Tadese v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TADESE v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2020] FCCA 1885
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Administrative Appeals Tribunal – extension of time application  – Minister consenting to the extension of time – matter proceeding as a final hearing – partner visa – DNA test showing that the likelihood of the applicant and his wife being half-siblings compared with unrelated individuals was 66 to 1 – half-sibling relationship a prohibited degree of relationship – Tribunal not satisfied that the applicant and his wife were not within a prohibited relationship – therefore, Tribunal not satisfied applicant and his wife were spouses or in a de facto relationship.
Legislation:
Marriage Act 1961, ss.23B(2), 88D, 88F, 88G
Migration Act 1958, s.477(1), 477(2)
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001, r.44.05(2)(c)

Cases cited:

Briginshawv Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; [1938] ALR 334; (1938) 12 ALJR 100; [1938] HCA 34
In the Marriage of Teves v Campomayor (1994) 122 FLR 172; 18 Fam LR 844; [1995] FLC 92-578
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; [1959] ALR 367; (1959) 32 ALJR 395; (1959) 76 WN (NSW) 278
M100 of 2004 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 213 FLR 63; [2007] FMCA 829

Applicant: DANIEL A TADESE
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File number: MLG 1580 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge Riley
Hearing date: 21 May 2020
Date of last submission: 21 May 2020
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 10 July 2020

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the applicant: Rolf Sorensen
Solicitors for the applicant: Goz Chambers Lawyers
Advocate for the first respondent: Keith Sypott
Counsel for the second respondent: No appearance
Solicitors for the respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. Pursuant to s.477(1) of the Migration Act 1958, the time for the applicant to file an application in this court be extended to 21 July 2017.

  2. The requirement in r.44.05(2)(c) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001, to file an affidavit explaining the delay in filing these proceedings, be dispensed with.

  3. The application filed on 21 July 2017 and amended on 24 April 2020 be dismissed.

  4. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs of the proceeding fixed in the sum of $7,467.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG1580 of 2017

DANIEL A TADESE

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First respondent

And

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This is an application for an extension of time to review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”). In that decision, the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant’s wife a partner visa.

Extension of time application

  1. The Tribunal’s decision was made on 12 June 2017. Under s.477(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (“the Act”), any application to this court is to be filed within 35 days of the date of the Tribunal’s decision. The application to this court was not filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tadese v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1885
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Mr Tadese against a decision of the Minister for Immigration, which affirmed a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Tribunal had affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse a visa application. The central dispute revolved around whether the applicant and the visa applicant were in a prohibited relationship, specifically as half-siblings, which would render their marriage invalid under the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and the *Marriage Act 1961* (Cth).

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had erred in its assessment of the evidence, particularly the 2012 DNA test results, and the applicant's subsequent refusal to undergo further DNA testing. The applicant contended that the 2012 DNA test results were "objectively inconclusive" and that the Tribunal failed to properly consider this, as well as the subsequent correspondence. The Tribunal, however, considered the 2012 DNA test results to be "probative evidence" and "extremely relevant" in determining the relationship between the applicant and the visa applicant, despite acknowledging they were not definitive.

