Supacat Limited v Caterpillar Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Supacat Limited to application under section 92 of the Act by Caterpillar Inc to remove trade mark number 1098554(12) - SUPACAT - in the name of Supacat Limited

Delegate: Iain Campbell Thompson
Representation: Removal Opponent: Andrew Sykes of Counsel instructed by David Drew of Tatlocks Chrysilliou IP
Removal Applicant: Warwick Rothnie of Counsel instructed by Nicholas Butera of Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Decision: 2014 ATMO 104
s92 Removal Opponent’s evidence establishes use in Australia of the Trade Mark in relation to the Goods; otherwise, the Registrar’s discretion would be exercised in favour of retention of the Trade Mark on the Register of Trade Marks.

Background

  1. In this proceeding under paragraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) Caterpillar Inc (‘the Removal Applicant’) applied (‘the Application’) on 23 February 2012 for the removal from the Register of Trade Marks of the trade mark registration which appears below:

Registration No:         1098554
Filing Date:                13 February 2006

Goods:Class 12: Wheeled military vehicles; off-road vehicles; vehicles for use in transporting and launching boats

(‘the Goods’)

Trade Mark:               SUPACAT

(‘the Trade Mark’)

  1. The Application seeks the complete removal of Trade Mark in respect of the Goods.

  2. On 8 June 2012 the owner of the Trade Mark, Supacat Inc, (‘the Removal Opponent’) filed Notice of Opposition to the removal of the Trade Mark.

  3. Both parties have filed evidence as is further discussed under the heading Evidence below.

  4. The matter duly came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, at a hearing in Melbourne on 29 May 2014.  The Removal Opponent was represented by Andrew Sykes of Counsel instructed by David Drew of Tatlocks Chrysilliou IP; and, the Removal Applicant was represented by Warwick Rothnie of Counsel instructed by Nicholas Butera of Corrs Chambers Westgarth.

Onus & Relevant Period

  1. In terms of section 100 of the Act, the burden is on the Removal Opponent to establish the use of the Trade Mark and the relevant period during which the Removal Opponent must establish the use in good faith of the Trade Mark is the three years ending on 23 January 2012 (‘the Relevant Period’).

Evidence

  1. Before the hearing the Removal Opponent applied to file further evidence, this being a statutory declaration by Michael Halloran dated 12 May 2014.  At the start of the hearing there was some discussion whether regulation 5.15 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’) as it was prior to the commencement of the Raising the Bar Act[1] on 15 April 2013 applied to the filing of the further evidence of the Removal Opponent or if the Regulations as they stood post 15 April 2013 applied. The position of the Registrar is that it is regulation 5.15 as it stood at the date the Notice of Opposition was filed which continues to apply to the proceedings.

    [1] Intellectual Property Legislation Amendment (Raising the Bar) Regulation 2013 (No.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Supacat Limited v Caterpillar Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ATMO 104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before the Court concerning a dispute between Supacat Limited (the Removal Opponent) and Caterpillar Inc (the Removal Applicant). The core of the dispute involved the use and registration of the trade mark "Supacat" in Australia. Supacat Limited, a company with a long history of producing off-road and military vehicles, asserted its rights to the trade mark, particularly in relation to vehicles supplied to the Australian Special Air Services Regiment and its tendering processes with the Australian Defence Force.

The legal issues before the Court were primarily concerned with the use and reputation of the trade mark "Supacat" in Australia. Specifically, the Court was required to determine whether Supacat Limited had established sufficient use and recognition of the trade mark in the Australian market to support its claim. This involved assessing evidence of the company's trading activities, public announcements regarding its Australian operations, and the association of the "Supacat" name with its products in Australian publications.

The Court considered evidence presented by both parties, including statutory declarations and annexed exhibits. The Removal Opponent, Supacat Limited, provided evidence detailing its history of vehicle production, its contract to supply vehicles to the Australian SASR, and the common reference to these vehicles as "Supacat" vehicles in Australia. Furthermore, evidence was presented regarding the establishment of its Australian representative company, Supacat Pty Ltd, its public announcements of operational capability in Australia, and its tendering activities with the Australian Defence Force. This evidence aimed to demonstrate a strong market presence and recognition of the "Supacat" trade mark in relation to wheeled military and off-road vehicles within Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the evidence filed in relation to these proceedings comprises the following statutory declarations:Evidence in Support (Removal Opponent)Michael Halloran made on 29 August 2012 with exhibits MH-1 to MH-4Evidence in Answer (Removal Applicant)Christina M Gensler made on 4 September 2013 with exhibits CMG-1 to CMG-25Nicholas Patrick Butera made on 5 September 2013 with annexures NPB-1 to NPB-4.Evidence in Reply (Removal Opponent)Michael Halloran made on 9 December 2013 with exhibit MH-5Further Evidence (Removal Opponent)Michael Halloran made on 12 May 2014 with exhibit MH-6Further Evidence (Removal Applicant)Nicholas Butera made on 1 August 2014 with annexure NPB-5Wayne Higgins RFD, psc (r) made on 6 August 2014Allister E Kirpalani made on 15 August 2014 with annexures AEK-1 to AEK-2Steven Schmied made on 10 August 2014 with annexures SSC-1 to SSC-6 In his first declaration Mr Halloran explains that he is the Managing Director of Supacat Pty Ltd, the Australian representative company of the Removal Opponent which:… has been producing off-road vehicles and military vehicles for 30 years and more details of the range of products offered by [the Removal Opponent] can be seen on their website at Annexed hereto and marked exhibit MH-l are photographs of examples of these products supplied by [the Removal Opponent] around the time of the application for the above referenced Trade Mark Registration, i.e. prior to 2006. Concerning the use by the Removal Opponent of the Trade Mark in Australia, Mr Halloran states:In December 2006, [the Removal Opponent] won a contract to deliver a high mobility transport vehicle (HMT) to the Australian Special Air Services Regiment (SASR). The vehicle was named the "Nary" by the SASR in recognition of one of their fallen colleagues. The vehicles however are commonly referred to in Australia as "Supacat" vehicles. Annexed hereto and marked exhibit MH2 are a bundle of internet articles that have been published between 2008-2011, in Australia. These publications indicate the strong market presence and recognition of the name "Supacat" in relation to "wheeled military vehicles and off-road vehicles" in Australia, and particularly the strong association of the name "Supacat" with the owner's products during that period. Significantly, the articles referred to by Mr Halloran include a range of articles from 19 August 2011 to March 2012, within the relevant period, which relate to the Removal Opponent’s tendering to the Australian Defence Force (‘ADF’) for the supply of its goods under the Trade Mark. Mr Halloran continues:While [the Removal Opponent] and Supacat Pty Ltd have traded under the name of "Supacat", the trading name for my company was formally established in Australia in 2007. The intent to establish operational capability in Australia was announced publicly in Oct 2011 and the company commenced engineering operations in Jan 2012. In addition, Supacat Team Australia was launched in Oct 2011 to establish a network of partners for the purposes of manufacture of spare parts and servicing of Supacat vehicles. Supacat provides services into the Australian market from both the parent company and my company, however, Supacat hardware sold into the Australian market has, to date, been carried out by Supacat in the UK. My company is authorised by Supacat Group Limited to use the Trade Mark "Supacat" in relation to the goods covered by the above referenced registration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.