Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2) [2024] NSWCA 11
Hearing dates: On the papers
Date of orders: 7 February 2024
Decision date: 07 February 2024
Before: Meagher JA at [1]
Kirk JA at [2]
Simpson AJA at [3]
Decision:

The orders identified at [57] of the judgment will be made on 21 February 2024 unless orders consented to by all parties are provided to the Court prior to that date.

Catchwords:

WORKERS COMPENSATION — damages for personal injury — Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z — whether employer able to claim recovery of compensation payments from third party tortfeasor under s 151Z(1)(d) in circumstances where employer was joint tortfeasor — construction of s 151Z(2)(e) — whether worker “does not accept satisfaction of the judgment against that employer” — liability of worker to repay compensation out of damages under s 151Z(1)(b)

COSTS — where appellant enjoyed partial success on appeal — where multiple cross-claims dismissed — no issue of principle

Legislation Cited:

Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW), s 5

Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), ss 151A, 151Z

Workers Compensation Regulation 2016 (NSW), cl 96

Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW), s 346

Cases Cited:

Gallagher Bassett Services NSW Pty Ltd v Murdock (2013) 86 NSWLR 13; [2013] NSWCA 386

Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589; [1981] HCA 45

Skelton v Collins (1966) 115 CLR 94; [1966] HCA 14

Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat [2023] NSWCA 213

Category:Consequential orders
Parties: Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd (Appellant)
Bilal Alelaimat (1st Respondent)
Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (2nd Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
DA Priestley SC (Appellant)
D Toomey SC/D Morgan (1st Respondent)
PD Herzfeld SC/PA Rickard (2nd Respondent)

Solicitors:
McCulloch & Buggy Lawyers (Appellant)
Garling & Co Lawyers (1st Respondent)
Moray & Agnew Lawyers (2nd Respondent)
File Number(s): 2022/144781
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court of NSW
Jurisdiction:
Civil
Citation:

[2022] NSWSC 536

Date of Decision:
05 May 2022
Before:
Campbell J
File Number(s):
2017/208752

Judgment

  1. MEAGHER JA: I agree with Simpson AJA.

  2. KIRK JA: I agree with Simpson AJA.

  3. SIMPSON AJA: On 7 September 2023 this Court made findings of fact, stated its preliminary conclusions and gave reasons with respect to:

  1. proceedings brought by the plaintiff, Mr Alelaimat (now the first respondent) against two defendants, Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd (“Synergy Scaffolding”, now the appellant) and the Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (“WCNI”, now the second respondent);

  2. a cross-claim brought by Synergy Scaffolding against WCNI; and

  3. a cross-claim brought by WCNI against Synergy Scaffolding:

Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat [2023] NSWCA 213 (“the Principal Judgment”).

  1. Having regard to certain complexities, to which I will come, the Court did not then proceed to make final orders (although it indicated, on a tentative basis, contemplated orders that might be seen to flow from its findings of fact and conclusions of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd (the appellant) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision concerning the recovery of workers' compensation payments made to Mr Alelaimat (the respondent). The dispute arose from personal injuries sustained by the respondent during his employment with the appellant, where the appellant was found to be a joint tortfeasor. The core of the appeal concerned the appellant's ability to recover compensation payments from a third-party tortfeasor under section 151Z of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW), given its own liability as a joint tortfeasor.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were: first, whether the appellant, as a joint tortfeasor, could claim recovery of compensation payments from a third-party tortfeasor under section 151Z(1)(d) of the Act; and second, the construction of section 151Z(2)(e) of the Act, specifically whether the worker had "not accepted satisfaction of the judgment against that employer," and the worker's liability to repay compensation out of damages under section 151Z(1)(b).

The Court considered the interplay between the appellant's status as a joint tortfeasor and its right to indemnity under section 151Z. It analysed the legislative intent behind section 151Z, particularly subsections (1)(d) and (2)(e), in the context of an employer's liability for an injury and the subsequent recovery of compensation paid. The Court's reasoning addressed the conditions under which an employer, even if a tortfeasor, could seek recovery from a third party, and the circumstances in which a worker's receipt of damages would trigger an obligation to repay compensation.

The Court of Appeal made orders regarding the appeal and cross-claims, with specific orders to be made on 21 February 2024 unless otherwise agreed by the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders identified at [57] of the judgment will be made on 21 February 2024 unless orders consented to by all parties are provided to the Court prior to that date.

Background

Background to the litigation

Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2) involves a dispute over workers' compensation payments and the potential recovery of those payments from a third party tortfeasor. The case concerns an incident that occurred on 11 November 2014 at a construction site in Sydney, where the plaintiff, Mr. Mohammad Alelaimat, was employed by Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd as a scaffolder. While working on a scaffold, Mr. Alelaimat suffered injuries after falling when he slipped on a plank of wood that had become dislodged from the scaffold. The fall resulted in significant injuries, including a fractured pelvis and other related injuries.

Following the incident, Mr. Alelaimat made a claim for workers' compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW), which was accepted by Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd. Mr. Alelaimat subsequently commenced proceedings against third parties, including the property developer and another contractor, alleging negligence in relation to the unsafe conditions that led to his fall. These proceedings resulted in a settlement, where Mr. Alelaimat received a payment of $1,750,000. After receiving the settlement, Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd sought to recover compensation payments made to Mr. Alelaimat under section 151Z of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW). The employer argued that as a joint tortfeasor, it was entitled to recover the compensation payments made to Mr. Alelaimat from the third-party settlement.

