SZLRD v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZLRD v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2008] FMCA 462
MIGRATION – Review of Refugee Review Tribunal decision – refusal of a protection visa – applicant claiming political and religious persecution in India – Tribunal finding applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution by reference to country information – whether the Tribunal breached s.425 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) considered – applicant seeking opportunity to comment on country information referred to at Tribunal hearing – Tribunal supplying partially inaudible sound recording of the hearing – Tribunal failing to offer alternative means of dealing with the country information referred to – Tribunal apparently extending an invitation to comment but not providing the means to do so – jurisdictional error established.
Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.422B, 424A, 425, 430
Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 180 ALR 1
NAFF v Minister for Immigration [2004] HCA 62; (2004) 221 CLR 1
Applicant: SZLRD
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP
Second Respondent: REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 3598 of 2007
Judgment of: Driver FM
Hearing date: 11 April 2008
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 16 May 2008

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms N Walker
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Cleary
Solicitors for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

  1. The Court directs that the name of the applicant is not to appear on the transcript of proceedings.

  2. A writ of certiorari shall issue, quashing the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal signed on 25 October 2007 and handed down on the same day.

  3. A writ of mandamus shall issue requiring the Tribunal to redetermine the review application before it according to law.

  4. The first respondent shall pay the applicant’s costs and disbursements of and incidental to the application in the sum of $5,000 in accordance with rule 44.15(1) and item 1(c) of part 2 of schedule 1 to the Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth).

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 3598 of 2007

SZLRD

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP

First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. This is an application to review a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).  The decision was handed down on 25 October 2007.  The Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a protection visa.  The applicant is from India and had made claims of religious and political persecution.  Background facts relating to the applicant’s protection visa claims and the Tribunal’s decision on them are set out in the Minister’s written submissions filed on 8 April 2008 and the applicant’s written submissions filed on 3 April 2008.  The following statement of background facts is derived from those submissions.

  2. The applicant is from the Punjab state of India, born on 6 December 1964, arrived in Australia on 28 March 2007 and applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZLRD v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FMCA 462
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, SZLRD, sought judicial review of a decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) to refuse his application for a protection visa. The Tribunal had found that SZLRD did not meet the definition of a refugee as set out in the Migration Act. The primary issue before the court was whether the Tribunal breached section 425 of the Migration Act by failing to ensure that the Tribunal hearing was recorded in a manner that allowed for a proper review of its decision. The court had to determine if the Tribunal's reliance on an audio recording, which was of such poor quality that it rendered the recording largely unusable, was in breach of the statutory requirement.

The court found that the quality of the audio recording was so poor that it was impossible to adequately review the Tribunal's decision. The applicant's agent had highlighted the poor quality of the recording and requested additional time to review the material, but the Tribunal proceeded to hand down its decision without addressing these concerns. The court held that the Tribunal's failure to provide an adequate recording meant that the applicant was unable to properly challenge the Tribunal's decision, thus breaching section 425 of the Migration Act. The court concluded that the Tribunal's actions were unreasonable and that the decision should be quashed.

The court issued a writ of certiorari to quash the Tribunal's decision and a writ of mandamus to require the Tribunal to redetermine the application according to law. The Minister was ordered to pay the applicant's costs and disbursements in the sum of $5,000. The court also directed that the applicant's name should not appear on the transcript of proceedings to protect his privacy.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Court directs that the name of the applicant is not to appear on the transcript of proceedings.

2.

A writ of certiorari shall issue, quashing the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal signed on 25 October 2007 and handed down on the same day.

3.

A writ of mandamus shall issue requiring the Tribunal to redetermine the review application before it according to law.

4.

The first respondent shall pay the applicant’s costs and disbursements of and incidental to the application in the sum of $5,000 in accordance with rule 44.15(1) and item 1(c) of part 2 of schedule 1 to the

