Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
I will first set out the evidence in narrative form, and make some findings on the basis of that evidence. Unless the context suggests otherwise, unqualified statements of fact are to be taken to reflect my finding of the fact stated. Next, I will consider the meaning of s 119(1)(a) of the FW Act. I will then consider whether PW contravened s 119(1)(a) of the FW Act and, if so, whether Mr Vercoe or Mr Fink or both were involved in such contravention.EVIDENCE AND SOME FINDINGSPW’s business PW was formed in 1992 to exploit a warehouse software management system it owned by making it available to customers who operate warehouses, and to train customers in the use of the software.[2] This constituted PW’s business for up to at least some time after PW terminated Mr Symons’ employment.[2] 09.08.2021 T66.20 The original shareholders and directors of PW were Mr Vercoe senior, Mr Gerard Macreadie, and Mr Warren Notley.[3] Mr Notley passed away in May 2015, and Mr Macreadie retired in June 2015. In May and June 2015 Mr Vercoe acquired their shares in PW.[4] Mr Vercoe senior was the moving force behind PW’s business until he passed away in October 2019. [3] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [3], [4]; affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [13][4] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [15]; affidavit M Tzirtzilakis 20.05.2021, [4], annexure MXT-1Mr Symons’ employment with PW On about 8 May 1998 Mr Symons commenced employment with PW as an “Implementation Consultant”. At that time around 10 to 12 persons, including the directors, worked in PW’s business.[5] As implementation consultant Mr Symons trained employees in the use PW’s software, and undertook “go-live” support of clients in their use of PW’s software.[5] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [5] In about 2000 or 2001 PW employed another two or three implementation consultants, and they reported to Mr Symons. By that time Mr Symons occupied the position of operations manager. [6][6] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [9] In about 2007 or 2008 PW appointed Mr Symons general manager.[7] [7] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [12]Mr Vercoe joins PW In February 2010 Mr Vercoe was appointed chief information officer of PW. In that role Mr Vercoe focused on PW’s information technology department and capabilities.[8] In 2015 Mr Vercoe was appointed chief financial officer.[8] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [8], [9]July 2017 – Mr Symons signs employment contract On about 1 July 2017 Mr Symons signed an employment contact (Employment Contract) which described his title as “Executive Manager of Sales and Marketing”. Although the Employment Contract describes Mr Symons’ position as “Executive Manager of Sales and Marketing”, on the pleadings it is agreed that Mr Symons’ held the position of general manager.[9] [9] Affidavit of S W Symons 13.08.2020, [18], [19]Mr Symons’ duties and responsibilities There are a number of items of evidence that are relevant to identifying the duties and responsibilities attached to Mr Symons’ employment with PW immediately before PW terminated his employment. (a)In his affidavit of 15 September 2020 Mr Vercoe says:[10][10] Affidavit M J Vercoe 15.09.2020, [5]The Applicant was employed as a “General Manager - Sales and Marketing”. The Applicant’s duties consisted of, among other things, managing new client acquisitions; managing existing client relationships; managing the engagement of major projects with existing clients; overseeing marketing strategies; inducting and training sales staff; assisting with closing sales; obtaining client agreements to proceed with major projects and raising the profile of the First Respondent as a premium WMS solutions provider.(b)In his affidavit of 20 May 2021 Mr Vercoe says that Mr Symons held the position of “General Manager – Sales and Marketing” for approximately 12 years. The person occupying that position would report directly to the managing director and CEO of PW. There were other positions in PW’s business “with similar reporting duties to” the managing director and CEO of PW, these being the “Chief Financial Officer”, the “Chief Technical Officer (Systems Manager)”, and the “Chief Operating Officer (Operations Manager)”. Mr Vercoe says that these positions, including “General Manager – Sales and Marketing,” “are senior positions” on which “the Managing Director and CEO rely . . . to receive direct reports . . . to manage the business”.