Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The applicant sought review of the Tribunal’s decision by the Court, and on 11 October 2005 the Court set aside the decision and remitted the matter to the Tribunal to be determined according to law. On 22 June 2006 a differently constituted Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Minister’s delegate not to grant the applicant a protection visa. In considering the applicant’s claims, the Tribunal made the following relevant findings (CB 230-235) (highlighting added):I am also satisfied that she supported the June 1989 protests in China and was penalised at the time. However, as she told the Tribunal, by 1993 she was not facing any ongoing disadvantage, and that the events of 1998 and 1999 relating to the China Democracy Party were the focus of her claims when she first applied for a protection visa. She did not claim to have been subject to any ongoing discrimination or harm in recent years because of the events of June 1989. That evidence is consistent with the absence of evidence in the sources searched by the Tribunal of a continuing interest by authorities in those who participated in the 1989 protests. A 1999 report suggests a further relaxation of the authorities' attitude toward the events surrounding Tiananmen Square. "Counter-revolution" (which is how events of 4 June 1989 have been described) is no longer a crime, and the protests at Tiananmen are now seen as "disturbances rather than the official 'counter-revolutionary riot'" ("Transforming Tiananmen", 1999, Asiaweek, 18 June). I am therefore satisfied, as [the applicant’s] written and oral evidence made clear, that she initially sought asylum in Australia solely on the basis of a fear of persecution arising from her membership of the CDP. As to that claim, I have considered the following. I note, as did the first Tribunal Member, that her account and that of Mr… have been consistent with each other. That lends some plausibility to her account. However because of various other inconsistencies and aspects of the account which give rise to considerable doubt about its plausibility, I do not consider credible her claim to have been associated with the CDP. In her evidence [the applicant] said that she mixed with pro-democracy people in China, was interested in their political theories and was impressed by their thoughts. For that reason she accepted the role as the CDP’s local “propaganda cadre”, a role she continued to play even after the crackdown on the CDP, being the only opposition party in China in 1998. These are the characteristics of a person interested in political change in China and willing to take some risks in order to achieve it. However during her seven years in Australia she does not claim to have participated in any activities at all in pursuit of that aim. Further, despite asserting to the Tribunal, quite reasonably, that western NGOs and media may remain unaware of the imprisonment of certain CDP members, she does not claim to have tried to remedy that situation by offering information about those known to her to any agency in Australia or elsewhere. She also does not claim to have sought any human rights organisation’s assistance in locating and making contact with CDP members who have fled China, or to have enquired about any CDP members’ circumstances at all – all of which options were open to her to undertake in confidence. In particular, she claims that a Mr Jianguo Cui was a member of the CDP whose current imprisonment may still not be known to non-government organisations abroad, or to the international media, yet she has taken no steps to pass on this information. In my view, despite her understandable concerns about her situation in Australia, her failure to do any of these things here, when they could have been done at little or no risk to her, shows a passivity not generally consistent with her claim to have been a propaganda cadre for the CDP, to have any serious interest in the CDP or its aims or to have any serious interest in political change in China.[The applicant] claimed to the Tribunal that she had been following the activities of the CDP since her arrival in Australia and had been trying to contact CDP members for the past seven years (no evidence was submitted in support of these claims and, as I have noted, she has made no enquiries about them of human rights groups here). However her level of knowledge was not consistent with having any continuing interest in the CDP - she did not know of two significant developments relating to the party until the Tribunal brought them to her attention, the first being the establishment by the CDP’s leader of its “Overseas Exiles Headquarters” in the USA in 2004, which is in contact with supporters in many countries, and the second being its comprehensive statement of policy (the New Century Declaration) issued on 1 January 2000. It was also submitted, in favour of her general credibility, that [the applicant] had willingly contacted the CDP leader in the USA to seek verification of her membership. While I accept that she did contact him, she only did so after the Tribunal told her of the existence of the “Overseas Exiles Headquarters” and suggested she obtain documentation confirming her membership from it (RRT letter to RACS of 29 November 2005), a step which she could not have shown any reluctance to take without casting some doubt on the plausibility of her claim to be a CDP member.There is also no evidence from anyone independently verifiable as a member of the CDP, or from the US-based Mr Xu Wen