SZUAS v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZUAS v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCA 481

Appeal from: SZUAS v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 1953
File number: NSD 1233 of 2019
Judge: ANDERSON J
Date of judgment: 16 April 2020
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – appeal from decision of Federal Circuit Court of Australia (Circuit Court) dismissing application for judicial review of decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) not to grant protection visa – where grounds of review raised in Federal Court of Australia were not advanced in the Circuit Court – whether sufficient merit in proposed grounds – whether Tribunal unreasonably or illogically failed to give weight to, or rejected, expert medical information – whether Tribunal failed to have regard to evidence that appellant was taking anti-depressant medication – whether Tribunal failed to consider effect of appellant’s mental health issues

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to rely on new grounds of review that were not advanced in the Circuit Court – application for leave to adduce fresh evidence on appeal

Held: appeal dismissed – leave to rely on proposed grounds of appeal refused – insufficient merit in proposed grounds of appeal

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 36.57

Cases cited:

AFE18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 162

AGA16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 628

Alliance Craton Explore Pty Ltd v Quasar Resources Pty Ltd [2013] FCAFC 29; 296 ALR 465

BEP19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCA 80

CSF17 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 569

FBR18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2019] FCA 1620

GGD18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2019] FCA 1463

Han v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 331

MZZUQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 157; 145 ALD 662

Sami v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCAFC 128; 139 ALD 1

SZUAS v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 1953

Date of hearing: 13 March 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 41
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mr D R Taylor of Sydney West Legal and Migration
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr J Kay Hoyle
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent filed a submitting notice save as to
costs

ORDERS

NSD 1233 of 2019
BETWEEN:

SZUAS

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

ANDERSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 APRIL 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is dismissed.

2.The appellant pay:

(a)the first respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the vacation of the hearing of the appeal on 10 February 2020; and

(b)the first respondent’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZUAS v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 481
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of SZUAS v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involves an appeal against the decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which dismissed the applicant's application for judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal not to grant him a protection visa. The applicant, a 22-year-old Pashtun male from Pakistan, claims he is a practising Shia Muslim and fears returning to Pakistan due to threats from the Taliban. The Tribunal found the applicant's claims to be inconsistent and did not accept that his mental health issues explained the inconsistencies. The applicant sought to appeal the Tribunal's decision on various grounds, including that the Tribunal failed to properly consider his mental health and whether he could receive medical services in Pakistan.

The primary legal issue in this appeal was whether the Tribunal unreasonably or illogically failed to give weight to, or rejected, the applicant's expert medical information and his mental health issues. Additionally, the Court had to determine if the Tribunal failed to have proper regard to the evidence that the applicant was taking anti-depressant medication and the impact of his mental health issues on his ability to provide coherent evidence.

The Court found that the proposed grounds of appeal did not have sufficient merit to warrant allowing the applicant to rely on them. The Court concluded that the Tribunal had considered the medical evidence, but it was not satisfied that the reports overcame the problematic nature of the applicant's evidence. The Tribunal's findings were based on the applicant's inconsistent evidence and the fact that the medical reports did not indicate that he had catastrophic memory loss or an inability to recall basic facts. The Court held that the Tribunal did not act irrationally or unreasonably in not accepting the medical evidence because the reports were based on what the applicant had reported about his past events.

The appeal was dismissed, and the Court ordered the applicant to pay costs to the Minister.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The appellant pay:

(a) the first respondent’s costs thrown away by reason of the vacation of the hearing of the appeal on 10 February 2020; and

(b) the first respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal generally,

fixed in the lump sum amount of $12,198.10.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant’s appeal to this Court is accordingly dismissed.Background The applicant arrived in Australia on 22 July 2012. He applied for a protection visa on 20 November 2012. His claims were summarised in the reasons of the Circuit Court (SZUAS v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2019] FCCA 1953) at [3] as follows:a) The applicant is a 22-year-old Pashtun male from Parachinar, Kurram Agency, Khyber-Pakhtunhkua, Pakistan, and is a practising Shia Muslim.b) When he was a student the applicant received several threatening letters “signed by the Taliban warning that if we Shias did not leave Pakistan we would be killed”. The Taliban had road blocks, checking cars randomly, and they usually beheaded any Shias they found.c) In July 2011, while travelling from Peshawar to Parachinar, the applicant was detained by the Taliban. The Taliban did not identify the applicant as a Shia because he did not carry with him any identification, and he did not carry any scars on his back because he did not believe in flagellation on Ashura day. This incident scared the applicant, and his parents told him he had to discontinue his studies in Peshawar, and leave Pakistan altogether.d) He fears returning to Pakistan because he is recognisably Shia, the Pakistani Sunnis say Shias are infidels, and they have declared Jihad against Shias all over Pakistan. On 6 August 2013, a delegate of the Minister rejected the appellant’s visa application and, on 23 January 2014, the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) affirmed the delegate’s decision. However, on 20 August 2015, the Circuit Court, by consent, set aside the RRT’s decision and ordered the Tribunal to reconsider the applicant’s review application according to law.Tribunal’s decision On 22 February 2016, the Tribunal, upon its reconsideration of the appellant’s review application, determined to affirm the delegate’s decision not to grant the appellant a protection visa. Before both the RRT and the Tribunal, the appellant relied on evidence concerning his mental state as an explanation for the manner in which he gave, and the inconsistencies in, his evidence. Before the RRT, the appellant provided written submissions dated 22 November 2013, including a submission about matters affecting the appellant’s credibility. Before the Tribunal, the appellant provided another written submission dated 24 January 2016, which dealt with certain mental health issues, and also relied on a psychologist’s report dated 17 March 2014, a further written submission dated 6 February 2016, a hospital Transfer Discharge Summary dated 30 November 2015, and letters dated 7 January and 25 January 2016 from Dr Bronwyn Wells (Dr Wells). In its statement of decision and reasons (AAT Reasons), the Tribunal, in summary:(a)referred to the evidence before the Tribunal: AAT Reasons at [11]–[21];(b)noted that Dr Wells had referred to the appellant’s inability to accurately testify: ibid at [16]–[17];(c)accepted that the appellant suffered from depression and associated medical and psychological conditions, but did not accept that he had attempted to commit suicide or that his memory had been catastrophically impaired (as submitted by the appellant): ibid at [24] and [51]–[53];(d)took into account that there were a number of inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence and claims, including about his addresses, the letters he claimed to have received, the incidents with the Taliban and his father’s position in the Jirga: ibid at [25]–[43]. The Tribunal moreover found that the appellant had provided a variety of explanations to the Tribunal for the inconsistencies in his evidence: ibid at [44]–[47];(e)considered the appellant’s psychological problems and the fact of his mother’s death: ibid at [49]–[52]; and(f)held that it was not satisfied that the medical or psychological reports overcame the problematic nature of the appellant’s evidence: ibid at [54].