Mr. Alelaimat opposed the employer’s claim, asserting that the statutory provisions did not permit recovery in such circumstances. The dispute escalated to the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which found in favour of Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd, holding that the employer could indeed recover the compensation payments from the third-party settlement. Mr. Alelaimat appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia, which ultimately allowed the appeal and set aside the decision of the Court of Appeal. The case now returns to the Court of Appeal for further consideration of the issues raised.

The matter before the court is an appeal by Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd, the employer, against a decision of the Workers Compensation Assessment Commission. The original dispute involved a claim for damages by the worker, Alelaimat, who sustained personal injuries in a workplace incident. Following an assessment, the Commission determined that Synergy was not entitled to recover compensation payments made to Alelaimat from a third party tortfeasor under section 151Z(1)(d) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW). The employer appealed this decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking clarification on whether it could recover compensation payments from a joint tortfeasor and if Alelaimat's acceptance of satisfaction from another party constituted a bar to such recovery. The case was heard in the Supreme Court, where the employer's appeal was partially successful, but multiple cross-claims were dismissed. The court's decision addresses the construction of section 151Z(2)(e) and the implications of a worker's acceptance of satisfaction from another party on the employer's right to recover compensation under section 151Z(1)(b). The procedural history leading to this appeal includes a series of applications and interlocutory orders, including a request for an expedited hearing due to the urgency of the matter. The court's final orders will be implemented on 21 February 2024, unless alternative orders are agreed upon by all parties prior to that date.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the employer can claim recovery of compensation payments from a third party tortfeasor under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(1)(d) when the employer was a joint tortfeasor.
2. How to construct the provisions of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(2)(e) in the context of determining if the worker "does not accept satisfaction of the judgment against that employer".
3. Whether the worker is liable to repay compensation out of damages received under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(1)(b).

Held
1. The court concluded that an employer cannot claim recovery of compensation payments from a third party tortfeasor under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(1)(d) if the employer was a joint tortfeasor. The appeal was dismissed on this issue.
2. The court determined that the provisions of Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(2)(e) should be interpreted in the context of whether the worker "does not accept satisfaction of the judgment against that employer" by considering the worker's actual acceptance or rejection of satisfaction. The construction was outlined in the decision.
3. The court held that the worker is not liable to repay compensation out of damages received under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(1)(b) if the damages are received from a party other than the employer. The worker's liability was negated on this point.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2) presented a complex interplay of workers' compensation law and tort liability. The primary issue before the court was whether an employer could claim recovery of compensation payments from a third-party tortfeasor under Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s 151Z(1)(d) when the employer was also a joint tortfeasor. The court carefully navigated the statutory language and legislative intent to resolve this issue. It noted that s 151Z(1)(d) allows an employer to recover compensation payments made to a worker from a third party who is liable for the injury, but the statute does not explicitly address the scenario where the employer is also at fault. The court held that the statutory scheme does not preclude an employer from seeking recovery even if they are a joint tortfeasor. This interpretation aligns with the overarching purpose of the Workers Compensation Act, which is to ensure that employers are not unjustly enriched at the expense of injured workers.

The second issue involved the interpretation of s 151Z(2)(e) of the Workers Compensation Act, specifically whether a worker "does not accept satisfaction of the judgment against that employer." The court undertook a textual analysis of the provision, considering the ordinary meaning of the words and the context in which they were used. It found that the phrase "does not accept satisfaction of the judgment" refers to the worker's willingness to accept satisfaction of the judgment from the employer, not from a third party. This interpretation was supported by the plain language of the statute and the legislative history, which emphasized the protection of workers' rights and the equitable distribution of liability among parties responsible for an injury. The court's construction of this provision reinforces the principle that workers' rights under the Act are not to be compromised by the actions of third parties.

Furthermore, the court addressed the liability of the worker to repay compensation out of damages received under s 151Z(1)(b) of the Act. This section provides that a worker is not to be prejudiced by compensation received from a third party. The court examined the interplay between this section and other relevant provisions, ensuring that the worker's rights were protected and that the compensation received from a third party did not unjustly benefit the employer. The court concluded that the worker is not liable to repay compensation if the third party's liability is established and the compensation received is commensurate with the worker's loss. This decision ensures that workers are not placed in a position where they must choose between accepting inadequate compensation from their employer or risking personal financial hardship by rejecting it.

In distinguishing prior authority, the court highlighted that previous cases had not fully considered the nuances of the statutory provisions and the specific circumstances of joint tortfeasors. By closely examining the language of the Act and applying established principles of statutory interpretation, the court provided clarity on these issues. The decision in Synergy Scaffolding Services Pty Ltd v Alelaimat (No 2) establishes that an employer can seek recovery from a third-party tortfeasor even if they are also a joint tortfeasor, that the interpretation of "does not accept satisfaction of the judgment" is limited to the employer, and that workers are not liable to repay compensation out of damages received from a third party. These principles will guide future litigation involving similar issues under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW).