MIGRATION – application for a Protection (Class XA) visa – whether Refugee Review Tribunal addressed all appellant’s claims, adopted an active intellectual process, applied the correct legal tests or made unreasonable findings – real chance test – no onus of proof in Tribunal proceedings
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – role of the Court to decide whether decision was invalid by reason of jurisdictional error – role of the Court not to consider factual merits of Tribunal’s decision
Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category:
Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
57
Counsel for the Appellant:
The Appellant appeared in person
Solicitor for the First Respondent:
Mr M Glavac of Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent:
The Second Respondent filed a submitting appearance, save as to costs
ORDERS
NSD 1380 of 2016
BETWEEN:
SZVDH
Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
JUDGE:
BURLEY J
DATE OF ORDER:
10 FEBRUARY 2017
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The appeal be dismissed with costs.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
1 INTRODUCTION
[1]
2 BACKGROUND
[5]
2.1 The Visa application and the decision of the Delegate
[5]
2.2 The Tribunal’s decision
[7]
2.3 The decision of the FCCA
[14]
3 THE PRESENT APPEAL
[26]
3.1 Ground 1: Failure to consider the future
[30]
3.2 Ground 2: Failure to deal with the claim
[32]
3.3 Ground 3: Failure to adopt any active intellectual process
[44]
3.4 Ground 4: Error in rejecting a claim of fear of persecution as “speculation”
[47]
3.5 Ground 5: Onus of proof
[52]
3.6 Ground 6: Unreasonable finding of applicant’s credibility
[56]
4 DISPOSITION
[58]
BURLEY J:
1. INTRODUCTION
This is an appeal from the judgment and orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA) dismissing an…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZVDH v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
The case of SZVDH v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involved a Nepali national, SZVDH, who applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa in Australia. SZVDH arrived in Australia on a student visa in 2008 and applied for the visa after his student visa expired. The Delegate initially refused the visa application, a decision that was upheld by the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal). SZVDH appealed the Tribunal’s decision to the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues in the case were whether the Tribunal had addressed all of SZVDH's claims, adopted an active intellectual process, applied the correct legal tests, and made any unreasonable findings. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the Tribunal correctly applied the 'real chance' test and whether there was an onus of proof on SZVDH in the Tribunal proceedings.
The Federal Court found that the Tribunal had indeed addressed all of SZVDH's claims and applied an active intellectual process in its reasoning. The court examined whether the Tribunal applied the correct legal tests, particularly the 'real chance' test, which assesses whether there is a significant possibility of persecution if a person is returned to their country of origin. The court noted that the Tribunal had considered the appellant's claims in detail and had properly applied the legal standards. The Tribunal concluded that SZVDH did not have a well-founded fear of persecution as required under the 1951 Refugee Convention. The court also confirmed that there was no onus of proof on SZVDH in the Tribunal proceedings, aligning with established case law. Given these findings, the court held that the Tribunal's decision was not invalid due to any jurisdictional error.
The Federal Court dismissed the appeal and ordered that costs be paid by SZVDH. The court's decision underscored the limited role of the judiciary in reviewing the factual merits of the Tribunal's decisions, emphasizing the importance of the Tribunal's adherence to legal standards and proper application of the relevant legal tests.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed with costs.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Minister filed an outline of written submissions on 3 November 2016. At the commencement of the hearing, the appellant confirmed that the submissions had been translated for him.2. BACKGROUND2.1 The Visa application and the decision of the Delegate The appellant is a citizen of Nepal. He arrived in Australia on a student visa in November 2008. That visa ceased in May 2011 and he was then granted a further student visa in June 2011 which expired on 9 November 2011. The appellant was then provided with a succession of bridging visas and on 17 July 2013 he applied to the Department of Immigration for the Visa. On 24 December 2013, the Delegate refused to grant the Visa. In essence, the Delegate found that the appellant has an entitlement to statutory protection in a third country, India, and that accordingly he is not owed protection obligations by Australia in accordance with subsections 36(3), (4), (5) and (5A) of the Act.2.2 The Tribunal’s decision The appellant applied for a review of the Delegate’s decision. Submissions were filed on behalf of the appellant prior to the hearing by a firm of lawyers and migration agents. A hearing was conducted on 30 July 2014 at which the appellant was represented by his migration agent. The appellant gave evidence at the hearing and submissions were filed after the conclusion of the hearing on 22 August 2014. On 25 August 2014, the Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s decision not to grant the Visa. The Tribunal concluded that it was not satisfied that the appellant has a well-founded fear of persecution within the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (Convention). The appellant’s claims were set out in his Visa application, his handwritten statement, submissions provided by his advisers, in his statements made during his protection Visa interview, and his evidence given during the course of the hearing before the Tribunal. The handwritten document noted above, which was apparently in Nepalese, was attached to the appellant’s protection Visa application without a translation. At the hearing before the Tribunal, the appellant submitted a statement in English which he identified as a translation of this document. This document included claims made by him and attracted some attention in the present appeal. In summary, the appellant claimed that he had been obliged to leave his home village because members of the Nepalese Maoist Communist Party had begun to pressure him into joining in with their activities. He was resistant, and they threatened him and his parents. As a result, his parents sent him to another town for his higher education. However, when there, he began to receive threats from the Maoists again and also from another terrorism organisation referred to as Terai Mukti Morcha or Janatantrik Terai Mukti Morcha (JTMM) which, the country information revealed, is a terrorist organisation which seeks the independence of the Terai region from Nepal. As a result, his parents consented to the appellant travelling to Australia to continue his studies.