T O'Connor & Sons Pty Ltd v Entact Clough Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   T O'CONNOR & SONS PTY LTD -v- ENTACT CLOUGH PTY LTD [2003] WASC 69

CORAM:   HASLUCK J

HEARD:   31 OCTOBER 2002

DELIVERED          :   4 APRIL 2003

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2293 of 1995

CIV 1400 of 1996
Consolidated by Order dated 11 June 1996

BETWEEN:   T O'CONNOR & SONS PTY LTD (ACN 001 664 740)

Plaintiff

AND

ENTACT CLOUGH PTY LTD (ACN 052 178 088)
Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Discovery - Application for further and better discovery - Nature of evidence required to support such an application - Whether an order should be made providing for cross-examination of a person who has sworn an affidavit of discovery - Application dismissed on grounds that the case underlying the application for further and better discovery was speculative - Application for cross-examination and for the issue of a subpoena to a third party dismissed on the same grounds - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court, 1971, O 26 r 6, O 36 r 12

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr B M O'Brien

Defendant:     Mr P K Walton

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Phillips Fox

Defendant:     Jackson McDonald

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Attorney‑General for New South Wales v Stuart (1994) 34 NSWLR 667

Auspine Ltd v HS Lawrence & Sons Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1749

Australian Securities Commission v Zarro (No 2) (1992) 34 FCR 427

Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Myers (Co) [1979] VR 273

Finance Sector Union of Australia v Commonwealth Bank Australia Ltd [2000] FCA 1389

Fruehauf Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd (1990) 20 NSWLR 359

Midalco Pty Ltd v Simpson, unreported; SCt of WA; Library No 6747; 5 June 1987

Mulley & Marney v Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341

Olympic Airways SA v Spiros Alysandratos & Consolidated Travel (Vic) Pty Ltd, unreported; SCt of Vic; 26 May 1997

The Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 564

Case(s) also cited:

Nil

  1. HASLUCK J:  The parties to these proceedings each provided discovery of documents in the usual form, that is to say by filing and serving, a list of documents verified by affidavit.  The plaintiff, T O'Connor & Sons Pty Ltd, then raised an issue as to whether the discovery provided by the defendant, Entact Clough Pty Ltd, was sufficient.  The plaintiff took out a chamber summons for further and better discovery and supported the same by filing and serving an affidavit sworn by the plaintiff's solicitor, Ronald David Windevere Bellman on 18 September 2001.

November discovery order

  1. On 26 November 2001 an order was made for further discovery whereby the defendant was to make and file an affidavit stating whether certain specified documents were or had been in its possession, namely, all notes, memoranda, correspondence and other documents in respect of the defendant's dealing and/or Clough Engineering Ltd's dealings with Indosuez Australia Ltd.

  2. The defendant purported to provide further discovery in compliance with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read T O'Connor & Sons Pty Ltd v Entact Clough Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] WASC 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of T O'Connor & Sons Pty Ltd v Entact Clough Pty Ltd, the parties were engaged in a dispute regarding a construction project. The applicant, T O'Connor & Sons Pty Ltd, sought further and better discovery from the respondent, Entact Clough Pty Ltd, in order to obtain additional evidence for their case. This application included a request for cross-examination of a person who had sworn an affidavit of discovery. The court was required to determine the nature of the evidence required to support such an application and whether an order should be made providing for the cross-examination of the person who had sworn the affidavit.

The court found that the case underlying the application for further and better discovery was speculative, and therefore dismissed the application. The court also dismissed the application for cross-examination and for the issue of a subpoena to a third party on the same grounds. The case turned on its own facts and the court noted that the circumstances in which cross-examination will be allowed are rare, as an affidavit of discovery is generally conclusive. The court found that the case before them was exceptional and did not envisage a general widening of the ordinary rule that an affidavit of discovery is conclusive. The court was concerned that allowing cross-examination would give the plaintiff an unfair advantage and enable them to tackle an area of evidence in respect of which they had already had the opportunity of cross-examination.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the application for further and better discovery, cross-examination, and the issue of a subpoena to a third party. The court found that the case was speculative and that allowing cross-examination would give the plaintiff an unfair advantage. The court's decision was based on the principle that an affidavit of discovery is generally conclusive, and the exceptional circumstances of this case did not warrant a departure from that principle.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Fruehauf Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd (1990) 20 NSWLR 359 Giles J held that an affidavit of discovery is generally conclusive not only in relation to the amplitude of discovery but also in relation to any claim to protection from inspection of a discovered document, including a claim to legal professional privilege; and in particular cross‑examination of the maker of the affidavit will not be permitted. Harper J in Olympic Airways SA v Spiros Alysandratos & Consolidated Travel (Vic) Pty Ltd, unreported; SCt of Vic; 26 May 1997 undertook a review of the circumstances in which cross‑examination will be allowed. He observed at page 9 that the fact that cross‑examination on an affidavit of discovery has rarely ever been allowed is doubtless a reflection of the policy that affidavits of discovery are conclusive. In regard to the case before him, Harper J noted that there was cogent evidence to suggest the existence of documents which one would expect, if they do or did exist, were generated by one or other of the defendants. The evidence that the documents either never existed or were never in the possession of the defendants was much less cogent. The evidence raised serious doubts as to whether the process of the Court was being abused by the defendants in relation to discovery. His Honour was therefore prepared to make an order for cross‑examination. His Honour then went on to say:"…I wish to make it clear that I see this case as exceptional. I do not envisage a general widening of the ordinary rule that an affidavit of discovery is in the usual case conclusive, subject only to such application as may be appropriate pursuant to r 29.8.If this appeal were allowed the processes of the court may be abused and injustice may be done to one side or the other. I say one side or the other because it may well be that the defendants have a very good answer to what appears to me at present to be prima facie an unsatisfactory state of the evidence. If they do have such an answer, it would doubtless be of advantage to the defendants to have that answer aired immediately.If, on the other hand, the suspicions of the plaintiff are justified, then it may be that unless those suspicions are further explored, the plaintiff will suffer an injustice which it may be difficult, if not impossible, later to rectify and it may be that the processes of the court will be abused." He then proceeded to make orders designed to ensure that the scope of the cross‑examination was strictly limited. He accepted that one reason why the procedure for cross‑examination should be regarded as unusual was that it had the potential of giving the plaintiff an advantage: the advantage of having two opportunities to cross‑examine a witness for the defendants on an important part of the case. It would be quite wrong for the Court to permit the plaintiff to take unfair advantage of this. The plaintiff ought not to be put in a position where it will be enabled, at trial, to tackle once again an area of evidence in respect of which it has already had the opportunity of cross‑examination.