Sunshine Coast Regional Council v Ebis Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Sunshine Coast Regional Council v EBIS Enterprises P/L
[2010] QCA 379
PARTIES:  SUNSHINE COAST REGIONAL COUNCIL
(applicant/respondent)
v
EBIS ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
ACN 001 060 021
(respondent/applicant)
FILE NO/S:  Appeal No 7980 of 2010
DC No 3591 of 2009
DIVISION:  Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:  Miscellaneous Application – Civil
ORIGINATING 
COURT: 
Planning and Environment Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  23 December 2010
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  18 November 2010
JUDGES:  Margaret McMurdo P, Chesterman JA and Philippides J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court,
each concurring as to the orders made
ORDERS: 
1.  Grant leave to appeal;
2. Allow the appeal;
3.  Set aside the order of the Planning and Environment Court made in Brisbane on 24 June 2010 and instead order that the respondent’s Originating Application of 11 December 2009 be dismissed;
4.  Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application for leave to appeal and the appeal to be assessed on the standard basis;
5.  The parties are to provide written submissions on the question of costs of the proceedings in the Planning and Environment Court in accordance with the Practice Direction.
CATCHWORDS:  ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING OFFENCES – USE OF LAND CONTRARY TO PLANNING SCHEME – where applicant owns a large house at Caloundra and lets the premises to groups not exceeding 20 persons usually for two or three day periods – where respondent argued the premises was used as an “accommodation building” pursuant to the relevant Plan and constituted assessable development which required a permit – where applicant argued the premises was a “detached house” comprising a “dwelling unit” – where the Plan defines “dwelling unit” as a unit “designed, adapted or used” for the exclusive use of one household – where a flow chart contained in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan suggested premises would only be a “detached house” if used for long term accommodation – where the explicit definition of “detached house” does not refer to the long or short term nature of the accommodation – whether trial judge erred by interpreting “detached house” by reference to the flow chart – whether trial judge erred in failing to consider whether the premises were “designed or adapted” for the exclusive use of one household
Integrated Planning Act 1997 (Qld), s 4.3.1, s 4.3.5, s 4.3.22, s 4.3.26
Federal Steam Navigation Co Ltd v Department of Trade and
Industry [1974] 1 WLR 505, cited
COUNSEL:  S J Keim SC for the applicant
M A Williamson for the respondent
SOLICITORS:  P & E Law for the applicant
DLA Phillips Fox for the respondent
  1. MARGARET McMURDO P: I agree with the reasons of both Chesterman JA and Philippides J, and with the orders proposed by Chesterman JA.

  2. CHESTERMAN JA: The premises at 26 Ascot Way, Little Mountain at Caloundra consist of a large house set on 4,000m2 of land. The house has six bedrooms, four bathrooms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunshine Coast Regional Council v Ebis Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QCA 379
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Sunshine Coast Regional Council brought an action against Ebis Enterprises Pty Ltd, seeking to enforce provisions of the Sunshine Coast Regional Planning Scheme (Qld) concerning alleged planning offences. The dispute centred around the interpretation of the planning scheme and whether the premises owned by the applicant and leased to groups for short-term stays constituted a "detached house" or an "accommodation building." The trial judge had ruled that the premises constituted an "accommodation building" and, therefore, required a permit under the planning scheme. The applicant sought leave to appeal the decision of the trial judge, arguing that the premises was a "detached house" and that the trial judge had erred in interpreting the planning scheme by referring to a flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan. The applicant further argued that the trial judge had failed to consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the trial judge erred in interpreting the term "detached house" by reference to the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan, and whether the trial judge failed to consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household. The court examined the explicit definition of "detached house" in the planning scheme, which did not refer to the duration of accommodation, and the broader context of the planning scheme. The court also considered whether the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan could be used to interpret the explicit definition of "detached house" and whether the trial judge had failed to consider the applicant's argument that the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household.

The court found that the trial judge had erred in interpreting the term "detached house" by reference to the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan, which was not part of the express terms of the planning scheme and did not accurately reflect the definition of "detached house." The court also found that the trial judge had failed to consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household, as required by the definition of "dwelling unit." The court held that the premises was a "detached house" and that the applicant had not contravened the Sunshine Coast Regional Planning Scheme. Accordingly, the court allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of the trial judge, and remitted the matter to the trial judge for redetermination in light of the findings.

The court granted leave to appeal, set aside the decision of the trial judge, and remitted the matter to the trial judge for redetermination in light of the findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

Grant leave to appeal;

Background

Background to the litigation

Ebis Enterprises Pty Ltd owns a large house at Caloundra which it lets to groups not exceeding 20 persons, usually for periods of two or three days. The Sunshine Coast Regional Council argued that the premises was used as an "accommodation building" pursuant to the relevant Planning Scheme, and constituted assessable development which required a permit. Ebis Enterprises argued that the premises was a "detached house" comprising a "dwelling unit". The Plan defines "dwelling unit" as a unit "designed, adapted or used" for the exclusive use of one household. However, a flow chart contained in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan suggested that the premises would only be a "detached house" if used for long term accommodation. The explicit definition of "detached house" does not refer to the long or short term nature of the accommodation.

The case came before the court on appeal from a decision of the Land Court of Queensland. The trial judge had found that the premises was an "accommodation building" and that the use of the premises constituted assessable development which required a permit. The trial judge had interpreted the term "detached house" by reference to the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan, and had not considered whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household. The appeal was brought by Ebis Enterprises, who sought to overturn the trial judge's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge erred by interpreting "detached house" by reference to the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household.

Held
1. The court held that the trial judge erred by interpreting "detached house" by reference to the flow chart in Part 3.2.2 of the Plan. The court concluded that the flow chart was not a determinative factor in defining "detached house" and that the explicit definition of "detached house" should be considered independently of the flow chart.
2. The court also held that the trial judge erred in failing to consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household. The court concluded that the trial judge should have examined whether the premises met the definition of "dwelling unit" as defined in the Plan, specifically whether it was designed or adapted for the exclusive use of one household.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the definition of "detached house" provided in the Plan and noted that the definition did not inherently refer to the duration of occupancy, unlike the flow chart in Part 3.2.2. The court held that the trial judge's reliance on the flow chart to interpret "detached house" was erroneous as the flow chart did not form part of the explicit definition in the Plan. Instead, the court stressed that the explicit definition should be the primary guide in determining whether the premises constituted a "detached house."

In relation to the second issue, the court found that the trial judge failed to properly consider whether the premises were "designed or adapted" for the exclusive use of one household, as required by the definition of "dwelling unit." The court emphasised that the explicit definition of "dwelling unit" encompasses any unit designed, adapted, or used for the exclusive use of one household. The court noted that the trial judge should have examined the physical design and intended use of the premises to ascertain whether it met the criteria of a "dwelling unit." This oversight was deemed a significant error as it impacted the overall determination of the use of the premises and whether it required a permit under the Planning Scheme. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to explicit definitions within planning schemes and ensuring that all relevant criteria are properly considered in judicial determinations.