Li, who I have no doubt was the CDP’s leader in China and is in contact with many past CDP members, that [the applicant] ever had any link with this party. It is of course possible that the reason Mr Xu Wen Li does not know of her is, as was stated, that he was in prison during the relevant period. However [the applicant] has asserted that she has also asked Mr Li to help her locate Jin Zhu Zhang, who she claims was the CDP member and “known dissident” who sponsored her into the party. She has provided no evidence that she actually did make this request of Mr Li, and I cannot be satisfied that she did. The Tribunal thus has no evidence from Mr Li that Mr Zhang is known to him. It seems unlikely, although not impossible, that if Jin Zhu Zhang were a known dissident now in the USA who was active in the CDP in 1999, its leader would not know anything of him. In sum, the Tribunal has before it no confirmation from the CDP leader that he either knows of [the applicant], or knows anyone who can confirm her membership of the CDP, or knows of the person claimed by her to be her CDP sponsor.I do not think it is unreasonable to expect that a person responsible for CDP propaganda would have been both an experienced activist and dissident, as well as thoroughly briefed by more senior CDP activists about the party’s policies. [The applicant] gave evidence that her anti-government activities prior to 1998 had consisted of a brief involvement in the June 1989 protests. She was unable to provide a cogent explanation as to why she was invited to act as a CDP “propaganda cadre”, apart from saying that the CDP wanted to attract female members. She was not provided with any training for that role beyond being given written material, and her evidence was that her main role was organising cultural or leisure activities. In short she does not appear to have been equipped by the party to attract new members to it, and I have strong doubts about the plausibility of her claim to have played the role she claims she did.She has submitted two letters to Mr … from Mr Cui, who she claims is the brother of an imprisoned CDP member. I consider reliable the evidence from independent sources that international mail is monitored in China. It is also clear that Mr … address in Sydney must have been provided to Mr Cui by Mr …, after which Mr Cui wrote two letters to him whose purpose can only be to provide evidence of Mr … claims to this Tribunal (as was claimed by [the applicant]). In my view, the fact that the author unnecessarily provided his own full identity on the envelope, and included Mr … full name as addressee, reflects some confidence that the contents would not, even if checked by the PRC authorities, incriminate him in any way. As there is no evidence beyond these letters and [the applicant’s] (and Mr …) assertions that the author’s brother is in prison for political reasons, or was a member of the CDP, I do not propose to give any weight to these letters. [The applicant] has invited the Tribunal to ring the author of the letters in China to verify the content of the letters. I have considered this request but, as the Tribunal cannot confirm the author’s identity or the reliability of his account by ringing him, have not done this. As to [the applicant’s] claim that individuals connected with her workplace have told her that the Australian Embassy revealed some information about her to her employer, as a result of which she is now at risk, I am not satisfied that such information was ever revealed. The evidence provided both by DIMA and DFAT is detailed and unequivocal and reflects that a thorough check was done in response to the Tribunal’s recent enquiries on this matter. [The applicant’s] records were located at the post by DFAT and DIMA respectively, and contained no record of any contact with the hospital. It is also clear that the post was aware that she had made a protection visa application, and that it was a long established procedure that under those circumstances no such enquiry would have been made. [The applicant] has claimed she has been informed that a “fax” was sent to the hospital from the post, and I note that the person with whom Mr Carney spoke on 31 May 2006 (Statutory Declaration of 1 June 2006) told him that a letter referring to the “Democracy Party” was faxed to the hospital. One would therefore expect that it would have remained on [the applicant’s] (or Mr …) files at the Australian embassy, but it is apparent from the post’s response to the Tribunal’s enquiries that there is no copy of it on those files. Indeed the Tribunal has before it no record of its having actually been sent to the post from Australia. Mr Carney has also suggested that, because it would not have been established procedure to contact the hospital, it is possible that a telephone call was made by someone at the post which that person chose not to record on the file. That is possible but unlikely, because in that scenario the letter would have remained on the files, even if no record of the telephone call was kept. It is also entirely unclear from any of the arguments presented what might have been gained by the post revealing to the hospital that [the applicant] had applied for a protection visa or was claiming to be a member of the CDP. While her employer obviously knows that [the applicant] did not return to her workplace at the time she undertook to do so, I am not satisfied that the hospital was given any information by the post about her. For that reason I have not contacted the individuals in China whose telephone numbers have been