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 24 October 2007 the applicant’s agent sent a facsimile to the Tribunal relevantly stating[23]:Please find attached a ruff [sic] letter responding to what little could be heard from the CD. Also kindly excuse the lateness of this as I have been trying to hear what was said on the CD. Supportive evidence has not been supplied as I am not sure what the reasons for possible refusal are. (emphasis added)[23] CB 147 On the same day the agent wrote again to the Tribunal to complain about the quality of the fresh CD that had been supplied. In particular, the agent stated[24]:I have received a new CD of the hearing, however, this one although it has no errors, is still very bad and in fact it is so bad that I have been unable to hear the “Independent Information” put to the above-named. As I do have some hearing problems, I requested others to listen to the CD and tell me what the Independent Information was. However, they have just reported back and informed me that they were also unable to hear what information was put to the above-named client during the hearing.[24] CB 148 The following day the Tribunal confirmed by letter that the Tribunal’s decision would be handed down on 25 October 2007[25].[25] CB 149 In its reasons for decision the Tribunal dealt with the circumstances in the following terms[26]:The Tribunal has considered the concerns raised by the representative (as well as the additional comments and information provided in his faxed letter dated 24 October 2007) and has decided to proceed with the handing down of the decision on 25 October 2007. The principal factors in the Tribunal’s decision to proceed with the handing down are as follows:· The representative was present with the applicant at the hearing.· The Tribunal has listened to the second CD recording of the hearing and considers that the comments by the Presiding Member and other participants at the hearing are audible.· The quality of the sound in the second CD recording is the best that the Tribunal’s technical staff can produce.· In the interests of procedural fairness the Tribunal chose to put to the applicant at the hearing independent country information not specifically about the applicant on which the Tribunal subsequently relied in making its decision. The Tribunal notes, however, that under s.424A(3)(a) of the Act, the Tribunal is not obliged to put such information in writing to the applicant.[26] CB 160 For the purposes of the proceeding in this Court the applicant attempted to have a transcript of the Tribunal hearing prepared by Spark & Cannon. The quality of the sound recording was so poor that Spark & Cannon was unable to prepare a transcript. The Minister arranged for the purported transcript now in evidence to be prepared by Auscript but Auscript also noted that the sound quality of the audio recording was very bad. The purported transcript is more noteworthy for what it does not contain than for what it contains. It consists substantially of gaps. I counted 108 gaps where Auscript was unable to reproduce anything from the sound recording. I read the transcript in 10 minutes. At the commencement of the sound recording the Tribunal officer stated that the hearing had commenced at 2.33pm. At the end of the sound recording the Tribunal officer stated that the hearing had concluded at 3.36pm. The hearing therefore ran for just over an hour. Even allowing for slow speech and pregnant pauses it is obvious that a substantial amount of what occurred at the hearing has not been reproduced in the transcript. What is reproduced in the transcript must be treated with caution, given the very poor audio quality of the sound recording. I am bound to conclude that the presiding member was wrong in stating that the comments by him and the other participants at the hearing were audible on the sound recording. Only some of them were. The presiding member’s opinion was used to support the Tribunal’s decision to hand down its decision on 25 October 2007, notwithstanding the protests from the applicant’s agent. The question is not, however, whether the Tribunal decision should have been handed down on that day. The question is whether the Tribunal breached s.425 of the Migration Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The transcript records that the following discussion occurred at the hearing between the presiding member and the applicant (and his agent) about the country information[30]:[30] transcript, pages 11-15MR DELOFSKI: Now, I think I now have an understanding of the sequence of your arrests and claim of persecution. I have here some independent country information about India and situation for Sikhs that I would like to put to you just for your comment. According to this independent information at the current time we were talking about at the moment, in recent years, not so much at the time in the ‘80s when there was the attack on the Golden Temple. Because what I’m looking at in assessing whether you meet the definition of a refugee is whether you have a well foundered fear of persecution if you return to India in the future. So even if I accept that you have been persecuted in the past that does not necessarily mean that you meet the definition of a refugee if I feel that the situation has improved. ..... I have tissues and everything as well.Okay. Now, this independent information that we have here suggests that at the moment Sikhs are able to practice their religion without restriction. Do you say that’s correct?THE INTERPRETER: No.MR DELOFSKI: That’s not correct?THE INTERPRETER: All people from my party ..... are actually being punished at present and some of them are ..... and the ..... party actually tells the police inspector the police to ..... MR DELOFSKI: Now, the other – another piece of company information that we have is that certainly since Manmohan Singh has become Prime Minister, a good cause for the Sikh. Conflict between Sikhs and Hindu has ceased.THE INTERPRETER: This is actually ..... very high level. High