Judge Riley reasoned that while DNA results inherently deal with likelihoods rather than absolute certainties, the Tribunal's task was not to establish absolute genetic truth but to be satisfied that the parties were not within a prohibited relationship. The Tribunal found that the 2012 DNA test, which indicated a 66 to 1 likelihood of the parties being half-siblings, was probative and highly relevant to this assessment. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered the applicant's refusal to undertake further DNA testing, despite the matter having been remitted for that specific purpose, as a significant factor. The Tribunal ultimately concluded that it was not satisfied that the applicant and visa applicant were not within a prohibited relationship, and therefore, their marriage was not valid for the purposes of the Act.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision, finding that the visa applicant was not the spouse or de facto partner of the applicant. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision, finding no jurisdictional error in its assessment of the evidence and the application of the relevant legal principles.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The correspondence at CB142 is the original test results from the lab, which stated that:Based on the autosomal STR results presented on Table 1, the statistical likelihood of Daniel Tadese and Genet Hailu Abebe being related as biological half siblings, compared to unrelated individuals, was calculated as 66 to 1. ŸBased on the above statistical analysis of the autosomal STR results, there is moderately strong evidence to support the proposition that Daniel Tadese and Genet Hailu Abebe are related as biological half siblings. The correspondence at CB155 is the email from the senior scientist set out above. In relation to this sub-ground, the Minister submitted that:42.By this ground the applicant contends that the Tribunal failed to have regard to the 2012 DNA test’s ‘objectively inconclusive’ results before characterising them as ‘probative evidence’ and ‘extremely relevant’. It is said that the results are objectively inconclusive having regard to ‘the results themselves’ and ‘subsequent correspondence’ at CB 142 and 155.2543.This ground may be a reference to the fact that the 2012 DNA test results provided that there was a 66 to 1 likelihood of the visa applicant and applicant being half- siblings, as opposed to stating that it was a certainty that such a relationship existed. The Tribunal noted at [49] that these results were not ‘definitive’, but that they cast light on the most likely relationship between the visa applicant and applicant.44.The applicant does not identify what aspect of the subsequent correspondence at CB 142 and 155 renders the 2012 DNA test results ‘objectively inconclusive’. This appears to be a reiteration of previous argument that the 2012 DNA test results do not indicate how the ‘66 to 1’ ratio converts to a likelihood that the applicant and visa applicant are half-siblings, and that an unsatisfactory response was received by the Department about the likelihood of the applicant and visa applicant being cousins. Again, the applicant is seeking merits review of the Tribunal’s decision.25 AS at [15]. This sub-ground asserts that the 2012 DNA results were objectively inconclusive. In a sense, they were, because DNA results are inherently incapable of establishing absolutely the closeness of the relationship between people. DNA results by their nature concern likelihoods, rather than absolute truths. However, the Tribunal’s task was not to determine absolutely the genetic relationship between the applicant and his wife. The Tribunal’s task was to determine whether or not it was satisfied that the applicant and his wife were not within a prohibited relationship. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant and his wife were not within a prohibited relationship. The 2012 DNA test was probative and extremely relevant in answering that question. The third aspect of ground 1 is as follows:c.consequently having no basis for any assessment of what weight if any to attach to the Applicant’s failure to participate in further DNA testing …

