SYNICAST PTY LTD and SHOWROOM X PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985

CITATION:   SYNICAST PTY LTD and SHOWROOM X PTY LTD [2023] WASAT 47

MEMBER:   PRESIDENT PRITCHARD

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

DELIVERED          :   26 JUNE 2023

PUBLISHED           :   26 JUNE 2023

FILE NO/S:   CC 421 of 2021

BETWEEN:   SYNICAST PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

SHOWROOM X PTY LTD

Respondent


Catchwords:

Commercial tenancy — Retail shop lease — Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 — Application to Tribunal for approval of a clause permitting early termination in a retail shop lease for the redevelopment of a shopping centre — Construction of s 13(7) — Construction of s 14A — Redevelopment and relocation clauses — Meaning of special circumstances — Special circumstances exist

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 13, s 13(1), s 13(3), s 13(6)(a), s 13(6)(b), s 13(6)(c), s 13(6)(d), s 13(6)(da), s 13(7), s 13(7)(b), s 13(7a), s 13(7b), s 14A, s 14A(1), s 14A(1)(b), s 14A(2), s 14A(3)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 77

Result:

Early termination clause approved

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Solicitors:

Applicant : Chalmers Legal Studio
Respondent : N/A

Cases referred to in decision(s):

480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Irwin St Lower Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 59

480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Uber Australia Pty Ltd [2019] WASC 461

Hay & Colin Pty Ltd v West End Hospitality Pty Ltd [2021] WASC 458

Klein v Domus Pty Ltd (1963) 109 CLR 467

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

Re Commercial Registrar of the Commercial Tribunal of Western Australia; ex parte Commissioner of Main Roads and Scarff and Hough (unreported, Sup Ct of WA, Lib No. 970522)

Refrigerated Express Lines (A/asia) Pty Ltd v Australian Meat and Live-Stock Corporation (1980) 44 FLR 455; 29 ALR 333

Swanville Investment Pty Ltd and Ors v Riana Pty Ltd [2003] WASCA 121

Synicast Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Quentin Avenue Unit Trust v Showroom X Pty Ltd [2021] WASC 449

WASCF Alliances Pty Ltd v Bowling Centres Australia Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 41

Yang v Hapisun Pty Ltd [2018] SASC 17

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. Synicast Pty Ltd, as trustee for the Quentin Avenue Unit Trust (Landlord), is the owner of land at 22 St Quentin Avenue Claremont (Land) and the lessor of a premises located at suites 5 to 9, 22 St Quentin Avenue Claremont (Premises).  The Premises are leased to Showroom X Pty Ltd (Tenant).  The lease of the Premises (Lease) commenced on 5 March 2021, for a term of five years. 

  2. On 23 March 2021, the Landlord applied to the Tribunal, pursuant to s 13(7) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) (Act) for the Tribunal's approval of the inclusion in the Lease of two clauses — clause 33, and Special Condition 5 — which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SYNICAST PTY LTD and SHOWROOM X PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASAT 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Synicast Pty Ltd and Showroom X Pty Ltd, the dispute involved the interpretation and application of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985, specifically in relation to an application for the approval of a clause permitting early termination in a retail shop lease. The Tribunal initially granted approval for the clause, but this was appealed by the landlord. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, finding that the clause constituted a redevelopment clause under the Act, which necessitated a separate application under section 14A. However, the Court found it could not determine whether special circumstances existed for the approval of the clause based on the evidence before it, and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration and further evidence.

The legal issues that arose in this case were centered on the interpretation of sections 13(7) and 14A of the Act, particularly in relation to the meaning of 'special circumstances' and the distinction between redevelopment and relocation clauses. The court had to consider whether the Tribunal had the authority to approve the redevelopment clause under section 13(7) or whether it required a separate application under section 14A. Furthermore, the Court had to determine whether the evidence provided was sufficient to establish the existence of special circumstances warranting the approval of the clause.

In reaching its decision, the Supreme Court considered the ordinary principles of statutory construction and noted that specific provisions should take precedence over general ones. The Court also reviewed previous decisions of the Supreme Court which had found special circumstances existed in similar cases. However, the Court found that it could not determine whether special circumstances existed in this case based on the current evidence and therefore remitted the matter to the Tribunal for further consideration. The Court emphasized the need for additional evidence to substantiate the existence of special circumstances, as the original application did not provide sufficient information.