[11] Mr Vercoe also said that Mr Symons’ position “involved leading the Sales and Marketing department”.[12] There may be some doubt about Mr Vercoe’s evidence that PW had a position known as “Chief Operating Officer (Operations Manager)”. As I note later, Mr Mannion has given evidence, which I accept, that in October 2019 Mr Vercoe senior requested Mr Mannion assume the role of chief operating officer shortly before PW terminated Mr Symons employment; and the position Mr Vercoe senior requested Mr Mannion assume was a new role.[13][11] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [30]-[33][12] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [18][13] 09.08.2021 T35.30. “It was a non-existent role. It was being created for the first time. No one had ever been the COO at that point.”(c)In evidence given under cross-examination Mr Vercoe said that Mr Symons’ role was General Manager of Sales and Marketing; and that Mr Symons “was the primary manager for the sales and marketing functions within” PW.[14][14] 09.08.2021 T58.5(d)There is the Employment Contract. [15] Mr Symons says the contract he signed did not contain any job descriptions; and it did not identify the duties Mr Symons was required to perform.[16] That is not correct. The Employment Contract provided that Mr Symons’ basic functions were to manage new client acquisitions, manage existing client relationships, manage the engagement of major projects with existing clients, and oversee marketing strategies and the execution of such strategies. The Employment Contract also provided that Mr Symons’ responsibilities were to induct and train sales persons, assist with closing sales, obtain client agreements to proceed with major projects, position PW as a reliable and valued business partner and solutions provider, ensure PW got value for its marketing investments, and raise PW’s profile as the premium “WMS” solutions provider.[15] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [21]; annexure “MJV-2”[16] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [18](e)In his affidavit Mr Symons says he reported to PW’s board, and every other employee reported to him. Mr Symons says he was responsible for: [17][17] Affidavit S W Symons 13.08.2020, [15](i)sales and marketing;(ii)managing high level client and customer relationships;(iii)direct supervision of the operations managers;(iv)acting as “project champion” for all major client projects; (v)the overall management of PW’s employees, including software developers, implementation consultants, logistic consultants, and (until 2017) employees responsible for collecting accounts receivable; (vi)overseeing a 24 hour per day, 7 days per week, support service for customers; and(vii)the complete operations of the business, including the training of implementation consultants, “go-live support”, and “software development”.(f)In evidence given under cross-examination Mr Symons said he ran PW’s business “but for the financial and accounting side on a day-to-day basis”.[18](g)In evidence given under cross-examination, Mr Mannion said PW had a small leadership team, so there was not one person in particular employees reported to; Mr Symons was Mr Mannion’s “direct line”, but on occasions Mr Mannion reported to Mr Vercoe senior and the other directors, Mr Macreadie, and Mr Notley; PW’s functions were spread across various managers within the senior leadership team, and a lot of the different departments within PW were spread across a number of people, so that managers would get involved with many different departments at the same time; Mr Symons not only had a “sales and marketing remit” but he also had responsibility for parts of PW’s operations, in particular software development; Mr Mannion saw Mr Symons in the general manager role “as having a number of responsibilities overarching”; he was “in charge of most of . . . the tasks that were required within” PW, so that Mr Mannion reported to Mr Symons “with anything that was critical and of importance within the operations role, and likewise . . . it was the same with software and development”.[19] For reasons I give later, I find that Mr Mannion was a witness of credit on whose evidence I can rely with confidence.(h)There is the evidence of Mr Fink. Mr Fink was appointed director on 9 October 2020 after he had acquired PW. When he commenced his role as director Mr Fink attempted to gain an understanding of PW’s business “from reviewing the records”.[20] Under cross-examination Mr Fink gave the following evidence:[21]Scott Symons was the General Manager and basically ran the company and had everybody reporting to him and I believe that at the time the – you know, the business was going along very successfully, understaffed if anything, and they – they – you know, you couldn’t – you couldn’t remove basically the key person and key face to the business, especially after John [Vercoe’s] demise, that he was almost the key man . . . .[18] 09.08.2021 T19.19[19] 09.08.2021 T33.10-T34.5[20] Affidavit P A Fink 04.08.2021, [9][21] 09.08.2021 T77.202019 – Mr Vercoe appointed to various positions
