance due to him or her after the payment referred to in that subsection has been made.(3)This section applies notwithstanding any agreement to the contrary, whether entered into before or after the commencement of this Act.