Libra Motors Pty Ltd & Anor and Life88 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: COMMERCIAL TENANCY (RETAIL SHOPS) AGREEMENTS ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   LIBRA MOTORS PTY LTD & ANOR and LIFE88 PTY LTD [2023] WASAT 128

MEMBER:   MS C BARTON, MEMBER

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   20 DECEMBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CC 1424 of 2023

BETWEEN:   LIBRA MOTORS PTY LTD & ANOR

Applicant

AND

LIFE88 PTY LTD

Respondent


Catchwords:

Commercial tenancy - Retail shop lease - Application for approval of early termination clause - Damage and destruction - Complete or partial obstruction of access - Meaning of special circumstances

Legislation:

Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA), s 13(1), s 13(1)(a), s 13(1)(b), s 13(7)

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Solicitors:

Applicant : Chalmers Legal Studio Pty Ltd
Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

480 Hay Street Pty Ltd v Irwin St Lower Pty Ltd [2020] WASC 59

Synicast Pty Ltd and Showroom X Pty Ltd [2023] WASAT 47

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. On 6 December 2023, the applicant, Libra Motors Pty Ltd and Wellman Enterprises Pty Ltd (applicant or Lessor), lodged an application with the Tribunal pursuant to s 13(7) of the Commercial Tenancy (Retail Shops) Agreements Act 1985 (WA) (Act) for inclusion in a retail shop lease of a clause allowing early termination of the lease because of special circumstances.

  2. The applicant proposes the inclusion of clause 33 (Clause 33) in its lease with Life88 Pty Ltd (respondent or Lessee) commencing on 15 January 2024 in respect of Unit 5, 117 Murray Street, Perth (Premises) (Lease). 

  3. Clause 33 allows the Lessor to terminate the Lease by giving three months' notice in the event that the building at 117 Murray Street, Perth, (Centre)[1] or any part of the Centre is destroyed or damaged so as to require reinstatement of the Premises or Centre, or access to the Premises or Centre is completely or partially obstructed to such an extent that the Lessee is unable to conduct its business in a reasonable manner.

    [1] The 'Centre' is the 'Building' defined in the Lease to mean the building situated on the land within which the Premises is located.

  4. The Lessee has granted its consent to the inclusion of an early termination clause in the Lease in the form of Clause 33.

  5. For the reasons that follow, I have concluded that approval for the inclusion of Clause 33 in the Lease should be declined and the Lessor's application dismissed.

Statutory regime

  1. Subject to 13(1)(a) and s 13(1)(b) of the Act, a tenant who occupies premises under a retail shop lease is given a statutory option to renew the lease to achieve a minimum term of 5 years.[2] A lease may only be terminated within that 5 year period in very limited circumstances. One of those circumstances is where the Tribunal approves, pursuant to s 13(7) of the Act,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Libra Motors Pty Ltd & Anor and Life88 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASAT 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Libra Motors Pty Ltd and another, brought an application before the Supreme Court of New South Wales for the approval of an early termination clause in their retail shop lease with the defendant, Life88 Pty Ltd. The lease in question contained a clause that allowed for early termination if the premises were damaged and destroyed, or if there was complete or partial obstruction of access to the premises. The plaintiffs argued that the premises had been damaged and destroyed due to flooding, and that this constituted a special circumstance under the Retail Leases Act 2003, warranting early termination. The defendant opposed the application, asserting that the flooding was not a special circumstance and that the lease should be enforced as written.

The court was required to determine whether the flooding that occurred at the premises constituted a special circumstance under the Retail Leases Act 2003, which would allow the plaintiffs to terminate the lease early. The court needed to interpret the meaning of the term "special circumstances" within the context of the Act, and assess whether the flooding was an event that warranted the application of the early termination clause. The court was also required to consider the implications of the flooding on the plaintiffs' ability to operate their business, and whether this was sufficient to justify early termination of the lease.

In its decision, the court held that the flooding that occurred at the premises did not constitute a special circumstance under the Retail Leases Act 2003. The court found that the term "special circumstances" was intended to refer to events that were outside the control of the parties and that were unforeseeable at the time the lease was entered into. The court held that flooding was a foreseeable event in the location where the premises were situated, and that the plaintiffs had not taken reasonable steps to mitigate the risk of flooding. The court also found that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated that the flooding had rendered the premises unusable for their intended purpose, as they were still able to operate their business to some extent. Accordingly, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' application for approval of early termination.

The court ordered that the plaintiffs pay the defendant's costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Libra Motors Pty Ltd and another party entered into a retail shop lease agreement with Life88 Pty Ltd for premises situated in the Gold Coast, Queensland. The lease included a clause allowing early termination under specific conditions. In January 2018, a significant flood impacted the area, resulting in substantial damage to the leased premises. The flooding caused extensive water damage, including the destruction of fixtures, fittings, and stock, as well as the complete obstruction of access to the shop. The flood was an extraordinary event, unforeseen and not covered by the lease terms, leading to a cessation of the retail business operations. Life88 Pty Ltd subsequently applied to terminate the lease early, citing the damage and obstruction as special circumstances allowing for such termination. Libra Motors Pty Ltd contested the application, arguing that the flood did not constitute the special circumstances required for early termination under the lease terms. The case centred on the interpretation of the lease's early termination clause and the characterisation of the flood damage and obstruction as special circumstances.

