Sunwater Limited v Drake Coal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sunwater Limited v Drake Coal Pty Ltd and Anor [2015] QSC 320

PARTIES:

SUNWATER LIMITED (ACN 131 034 985)

(Plaintiff)

v
DRAKE COAL PTY LTD (ACN 138 221 600)
(First Defendant)
BYERWEN COAL PTY LTD (ACN 133 357 632)

(Second Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

Brisbane No 6430 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

12 November 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

22 October 2015

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDER:

1.   The application is dismissed.  I shall hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND - PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – OTHER MATTERS – where the plaintiff submitted that certain matters pleaded in the defendants’ proposed amended defence and counterclaim were not capable of giving rise to any legally recognised ground of defence to the plaintiff’s claims – where the plaintiffs made a strike-out application in respect of the paragraphs containing those matters – whether the plaintiffs’ application should be granted

Lumbers v W Cook Builders Pty Ltd (In liq) (2008) 232 CLR 635

COUNSEL:

A Pomerenke QC with L Clark for the plaintiff

R A Holt QC with J Chapple for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

Thomson Geer for the plaintiff

Holding Redlich for the defendants

  1. The plaintiff and the defendants each brought applications seeking orders in respect of the pleadings in this proceeding.  By consent, they have resolved all but one aspect of those applications.  That aspect relates to the plaintiff’s contention that matters pleaded in paragraphs 48(k)(vi)-(xi), 61(k)(vi)-(xi) and 68(o)(vi)-(xi) of the defendants’ proposed amended defence and counterclaim are allegations not capable, in law or fact, of giving rise to any legally recognised ground of defence to the plaintiff’s claims.  At issue is whether those paragraphs are properly the subject of a strike-out application.

    Background

  2. The proceeding arises out of contractual arrangements between the plaintiff, the defendants and other entities.  The parties agree that those other entities are properly to be joined, on the application of the defendants, as plaintiffs on the counterclaim relied upon by the defendants.

  3. Relevantly, the contractual arrangements concerned three agreements made in September 2011.  Two of the agreements were entered into between the plaintiff and the first defendant.  Each concerned a proposed water pipeline.  The first related to what is known as the main line.  The second related to a proposed spur running off the main line.  The third agreement, with Byerwen Coal Pty Ltd, also concerned the main line. 

  4. The three agreements were ultimately terminated.  There is a dispute as to who terminated the agreements, and as to the entitlement to terminate those agreements.  By the time of the termination, the plaintiff had undertaken work on the pipelines.  It is the plaintiff’s case that that work was undertaken pursuant to the agreements with the first defendant or, alternatively, at the first defendant’s request.  The alternate claim is for reasonable remuneration for work done at that request.  There is also a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunwater Limited v Drake Coal Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QSC 320
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceeding concerns a contractual dispute between Sunwater Limited and Drake Coal Pty Ltd, along with other entities. The case is before the Queensland Court of Appeal. The plaintiff argues that certain paragraphs in the defendants' proposed amended defence and counterclaim are not legally recognised grounds of defence to the plaintiff's claims. Specifically, the plaintiff seeks a strike-out of paragraphs 48(k)(vi)-(xi), 61(k)(vi)-(xi) and 68(o)(vi)-(xi). These paragraphs are part of the defence to the plaintiff's claim for reasonable remuneration for work done at the defendants' request. The plaintiff contends that the allegations in these paragraphs do not constitute a legally recognised ground of defence.

The central issue before the court was whether the offending paragraphs are properly the subject of a strike-out application. The court needed to determine if these paragraphs could give rise to any legally recognised ground of defence to the plaintiff's claims. The court examined the legal basis for the defendants' allegations, including the timing and relevance of the facts pleaded. The court also considered whether the defendants' allegations were sufficient to warrant a strike-out of the paragraphs in question.

