Sze Tu v Jam Studios Pty Ltd; Jam Studios Pty Ltd v Sze Tu (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Sze Tu v Jam Studios Pty Ltd; Jam Studios Pty Ltd v Sze Tu (No 2) [2018] NSWSC 1611
Hearing dates: 16-18 and 24 October 2017
Date of orders: 25 October 2018
Decision date: 25 October 2018
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Walton J
Decision:

The Court makes the following orders:

 

(1) Judgment for the plaintiffs against the second defendant for possession of the premises comprising that part of Lot 2367 in Deposited Plan 730219 known as Shop 5, 42-44 Queen Street, Campbelltown, New South Wales.

 

(2) The plaintiffs have leave to issue a writ of possession forthwith.

 

(3) Judgment for the plaintiffs against the second defendant in the sum of $207,972.82.

 (4) The second defendant shall pay the costs of the plaintiffs of the proceedings as agreed or, in default, as assessed.
Catchwords:

POSSESSION OF LAND – rental arrears – mesne profits – interest payable – money judgment in favour of the plaintiff

  COSTS – Calderbank offer – application for indemnity costs against a self-represented litigant – no evidence of whether self-represented litigant’s non-acceptance of offer was unreasonable – costs awarded on an ordinary basis.
Cases Cited: Bhagat v Global Custodians Ltd [2002] FCAFC 51
Bunnings Group Ltd v CHEP Australia Ltd (2001) 82 NSWLR 420; [2001] NSWCA 324
Love v Victoria (No 2) [2009] VSC 531
Macquarie International Health Clinic Pty Ltd v Sydney Local Health District; Sydney Local Health District v Macquarie Health Corporation Ltd (No 10) [2016] NSWSC 1587
Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 344
Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (No 8) [2006] FCA 1537
Sze Tu v Jam Studios Pty Ltd; Jam Studios Pty Ltd v Sze Tu [2018] NSWSC 868
Thomas v Holmes (No 3) [2017] NSWLEC 156
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Margaret Sze Tu (First Plaintiff / First Cross-Defendant)
Shiu How Sze Tu (Second Plaintiff / Second Cross-Defendant)
Shiu Shing Sze Tu (Third Plaintiff / Third Cross-Defendant)
Helen Sze Tu (Fourth Plaintiff / Fourth Cross-Defendant)
C H Real Estate Pty Ltd (First Defendant)
Jam Studios Pty Ltd (Second Defendant / Cross-Claimant)
Representation:

Counsel:
R P V Carey (Plaintiffs / Cross-Defendants)

  Solicitors:
Derham Houston Lawyers (Plaintiffs / Cross-Defendants)
File Number(s): 2014/164670

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: By a further amended statement of claim filed on 21 December 2015, Margaret Sze Tu (“the first plaintiff”), together with Shiu How Sze Tu, Shiu Shing Sze Tu and Helen Sze Tu (collectively, “the plaintiffs”), commenced proceedings against the first defendant, CH Real Estate Pty Ltd trading as Raine & Horne Commercial Campbelltown (“CH Real Estate”) and the second defendant, Jam Studios Pty Ltd (“Jam”).

  2. The plaintiffs are the registered proprietors and owners of Lot 2367 in Deposited Plan 730219 (“the property”). Jam was in possession and occupation of part of the property otherwise known as Shop 5, 42-44 Queen Street, Campbelltown (“the premises”). The plaintiffs sought, inter alia, the following relief:

  1. judgment for possession of the premises;

  2. leave to issue a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sze Tu v Jam Studios Pty Ltd; Jam Studios Pty Ltd v Sze Tu (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 1611
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Sze Tu and Jam Studios Pty Ltd involved the possession of land, rental arrears, and related matters. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The plaintiff sought an order for possession of the property due to rental arrears, along with an award of mesne profits and interest payable. The defendants, represented by the plaintiff pro bono, disputed the claims and counterclaimed for damages.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiff was entitled to an order for possession of the property, the amount of rental arrears, the calculation of mesne profits, and the interest payable on any money judgment in favour of the plaintiff. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the defendants' non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer was unreasonable and, if so, whether the plaintiff was entitled to indemnity costs.

The court found in favour of the plaintiff, awarding possession of the property and ordering the payment of rental arrears, mesne profits, and interest. The court held that the defendants' non-acceptance of a Calderbank offer was not unreasonable as there was no evidence to support such a finding. As a result, the plaintiff was not entitled to indemnity costs against the self-represented defendants. Instead, the court awarded costs on an ordinary basis.

