FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
SZDTX & ANOR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS[2005] FMCA 1087
MIGRATION – Review of decision by Refugee Review Tribunal – refusal to grant protection visa – applicant claims persecution in Bangladesh as a member of the BJP political party and as a Hindu.
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s.39B
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.5(1); 62(2); 65(1); 422B; 425; 426A
Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal (2002) 190 ALR 601
NADR vMinister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 293
B41of 2003, in the matter of an application for a Writ of Mandamus, Prohibition and Certiorari against Refugee Review Tribunal [2004] FCA 30S58of 2003 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 283
Walton v Phillip Ruddock, Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2001) 115 FCR 342
Abebe v Commonwealth of Australia (1999) 197 CLR 510
NAVX v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 287
Applicants: SZDTX AND& SZDTY
Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
File Number: SYG1738 /of 2004
Judgment of: Emmett mmettFM
Hearing date: 18 JulyJuly 2005
Date of Last Submission: 18 JulyJuly 2005
Delivered at: SYDNEYSydney
Delivered on: 5 August 2005 REPRESENTATION
Counsel for the Applicant:The Applicant on behalf of himself
Solicitors for the Respondent: M rs J. BautistaSnell, Sparke Helmore LawyersORDERS
(1)
Orders StyleThe Amended Application filed 7 March 2005 is dismissed with costs.
(a)Orders-abc Style
(i)Orders-123 Style
FEDERAL MAGISTRATES
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEYSYG1738 of
/2004
SZDTX & ANDSZDTYApplicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL & INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The application
1.This is an application pursuant to s.39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) for judicial review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) to affirm the decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (“the delegate”) not to grant a protection visa to the Applicant.
2.The Applicants are husband and wife and are citizens of India who arrived in Australia on 17 November 2003 under a tourist visa. On 15 December 2003 the Applicants applied to the Respondent for a class XA protection visa and on 9 January 2004 that application was refused by the Minister’s delegate
(“the delegate”).3.On 11 May 2004 the
Migration ReviewTribunal(“the Tribunal”)affirmed the decision of the delegate.4.On 7 June 2004 the Applicants filed an Application for judicial review by
inthis Court of the Tribunal’s decision.5.For the purposes of this hearing the interests of both Applicants rest on the claims of the first named Applicant. For this reason, I shall refer in this jud
ggement to the situation as it affected the first named Applicant.6.Pursuant to directions made on 3 February 2005 the Applicants filed an Amended…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SZDTX v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indig... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] FMCA 1087
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered two primary arguments advanced by the applicants. Firstly, the applicants contended that the RRT failed to consider relevant documents submitted as part of their application, leading to a denial of procedural fairness akin to the case of Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal. The court found that there was no evidence to support the applicants' claim that the RRT did not consider the relevant documents, and the applicants did not specify which documents were allegedly overlooked. Furthermore, the applicants did not demonstrate how the absence of these documents would have affected their case, leading the court to reject this claim.
Secondly, the applicants argued that the RRT's decision to proceed with the review in their absence constituted procedural unfairness. The applicants claimed they did not attend the hearing because they were misled by their previous migration agent and were not properly informed about the proceedings. The court held that reliance on advice from a migration agent does not, in itself, establish a denial of procedural fairness. Moreover, the applicants had been given a clear opportunity to attend the hearing and present their evidence but chose not to do so. The court concluded that the RRT's decision to proceed without the applicants did not amount to procedural unfairness.
In light of the foregoing, the court dismissed the applicants' Amended Application, finding no merit in their claims of procedural unfairness. The court awarded costs against the applicants, reflecting the lack of success in their judicial review application.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Orders StyleThe Amended Application filed 7 March 2005 is dismissed with costs.