political level but in ..... of ..... who are actually at a lower level, they are still actually tortured ..... They actually provide information to UN over the government to say that everything is safe when it isn’t. One of the Sikh ..... he was actually taken away by the police and they interrogated ..... and now there is a case in the court against the ..... inspector who was interrogated. MR DELOFSKI: Well, the information we have is that if you are not in a senior leadership level then you are not likely to be of interest to the police because of your political beliefs. There may be isolated instances where police harass the individual people but it may be for reasons other than because they are a Sikh and I think because they have family problems ..... THE INTERPRETER: Because he was – he belong to that party. That party from ..... That’s why he was ..... The police they actually gave back to us they said you are to leave Khalistan otherwise you will be killed in ..... the hit list. They were torturing them.MR DELOFSKI: Now, we have other country information that suggests that the Indian Constitution and the Indian courts do provide protection to the rights of Sikhs. THE INTERPRETER: But it is not the case.MR DELOFSKI: You, of course, were charged in the courts and were acquitted which suggests that at least in certain places you are provided a protection.THE INTERPRETER: Yes, but I was detained all that time.MR DELOFSKI: It does seem like a long time between the time you were arrested. Now, other information that the tribunal has received includes a statement by Amnesty International in 2003 that police generally no longer torture Sikhs on account of their political views and suspected militant links. THE INTERPRETER: But you can see what happened to me. That and the ..... 11 who are being tortured. ..... They come to our house, they arrest us, detain us and then they torture us but it doesn’t open up – people don’t know actually what is – what happened at that level.MR DELOFSKI: Now, Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade have provided advice that there are provisions under Indian law for redress of human rights abuses. Do you have a comment on that?THE INTERPRETER: So police can have us many time and the inspector of police ..... get that opportunity ..... torture us and ..... they wish to. ..... gangs who actually torture us and they are called ..... there are many newspaper articles on these gangs ..... who have been harassing other people. MR DELOFSKI: I’ve got some of the – I’ve obviously got the newspaper advice and other information you have provided and I will look at that before I make any decision. I just wanted to mention one other piece of country information. Advice from our Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. They have also advised that if supporters of registered political parties in India are subject to political persecution, they have recourse through the Indian legal system.THE INTERPRETER: ..... was actually ..... see what happened to him and he was actually tortured ..... parliament member. They told ..... member of parliament ..... MR DELOFSKI: Thank you for that. I haven’t had a chance to look at the material – the additional material. MR ADVISOR: Some of those works in there are actually ..... very recent. ..... MR DELOFSKI: Well, I mean, I will take into account any information including the information you have already provided up until the time that the decision is made. MR SINGH: ..... tortured to death ..... this one - - - MR DELOFSKI: We have the ..... certificate. We have the medical certificate. THE INTERPRETER: I got fed up because I was tortured ..... tied up like that.MR DELOFSKI: I think the medical certificate ..... the torture. I will certainly take that into account. Is there anything else that you wanted to cover? Do you think we’ve covered the main ..... issues of persecution? We’re nearing the end of the – what happens now is that I will go away and think about what you’ve told me at the hearing. I will read the material and then make a decision as to whether I feel that you do meet the definitions I have described at the start of the hearing. That takes probably – quite a few weeks. A few weeks. I’ll try not to delay it too long ..... fresh in my mind. THE INTERPRETER: One inspector he did give me hard time and he was almost certain that I will be killed if I go back home ..... As I told you before, this particular inspector warned me.MR DELOFSKI: Why do you feel he’s concerned with you as an individual?THE INTERPRETER: He said because I am one of the political figure and I have political contacts with other. So I am not treated as a political member ..... torture ..... MR DELOFSKI: Why do they see you as the key political figure when you say you were just a member?THE INTERPRETER: Because I have been in politics for a long time. Many contacts. Since 1984. ..... contact too many ..... I am unable to stay at home because I was under surveillance all the time by the police and that is the reason my father was ..... and he passed away.MR DELOFSKI: Are you in favour of the establishment of independent fixed date in the Punjab region by military means or do you hope to do it by peacefulness?THE INTERPRETER: By peacefulness. They are – this is ..... actually after ..... but I was ..... MR DELOFSKI: I’ll have a look at that material. As I said, I will try to make the decision fairly soon after we have the hearing so things are still fresh in my mind. But it does – I mean, there is a process involved so it will probably be a few weeks.MR ADVISOR: ..... in jail ..... MR DELOFSKI: I mean as I said any information in any statement that you have provided before the decision is made I will take into account...... MR DELOFSKI: When did he obtain his protection visa?THE INTERPRETER: ..... MR DELOFSKI: When? Do you know when?THE INTERPRETER: Three years ago.MR DELOFSKI: Three years ago. Well, if you want, if you can say in a written statement ..... (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.