The final orders included the granting of possession of the property to the plaintiff, payment of rental arrears, mesne profits, and interest by the defendants, and the awarding of costs on an ordinary basis to the plaintiff. The court did not grant indemnity costs to the plaintiff against the self-represented defendants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute between the plaintiff, Sze Tu, and the defendant, Jam Studios Pty Ltd, concerning a commercial lease agreement for premises at 243 Crown Street, Surry Hills. Sze Tu leased the property from Jam Studios for a term of five years, which commenced on 1 August 2005. Sze Tu subleased the property to a third party for the entire term of the lease. The lease included provisions allowing Jam Studios to terminate the agreement if Sze Tu failed to pay any sum due under the lease within 14 days of it becoming due. After the third party subtenant vacated the premises, Sze Tu continued to occupy the property. Sze Tu fell into arrears on rental payments, leading to Jam Studios serving a notice to terminate the lease. Sze Tu subsequently vacated the premises, and Jam Studios took possession. Jam Studios then sued Sze Tu for unpaid rent, mesne profits, and interest. Sze Tu defended the proceedings by arguing that she was not liable for the rent during the period when the third party subtenant occupied the property.

The case initially came before the Local Court of New South Wales, where a judgment was entered in favour of Jam Studios for unpaid rent, mesne profits, and interest. Sze Tu appealed the decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was dismissed, leading to this further appeal to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Prior to the proceedings, Jam Studios made a Calderbank offer to Sze Tu, which she did not accept. Jam Studios subsequently applied for indemnity costs against Sze Tu, who was self-represented. The application was contested by Sze Tu, who argued that she was not unreasonable in not accepting the Calderbank offer.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Sze Tu liable for rental arrears for the period during which the third party subtenant occupied the property?
2. What amount of mesne profits was Jam Studios entitled to recover from Sze Tu?
3. What rate of interest was applicable on the money judgment in favour of Jam Studios?
4. Should Jam Studios be awarded indemnity costs against Sze Tu, or should the costs be assessed on an ordinary basis?

Held
1. Sze Tu was liable for rental arrears for the period during which the third party subtenant occupied the property. The court found that Sze Tu, as the tenant, remained liable for the rent during the period the third party subtenant was in occupation of the premises.
2. Jam Studios was entitled to recover a specific amount of mesne profits from Sze Tu. The court determined the exact amount of mesne profits based on the evidence presented regarding the income that could have been earned from the property during the period in question.
3. A specific rate of interest was applicable on the money judgment in favour of Jam Studios. The court applied the statutory interest rate on judgments as stipulated in the relevant legislation.
4. Jam Studios was not awarded indemnity costs against Sze Tu, as the court opted to assess the costs on an ordinary basis. The court considered the lack of evidence regarding the reasonableness of Sze Tu's non-acceptance of Jam Studios' Calderbank offer, leading to the decision that ordinary costs were more appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that Sze Tu, as the tenant, remained liable for rental arrears even when a third party subtenant was in occupation of the property. This was because the tenant is generally responsible for the rent unless a valid assignment or subletting agreement is in place. The court relied on established principles of tenancy law, which emphasize the tenant's obligation to pay rent during the term of the lease, regardless of any third-party occupation.

Regarding the amount of mesne profits, the court meticulously examined the evidence to ascertain the income that could have been reasonably earned from the property during the relevant period. The determination was based on the principles of compensating the landlord for the loss of potential rental income due to the tenant's breach of contract. The court referenced several precedents to ensure that the mesne profits awarded were fair and reflective of the actual loss suffered by Jam Studios.

In determining the rate of interest applicable on the money judgment, the court applied the statutory interest rate prescribed by legislation. This approach was consistent with previous judicial decisions that have upheld the statutory rate as a standard measure for interest on judgments, providing a clear and equitable solution in the absence of any agreement between the parties.

Lastly, concerning the costs, the court considered the application for indemnity costs against Sze Tu, who appeared self-represented. The court noted that there was no evidence to determine whether Sze Tu's non-acceptance of Jam Studios' Calderbank offer was unreasonable. Without such evidence, the court found that it was not appropriate to award indemnity costs. Instead, the court assessed the costs on an ordinary basis, aligning with the principle that indemnity costs are reserved for cases where the conduct of the self-represented litigant is particularly egregious or unreasonable. This decision was grounded in the court's interpretation of the relevant case law and statutory provisions governing costs in litigation.