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following paragraphs of the AAT Reasons summarised the Tribunal’s view as to the veracity of the appellant’s claims to past harm:CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEDoes the applicant have a well founded fear of being persecuted for one or more of the five reasons set out in the Refugees Convention?…[24]Having considered all of the evidence in relation to the applicant’s claims regarding his experiences in Pakistan, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant has given a truthful account of these experiences. Although the Tribunal accepts that the applicant is suffering from depression and associated medical and psychological conditions, and his medical practitioner was told that he had a “suicide attempt”, the hospital report provided at the Tribunal’s request after the hearing indicates that he was suffering from suicidal ideas whilst he was at home but he did not attempt self harm or attempt to take his own life. The Tribunal does not accept that this constitutes a “suicide attempt” as reported by the medical practitioner who appears to have relied on the applicant’s account of the incident. The Tribunal also does not accept the submission that the applicant’s memory has been “catastrophically” impaired or affected by his experiences. The Tribunal does not accept that this is consistent with any of the medical or psychological reports provided which, whilst referring to difficulties and depression and post traumatic stress arising from the applicant’s experiences, his uncertain immigration status and the death of his mother, do not indicate that he has “catastrophic” memory recall or an inability to recall very basic facts relating to his claims for protection. The Tribunal is drawn to the conclusion that the applicant has manufactured his claims to have been sought by the Taliban and has attempted to rely on his psychological problems to overcome his inability to provide a reasonably consistent or coherent account of his experiences in Pakistan. ……Conclusion on past harm…[54]As the Tribunal has stated above, the applicant has conflated and jumbled his claims regarding to incidents to a significant degree, and the Tribunal has not accepted the explanations for the problematic nature of his evidence. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was involved in incidents on the road with the Taliban. The Tribunal also does not accept that the applicant moved around in either Peshawar of Lahore to avoid threats from the Taliban. The Tribunal also does not accept that the applicant’s father held a position of responsibility in the Shia community in Parachinar. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant’s father held a position of responsibility in the Shia community or that his brother was kidnapped of that the applicant does not know where he is. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was ever targeted by the Taliban, and accepts only that the extent of his contact was general letters which were left at the hostel in Parachinar. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was targeted by the Tribunal or any other insurgent group at any time. The Tribunal is prepared to accept that the applicant’s mother is deceased and he may know of people who have dies as a result of attacks from the Taliban or other extremist groups, but the Tribunal does not accept that his mother dies shortly before the first hearing of that this affected his ability to give evidence at the first Tribunal hearing. The Tribunal has found his evidence in relation to his mother’s death and the effect that this had upon him to be extremely problematic. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the medical or psychological reports overcome the problematic nature of the applicant’s evidence. As stated above, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the medical practitioners or psychologists have any personal knowledge of the applicant’s experiences in Pakistan, apart from what has been reported to them by the applicant.Federal Circuit Court’s decision