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 24 December 2013, the Delegate refused to grant the Visa. In essence, the Delegate found that the appellant has an entitlement to statutory protection in a third country, India, and that accordingly he is not owed protection obligations by Australia in accordance with subsections 36(3), (4), (5) and (5A) of the Act.2.2 The Tribunal’s decision The appellant applied for a review of the Delegate’s decision. Submissions were filed on behalf of the appellant prior to the hearing by a firm of lawyers and migration agents. A hearing was conducted on 30 July 2014 at which the appellant was represented by his migration agent. The appellant gave evidence at the hearing and submissions were filed after the conclusion of the hearing on 22 August 2014. On 25 August 2014, the Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s decision not to grant the Visa. The Tribunal concluded that it was not satisfied that the appellant has a well-founded fear of persecution within the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees (Convention). The appellant’s claims were set out in his Visa application, his handwritten statement, submissions provided by his advisers, in his statements made during his protection Visa interview, and his evidence given during the course of the hearing before the Tribunal. The handwritten document noted above, which was apparently in Nepalese, was attached to the appellant’s protection Visa application without a translation. At the hearing before the Tribunal, the appellant submitted a statement in English which he identified as a translation of this document. This document included claims made by him and attracted some attention in the present appeal. In summary, the appellant claimed that he had been obliged to leave his home village because members of the Nepalese Maoist Communist Party had begun to pressure him into joining in with their activities. He was resistant, and they threatened him and his parents. As a result, his parents sent him to another town for his higher education. However, when there, he began to receive threats from the Maoists again and also from another terrorism organisation referred to as Terai Mukti Morcha or Janatantrik Terai Mukti Morcha (JTMM) which, the country information revealed, is a terrorist organisation which seeks the independence of the Terai region from Nepal. As a result, his parents consented to the appellant travelling to Australia to continue his studies. The factual basis for the appellant’s claims before the Tribunal was recorded by the Tribunal to be as follows:(1)The appellant’s parents had previously supported the Maoists and for this reason he was more susceptible to the pressures that they placed on him to join them.(2)His father is a civil servant and owns a large amount of agricultural land, deriving income from it. His parents continue to live in his home village.(3)He endured threats from the Maoists in his home village and when he resisted their invitations to join them, they forcibly took him to attend various programs. To avoid the threat of physical harm that would result if he continued to resist, he moved to a larger town, remote from his home village, to continue his studies.(4)At the new town, the appellant began to receive threats from JTMM, who accused him of being from a social and cultural background which was different to theirs. They threatened him with physical harm. He was concerned that if they saw him they would seize him and make him carry out criminal activities. On one occasion, he heard members of the JTMM discussing him and his origins. He feared that they would attack him and so he ran away.(5)The JTMM had tried to catch him two or three times, but he was able to run away from them. Had they caught him they would have killed him or forced him to join in their activities. When asked about the circumstances in which these incidents happened, he said that he had been living in a friend’s apartment for ten months while he studied. He was on his bicycle when they approached him, but he was able to pedal away. They had not done anything else to him.(6)The Tribunal noted that the country information indicates that JTMM is a Madhesi organisation which supports the rights of the Madhesi people in the Terai. The Tribunal suggested that the JTMM would not be interested in inviting him to join them, to which he responded that they could not use Madhesi people to do “bad things for them and instead used non-Madhesis for this purpose”.(7)The Tribunal suggested to the appellant that it was difficult to believe that he would be at risk from harm from the Maoists or the JTMM given that he “never suffered harm from these bodies in the past and had been away from Nepal for six years”. He responded that they had already targeted him and if they saw him again they would harm him. This was why his parents had advised him that he would be better to remain in Australia.(8)The appellant recorded his concern that the Maoists would ask him for a large amount of money if he was returned from Australia. He was concerned that if he could not pay them “anything could happen”.(9)The Tribunal expressed scepticism about the assertion that the appellant had left Nepal in fear of his life, because he had received his student visa in October 2008, but had not left Nepal for another three weeks. His response was that at the time of receiving his visa he had been in Kathmandu and that this city was removed from the town where he had previously been studying and from where the threats were made. He also said this was the “minimum time in which he could leave”.(10)The Tribunal also recorded scepticism arising from the delay of nearly five years that took place between the appellant’s arrival in Australia and his submission of his application for the Visa. He responded by saying that he did not need to claim protection until his student visa had run out.(11)The appellant expressed concern that if he returns to Nepal, the Maoists and the JTTM “can do anything to him”. They will pressure him and ask for donations because they will assume he must be wealthy as he comes from a foreign country (this claim is addressed in further detail below).