Decision
Reasons for decision
It is not necessary to make any more precise findings than that some three years before PW terminated Mr Symons’ employment, Mr Vercoe and Mr Symons, while intoxicated, were parties to a heated verbal altercation that occurred late in the evening at a pub after an all-day senior executive workshop. There is no evidence, and it has not been suggested, that any altercation, let alone one that approached the nature of the altercation at the pub, occurred at the workplace; and there is no evidence that Mr Vercoe’s and Mr Symons’ relationship at the workplace was anything other than professional. Decision to terminate Employment Contract There are a number of items of evidence that are relevant to assessing the reasons for which PW terminated Mr Symons’ employment.Mr Vercoe’s affidavit of 20 May 2021 In his affidavit made on 20 May 2021 Mr Vercoe deposes he had three reasons for terminating Mr Symons’ employment: Mr Vercoe senior “had indicated he wanted to terminate Mr Symons [sic] employment prior to him passing away”; Mr Vercoe had “a very poor relationship with Mr Symons and [had] been threatened by him”; and the “Board had suggested employing someone with better skills”.[34] The following observations may be made about this part of Mr Vercoe’s evidence.(a)Mr Vercoe does not say when Mr Vercoe senior instructed or requested Mr Vercoe, or otherwise expressed to Mr Vercoe a wish that Mr Vercoe terminate Mr Symons’ employment; nor does Mr Vercoe set out the effect of the words by which Mr Vercoe senior conveyed his instructions or desire that Mr Vercoe terminate Mr Symons’ employment. Further, Mr Vercoe’s evidence is silent about the reasons Mr Vercoe senior gave for such instruction or request. Mr Vercoe senior could have made the request either because he was not satisfied with Mr Symons’ performance or because he was of the view that the job Mr Symons performed was no longer required performed by any person.(b)Mr Vercoe does not identify when “the Board” suggested employing someone with better skills, or the person or persons who were members of the board at the time the suggestion was made, or the effect of the words by which the person or persons who were board members conveyed the suggestion that PW employ a person with “better skills”.(c)Mr Vercoe does not identify any incident in or outside of the workplace, other than the altercation that occurred at the pub three years before PW terminated Mr Symons’ employment, or any other matter, on the basis of which he deposed that he and Mr Symons had a very poor relationship.[34] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [50] Mr Vercoe also deposes that he “could see there was a lack of effective leadership and the inability to manage [Mr Symons’] workload”; Mr Vercoe “could see [Mr Symons] was reluctant to learn new processes and skills to remain updated”, and Mr Symons’ “level of pay and expenses were also very substantial considering how little he brought in despite being General Manager Sales and Marketing”.[35] These are conclusions, but Mr Vercoe does not identify any particular fact or circumstance on which he has based these conclusions. For that reason alone I give no weight to Mr Vercoe’s conclusions. Further, they appear to be inconsistent with the contents of an email (to which I refer later) Mr Vercoe sent on 22 November 2019 to his sister, Ms Prue Vercoe, to be distributed to PW’s staff announcing Mr Symons’ departure from PW. Mr Vercoe there described Mr Symons as a “valued and long-term employee”, a “respected and well-liked member of the team”, a “huge believer in the company and [its] products”, and a person who “was instrumental in assisting the growth and character of the company and a great support to our Founder John Vercoe”. Mr Vercoe has not given evidence that he authorised an email containing these statements be sent in his name not believing the statements to be true.[35] Affidavit M J Vercoe 20.05.2021, [60], [61]Mr Vercoe’s affidavit of 30 July 2021