SZRUT v Minister for Immigration & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZRUT v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2015] FCCA 263
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Refugee Review Tribunal – whether it was reasonable to seek protection in a third country – application dismissed.

Legislation:  

Migration Act 1958
Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal India–Nepal, signed 31 July 1950, 1302 UNTS 4 (entered into force 31 July 1950).

Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship v SZRHU  [2013] FCAFC 91
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj [2002] HCA 11

SZRTC v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 43
SZTQN v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCCA 188

Applicant: SZRUT
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 944 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Street
Hearing date: 5 February 2015
Date of Last Submission: 5 February 2015
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 5 February 2015

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: In person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr B D Kaplan
Solicitors for the Respondent: DLA Piper

ORDERS

  1. The application for leave to extend time under s.477 of the Migration Act 1958 be dismissed.

  2. The applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $6825.

  3. I direct pursuant to s.91X of the Migration Act 1958 that the name of the Applicant and date of birth in the transcript of the proceedings not be published.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA

AT SYDNEY

SYG 944 of 2014

SZRUT

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This is a matter within the court’s jurisdiction under s.476 of the Migration Act 1958 in which the applicant is seeking a constitutional writ.  The grounds of the application are as follows. 

    1. The Refugee Review Tribunal erred in law in considering that I have a right to enter and reside in India a country I have never lived.

    2. The Tribunal failed to consider my subjective well founded fear of persecution and the violence against Christians in India, fear of sexual harassment and rape and other problems such as lacking Indian language.

    3. The Tribunal misunderstood my case and misapplied the law.

  2. The proceedings were commenced on 7 April 2014 and leave is required under s.477. This is a case in which the question of leave really turns on the substance of the merits of the application advanced asserting jurisdictional error in the decision of the Tribunal delivered on 19 February 2014. The applicant had made an application for a Protection (Class XA) visa under s.65 of the Act. The applicant was found to be a citizen of Nepal and the delegate refused to grant the visa on 22 March 2012.

  3. The matter was previously considered by a Tribunal differently constituted (the first Tribunal). As a result of a judicial review, the case was returned to the Tribunal by the Federal Court on 20 November 2013 ( the second Tribunal). In the reasons for decision the second Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZRUT v Minister for Immigration & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 263
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, SZRUT, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration and the second respondent, the Department of Home Affairs, concerning the applicant's visa status. The dispute centred on the Minister's decision to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection Visa (Class XA) and to cancel the applicant's substantive visa. The matter came before Judge Street in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the delegate of the Minister had erred in law in their assessment of the applicant's claims for protection, specifically in relation to the assessment of whether the applicant would be a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth). This involved a consideration of whether the delegate had properly applied the relevant legislative criteria and case law concerning the assessment of claims for protection.

Judge Street's reasoning focused on the proper interpretation and application of the non-refoulement obligations under international law, as incorporated into Australian domestic law. The Court examined the delegate's findings regarding the applicant's fear of persecution and the assessment of the real chance of harm. The judge applied established principles of administrative law, including the requirement for a decision-maker to undertake a comprehensive and logical assessment of the evidence presented, and to provide adequate reasons for their findings. The Court considered whether the delegate's decision was affected by jurisdictional error, particularly in relation to the evaluation of the credibility of the applicant's claims and the assessment of the risk of harm upon return to their country of origin.

The Court found that the delegate had made a jurisdictional error in their assessment of the applicant's claims. Consequently, the decision of the Minister to refuse the Protection Visa was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Department of Home Affairs for redetermination according to law.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, a citizen of Nepal, applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa under the Migration Act 1958. The delegate initially refused the application on 22 March 2011. The applicant applied to the Refugee Review Tribunal for a review of the delegate's decision. The matter was considered by a differently constituted Tribunal, referred to as the first Tribunal. The first Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision and the applicant applied for a review of the first Tribunal's decision. This review was considered by another differently constituted Tribunal, referred to as the second Tribunal. The second Tribunal affirmed the decision of the first Tribunal not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa.

The applicant is a Christian who claims that she will be persecuted in Nepal because of her Christian faith. The applicant also claims that she will be discriminated against in Nepal because she is a woman. The applicant claims that she cannot relocate to India because of the discrimination there and refers to reports of rape and assault of foreigners in India. The first Tribunal put to the applicant that she could reasonably relocate to India if she feared harm in Nepal, given that she had lived and been academically successful in Singapore and Australia. The first Tribunal also noted that the Constitution of India protects religious freedom and that there is a concentration of a Christian population in the north-eastern states in India. The first Tribunal concluded that the applicant could reasonably relocate to India if she feared harm in Nepal.

The second Tribunal considered the applicant's claims and noted that the applicant had a right to reside in India pursuant to the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950. The second Tribunal noted that the provisions of the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950 granted Nepalese nationals in India the same privileges in the matter of residence, ownership, property, participation of trade, commerce, movement and other privileges of a similar nature as Indian nationals in Nepal. The second Tribunal concluded that, as a matter of practical reality, the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India. The second Tribunal found that it was not satisfied that the applicant had a well-founded fear of Convention-related persecution in India or that there are substantial grounds for believing that, as a necessary or foreseeable consequence of her availing herself of her right to enter and reside in India, there would be a real risk that she will suffer significant harm. The second Tribunal concluded that Australia does not have protection obligations in respect of the applicant and affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa.