The final orders of the Court were that the Tribunal should reconsider the application for approval of the redevelopment clause, taking into account any further evidence provided by the parties regarding the existence of special circumstances. The Court did not make any definitive orders regarding the approval of the clause but rather directed the Tribunal to undertake further proceedings to determine whether special circumstances existed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 23 March 2021, the Landlord, Synicast Pty Ltd, applied to the Commercial Tenancies Tribunal of Western Australia for approval of a clause permitting early termination in a retail shop lease for the redevelopment of a shopping centre. The application was made under section 13(7) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985. The application was supported by a letter from the Landlord's solicitors, which attached a three-line statement described as 'acknowledgment and consent by lessee', which was apparently signed by a director of the Tenant, Showroom X Pty Ltd, on 22 March 2021. The application did not include a copy of the Lease in its entirety, and the copy of the clause in question did not reflect the terms of the clause as it appeared in the Lease. The Tenant did not provide any further evidence or submissions to the Tribunal when the application was filed.

On 24 March 2021, the Tribunal determined the application and ordered that the inclusion of clause 33.3 in the Lease was approved, and otherwise ordered that the Tribunal had no power to consider special condition 5 in item 20 of the Schedule in an application under s 13(7) of the Act, as a redevelopment or relocation clause falls exclusively within the provisions of s 14A of the Act, and a separate application is required under s 14A(3). The Landlord appealed the Decision, and the Supreme Court allowed the appeal. However, Archer J concluded that she was unable to receive additional evidence to substantiate the existence of 'special circumstances' in this case, and that on its face, the application itself did not establish the existence of 'special circumstances'. Accordingly, her Honour remitted the matter to the Tribunal, to be constituted by a different member, for reconsideration and 'for the hearing of further evidence in relation to whether special circumstances exist'.