provided to the Tribunal, and who it is claimed will state that such information had been given. The Tribunal cannot establish their identity or reliability as witnesses with confidence. That is also true of Mr Yu Le. I prefer the evidence from the post and consider it reliable. Therefore I do not consider that [the applicant] has been truthful that anyone has told her (other than for the purpose of enhancing the present application) of an enquiry by the post linking her with the CDP. I accept that she failed to return from a work-related trip to her position at the hospital when expected, and am satisfied that she has been dismissed from that position for that reason. I accept that the letter she has submitted confirming this is genuine. However I am not satisfied that the letter purporting to be from her employer linking her with the CDP is genuine. As has been put to her, by the time it was issued she was no longer an employee of the hospital and its content was therefore redundant. Further, its letterhead and general appearance differed considerably from the other letter she submitted from the same workplace. Mr Carney has argued that, if it were fraudulent, it would be more, rather than less, likely to have an identical letterhead. However, even if it is a letter issued on an alternative letterhead which was being used by the hospital in 1999, in light of my very strong doubts about [the applicant’s] general credibility, I am not satisfied that it was obtained or written for any reason other than to enhance her application for the protection visa. In light of my strong doubts about her general credibility and the difficulty in establishing definitively what letterheads were used by the hospital in 1999, I do not propose to make the enquiries she has suggested with regard to the hospital’s past letterheads.I have considered how much weight can fairly be given to the fact that, as her witness, Mr … readily answered several questions about the last CDP meeting the two claimed to have attended. His answers were consistent with oral evidence she had just given the Tribunal in response to several specific questions. [The applicant] has since claimed (statement of 2 May 2006) that when she wrote notes about the last CDP meeting she and Mr … had attended she had no idea he would be called into the room during her hearing. She has claimed that she did not place her responses to my questions about that meeting in such a way that he could easily see them. However I note that Mr … was named as a witness by [the applicant] on her “Response to hearing invitation” (received by the Tribunal on 14 November 2005), from which I am satisfied that she was expecting the Tribunal to take evidence from him. Further, before he entered the hearing room I told [the applicant] that I intended to ask him the same questions as had been put to her about the CDP meeting. In light of my strong doubts about [the applicant’s] general credibility, my observations of both Mr … and [the applicant] while Mr … was giving evidence about the meeting (which included his appearing to repeatedly focus on the page held by [the applicant] which was turned towards him) and the fact that he volunteered the answer to a question not yet posed, but which was answered in [the applicant] notes, I am unable to rely on the evidence he gave about that meeting. In sum, although consistency between the two accounts of the meeting would otherwise have added to the plausibility of [the applicant’s] claim to have attended such a meeting, I am unable to rely on it in this case.For the above reasons I do not consider credible [the applicant’s] claim to have been associated with the CDP. [The applicant] claimed (statement of 2 May 2006) to have been held at Villawood immigration detention centre for five weeks, during which time the Department staff told her she would have to return to China and gave information about her to the Chinese authorities so she could be granted a travel document. I accept that that may have occurred. She made no further claim in relation to this matter - however it is possible, and I am satisfied, that the PRC authorities may assume that she has overstayed a visa in Australia. Even if they assumed that she had also applied for a protection visa, DFAT’s evidence (2003) is that this would not give rise to any serious politically-motivated harm in China unless there were grounds for assuming her to be politically active in some way. It is possible, as DFAT (2003) has indicated, that if she were to return to China she may face some monitoring of her movements. However, as [the applicant] has not been a critic of the PRC government since her arrival in Australia, nor indeed for some seventeen years, and I am not satisfied that she holds dissident views which she may wish to express if she returns to China, I am not satisfied that she might face anything more serious than monitoring, and consider that that would not amount to persecution.For these reasons I am not satisfied, and do not accept, that [the applicant] left China for the reasons she has given, nor that she might be imputed with an anti-government political opinion if she returns to China. She does not have a well-founded fear of Convention-related persecution in China.Having considered the evidence as a whole, the Tribunal is not satisfied that [the applicant] is a person to whom Australia has protection obligations under the Refugees Convention as amended by the Refugees Protocol. Therefore she does not satisfy the criterion set out in s.36(2) of the Act for a protection visa.