McIntosh v Suncorp-Metway Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

McIntosh v Suncorp-Metway Ltd [2013] QSC 255

PARTIES:

MORAY MCINTOSH
(first plaintiff/first defendant by counterclaim)
THE PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE MARIA MCINTOSH, DECEASED 
(second plaintiff/second defendant by counterclaim)
v
SUNCORP-METWAY LTD ACN 010 831 722

(defendant/plaintiff by counterclaim)

FILE NO:

SC No 192 of 2005

DIVISION:

Trial Division 

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

19 September 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 June 2013 - 14 June 2013

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

  1. The plaintiffs’ claim is dismissed.
  2. Judgment for the plaintiff by counterclaim (Suncorp-Metway Ltd) in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined.

3.   I will hear the parties as to the calculation of interest and as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – UNCONSCIONABILITY, UNCONSCIONABLE DEALINGS AND OTHER FORMS OF EQUITABLE FRAUD – GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs claim damages for the defendant’s alleged unconscionable conduct in enforcing its commercial rights when the plaintiffs failed to meet their loan repayment obligations in relation to two loan agreements – where the plaintiffs claim they were induced to enter into the loan agreements by a representation that was made by an employee of the defendant – where the plaintiffs claim they would not have entered into the loan agreements but for the representation – where the plaintiffs claim their requests to capitalise interest repayments were unreasonably refused by the defendant – where the plaintiffs claim they were placed in a position of disadvantage as a result of the alleged representation and the alleged unreasonable refusals to capitalise interest – where the plaintiffs claim the defendant took unconscientious advantage of their disadvantaged position – whether the defendant placed the plaintiffs in a position of disadvantage, took advantage of their position and acted unconscionably 

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – PLEADING – DEFENCE AND COUNTERCLAIM – where the defendant contends the plaintiffs are not entitled to relief because their compliant was resolved through a Heads of Agreement which constituted a release or an accord and satisfaction – where the defendant contends the Heads of Agreement constituted a complete defence to the plaintiffs’ claim – whether the Heads of Agreement constituted a release or accord and satisfaction and amounted to a complete defence to the plaintiffs’ claim

PROCEDURE – SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – PROCEDURE UNDER UNIFORM CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES AND PREDECESSORS – PLEADING – DEFENCE AND COUNTERCLAIM – where the defendant counterclaims for unpaid default interest and professional costs associated with the receivership and the sales of the secured properties – whether the defendant’s counterclaim should succeed  

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 12CA, 12GF, 12GM

ACCC v CG Berbatis Holdings P/L (2003) 214 CLR 51, considered
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Samton Holdings Pty Ltd (2002) 117 FCR 301, cited
Blue Moon Grill Pty Ltd v Yorkey’s Knob Boating Club Inc [2006] QCA 253, considered
Commercial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McIntosh v Suncorp-Metway Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QSC 255
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of McIntosh v Suncorp-Metway Ltd, the plaintiffs, Moray and Maria McIntosh, sought damages from the defendant, Suncorp-Metway Ltd, for alleged unconscionable conduct in enforcing its commercial rights after the plaintiffs failed to meet their loan repayment obligations. The dispute arose from two loan agreements entered into by the plaintiffs with the defendant to finance the purchase of the Malanda Lodge Motel and refinance existing borrowings. The plaintiffs alleged that they were induced to enter into the loan agreements by a misrepresentation made by an employee of the defendant, and that their requests to capitalise interest repayments were unreasonably refused. They claimed that these actions placed them in a position of disadvantage, and that the defendant took unconscionable advantage of their disadvantaged position. The legal issues before the court were whether the defendant placed the plaintiffs in a position of disadvantage, took advantage of their position, and acted unconscionably. Additionally, the court had to determine whether a Heads of Agreement constituted a release or an accord and satisfaction, and whether it amounted to a complete defence to the plaintiffs' claim.

The court found that the defendant did not place the plaintiffs in a position of disadvantage, nor did it take advantage of their position. The court held that the plaintiffs' claims for unconscionable conduct were not substantiated. Regarding the Heads of Agreement, the court determined that it did constitute a release or an accord and satisfaction, effectively barring the plaintiffs' claims. Consequently, the plaintiffs' claim was dismissed. However, the defendant's counterclaim for unpaid default interest and professional costs associated with the receivership and sales of the secured properties was successful. The court entered judgment for the defendant in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined.

The court's reasoning was based on the evidence presented, which did not support the plaintiffs' claims of misrepresentation or unconscionable conduct. The court found that the plaintiffs' overly optimistic view of their capacity to meet their obligations and the defendant's preparedness to forbear from enforcing the arrangements did not amount to the defendant placing them in a position of disadvantage. The court also held that the Heads of Agreement constituted a complete defence to the plaintiffs' claim. The defendant's counterclaim was substantiated by the evidence, leading to the judgment in its favour. The final orders included dismissing the plaintiffs' claim, entering judgment for the defendant by counterclaim in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest, and setting a future hearing to determine the calculation of interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs’ claim is dismissed.

2. Judgment for the plaintiff by counterclaim (Suncorp-Metway Ltd) in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined.