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his written submissions filed on 7 May 2020, the Minister summarised the proceedings before the Tribunal as follows:The first Tribunal decision11.On 2 May 2014 the applicant lodged an application for review of the delegate’s decision with the Tribunal.88 CB 172-183. At this time, the Tribunal was the ‘Migration Review Tribunal’.12.On 23 February 2015 the Tribunal held a hearing, and granted the applicant until 10 March 2015 to provide a further DNA report addressing the reliability of the 2012 DNA report.9 An extension to 31 March 2015 was granted after the applicant advised that he and his wife had engaged Bioservices Pty Ltd with a view to obtaining a further DNA report.109 CB 200-202.10 CB 204-205, 209-210.13.On 1 April 2015 the applicant sent the Tribunal a letter advising that more time was required in order to provide further DNA evidence. It was said that the specimen collection agencies in Ethiopia would not assist until there was a letter from the Tribunal advising that a DNA sample was required.1111 CB 211.14.On 2 April 2015 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision.1212 CB 215-221.Remittal to the Tribunal15.On 10 May 2016 her Honour Judge Jones made orders by consent quashing the Tribunal’s decision and remitting the application to the Tribunal to be determined according to law. The notation to those orders provides that:In making its decision, the Second Respondent fell into jurisdictional error by unreasonably refusing to further adjourn the review to provide the applicant and sponsor with an opportunity to undertake another DNA test.1316.On 21 June 2016 the applicant sent submissions and material to the Tribunal highlighting that his son had been granted Australian citizenship by descent and that this had occurred after a DNA test concluded that this child was his and the visa applicant’s biological child.1417.On 12 December 2016 the Tribunal sent the applicant a letter offering the him further time to undergo DNA testing disproving a sibling relationship with the visa applicant.15 In response, the applicant advised that he did not consider further DNA testing was necessary in light of the DNA test undertaken in late 2015, which confirmed the parentage of his son.1618.On 16 March 2017 the Tribunal held a hearing.17 The applicant provided further submissions post-hearing.18 On 12 June 2017 the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision.1913 CB 224-225.14 CB 235-245.15 CB 247-254.16 CB 261-276. See, in particular, CB 264 at [9].17 CB 307-310.18 CB 311-317.19 CB 321-330. In his written submissions filed on 7 May 2020, the Minister summarised the Tribunal’s reasons for decision as follows:19.The Tribunal’s decision record recounts that, at hearing, it urged the applicant, if he considered that the 2012 DNA test results were defective, to undergo further DNA testing and indicated that it was prepared to wait ‘however long it may take’ if the applicant wished to pursue a further DNA test: [20].20.The Tribunal was concerned by two post-hearing submissions made by the applicant’s representative.20.1.First, it was erroneously claimed that the applicant had not given evidence at hearing. It recalled that the applicant had given oral evidence and that this was evidenced by the hearing record.20.2Second, the Tribunal rejected the suggestion that at hearing it had contended that the applicant’s application would not succeed as a matter of law without a DNA report countering the 2012 DNA report, and noted that it had stated at hearing that ‘it may place greater weight on the 2012 DNA report, given the review applicant’s refusal of the Tribunal’s offer to undergo further DNA testing’: [22]-[24].21.The Tribunal noted that the issue before it was whether the visa applicant satisfied cls 309.211 and 309.221 of Sch 2 to the Regulations, and that this required the consideration of whether, at both the time of the visa application and at the time of the Tribunal’s decision, the applicant was the spouse or de facto partner of an Australian citizen or permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen: [25].22.The Tribunal noted that s 5F of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) provided that a person is the ‘spouse’ of another person if those two persons are in a married relationship. It outlined the relevant criteria for a ‘married relationship’, including that persons in a married relationship must be married to each other under a marriage that is valid for the purposes of the Act20: [26].23.The Tribunal noted that s 23B(1)(b) of the Marriage Act 1961 (Cth) (the Marriage Act) provided that a marriage in Australia is void if the parties are within a ‘prohibited relationship’ and that s 88D(2)(c) of the Marriage Act rendered foreign marriages invalid if the parties are in a prohibited relationship. It also noted that s 23B(2)(b) of the Marriage Act provided that a marriage between a brother and sister, whether of full blood or half blood, was a prohibited relationship. Accordingly, it observed that if the applicant and visa applicant were related as half-siblings, their marriage would be invalid for the purposes of the Act, irrespective of whether their relationship was genuine and continuing: [36].24.The applicant’s representative had submitted, with reference to the Procedures Advice Manual 3 (the PAM3), that little weight should be given to the applicant’s decision to not undergo such testing: [37]. The Tribunal noted that the PAM3 did not bind it and that the situation before it differed from other cases where DNA testing had yet to occur. It also noted that the matter had been remitted to it on the basis that the Tribunal, as previously constituted, had unreasonably refused to adjourn the review in order to enable the applicant to undertake another DNA test: [38].25.The Tribunal had regard to the applicant’s evidence that he was ‘shocked’ by the results set out in the 2012 DNA report, that there was an ‘initial investigation’ prior to his marriage by family members that concluded that he and the visa applicant were not related and that, after receiving the 2012 DNA test results, he and the visa applicant consulted their respective families who had confirmed that there was no biological connection between the applicant and visa applicant: [44].26.The applicant had claimed that he and the visa applicant had not undertaken further DNA testing as they found the 2012 DNA test process to be ‘humiliating, and emotionally and financially stressing’. The Tribunal rejected this claim, citing the applicant’s statements to both the Department and Tribunal (as previously constituted) that he and the visa applicant wished to undertake further DNA testing to prove that the conclusions in the 2012 DNA report were incorrect: [46]-[48].27.The Tribunal accepted that the conclusions in the 2012 DNA report were not definitive; however, it noted that this analysis was scientifically undertaken and that the report assessed the most likely relationship between the applicant and visa applicant. Such an assessment was, in the Tribunal’s view, ‘probative evidence’ and ‘extremely relevant’: [49].28.In relation to the 2015 DNA test, the Tribunal noted that this test only involved the applicant and his son, and that it offered no assessment of whether there was a biological relationship between the applicant and visa applicant. The Tribunal did, however, accept that the 2015 DNA test evidenced that the applicant’s son was the biological child of the applicant and visa applicant”: [50].29.The Tribunal placed significant weight on the 2012 DNA test report in making its assessment of the validity of the marriage. It also placed significant weight on the applicant’s refusal to participate in further DNA testing, notwithstanding that this was the specific reason for the remittal of his application by this Court in 2016. The Tribunal found that the applicant and visa applicant were related by family, notwithstanding the evidence that their relationship was genuine and that they, and their wider circle of friends and family, may not have been aware of this biological connection. It concluded that it was not satisfied that the applicant and visa applicant were not within a prohibited relationship and that, therefore, they were not married to each other under a marriage that was valid for the purposes of the Act: [51]-[52].30.As to any de facto relationship, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the parties were not related by family. It concluded that s 5CB(2) of the Act was not satisfied, and that the visa applicant was not the de facto partner of the applicant: [53]-[56].20 Act s 5F(2)(a). See also s 12.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.