SULLIVAN v MOODY & ORS
[2000] SASC 340
Full Court: Doyle CJ, Williams & Wicks JJ
1................ DOYLE CJ..................... A Master of this Court decided that a Statement of Claim filed in this Court was liable to be struck out on the ground that it does not disclose a cause of action. The Master took the view that it was not capable of being amended to disclose a cause of action, and accordingly ordered that the Plaintiff’s action be dismissed.
Before the Master, counsel for the Plaintiff conceded that the decision of this Court in Hillman v Black & Ors (1996-97) 67 SASR 490 (“Hillman”) governed the case pleaded by the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff acknowledged that the decision in Hillman could not be distinguished. Accordingly, while not consenting to the order, the Plaintiff advanced no opposition to the orders ultimately made by the Master. The Plaintiff appears to have accepted that it could not re-plead the claim so as to plead a maintainable cause of action, so long as the decision in Hillman remained good law.
After the Master made his decision, this Court in CLT v Connon & Ors [2000] SASC 223 considered a challenge to the correctness of the decision in Hillman. The Court affirmed the result of that case, although not necessarily all of the reasoning found in the judgments in that case. By this I mean that the Court in Connon held that causes of action, indistinguishable from those advanced in Hillman, could not succeed as a matter of law.
On the hearing of the present appeal Mr Kourakis QC, counsel for the Plaintiff, conceded that the Master had been bound by the decision in Hillman to make the orders that he made. Mr Kourakis accepted that this Court’s later decision in Connon meant that the appeal must fail, unless the Court were to reconsider the correctness of the decision in Connon. He did not ask the Court to reconsider the correctness of Connon.
I understand that the Plaintiff in Connon has sought special leave to appeal from the High Court with a view to challenging the correctness of the decision in Connon. I understand that the present appeal is brought with a view also to challenging the correctness of the decision in Connon.
In these circumstances, there is no need to reconsider the questions of law considered by this Court in Connon. I agree with the submission that the decision in Connon governs the case pleaded by the Plaintiff against the Defendants, subject to a difficulty in relation to the fourth Defendant with which difficulty I will deal shortly. It follows that the appeal must be dismissed, subject to the matter yet to be dealt with.
Before dealing with that matter, it is appropriate to outline very briefly the nature of the claim pleaded by the Plaintiff.
In its essentials, the case pleaded appears to be identical to the case pleaded in Connon. The case…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Sullivan v Moody & Ors No. Scgrg-93-142 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 340
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the plaintiff had a valid cause of action against the defendants, and if the Master's decision to dismiss the case was correct. The Court found that the decision in Connon governed the case, and the plaintiff's cause of action against the first six defendants could not succeed as a matter of law. However, the Court found that the fourth defendant, a private medical practitioner, was in a different position and the decision in Connon did not necessarily apply to him. The Court also found that the fourth defendant's submission on witness immunity could not be decided without specific and detailed findings of fact, which were not made by the Master.
The Court dismissed the appeal against the first six defendants but did not dismiss the appeal against the fourth defendant. The Court requested further submissions from the parties to address the uncertainties in the pleadings against the fourth defendant and to clarify the basis for a potential cause of action against him.
In conclusion, the Court dismissed the appeal against the first six defendants, but did not dismiss the appeal against the fourth defendant. The Court requested further submissions from the parties to address the uncertainties in the pleadings against the fourth defendant and to clarify the basis for a potential cause of action against him. The Court emphasized the need for clearly pleaded matters and appropriate findings of fact to properly consider the claimed defence of witness immunity.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.