The matter originated as an application by the Landlord to the Tribunal for the approval of a clause permitting early termination in a retail shop lease for the redevelopment of a shopping centre. The Tribunal considered the application under section 13(7) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 and concluded that a separate application was required under section 14A(3) of the Act as the clause in question fell within the provisions of a redevelopment clause. The Tenant subsequently appealed the Tribunal's decision to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, holding that the clause did permit early termination and was therefore subject to section 13(7) of the Act. However, the Court found that it could not receive additional evidence to substantiate the existence of 'special circumstances' in this case and that the application itself did not establish the existence of 'special circumstances'. Consequently, the Supreme Court remitted the matter back to the Tribunal, constituted by a different member, for reconsideration and for the hearing of further evidence in relation to whether special circumstances exist. Following the remittal, the Tribunal ordered the parties to file any further evidence and submissions on the issue of whether special circumstances exist warranting the grant of approval for the inclusion of the clause in the Lease. The Tribunal directed that the matter be dealt with on the documents unless otherwise ordered by the Tribunal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 24 March 2021, the Tribunal determined the Application (Decision). The Tribunal ordered that the inclusion of clause 33.3 in the Lease was approved, and otherwise ordered that:… the Tribunal has no power to consider special condition 5 in item 20 of the Schedule in an application under s 13(7) of the Act, as a redevelopment or relocation clause falls exclusively within the provisions of s 14A of the Act, and a separate application is required under s 14A(3). The Landlord appealed the Decision. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal[1] on the basis that Special Condition 5 was a clause which permitted early termination of the lease for the redevelopment of the shopping centre in which the Premises is located.[2] However, Archer J concluded that she was unable to receive additional evidence to substantiate the existence of 'special circumstances' in this case,[3] and that on its face, the Application itself did not establish the existence of 'special circumstances'. Accordingly, her Honour remitted the matter to the Tribunal, to be constituted by a different member, for reconsideration and 'for the hearing of further evidence in relation to whether special circumstances exist'.[4] [1] Synicast Pty Ltd as Trustee for the Quentin Avenue Unit Trust v Showroom X Pty Ltd [2021] WASC 449 (Synicast).[2] Synicast at [22] – [23] (Archer J).[3] Synicastat [28] (Archer J).[4] Orders of the Hon Justice Archer 2 December 2021. For the reasons which follow, approval should be given to the inclusion in the Lease of Special Condition 5. The Application, as initially filed, was supported by a letter from the Landlord's solicitors dated 23 March 2021 (Letter), which attached a three line statement described as 'acknowledgment and consent by lessee' which was, apparently, signed by a director of the Tenant on 22 March 2021 (Tenant Consent), and a document setting out what were said to be the terms of clause 33 and Special Condition 5. The Application as originally filed was not accompanied by a copy of the Lease in its entirety. Further, as explained below, the copy of Special Condition 5 which was provided with the Application did not actually reflect the terms of Special Condition 5 as it appeared in the Lease. In the Letter, the Landlord's solicitors submitted that Special Condition 5 'constitutes special circumstances within the meaning given to that term by the Supreme Court as held in 480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Irwin St Lower Pty Ltd.[5][5] 480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Irwin St Lower Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 59 (480 Hay Street v Irwin St). No further evidence or submissions were provided to the Tribunal when the Application was filed to explain why special circumstances existed warranting the grant of approval for the inclusion of Special Condition 5 in the Lease. Following the remittal of the Application to the Tribunal for reconsideration, the Tribunal ordered that the Landlord file any further evidence on which the Landlord intended to rely, together with any submission 'about what the special circumstance is for which it seeks approval pursuant to s 13(7) of the [Act]'. In addition, the Landlord was ordered to 'clarify whether in its view proposed special condition 5.2 and 5.3 in Item 20 of the Schedule, which relate to compensation for any early termination of the lease pursuant to s 13(7) of the Act, is to be approved by the Tribunal pursuant to s 13(7)'. The Tenant was given the opportunity to file a submission and evidence in response. The Tribunal ordered that the matter be dealt with on the documents unless otherwise ordered by the Tribunal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ordinary principles of statutory construction would require that general provisions give way to specific provisions.[35] If that approach to the construction of the Act were adopted, applications for approval for relocation clauses would be dealt with under s 14A(3) rather than s 13(7) of the Act. However, a series of decisions of the Supreme Court, in appeals against Tribunal decisions, might be seen to be inconsistent with that approach. Each involved an appeal against a decision of the Tribunal refusing approval under s 13(7) of the Act. In each case, the Court found that the Tribunal had erred in law in reaching that decision, and itself proceeded to consider whether special circumstances existed, sufficient to warrant approval for an early termination clause under s 13(7) of the Act. In each case, the Court found that special circumstances existed, and granted approval for the early termination clause.[35] Refrigerated Express Lines (A/asia) Pty Ltd v Australian Meat and Live-Stock Corporation (1980) 44 FLR 455 at [469]; 29 ALR 333 at [347]. In WASCF Alliance, special circumstances were found to exist sufficient to warrant approval under s 13(7) of the Act where the landlord had plans to redevelop and demolish a shopping centre; where the early termination clause was only to operate if the major tenant of the shopping centre intended to vacate; when that tenant had in fact done so; and where the lessee had agreed to the proposed early termination clause.[36] (I note that nothing in the Tribunal's decision which was the subject of the appeal (that is, its order) made any reference to s 14A, and there is no discussion of s 14A in the Court's reasons.) [36] WASCF Alliance at [24]. In 480 Hay Street v Irwin St, special circumstances were found to exist sufficient to warrant approval under s 13(7) of the Act where the subject retail shop premises was located within the footprint of a proposed redevelopment of an office building; where the subject tenancy was marketed on the basis that it would be part of that future office building; where the subject premises was only accessible through the premises of another, larger tenancy and could only be tenanted in conjunction with that tenancy; where the subject lease contemplated that if the larger tenancy terminated, the subject lease would also terminate; and where the tenant of the subject lease was to be compensated by significantly reduced rent and other favourable terms.[37] [37] 480 Hay Street v Irwin St at [41] – [43] (Curthoys J). In that case, the Tribunal's order noted that the lease term was not approved because the Tribunal had no power to do so under s 13(7) of the Act, and a separate application was required under s 14A(3). One of the grounds of appeal was that the Tribunal had erred in finding that the lease clause was in the nature of a relocation clause, and that the Tribunal had failed to consider whether special circumstances existed for the purposes of s 13(7). Curthoys J held that the subject lease did not deal with the relocation of the tenant's business in the event of the redevelopment of the office building (that is, the subject termination clause was not a 'relocation clause' in the sense that I have defined it). His Honour found that s 14A of the Act was 'concerned with forced relocation and is silent with respect to the issue of redevelopment … Further, it does not deal with the early termination of the [l]ease.'[38] He therefore considered it open to the Tribunal to have dealt with the application for approval under s 13(7) of the Act. [38] Cf 480 Hay Street v Irwin St at [35] (Curthoys J).