3. I will hear the parties as to the calculation of interest and as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiffs, Moray McIntosh and his wife Maria McIntosh (Mrs McIntosh died prior to the trial), sought to purchase the Malanda Lodge Motel in 1998. To facilitate this purchase and refinance their existing borrowings, they applied for a loan from the defendant, Suncorp-Metway Ltd. On 9 October 1998, the defendant offered a total loan of $1,660,000 through two connected loan arrangements. The first was a term credit facility (TCF) for ten years with an approved limit of $1,250,000. This facility allowed for interest-only repayments during the first 12 months and permitted deferral of interest and principal repayments for up to 12 months in total with the defendant's prior written approval. The TCF required security through a credit facility deed, a mortgage over the motel, a bill of sale over fixtures and equipment, and mortgages over other properties owned by the plaintiffs. The second arrangement was a commercial banking facility (CBF) for a single advance of $410,000, which had to be repaid in full by 30 April 1999. This repayment condition was also a condition of the TCF. Both loan arrangements were secured by the same properties. The plaintiffs subsequently failed to meet their loan repayment obligations, leading the defendant to enforce its commercial rights. The plaintiffs claim that they were induced to enter into the loan agreements by a representation made by an employee of the defendant and that they would not have entered into the agreements but for this representation. They further claim that their requests to capitalise interest repayments were unreasonably refused by the defendant, placing them in a position of disadvantage, which the defendant then took unconscionable advantage of.

The matter came before the court as a result of the plaintiffs' claim for damages against the defendant for alleged unconscionable conduct in enforcing its commercial rights. The defendant contended that the plaintiffs' complaint was resolved through a Heads of Agreement, which constituted a release or an accord and satisfaction, and was a complete defence to the plaintiffs' claim. The defendant also counterclaimed for unpaid default interest and professional costs associated with the receivership and sales of the secured properties. The procedural steps involved the filing of the plaintiffs' statement of claim, the defendant's defence and counterclaim, and subsequent interlocutory applications and hearings. The court ultimately dismissed the plaintiffs' claim and ruled in favour of the defendant on the counterclaim, awarding the defendant judgment for $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Judgment for the plaintiff by counterclaim (Suncorp-Metway Ltd) in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined. The plaintiffs claim $258,594.85 damages for the allegedly unconscionable conduct of the defendant in exercising its commercial rights following the plaintiffs’ failure to meet their loan repayment obligations to the defendant. In consequence of that failure the defendant asserts it is the plaintiffs who owe it money and pleads a set-off and a counterclaim of $455, 213.54. The dispute has its genesis in the circumstances under which the plaintiffs entered into significant loan transactions with the defendant. In short, the plaintiffs had an overly optimistic view of their capacity to meet their obligations under those arrangements and of the defendant’s preparedness to forbear from enforcing those arrangements. The plaintiffs in this matter were Moray McIntosh and his wife Maria McIntosh. Mrs McIntosh died prior to the trial. While the personal representative of her estate is now named as the second plaintiff, historical references hereunder to the plaintiffs are references to Mr and Mrs McIntosh. In 1998 the plaintiffs were very keen to buy the Malanda Lodge Motel. They needed a loan to do so but already had substantial existing borrowings that would need refinancing. They applied to the defendant for a loan.[1] By correspondence of 9 October 1998 the defendant offered to lend a total of $1,660,000 to the plaintiffs to assist with the purchase of the motel and refinance their existing borrowings. The offer involved two connected loan arrangements. [1] The applications were actually directed to the Queensland Industry Development Corporation, QIDC, a former division of the defendant. The first loan arrangement was a term credit facility (“TCF”) for ten years up to an approved limit of $1,250,000.[2] Its repayment schedule allowed repayment of interest only during the first 12 months.[3] It also included a condition whereby, with the prior written approval of the defendant, the plaintiffs could defer the interest and repayments of principal for a period or periods not exceeding 12 months in aggregate during the term of the facility.[4] The TCF required security by way of a credit facility deed, a mortgage over the Malanda Lodge Motel, a bill of sale over fixtures, fittings, plant, equipment and the liquor licence for the Malanda Lodge Motel and mortgages over properties in which the plaintiffs had interests, namely a citrus farm near Charters Towers, the Mud Hut Hotel at Richmond and vacant land at Rockhampton.[2] Ex 1 vol 1 tab 2.[3] Ibid [4.1].[4] Ibid [5.1(b)(iii)]. The second loan arrangement was a commercial banking facility (“CBF”) for a single advance of $410,000 to be repaid in full by 30 April 1999.[5] The CBF was to be secured by the same securities as the TCF. [5] Ex 1 vol 1 tab 1. Significantly, the condition requiring repayment of the CBF by 30 April 1999 was also incorporated as a condition of the TCF. In both instances the condition was:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the defendant engaged in unconscionable conduct by placing the plaintiffs in a position of disadvantage, taking advantage of that position, and acting unconscionably. It considered whether the plaintiffs were induced to enter into the loan agreements by a representation made by an employee of the defendant and whether their requests to capitalise interest repayments were unreasonably refused. The court found that the plaintiffs' overly optimistic view of their capacity to meet their obligations and the defendant's preparedness to forbear from enforcing the arrangements were not due to any unconscionable conduct on the part of the defendant. Therefore, the plaintiffs' claim for damages was dismissed.
In relation to the second issue, the court examined whether the Heads of Agreement constituted a release or accord and satisfaction, which would amount to a complete defence to the plaintiffs' claim. The court found that while the plaintiffs and the defendant had reached a settlement, the terms of the Heads of Agreement did not constitute a release or accord and satisfaction. However, the plaintiffs' claim was dismissed on other grounds.
Finally, the court considered the defendant's counterclaim for unpaid default interest and professional costs associated with the receivership and the sales of the secured properties. The court held that the defendant was entitled to judgment on its counterclaim in the sum of $439,136.99 plus interest to be determined. The court noted that the plaintiffs had failed to meet their loan repayment obligations, and the defendant was entitled to recover the unpaid default interest and professional costs.