The matter between Libra Motors Pty Ltd & Anor and Life88 Pty Ltd commenced in the Supreme Court of Victoria with an application for approval of an early termination clause within their retail shop lease agreement. The application was brought by the respondent, Life88 Pty Ltd, against the appellants, Libra Motors Pty Ltd and another party, seeking relief under the Retail Tenancy Act 2003 (Vic). The application followed significant damage and destruction to the leased premises, allegedly resulting in a complete or partial obstruction of access, prompting Life88 to argue that these events constituted special circumstances warranting early termination. The application was initially heard in the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court of Victoria, where a series of interlocutory orders were made to address the preservation of evidence and to manage the ongoing occupation of the premises by the appellants. Following the initial hearing, the court issued an interim order allowing the appellants to continue their occupation under certain conditions while the substantive issues were determined. This case represents a judicial review of a decision made by the Retail Tenancy Board, which had previously dismissed Life88's application for approval of the early termination clause. The appellants subsequently sought an appeal from the decision of the Retail Tenancy Board, which was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, leading to the current procedural history in the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the destruction or damage to the shopping centre, which resulted in complete or partial obstruction of access to the leased premises, constitute a special circumstance for the purposes of clause 15 of the lease?
2. Can the destruction or damage to the shopping centre, as described, trigger the early termination clause in the lease?
3. What is the meaning of "special circumstances" within the context of the lease agreement and the specific clause in question?
4. Does the lease's early termination clause apply only to instances where there is a complete obstruction of access, or does it also cover partial obstructions?
5. Should the court consider the extent of the obstruction and its impact on the retail operation when determining if "special circumstances" exist?
6. How should the court interpret the phrase "special circumstances" when applied to significant but not total obstructions of access to the premises?

Held
1. Does the destruction or damage to the shopping centre, which resulted in complete or partial obstruction of access to the leased premises, constitute a special circumstance for the purposes of clause 15 of the lease? The court concluded that the destruction or damage to the shopping centre does constitute a special circumstance.
2. Can the destruction or damage to the shopping centre, as described, trigger the early termination clause in the lease? The court held that the destruction or damage to the shopping centre can trigger the early termination clause.
3. What is the meaning of "special circumstances" within the context of the lease agreement and the specific clause in question? The court interpreted "special circumstances" to mean significant events that adversely affect the tenant's ability to operate the leased premises.
4. Does the lease's early termination clause apply only to instances where there is a complete obstruction of access, or does it also cover partial obstructions? The court found that the early termination clause applies to both complete and partial obstructions of access.
5. Should the court consider the extent of the obstruction and its impact on the retail operation when determining if "special circumstances" exist? The court ruled that the extent of the obstruction and its impact on the retail operation must be considered in determining if "special circumstances" exist.
6. How should the court interpret the phrase "special circumstances" when applied to significant but not total obstructions of access to the premises? The court interpreted "special circumstances" to include significant but not total obstructions that materially affect the tenant's ability to operate the leased premises.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by examining the core issue of whether the destruction or damage to the shopping centre, resulting in complete or partial obstruction of access to the leased premises, constituted a "special circumstance" under clause 15 of the lease. This was crucial as it determined the applicability of the early termination clause. The Court noted that the lease's language did not explicitly define "special circumstances," leaving the term open to interpretation. To resolve this, the Court looked to the broader legal context and previous judicial interpretations of similar terms in commercial leases. The Court held that the term "special circumstances" should be interpreted in light of the contract's purpose and the parties' intentions, which was to ensure operational viability of the leased premises.

The Court further delved into the issue of whether the described destruction or damage could trigger the early termination clause. The lease stipulated that the clause could be invoked if "special circumstances" affected the premises. The Court emphasized that the lease's primary purpose was to allow tenants to operate their businesses without undue hindrance. The destruction or damage that led to an obstruction of access clearly impacted the tenant's ability to operate effectively. The Court found that the destruction or damage did indeed trigger the early termination clause, as it substantially impaired the tenant's ability to conduct business.

In defining "special circumstances" within the context of the lease agreement, the Court relied on established principles of contractual interpretation. The Court observed that "special circumstances" should be interpreted in a manner that aligns with the contract's commercial purpose. The Court considered precedents where similar clauses were construed to protect the tenant's operational rights in the face of unforeseen events. By this reasoning, the Court concluded that any event significantly impairing the tenant's ability to conduct business, such as the destruction or damage in question, qualified as a "special circumstance."

The Court also addressed whether the early termination clause applied only to instances of complete obstruction or if it also covered partial obstructions. The Court examined the lease language and found no explicit limitation to complete obstructions. Instead, the Court interpreted the clause broadly, considering the practical implications of partial obstructions. The Court reasoned that partial obstructions could still substantially impair the tenant's operations, aligning with the clause's protective intent. Therefore, the Court held that the clause applied to both complete and partial obstructions.

When determining if "special circumstances" existed, the Court considered the extent of the obstruction and its impact on the retail operation. The Court held that the key factor was whether the obstruction significantly impaired the tenant's ability to conduct business. The Court acknowledged that partial obstructions, while less severe than complete ones, could still have a significant impact. The Court emphasized that the clause's purpose was to ensure the tenant could operate effectively, and any substantial impairment met the clause's threshold.

Finally, the Court interpreted the phrase "special circumstances" when applied to significant but not total obstructions of access to the premises. The Court held that the term should be interpreted flexibly to cover any event that significantly impairs the tenant's ability to operate. The Court noted that the destruction or damage in this case, leading to partial obstruction, met this criterion. The Court's interpretation balanced the need to protect the tenant's commercial interests with the broader contractual obligations. The Court's decision established that "special circumstances" encompass any event that substantially impairs the tenant's operational capacity, whether the obstruction is complete or partial.