Suncorp Metway Limited v McIntosh

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

[2013] QCA 344

COURT OF APPEAL

FRASER JA

Appeal No 9606 of 2013
SC No 192 of 2005

SUNCORP METWAY LTD
ACN 010 831 722  Applicant

v

MORAY McINTOSH
as personal representative of the estate of
MARIA McINTOSH (deceased)  Respondent

BRISBANE

WEDNESDAY, 20 NOVEMBER 2013

FRASER JA:  The respondent has applied for orders that the appellants provide security for the respondent’s costs of resisting the appellants’ appeal.

The appellants owned improved real property and vacant land.  In order to obtain the purchase price to buy a motel, they borrowed from the respondent a total amount of $1,660,000 in two loan transactions upon the security of all of that property.  In proceedings in the Trial Division, the appellants claimed damages from the respondent of about $260,000 and they claimed to be relieved from what the respondent alleged was a substantial debt owing to it under the loan agreements and securities.

As a condition of one of the loan agreements, a commercial lending facility for about $400,000, that amount was to be repaid in full by 30 April 1999 from the sale of property.

The condition included the statement that “the bank is not prepared to extend the debt beyond this time and full clearance is expected”.  The appellants alleged that the respondent’s local manager, Mr Bath, represented, immediately before the execution of the documents and the drawing down of the advance, that provided that the appellants placed one of the secured properties, the “citrus farm”, on the market for sale, the bank would not enforce that condition because it was a “mere formality”.  Another condition in the respondent’s letter of offer permitted the appellants to defer the payment of interest and principal for certain periods, at the expiry of which the interest accrued would be capitalised and the term of the facility would be extended by the length of the period “provided you obtain the prior written approval of the bank”.

The appellants allege that the respondent’s refusal to capitalise interest payments as requested on two occasions was unreasonable.  The appellants then alleged that by a combination of those matters, they were in a position of economic disadvantage which they explained in detail in their pleading.  The appellants allege that the respondent unconscientiously took advantage of the appellants’ disadvantage, which the respondent had caused by treating the loans as being in default, imposing penalty interest, and appointing receivers to the security properties, thereby resulting in the incurring of substantial debts and expenses and ultimately the sale of the security properties.

The appellants’ claims were rejected by the trial judge, who gave judgment in favour of the respondent on the counterclaim for about $440,000: [2013] QSC 255.

The court’s discretion to order security for costs under r 772 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 is unfettered. Relevant considerations include the impecuniosity of an appellant, the fact that an appellant has already had a trial and lost, and the prospects of success on appeal: see Murchie v Big Kart Track Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Suncorp Metway Limited v McIntosh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCA 344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Suncorp Metway Limited, the applicant, appealing against Moray McIntosh, the personal representative of the estate of Maria McIntosh, the respondent. The dispute centres on the applicant's refusal to provide security for the respondent's costs of resisting the applicant's appeal, which originated from a trial division judgment that rejected the applicant's claims and ordered them to pay the respondent's costs. The applicants had borrowed $1,660,000 from the respondent to purchase a motel, secured by their real property. They alleged misrepresentations by the respondent and sought damages and relief from the debt. The applicants' claims were dismissed, and they now appeal.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicants' prospects of success on appeal were sufficient to warrant an order for security for the respondent's costs. The Court considered the applicants' impecuniosity, their loss at trial, and their prospects of success. The applicants argued that the bank's refusal to extend the repayment period for the loan was unreasonable and that the bank acted unconscionably. The Court examined the evidence and found that the applicants' claims were based on unreliable evidence and inconsistent statements. The trial judge's findings were supported by documentary evidence and witness testimonies, leading to the conclusion that the applicants' prospects of success were unpromising.

Given the applicants' lack of financial resources and their seemingly weak prospects of success, the Court decided to order security for the respondent's costs. The applicants were given a deadline to provide the required security, and the appeal was stayed until the security was furnished. Failure to meet the deadline would result in the appeal being dismissed.

The final order required the applicants to provide security for the respondent's costs of $21,121.70 by a specified date, with the appeal staying until the security was provided. Additionally, the costs of the application were to be costs in the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants, Suncorp Metway Limited, loaned a total of $1,660,000 to Moray McIntosh and Maria McIntosh, secured by their real property. The loan was intended to fund the purchase of a motel. The loan was provided in two transactions with conditions attached. One of the conditions required the appellants to repay a commercial lending facility of about $400,000 in full by 30 April 1999 from the sale of property. The appellants alleged that a bank manager, Mr Bath, represented that the repayment condition was a "mere formality" if the appellants placed one of the secured properties, the "citrus farm", on the market for sale. The appellants also alleged that the bank's refusal to capitalise interest payments as requested on two occasions was unreasonable. The appellants further alleged that due to these matters, they were at a position of economic disadvantage, which the bank had caused by treating the loans as being in default, imposing penalty interest, and appointing receivers to the security properties. This resulted in the incurring of substantial debts and expenses and ultimately the sale of the security properties. The appellants claimed damages of about $260,000 and sought to be relieved from the alleged substantial debt. Their claims were rejected by the trial judge, who gave judgment in favour of the respondent on the counterclaim for about $440,000.

The matter came before the Queensland Court of Appeal as an appeal from a decision of the trial judge in the Supreme Court. The appellants, Moray McIntosh and Maria McIntosh, sought to appeal the trial judge's decision in favour of the respondent, Suncorp Metway Limited, on the counterclaim for about $440,000. The appellants also sought rescission of the original contract and damages of about $1 million, which they alleged was the value of their equity in the security properties at the time of the loans. The respondent applied for orders that the appellants provide security for the respondent's costs of resisting the appeal. The appeal was heard by Fraser JA.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appellants have provided security for the respondent's costs of the appeal.
2. Whether the appellants have unpromising prospects of success in the appeal.
3. Whether the appellants' application to adduce fresh evidence should be allowed.

Held
1. The appellants are ordered to provide security for the respondent's costs of the appeal in the amount of $21,121.70 by 4 pm on Wednesday, 18 December 2013.
2. The appellants have unpromising prospects of success in the appeal.
3. The application to adduce fresh evidence is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appellants' application for security for costs of the appeal and their prospects of success on appeal. The court began by noting the trial judge's findings that the appellants' evidence was unreliable, and the appellants' claims were rejected based on reliable documentary evidence and the trial judge's assessment of the evidence given by some witnesses. The court found that the appellants' contention that the respondent acted unconscionably in not deferring the payment of interest was not supported by error in the trial judge's reasons. The court also considered the appellants' application to adduce fresh evidence, but found that the evidence did not satisfy the usual tests for the reception of fresh evidence in an appeal. The court concluded that the appellants' prospects of success in the appeal appear to be unpromising.

The court applied the principles set out in Murchie v Big Kart Track Pty Ltd (No 2) regarding the discretion to order security for costs under r 772 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999. The court found that the appellants' impecuniosity and apparently unpromising prospects of success in the appeal persuade it that security should be ordered, notwithstanding the possibility that this might result in the stifling of the appeal. The court also noted that there was no delay in applying for security such as would suggest that it ought not to be granted.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where an appellant is impecunious and has unpromising prospects of success in the appeal, the court may order the appellant to provide security for the respondent's costs of the appeal. The court did not depart from any prior authority in reaching this decision.