Symonds and Symonds

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SYMONDS & SYMONDS [2008] FamCA 858
FAMILY LAW – PROCESS AND PROCEDURE – Applications (part-heard as to one application) to adduce evidence by experts other than single experts

Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) Part 15.5

Louth v Diprose (1992) 175 CLR 62
Commercial Bank of Australia Ltd v Amadio (1983) 151 CLR 461

APPLICANT: Ms Symonds
RESPONDENT: Mr Symonds
FILE NUMBER: MLF 2474 of 2005
DATE DELIVERED: 21 January 2008
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Watt J
HEARING DATE: 21 January 2008

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr A I Strum
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Taussig Cherrie & Associates
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Ms S L Johns
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Stephen Farmer & Associates

Orders

BY CONSENT IT IS ORDERED (AS BETWEEN THE HUSBAND, WIFE AND INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER) THAT:

  1. The wife have leave to:

    (a)file the affidavit of Dr D sworn 21 November 2007; and

    (b)call Dr D by video link between Australia and France.

  2. The husband have leave to file the affidavit of Mr L sworn 20 December 2007.

  3. Liberty be reserved to each party to make objection to the admissibility of parts of the aforesaid affidavits filed by the other party.

  4. The husband attend such therapeutic counsellor as nominated by the independent children’s lawyer and the child M attend upon the counsellor as directed by the counsellor and all counselling be non-reportable.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT:

  1. The wife have leave to file and serve the affidavit of Dr Y sworn 15 November 2007.

  2. Within 28 days the husband may request an examination of the wife by a suitably qualified expert at a date and time not inconvenient to the wife such examination to be at the expense of the husband.

  3. I direct that a copy of any report of the psychiatrist’s assessment obtained by the husband pursuant to paragraph 6 hereof be provided to the wife’s solicitors within 7 days of receipt of that report by the husband or his solicitor.

  4. The wife’s application in a case filed 21 December 2007 is otherwise dismissed.

  5. The husband within 28 days deliver to the single expert witness, Mr M, the reports of Mr H and Mr A together with any questions to be addressed to the single expert witness in accordance with Rule 15.65 of the Family Law Rules 2004.

  6. The husband file and serve an affidavit annexing the questions and answers within 7 days of receipt by him or his solicitor of the answers.

  7. The wife have 28 days to file any affidavit by an appropriately qualified expert that she seeks to rely on in relation to the matters that are the subject of evidence set out in Mr L’s affidavit.

  8. I otherwise adjourn the application in a case filed by the husband on 18 January 2008 to adduce the evidence of Mr H and Mr A to a date to be fixed following the receipt of the single expert witness’ answers.

  9. I list the matter for trial commencing not before 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Symonds and Symonds and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FamCA 858
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned proceedings between a husband and wife, with the Independent Children's Lawyer also a party to the consent orders. The dispute involved various applications and the adducing of evidence, including expert reports and affidavits, in relation to proceedings before Watt J.

The court was required to determine a number of procedural and evidentiary issues. These included granting leave for the filing of affidavits and for a witness to give evidence via video link, as well as authorising the husband to request an examination of the wife by a suitably qualified expert. The court also needed to address the provision of expert reports to a single expert witness and the subsequent filing of questions and answers, and to set a trial date.

Watt J made orders by consent between the husband, wife, and Independent Children's Lawyer. These orders permitted the wife to file an affidavit from Dr D and to call Dr D by video link from France, and allowed the husband to file an affidavit from Mr L. Liberty was reserved for parties to object to the admissibility of parts of these affidavits. Further orders directed the husband to attend counselling and the child M to attend counselling, with all counselling to be non-reportable. The wife was granted leave to file an affidavit from Dr Y. The husband was given 28 days to request an expert examination of the wife at his expense, with any report to be provided to the wife's solicitors within seven days of receipt. The wife's application filed on 21 December 2007 was otherwise dismissed. The husband was directed to provide specific reports and questions to a single expert witness within 28 days, and to file an affidavit annexing the questions and answers within seven days of receipt. The wife was given 28 days to file any expert affidavit she sought to rely on concerning matters in Mr L's affidavit. The husband's application filed on 18 January 2008 was adjourned to a date to be fixed after receipt of the single expert witness's answers. The matter was listed for trial commencing not before 14 July 2008 for an estimated seven days. Specific directions were given regarding the husband's potential cross-examination of Dr D, and the question of costs was reserved. The court also noted that the matter reasonably required the attendance of counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

BY CONSENT IT IS ORDERED (AS BETWEEN THE HUSBAND, WIFE AND INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER) THAT:

1.

The wife have leave to:

(a) file the affidavit of Dr D sworn 21 November 2007; and

(b) call Dr D by video link between Australia and France.

2.

The husband have leave to file the affidavit of Mr L sworn 20 December 2007.

3.

Liberty be reserved to each party to make objection to the admissibility of parts of the aforesaid affidavits filed by the other party.

4.

The husband attend such therapeutic counsellor as nominated by the independent children’s lawyer and the child M attend upon the counsellor as directed by the counsellor and all counselling be non-reportable.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT:

5.

The wife have leave to file and serve the affidavit of Dr Y sworn 15 November 2007.

6.

Within 28 days the husband may request an examination of the wife by a suitably qualified expert at a date and time not inconvenient to the wife such examination to be at the expense of the husband.

7.

I direct that a copy of any report of the psychiatrist’s assessment obtained by the husband pursuant to paragraph 6 hereof be provided to the wife’s solicitors within 7 days of receipt of that report by the husband or his solicitor.

8.

The wife’s application in a case filed 21 December 2007 is otherwise dismissed.

9.

The husband within 28 days deliver to the single expert witness, Mr M, the reports of Mr H and Mr A together with any questions to be addressed to the single expert witness in accordance with Rule 15.65 of the Family Law Rules 2004.

10.

The husband file and serve an affidavit annexing the questions and answers within 7 days of receipt by him or his solicitor of the answers.

11.

The wife have 28 days to file any affidavit by an appropriately qualified expert that she seeks to rely on in relation to the matters that are the subject of evidence set out in Mr L’s affidavit.

12.

I otherwise adjourn the application in a case filed by the husband on 18 January 2008 to adduce the evidence of Mr H and Mr A to a date to be fixed following the receipt of the single expert witness’ answers.

13.

I list the matter for trial commencing not before 14 July 2008 at 10.00am with an estimated duration of seven (7) days.

14.

If the husband seeks to cross-examine Dr D on the basis of any document(s) (other than his affidavit) the husband is to either:

(a) provide the document(s) to be cross-examined on to the wife’s solicitors at least 14 days before the date on which the trial is listed, in which case the wife is to ensure that the documents are made available to Dr D before he gives oral evidence and are in his possession when he gives oral evidence; or

(b) request a listing of the matter for mention before Registrar Riddiford for consideration by him of an oral application for the wife to provide equipment to enable documents to be scanned in Australia and displayed in France during Dr D’s oral evidence by video link.

15.

I reserve the question of costs.

16.

Pursuant to Rule 19.50 of the Family Law Rules this matter reasonably required the attendance of counsel.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.