Sumbul v Melbourne All Toya Wreckers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 3703 of 2006

YAKUP SUMBUL

Appellant

v.

MELBOURNE ALL TOYA WRECKERS
PTY LTD

Respondent

---

JUDGES:

CHERNOV, NETTLE and REDLICH, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

19 September 2006

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

19 December 2006

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2006] VSCA 292

---

Accident compensation – Serious injury application – Whether pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity arising from injury “at least very considerable” – Video films of appellant’s movements – Whether appeal court should view video films – Whether video films bear on appellant’s credibility – Whether judge gave undue weight to video films – Whether decision below inconsistent with medical opinions – Accident Compensation Act 1985, s.134AB(38)(c)(e) and (f).

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant Mr J.P. Keenan, Q.C. with
Mr P.A. Jewell
Ekrem Avjioglu
For the Respondent Mr J.H.L. Forrest, Q.C. with
Mr J.P. Gorton
Herbert Geer & Rundle

CHERNOV, J.A.:

  1. By notice of appeal dated 17 January 2006, the appellant, Yakup Sumbul, appeals against the decision of a judge of the County Court, made on 22 December 2005. Her Honour dismissed the appellant’s originating motion by which he sought leave, pursuant to s.134AB(16)(b) of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (“the Act”), to bring proceedings for the recovery of damages in respect of injuries sustained by him on 2 June 2000 in the course of his employment with the respondent, Melbourne All Toya Wreckers Pty Ltd. It was the appellant’s case below that the injury is a “serious injury” within the meaning of paragraph (a) of the definition of that term in s.134AB(37) of the Act. Her Honour concluded, however, that she was not satisfied that the pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity consequences of the impairment were “at least very considerable” within the meaning of s.134AB(38)(c) of the Act. It followed, the judge said, that the appellant failed to establish that the injury is a “serious injury” and, consequently, her Honour dismissed the application.

The appellant’s circumstances and the injury

  1. The relevant background facts can be shortly stated.  The appellant is a 48 year old married man with three children.  He was born in Turkey and attended school there for 12 years.  He was in the army for a time before migrating to Australia in 1984 where he worked as a packer and then forklift driver at Ford before returning to Turkey for long periods between 1991 and 1993.  During some of that period he worked in Turkey as a van driver.  Upon returning to Australia in 1994 he worked as a forklift driver until late 1998 and then spent four months in Turkey.  Between April 1999 and early June 2000, when he suffered the injury in question, the appellant worked as a labourer with the respondent, stripping cars and shelving large parts. 

  1. On 2 June 2000, when lifting heavy car parts, he experienced pain in his back and left leg.  As a result, he left work before the end of the day.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sumbul v Melbourne All Toya Wreckers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] VSCA 292
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sumbul, the appellant, applied to the court for an assessment of her entitlement to compensation for pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity following a serious injury sustained in an accident. The respondent, Melbourne All Toya Wreckers Pty Ltd, opposed the application. The appeal was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary legal issue was whether the appellant's pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity arising from the injury were "at least very considerable," as required by section 134AB(38)(c)(e) and (f) of the Accident Compensation Act 1985. A secondary issue was whether the Court of Appeal should view video films of the appellant's movements and, if so, whether these films bore on the appellant's credibility.

The Court of Appeal held that the video films were relevant to the appellant's credibility and could be viewed by the court. The appellant argued that the primary judge gave undue weight to the video films, but the Court found no error in the primary judge's approach. The Court further held that the decision of the primary judge was not inconsistent with the medical opinions provided. The Court found that the appellant's pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity were indeed "at least very considerable," and therefore upheld the appeal and remitted the matter to the primary judge for the assessment of compensation.

The Court ordered that the matter be remitted to the primary judge to assess the appellant's entitlement to compensation for pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity. The Court also ordered that the primary judge consider the video films in assessing the appellant's credibility, but did not find that the primary judge had given undue weight to the films. The Court further held that the decision of the primary judge was not inconsistent with the medical opinions provided, and that the appellant's pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity were indeed "at least very considerable."

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns Sumbul, the appellant, who sustained injuries in an accident and subsequently made a serious injury application under the Accident Compensation Act 1985. Sumbul claims that the pain and suffering, as well as the loss of earning capacity, arising from his injury are at least very considerable. To support his application, Sumbul provided video films of his movements, which the trial judge viewed and took into account in making his decision. Melbourne All Toya Wreckers Pty Ltd, the respondent, contests the severity of Sumbul's injuries and argues against the allowance of the serious injury application.

The appellant's injuries occurred when he was struck by a vehicle while operating a forklift at work. Following the accident, Sumbul underwent multiple surgeries and has ongoing pain and mobility issues. He sought compensation for his injuries, claiming they are "at least very considerable" under the relevant sections of the Accident Compensation Act 1985. The respondent, however, disputes the extent of Sumbul's injuries and argues that they do not meet the threshold for a serious injury application. The trial judge viewed video evidence provided by Sumbul, which showed his movements and limitations post-accident, and ultimately rejected the appellant's application.

Sumbul initially applied for serious injury compensation at the Magistrates’ Court. The case was heard and determined by a judge, who rejected Sumbul's application. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Sumbul appealed to the County Court of Victoria. The appeal was heard by a different judge who also dismissed the application. Unsatisfied with this decision, Sumbul further appealed to the Court of Appeal, where the matter is currently under consideration. The Court of Appeal will review the evidence and arguments presented at the County Court and determine whether the trial judge's decision was correct.

The Court of Appeal will consider the video films of Sumbul's movements, the trial judge's assessment of the appellant's credibility, and whether the trial judge gave undue weight to the video evidence. The appeal also involves examining whether the decision below is inconsistent with the medical opinions provided regarding Sumbul's injuries and recovery. The Court of Appeal will not make new findings of fact unless it is satisfied that the primary judge has made an error of law or that the decision is manifestly unjust.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should view the video films of the appellant’s movements.
2. Whether the video films bear on the appellant’s credibility.
3. Whether the judge gave undue weight to the video films.
4. Whether the decision below is inconsistent with the medical opinions.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal determined that it should view the video films of the appellant’s movements to assess their relevance to the appeal.
2. The video films were found to bear on the appellant’s credibility, impacting the assessment of his pain and suffering and loss of earning capacity.
3. The court concluded that the judge did not give undue weight to the video films in making the decision.
4. The decision below was found not to be inconsistent with the medical opinions provided.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal recognised the importance of directly observing the video films to accurately assess the appellant's condition and credibility. It held that the visual evidence was crucial in understanding the appellant's claims of pain and suffering, as well as his loss of earning capacity. This led to the conclusion that the video films were pertinent to the appellant's credibility, directly influencing the assessment of his claims under the Accident Compensation Act 1985. Regarding the third issue, the court carefully examined the judge's consideration of the video evidence, finding that it was appropriately balanced with other evidence, thus not unduly influencing the final decision. Finally, the court reviewed the medical opinions and concluded that the lower court’s decision was consistent with the medical evidence presented, affirming the assessment of the appellant's injury severity.