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 6 August 2013, a delegate of the Minister rejected the appellant’s visa application and, on 23 January 2014, the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) affirmed the delegate’s decision. However, on 20 August 2015, the Circuit Court, by consent, set aside the RRT’s decision and ordered the Tribunal to reconsider the applicant’s review application according to law.Tribunal’s decision On 22 February 2016, the Tribunal, upon its reconsideration of the appellant’s review application, determined to affirm the delegate’s decision not to grant the appellant a protection visa. Before both the RRT and the Tribunal, the appellant relied on evidence concerning his mental state as an explanation for the manner in which he gave, and the inconsistencies in, his evidence. Before the RRT, the appellant provided written submissions dated 22 November 2013, including a submission about matters affecting the appellant’s credibility. Before the Tribunal, the appellant provided another written submission dated 24 January 2016, which dealt with certain mental health issues, and also relied on a psychologist’s report dated 17 March 2014, a further written submission dated 6 February 2016, a hospital Transfer Discharge Summary dated 30 November 2015, and letters dated 7 January and 25 January 2016 from Dr Bronwyn Wells (Dr Wells). In its statement of decision and reasons (AAT Reasons), the Tribunal, in summary:(a)referred to the evidence before the Tribunal: AAT Reasons at [11]–[21];(b)noted that Dr Wells had referred to the appellant’s inability to accurately testify: ibid at [16]–[17];(c)accepted that the appellant suffered from depression and associated medical and psychological conditions, but did not accept that he had attempted to commit suicide or that his memory had been catastrophically impaired (as submitted by the appellant): ibid at [24] and [51]–[53];(d)took into account that there were a number of inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence and claims, including about his addresses, the letters he claimed to have received, the incidents with the Taliban and his father’s position in the Jirga: ibid at [25]–[43]. The Tribunal moreover found that the appellant had provided a variety of explanations to the Tribunal for the inconsistencies in his evidence: ibid at [44]–[47];(e)considered the appellant’s psychological problems and the fact of his mother’s death: ibid at [49]–[52]; and(f)held that it was not satisfied that the medical or psychological reports overcame the problematic nature of the appellant’s evidence: ibid at [54]. The following paragraphs of the AAT Reasons summarised the Tribunal’s view as to the veracity of the appellant’s claims to past harm:CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEDoes the applicant have a well founded fear of being persecuted for one or more of the five reasons set out in the Refugees Convention?…[24]Having considered all of the evidence in relation to the applicant’s claims regarding his experiences in Pakistan, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant has given a truthful account of these experiences. Although the Tribunal accepts that the applicant is suffering from depression and associated medical and psychological conditions, and his medical practitioner was told that he had a “suicide attempt”, the hospital report provided at the Tribunal’s request after the hearing indicates that he was suffering from suicidal ideas whilst he was at home but he did not attempt self harm or attempt to take his own life. The Tribunal does not accept that this constitutes a “suicide attempt” as reported by the medical practitioner who appears to have relied on the applicant’s account of the incident. The Tribunal also does not accept the submission that the applicant’s memory has been “catastrophically” impaired or affected by his experiences. The Tribunal does not accept that this is consistent with any of the medical or psychological reports provided which, whilst referring to difficulties and depression and post traumatic stress arising from the applicant’s experiences, his uncertain immigration status and the death of his mother, do not indicate that he has “catastrophic” memory recall or an inability to recall very basic facts relating to his claims for protection. The Tribunal is drawn to the conclusion that the applicant has manufactured his claims to have been sought by the Taliban and has attempted to rely on his psychological problems to overcome his inability to provide a reasonably consistent or coherent account of his experiences in Pakistan. ……Conclusion on past harm…[54]As the Tribunal has stated above, the applicant has conflated and jumbled his claims regarding to incidents to a significant degree, and the Tribunal has not accepted the explanations for the problematic nature of his evidence. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was involved in incidents on the road with the Taliban. The Tribunal also does not accept that the applicant moved around in either Peshawar of Lahore to avoid threats from the Taliban. The Tribunal also does not accept that the applicant’s father held a position of responsibility in the Shia community in Parachinar. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant’s father held a position of responsibility in the Shia community or that his brother was kidnapped of that the applicant does not know where he is. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was ever targeted by the Taliban, and accepts only that the extent of his contact was general letters which were left at the hostel in Parachinar. The Tribunal does not accept that the applicant was targeted by the Tribunal or any other insurgent group at any time. The Tribunal is prepared to accept that the applicant’s mother is deceased and he may know of people who have dies as a result of attacks from the Taliban or other extremist groups, but the Tribunal does not accept that his mother dies shortly before the first hearing of that this affected his ability to give evidence at the first Tribunal hearing. The Tribunal has found his evidence in relation to his mother’s death and the effect that this had upon him to be extremely problematic. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the medical or psychological reports overcome the problematic nature of the applicant’s evidence. As stated above, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the medical practitioners or psychologists have any personal knowledge of the applicant’s experiences in Pakistan, apart from what has been reported to them by the applicant.Federal Circuit Court’s decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The four grounds of review relied on by the appellant in his amended application in the Circuit Court (disregarding the accompanying particulars) stated as follows:Ground 1: The Tribunal failed to take into account relevantly, the mental state of the applicant and as such, there was an insufficient logical or evidentiary basis for Tribunal’s adverse credibility finding against the applicant.