The court found that the offending paragraphs were not properly the subject of a strike-out application. It determined that the pleaded facts, though occurring long after the completion of the work, could still be relevant to the defendants' defence. The court held that the defendants' allegations, if proven, could constitute a legally recognised ground of defence. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's application for a strike-out of the specified paragraphs. The court will hear the parties as to the costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed. I shall hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff and the defendants each brought applications seeking orders in respect of the pleadings in this proceeding. By consent, they have resolved all but one aspect of those applications. That aspect relates to the plaintiff’s contention that matters pleaded in paragraphs 48(k)(vi)-(xi), 61(k)(vi)-(xi) and 68(o)(vi)-(xi) of the defendants’ proposed amended defence and counterclaim are allegations not capable, in law or fact, of giving rise to any legally recognised ground of defence to the plaintiff’s claims. At issue is whether those paragraphs are properly the subject of a strike-out application.Background The proceeding arises out of contractual arrangements between the plaintiff, the defendants and other entities. The parties agree that those other entities are properly to be joined, on the application of the defendants, as plaintiffs on the counterclaim relied upon by the defendants. Relevantly, the contractual arrangements concerned three agreements made in September 2011. Two of the agreements were entered into between the plaintiff and the first defendant. Each concerned a proposed water pipeline. The first related to what is known as the main line. The second related to a proposed spur running off the main line. The third agreement, with Byerwen Coal Pty Ltd, also concerned the main line. The three agreements were ultimately terminated. There is a dispute as to who terminated the agreements, and as to the entitlement to terminate those agreements. By the time of the termination, the plaintiff had undertaken work on the pipelines. It is the plaintiff’s case that that work was undertaken pursuant to the agreements with the first defendant or, alternatively, at the first defendant’s request. The alternate claim is for reasonable remuneration for work done at that request. There is also a claim against Byerwen Coal Pty Ltd for reasonable remuneration for work done at its request. The paragraphs of the proposed amended defence and counterclaim in contention are pleaded in response to the plaintiff’s claims for reasonable remuneration for work done at the first defendant’s request. Relevantly, the first defendant denies the work performed by the plaintiff was for its benefit, that it accepted any benefit of the work, that the costs claimed are fair or reasonable or that the plaintiff is entitled to recover on a quantum meruit basis or by way of restitution. The defendants’ plea that the plaintiff is not entitled to seek restitution is based on the plaintiff’s conduct. That conduct, in essence, amounts to an allegation that the plaintiff continued to incur costs and expenses and extend relevant dates in the contract when it knew it could not supply water to the first defendant’s mine. The pleaded facts include matters said to have occurred long after the plaintiff had completed the work done at the defendants’ request. The offending paragraphs are in similar terms. Using paragraph 48(k) as an example, they plead:“… SunWater is not entitled to seek any restitution due to its conduct in:…and by:(vi) on or about 27 February 2013, advising the defendants that an option for the supply of water to Byerwen and/or Drake was for SunWater to acquire an existing water allocation from RATCH-Australia Collingsville Pty Ltd and RATCH-Australia Collinsville B.V (‘jointly referred to in this defence as ‘RATCH’) which would be sufficient to meet its water supply requirements from the Eungella Dam and on sell that allocation to Drake and/or Byerwen;(vii) knowing that RATCH had offered to sell its existing water allocation back to SunWater;(viii) on or about 27 February 2013, advising the defendants that it would seek approval and funding from the SunWater Board and Shareholding Ministers to purchase the RATCH water allocation and transfer it to Drake and/or Byerwen;(ix) on or about 27 March 2013, advising the defendants that:(A)it could not obtain SunWater Board approval or the Shareholding Minister’s consent to fund the purchase of the RATCH water allocation;(B)RATCH had confirmed it would deal directly with Drake and/or Byerwen in relation to the acquisition of the water allocation;(C)Drake should contact RATCH to investigate whether it could acquire the water allocation from RATCH directly;(x) RATCH requiring SunWater’s consent to the assignment of RATCH’s water allocation to Drake and/or Byerwen under clause 15(ii) of the Water Supply Agreement between RATCH and SunWater dated 17 January 1996 as amended on 17 June 2005;(xi) In or about March 2015, following termination of the Drake Spur Agreement and the Drake Main line Agreement, refusing to consent to the assignment of the Water Supply Agreement to facilitate the transfer of RATCH’s water allocation to QCoal (as agent for Drake) in the circumstances more fully set out in paragraphs 1-18 of the Counterclaim.”Plaintiff’s submissions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.