(a)Orders-abc Style
(i)Orders-123 Style
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
(i) (i) Analogy of the Applicant’s case with the case of MuinTribunal’s consideration of Part B documents33.Muin is authority, inter alia, for the proposition that there is a lack of procedural fairness where an applicant before a Tribunal is misled into thinking that the Tribunal has considered particular relevant information and, as a result did note ensure that such information was placed before it.34.In relation to the first part of this claim, the Applicants submitted that there was a lack of procedural fairness in their his case in that the Tribunal did not read all of the Part B materials ‘which might help me make a positive decision to decide applicants claim as a refugee’. The Applicants wentgo on to submit the following: “At a factual level the present case differs substantially from Muin but the nature of denial of procedural fairness is very much similar. It is understandable that the letter misled the appellant, or that he would have taken any particular steps had he been told, if it was the case, that the tribunal had not been provided with them’.35.The RespondentRespondent referred to the Full court of the Federal Court of Australia, in NADR vMinister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 293 (“NADR”), in support of her submission that the Applicant’s case differed from that of Muin in that, inter alia, there was no agreed statement of facts in this case as was the case in Muin.Indeed, there is no identification by the Applicant of the documents that the Applicant claims the Tribunal did not consider.36.The Respondent Respondent further submitted that NADR made it clear that it is for the Applicants to establish the necessary factual sub-stratum by way of evidence to prove any allegation that the Tribunal did not receive or consider Part B documents.37.Further, an applicant must show that he would have taken a particular course had he known that the Tribunal had not been provided with the documents or did not intend to refer to them. It is also necessary to consider whether the particular matters upon which the applicant relies are, in any event, amongst the material identified by the Tribunal (NADR at paragraphs 24-26).38.The Respondent referred to the letter dated 25 February 2004 inviting the Applicants to a hearing on 25 March 2004 which stated that:“The Tribunal has considered the material before it in relation to your application but is unable to make a decision in your favour on this information alone.”1.There is no evidence otherwise to suggest that this information material considered by the Tribunal did not include the Part B documents. The Tribunal decision states that it had before it the Department’s file that included the protection visa application and the delegate’s decision. Part B of that decision listed documents that the Applicants asserts were not considered by the Tribunal. The Tribunal went on to state that it had had regard to the material in the delegate’s decision.1. The Full Court of the Federal Court in NADR at paragraphs [24] – [26] said the following about the relevance and application of Muin in cases such as the Applicants:“Muin does not establish, as the submissions for the appellant implied, that the effect of sending a letter in those terms will amount to a denial of procedural fairness in circumstances where the Tribunal has not referred to the Part B documents in its later decision. Rather it holds there is a want of procedural fairness where an applicant before a Tribunal is misled into thinking that the tribunal has considered particular relevant information and, as result, did not ensure that such information was placed before it. Whether it is necessary to infer that the tribunal was not likely to have considered the material, or whether it is sufficient that it may not have done so, is perhaps moot. It is also of importance that a conclusion that the plaintiff was misled was rendered possible largely because of agreed facts.At a factual level the present case differs substantially from Muin. It is not agreed that the documents were not physically provided to the tribunal. It is not agreed that the appellant was misled by the letter, or that he would have taken any particular steps had been told, if it was the case, that the tribunal had not been provided with them. It was submitted that the part B documents can be seen to relate to the appellant’s case. So much can be expected. Beyond that the appellant sought to utilise the findings of fact in Muin to make out his case. Needless to say, that is not a course which is open. Each case must be considered on its own facts.39.It cannot be inferred as a fact in every case involving a letter in these terms, that an applicant was affected in some way by it when they came to provide information to the Tribunal and participate in the hearing. Much of course will depend upon what information was contained in Part b documents and the issues in the applicant’s case. It could not be assumed that the appellant here would have taken any particular course had he know that the tribunal had not been provided with the documents, or did not intend to refer to them. It was not explained to the Court how that might be concluded by reference to the contents of the Part B documents. It would also be necessary to consider whether the particular matters, upon which the appellant would rely were, in any event, amongst the material identified by the Tribunal. Those matters were not identified for Court.”40.There is nothing other than the Applicant’s’ bare assertion that the Tribunal did not consider all the material before it. The Court is not obliged to accept bare assertions as fact. In any event, there is the statement of the Tribunal that it “had regard to the material referred to in the delegate’s decision”. In the absence of any evidence to the contrary, I find that there is no material before me to persuade meI am not persuaded that the Tribunal failed to consider the Part B documents in the circumstances contemplated by Muin.41.Accordingly, I find there has been no procedural unfairness established by the Applicants in respect of this submission and accordingly, I reject this ground.(ii) Tribunal decision to proceed in absence of parties42.The second basis relied on by the Applicants in submitting they he had been denied procedural fairness by the tribunal Tribunal is in respect of the Tribunal’s decision to proceed with the review in their his absence.43.Section 425 and 425A of the Act obliges the tTribunal to invite the Aapplicant to appear at a hearing. and provide the information required in any notice of invitation to appear. I note that Tthe tTribunal’s letter of 21 August 2003 complies with those requirements. 