…Ground 2: There was an insufficient logical or evidentiary basis for the finding by the Tribunal that the applicant did not face a real risk of harm if refouled to Pakistan.…Ground 3: The Tribunal failed to consider relevantly, whether the applicant can receive medical health services in Pakistan…Ground 4: The non-disclosure of information under section 438 of the Migration Act 1858 [sic] (Cth) As explained below, the appellant advances related, but different, grounds for impugning the Tribunal’s decision in this Court. As such, it is strictly unnecessary to detail the Circuit Court’s reasoning for dismissing each of the grounds of review advanced in that Court. However, the first ground of review advanced in the Circuit Court bears some resemblance to the grounds of appeal raised in this Court. It is accordingly convenient to extract part of the Circuit Court’s reasoning in relation to that ground of review:Did the Tribunal actively consider the medical evidence?[31] I do not accept the Tribunal did not actively consider the medical evidence on which the applicant relied. As I have already noted, the Tribunal identified the medical evidence, and the submissions the applicant made on the basis of those submissions. The Tribunal also considered that evidence. That is evident from the Tribunal’s having accepted the applicant suffers from psychological problems and is distressed and worried about his migration outcome. It is also evident from the Tribunal’s referring to the medical and psychological evidence and finding it was not satisfied that the evidence explained what the Tribunal found was the applicant’s inconsistent evidence. Its findings were based on a number of matters. First, the applicant did not raise his psychological difficulties as a reason for poor memory until after the RRT made its decision. Second, the Tribunal considered the medical and psychological evidence itself which it found did not indicate the applicant “has “catastrophic” memory recall or an inability to recall very basic facts relating to his claims for protection”. That was a finding open to it. The psychologist’s report dated 17 March 2014 referred to the applicant’s having displayed a “relatively good insight into his experiences, as evidenced by his ability to state his past traumatic experiences, current worries and escalating anxiety”. And although the two medical certificates dated 7 and 25 January 2016 expressed the opinions that the applicant would find it “difficult to concentrate in court and answer questions accurately”, and that “the current severity of his depression means that it will affect his ability to accurately testify in court”, they do not say the applicant had catastrophic memory loss. Nor do they express opinions about the applicant’s mental health at the time he had given what the Tribunal found was inconsistent evidence, and how this could have impacted on the applicant’s ability to give accurate evidence. [32]At one point of its reasons the Tribunal said that the psychologists had posited that the applicant’s inability to recall basic claims or to provide at least a reasonably consistent account of his experience is due to “traumatic events”. That, however, is not an opinion expressed by any of the reports that referred to the applicant’s mental health. It is reasonable to suppose that the Tribunal here had in mind the journal article on which the applicant’s representative relied in her written submissions dated 24 January 2016 for submitting that the applicant’s inconsistencies as identified by the RRT “can be explained by stress, memory loss and the destructive impact of trauma on memory function” and that, “the inconsistencies in the Applicant’s account are consistent with the Applicant’s claimed position”. In any event, the Tribunal did not accept these opinions because the psychologists “have no direct knowledge of the applicant’s experiences in Pakistan and have relied on the applicant’s account of those experiences”.Did the Tribunal act irrationally or unreasonably in not accepting the medical evidence?[33] This part of the applicant’s claims assumes that the medical reports that were before the Tribunal were reasonably capable of supporting a finding that the inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence the Tribunal identified, and on which it relied for not accepting the applicant’s claims, is to be explained by the applicant’s mental health, and in particular the mental difficulties caused by the applicant’s claimed loss of his mother. That assumption is incorrect. As I have already noted, the psychologist’s report dated 17 March 2014 referred to the applicant’s having displayed a “relatively good insight into his experiences, as evidenced by his ability to state his past traumatic experiences, current worries and escalating anxiety”. And although the two medical certificates dated 7 and 25 January 2016 expressed the opinions that the applicant would find it “difficult to concentrate in court and answer questions accurately”, and that “the current severity of his depression means that it will affect his ability to accurately testify in court”, they did not express any opinion about whether these conditions of the applicant explained or could explain inconsistencies in the applicant’s account of his past in Pakistan. There is nothing in the reports that could reasonably suggest the applicant brought to the attention of those who prepared the reports that he had given inconsistent accounts of what had occurred to him in Pakistan. For this reason alone, the Tribunal did not act irrationally or unreasonably by relying on the applicant’s inconsistencies as a ground for not accepting his claims about what occurred to him in Pakistan, notwithstanding the reports concerning the applicant’s mental health that were before it.[34] Even if the psychological reports and other materials that were before the Tribunal could reasonably be interpreted as conveying the opinion that the applicant’s inconsistent evidence could be explained by the applicant’s mental difficulties, or by his claimed trauma, it was reasonably open to the Tribunal not to accept an opinion to that effect for the reasons it gave, namely, that the reports themselves were based on what the applicant had reported about his past events.(Citations omitted.)Appeal to this Court