This case before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia involves an appeal by the applicant, SZRUT, against the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (the "Tribunal") which affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse a Protection (Class XA) visa under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958. The Tribunal found that the applicant, a citizen of Nepal, had a right to enter and reside in India and therefore, Australia did not owe protection obligations to her. The applicant's application for a Protection visa was initially refused by the delegate on 22 March 2012. The applicant then applied to the Tribunal for a review, which was conducted by a differently constituted Tribunal (the "first Tribunal"). However, a judicial review was subsequently lodged by the applicant in the Federal Court, which resulted in the case being returned to the Tribunal by the Federal Court on 20 November 2013 (the "second Tribunal"). The second Tribunal identified the criteria for a protection visa and the alternative criteria under s.36(2) of the Migration Act 1958. The second Tribunal also considered the applicant's claims for protection and whether she had a right to enter and reside in India under s.36(3) of the Act. The second Tribunal concluded that the applicant had a right to enter and reside in India and affirmed the decision not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant then filed an application for leave to extend time under s.477 of the Migration Act 1958 and sought constitutional relief. The Court dismissed the application for leave to extend time and found that there was no jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Refugee Review Tribunal erred in law in considering that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India a country she has never lived in.
2. Whether the Tribunal failed to consider the applicant's subjective well-founded fear of persecution and the violence against Christians in India, fear of sexual harassment and rape, and other problems such as lacking the Indian language.
3. Whether the Tribunal misunderstood the applicant's case and misapplied the law.
4. Whether the applicant's claims of discrimination in Nepal and India were considered by the Tribunal and if the Tribunal was correct in finding that Australia does not owe protection obligations to the applicant because she has a right to enter and reside in India.
5. Whether the Tribunal was correct in finding that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950.

Held
1. Whether the Refugee Review Tribunal erred in law in considering that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India a country she has never lived in.
The court concluded that the Tribunal was correct in finding that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950.
2. Whether the Tribunal failed to consider the applicant's subjective well-founded fear of persecution and the violence against Christians in India, fear of sexual harassment and rape, and other problems such as lacking the Indian language.
The court concluded that the Tribunal had considered the applicant's subjective fear of persecution and found it to be unfounded.
3. Whether the Tribunal misunderstood the applicant's case and misapplied the law.
The court concluded that the Tribunal did not misunderstand the applicant's case and misapply the law.
4. Whether the applicant's claims of discrimination in Nepal and India were considered by the Tribunal and if the Tribunal was correct in finding that Australia does not owe protection obligations to the applicant because she has a right to enter and reside in India.
The court concluded that the Tribunal had considered the applicant's claims of discrimination and found them to be unsubstantiated.
5. Whether the Tribunal was correct in finding that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950.
The court concluded that the Tribunal was correct in finding that the applicant has a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia dismissed the applicant's application for leave to extend time and for a constitutional writ. The applicant argued that the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) erred in law by considering she had a right to enter and reside in India, a country she has never lived in. The Court found that the Tribunal had properly considered the applicant's claims and did not err in finding she had a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950.

The applicant also argued that the Tribunal failed to consider her subjective fear of persecution and violence against Christians in India, fear of sexual harassment and rape, and other problems such as lacking the Indian language. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the applicant's claims and found that she did not have a well-founded fear of persecution or significant harm in India. The Court found that the Tribunal's decision was open on the material before it and that there was no legal error in the Tribunal's approach.

The applicant further argued that the Tribunal misunderstood her case and misapplied the law. The Court found that the Tribunal had properly understood and reviewed the applicant's case in accordance with the procedural requirements of the Migration Act 1958 and that the findings adverse to the applicant were open. The Court found that there was no legal error in the Tribunal's approach and that the findings were open on the material before the Tribunal.

Finally, the applicant argued that the Tribunal failed to consider her claims of discrimination in Nepal and India and that the Tribunal was incorrect in finding that Australia does not owe protection obligations to the applicant because she has a right to enter and reside in India. The Court found that the Tribunal had considered the applicant's claims and found that Australia did not owe protection obligations to the applicant because she had a right to enter and reside in India. The Court found that the Tribunal's decision was open on the material before it and that there was no legal error in the Tribunal's approach.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Tribunal did not err in law in finding that the applicant had a right to enter and reside in India under the Treaty of Peace and Friendship between India and Nepal 1950 and that Australia did not owe protection obligations to the applicant because of this right. The Court found that the Tribunal had properly considered the applicant's claims and that the findings were open on the material before the Tribunal. The Court also found that there was no legal error in the Tribunal's approach and that the findings were open. The Court distinguished the approach in SZRTC v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 43 and SZTQN v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCCA 188, finding that any error in the Tribunal's approach was one of no materiality given the adverse findings made under s.36(3) of the Migration Act 1958.