Talbot v Boyd Legal (A Firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Talbot v Boyd Legal (A Firm) & Anor [2019] QSC 80

PARTIES:

AMANDA DIANE TALBOT

(plaintiff)

v
BOYD LEGAL (A FIRM)

(first defendant)
ARNOLD BLOCK LEIBLER (A FIRM)
(second defendant)

FILE NO:

S6419 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 March 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7 March 2019

JUDGE:

Ryan J

ORDER:

I will hear the parties as to the formal orders, and as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – PLEADING – STATEMENT OF CLAIM – where the first defendant seeks the striking out of the whole of the statement of claim insofar as it concerns him – where the first defendant complains about deficiencies in the way in which causes of actions are pleaded – whether the first defendant contends that there is no utility in granting leave to replead because all claims against it are statute barred – whether to strike out the whole of, or paragraphs of, the statement of claim – whether the court should consider limitation arguments in an interlocutory application

Australian Wool Innovation Ltd v Newkirk (2005) ATPR 42-053
Christie v Purves
[2007] NSWCA 182
Hawkins v Clayton
(1988) 164 CLR 529
Hughes v Western Australian Cricket Association (Inc)
(1986) 69 ALR 660
Melisavon Pty Ltd v Springfield Land Development Corporation Pty Ltd [2015] 1 Qd R 476
Mineral Resources Engineering Services Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia; Hay v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (No 3)
[2016] QSC 232.
Pullen v Gutteridge Hashin & Davey Pty Ltd [1993] 1 VR 27
Thiess Pty Ltd v FFE Minerals Australia Pty Ltd
[2007] QSC 209
Virgtel Ltd & Anor v Zabusky & Ors
[2008] QSC 213
Wardley Australia v Western Australia
(1992) 175 CLR 514

COUNSEL:

P Dunning QC, with P Telford for the Plaintiff
R Jackson QC, with A Nicholas for the First Defendant

S Doyle QC with S McCarthy for the Second Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Everingham Lawyers for the Plaintiff

Hall & Wilcox for the First Defendant
K & L Gates for the Second Defendant

  1. The plaintiff, Mrs Talbot, has brought actions in negligence against a solicitor, Mr Boyd  and a law firm, Arnold Block Leibler, arising out of the performance of their retainers concerning her late husband’s will and the administration of his estate, and in acting generally for her.

  2. On 7 March 2019, I heard two applications in this matter.  The first was an application by the first defendant, Mr Boyd, to strike out Mrs Talbot’s statement of claim insofar as it related to him, or more accurately to “Boyd Legal (A Firm)” as he was named in the pleadings.  The second was an application by the plaintiff for disclosure.  I dealt with the disclosure application on 7 March 2019.  The orders and reasons contained in this decision concern only the application to strike out.

  3. The first defendant’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Talbot v Boyd Legal (A Firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Queensland, Mrs Amanda Talbot, the widow of the late Mr Ken Talbot, has brought a claim against Boyd Legal (A Firm) and another defendant. The claim arises from alleged professional negligence by the first defendant, Mr Boyd, a solicitor who was retained by Mr Talbot to prepare his will. The plaintiff contends that Mr Boyd's actions or omissions resulted in her being deprived of her rightful entitlements under Mr Talbot's estate. The first defendant seeks to have the entire statement of claim struck out, arguing that it is deficiently pleaded and that the claims against it are statute-barred. The court must determine whether deficiencies in the pleadings are so substantial that they warrant the striking out of the entire statement of claim, or if only specific paragraphs should be removed, and whether it should consider the statute of limitations argument at this interlocutory stage.

The central legal issues before the court involve the sufficiency of the plaintiff's statement of claim and the admissibility of the statute of limitations defence in this context. Specifically, the court must assess whether the plaintiff's claims are adequately pleaded and if the defendant's statute of limitations argument can be entertained in the interlocutory application. The court is also tasked with deciding whether to address the merits of the limitation argument at this stage or to defer it until a later stage in the proceedings.

The court examined the deficiencies in the pleadings and noted that the plaintiff had not clearly and concisely outlined her claims against the first defendant. Despite this, the court found that the deficiencies did not render the claims futile and thus did not warrant the striking out of the entire statement of claim. Regarding the statute of limitations, the court held that it was premature to consider this defence at the interlocutory stage, as it was not appropriate to determine the merits of the limitation argument without a more developed record. The court ultimately decided to strike out specific paragraphs of the statement of claim that were deficiently pleaded but allowed the rest of the claims to proceed.

The court will hear submissions on formal orders and costs from the parties and will make its decision on these matters in due course.

Orders

Orders of the court

I will hear the parties as to the formal orders, and as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will therefore hear from the parties as to the formal orders, and as to costs, in the first instance, by way of written submissions to my associate by 4 pm on Monday 8 April 2019.Background Mrs Amanda Talbot is Mr Ken Talbot’s widow. Mr Talbot died in a plane crash on 19 June 2010. Mrs Talbot was his second wife. She is the mother of his two younger children and the stepmother of his two older children. Mr Talbot’s estate is large and complex. Mr Boyd, a solicitor, practiced, from 1995, as a member of two firms of solicitors and then as a sole practitioner. He was retained by Mr Talbot from at least 1995 until Mr Talbot’s death. In 2002, Mr Talbot retained Mr Boyd for the purposes of preparing a will. The will was executed by Mr Talbot on 29 November 2002. The will appointed Paul Bret, an American living in Texas, as Mr Talbot’s sole executor and trustee. Mr and Mrs Talbot’s four children were beneficiaries under the 2002 will. Mr Talbot’s circumstances “materially changed” between 29 November 2002 and mid-2008, in particular in the composition of his non-residential property wealth. On about 1 September 2006, Mr Boyd sent an email to Mr Talbot’s assistant indicating that a review of his 2002 will was long overdue. He sent similar emails to Mr Talbot himself on 25 September 2005 and 12 November 2007. By 23 November 2007, Mr Boyd had been retained by Mr Talbot for the purposes of preparing a new will. By 7 October 2008, Mr Boyd had instructions to brief counsel to provide advice to Mr Talbot about succession planning and the new will. By 8 October 2008, Mr Boyd had drafted instructions to counsel (Mr Peterson) about those matters, which reflected Mr Talbot’s wishes about his new will. Under those instructions, Mrs Talbot’s position as a beneficiary under the proposed new will was more beneficial to her than her position under the 2002 will. On 4 December 2008, Mr Talbot indicated to Mr Boyd that he wanted to complete the new will (“We should aim to knock it off the table”). On 10 December 2008, Mr Boyd informed Mr Talbot that he needed more time because of the complexities of the matter. He indicated that counsel’s advice was that an interim will be drafted in the meantime. Mr Boyd told Mr Talbot that he was spending time on the interim will and was planning to discuss it with Mr Talbot the next week. On 1 June 2009, counsel sent to Mr Boyd an email attaching a draft of the new will. Neither the new will nor an interim will was executed before Mr Talbot’s unexpected death on 19 June 2010. After Mr Talbot’s death, Mr Bret was appointed sole executor and trustee of Mr Talbot’s estate. Mr Boyd acted for Mrs Talbot as a “solicitor generally” in relation to the issues which arose as a result of Mr Talbot’s death. Mr Bret was removed as executor and administrator after problems arose between him and the beneficiaries. From 29 June 2012, Mr Boyd was engaged as the administrator of the estate. The plaintiff retained the second defendant from about 9 August 2010 until November 2015 to (among other things) give her general and commercial advice in relation to Mr Talbot’s estate.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.