44.Pursuant to section .426A of the Act, relevantly, where the Applicant fails to appear having been invited pursuant to s.425 of the Act the Tribunal may make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the Applicant to appear before it. (1) If the applicant:is invited under section 425 to appear before the Tribunal; anddoes not appear before the tribunal on the day on which, or at the time and place at which, the applicant is scheduled to appear;the Tribunal may make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the applicant appear before it.This section does not prevent the tribunal from rescheduling the applicant’s appearance before it, or from delaying its decision on the review in order to enable the applicant’s appearance before it as rescheduled.45.On 25 February 2004 the Tribunal wrote to the Applicants inviting them him to give oral evidence and present arguments at a hearing on 25 March 2004. This letter was sent to the Applicant at the address identified by the Applicant in his application for review before the Tribunal.46.On 23 March 2004 the Applicants sent a response to the Tribunal’s invitation to appear at the hearing. The response was signed by the First Applicant on behalf of both Applicants. In answer to the question on their response ‘Ddo you want to come to a hearing’ the Applicants had ticked the box ‘No’, which included the information that, in the event that the Applicants did not come to a hearing, that the Ttribunal may proceed to make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the Applicants to appear before it.47.In its decision, the Tribunal referred specifically to the correspondence and the response and concluded that the Applicants did not wish to give oral evidence and consented to the Tribunal proceeding to make a decision on the review without taking any further action to allow or enable the Applicants to appear before it. The matter was then determined on the evidence material available to the Tribunal.48.In their his Amended Application, the Applicants claims that they he did not attend the Tribunal hearing because they he were was not properly informed by their his previous migration agent and wasere “ ‘misguided involving the RRT interview.’” 49.The Respondent Respondent referred to the decision of Dowsett J in B41of 2003, in the matter of an application for a Writ of Mandamus, Prohibition and Certiorari against Refugee Review Tribunal [2004] FCA 30 (“B41”) in which his honourHis Honour said that an applicant cannot complain that his actions, taken in reliance upon the advice received from his Immigration adviser, led to his being denied procedural fairness. In that case, the applicant claimed that his migration adviser advised him positively not to attend the Tribunal hearing. The Court still held that actions taken or not taken by an applicant pursuant to advice from a migration agent cannot lead to the applicant being denied procedural fairness.50.In the case before this Court, the Applicants claims that their his migration agent “did not properly inform” them him and that they werehe was “misguided regarding the RRT interview.”. The Applicants does not provide evidence beyond those assertions. B41 would suggest that, even if that evidence wereas available available, it would be insufficient to lead to a denial of procedural fairness. Accordingly, I find that the reliance by the Applicants on their his migration agent in the circumstances of this case does did not lead to a denial of procedural fairness. 51.In their his written argument, the Applicants also claims theyhe did not attend the interview (which I take to be the Tribunal hearing) because they he did ‘not know the conscience of the RRT Hearing’. The Applicant’ss concluding submission in relation to this issue iís that the “‘tribunal member must of known of its the error an did nothing to correct it’” (which I take to mean the decision of the tTribunal member to proceed to a hearingdecide the matter in the absence of the Applicant) and did nothing to correct it. The Applicants submits that this renders the decision one of bad faith on the part of the Tribunal. As referred to above there is no evidence whatsoever before me to suggest that the Tribunal was aware of any of the facts asserted by the Applicants in support of their claim that the hearing should not have proceeded in their absence. Otherwise I do not understand this submission. In any event I am not satisfied that it reveals any denial of procedural fairness.There is no further elaboration or particularisation by the Applicant of this claim. Accordingly, I reject this claim in so far as it refers to “bad faith on the part of the Tribunal”.52.The Respondent referred to S58of 2003 v Minister for Immigration &and Multicultural &and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 283 at [25] where the Full Court of the Federal Court said the following:“In any event, whether an applicant has been accorded procedural fairness is not to be decided on a minute or fragmented examination of each step of the process by which a tribunal has arrived at its decision. In the present case, the appellant was fully aware that the success of his application depended on an affirmative finding that he had a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason if he were returned to Bangladesh. He was given an invitation to attend a hearing before the tribunal which, apparently on advice, he deliberately declined. Having done so, he is to be taken to have assumed the risk that inconsistencies, omissions or other unsatisfactory features of his documents would be noted by the tribunal without his having an opportunity to explain or clarify them. Conversely, his conduct left it open to the tribunal to infer that, had he attended a hearing and given oral evidence, the appellant would not, on balance, have improved his case for the grant of a protection visa. In our view, the duty of the tribunal, in the circumstances of this case, was no higher than that identified in these terms by the Full Court in WACO v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 171 at [33];‘The Tribunal must give the appellant an opportunity to appear before it and give evidence: s425 of the Act. If an appellant seeks to give evidence, the Tribunal is under a duty to raise plainly and unambiguously the critical issues on which his or her application might depend so that he or she may have an opportunity of being heard on them: Meadows v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1998) 90 FCR 370 at 388 (per Merkel J) and see 382 (per Einfeld J) and 383 (per von Doussa J); Hussein v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 288 at [29] – [30] per O’Connor, Tamberlin and Mansfield JJ.’The Full Court also observed at [46]:‘There would be no unfairness where the person affected knew what he was required to prove to the decision maker and was given the opportunity to do so. An appellant then cannot complain if his application is rejected because the decision maker, without notice to him has rejected what was put forward.’In our view, the appellant was offered the opportunity to appear before the Tribunal and address any concerns it may have had about his claims and to put forward the documents upon which he relied. He cannot complain if his application was rejected because, amongst other reasons, he failed to take up that opportunity. 53.Similarly, in the case before this Court, that there was ample opportunity provided to the Applicants to present evidence and material to the Tribunal in support of their his application for review of the delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. Further, the Applicant was specifically notified by the Tribunal that the information presently before the Tribunal was not sufficient to make a decision in his favour. No opportunity offered to theThe Applicants failed to avail himself , including appearing at a hearing, was taken up by the Applicants.of the opportunity offered to him to appear at a hearing and to provide oral evidence and make submissions in support of his claims.1.Accordingly, I find reject this ground.the Tribunal decision to proceed with its review in the absence of the Applicants was not procedurally unfair in all the circumstances.