STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd v Bowen Basin Coal Group Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd v Bowen Basin Coal Group Pty Ltd (No 2)

[2010] FCA 1240

Citation: STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd v Bowen Basin Coal Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1240
Parties: STX PAN OCEAN CO LTD v BOWEN BASIN COAL GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 141 187 760), DAVID JOHN THOMSON and BEACH BUILDING AND CIVIL GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 081 893 414)
File number: NSD 561 of 2010
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 12 November 2010
Catchwords:

ADMIRALTY – contract of affreightment – voyage charterparty – payment of freight and load port demurrage due within five banking days after signing and release of bills of lading – time when charterer defaults

CONTRACT – TRADE AND COMMERCE – whether representations made by conduct of entry into contract – whether by entering into or signing contract party represents it is and will be ready, willing and able to perform all obligations at time performance is and after it becomes due – where standard-form contract, such as charterparty, not contain such term – use in contract in international trade and commerce – obligation to be ready, willing and able to perform – actual breach established by default in performance – anticipatory breach only established if party actually could not perform at all

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – admiralty and shipping – charterparty –whether officer of charterer made personally, or at all, representation that charterer ready, willing and able to perform both at time of contract and when performance would be due in future – representation not an express or implied term of contract – whether representation made by conduct of negotiating for and signing contract – allegation that party unable ever to perform, or not ready, willing and able to perform, its obligations as and when they fell due at the time of entry into charterparty – allegation must be proved in fact not supposition – Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 75B, 52, 82

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – damages – false representations as to charterer’s ability to pay hire under voyage charterparty after default in payment – shipowner induced to keep charterparty on foot – measure of damage

DAMAGES – misrepresentation as to readiness, willingness and ability to perform – shipowner induced to enter into charterparty or keep it on foot after default – distinction between damages in tort and contract – measure of damages under s 82 of the Act – whether damages in tort for loss opportunity to earn freight, demurrage and other entitlements assessed at the rates agreed to under charterparty – demurrage and other rates in charterparty not appropriate guide of a vessel’s earning capacity in market – no evidence of market or alternative charter rates

Words and Phrases: “ready, willing and able” – “within five (5) banking days”
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140(2)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 75B, 52 and 82

Cases cited:

Admiralty Commissioners v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd v Bowen Basin Coal Group Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd v Bowen Basin Coal Group Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute between the parties regarding a voyage charterparty contract. The shipowner, STX, alleged that the charterer, Bowen Basin, made misleading and deceptive representations regarding its ability to perform the contract, leading to damages when the charterer defaulted. The court was tasked with determining whether Bowen Basin made a representation that it was ready, willing, and able to perform the contract obligations and if this was a false representation. Additionally, the court had to decide if Bowen Basin's representative, Mr. Thomson, was responsible for any such representations and if STX suffered any damages as a result.

The court considered whether the conduct of Bowen Basin and Mr. Thomson amounted to a misleading or deceptive representation under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). It was established that a representation of readiness, willingness, and ability to perform could be inferred from conduct in a commercial context. However, the court found that Bowen Basin was not ready, willing, or able to perform the contract obligations at the time the representations were alleged to have been made. This finding did not necessarily determine the validity of the representations made earlier in the negotiations.

The court also addressed the measure of damages, noting that if STX were allowed to recover damages based on the charterparty rates, it would recover not only its actual loss but also anticipated profits. However, there was no evidence of market rates or alternative charter opportunities that could substantiate such a claim. Therefore, the damages should be limited to the actual losses incurred by STX.

In conclusion, the court found that Bowen Basin had not made a false representation regarding its ability to perform the contract obligations. Consequently, STX's claims for damages based on misleading and deceptive conduct were dismissed. The parties were ordered to agree on the sum for damages and interest for the period 6 to 17 May 2010 and to submit further on the matter of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties bring in short minutes of orders as to the sum of damages and interest for which judgment should be entered in respect of the period 6 to 17 May 2010 consistent with these reasons for judgment on or before 16 November 2010.

2. The parties exchange any submissions as to costs on or before 23 November 2010 and any submissions in reply by 25 November 2010.

3. The matter be relisted on 26 November 2010 for further hearing.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The critical issues are whether:(1) the ready, willing and able representation was made (Mr Thomson accepted in his written submissions that if it were, it would have been false to his knowledge);(2)the post contractual representation was made;(3)Mr Thomson was legally responsible for either of the representations;(4)STX suffered any loss or damage.THE BACKGROUND AND NEGOTIATIONS FOR THE CHARTERPARTY STX is a well known international shipowner and charterer. Its head office was in the Republic of South Korea, where its charterparty manager, Jung-Hyun Ahn was based. STX’s Australian representative Il-Hwan Kang was based in Melbourne. Bowen Basin was incorporated on 18 December 2009. Mr Thomson included it on web pages for the Beach Building and Civil Group Pty Ltd that he caused to be posted on the internet. One of the web pages stated that Bowen Basin “is an Australian company involved in the trading and export of Australian coal supply worldwide. We are a dynamic and global trading company …”. Another web page described Mr Thomson as the group’s founder and managing director who was very much a part of its day to day operations. Another of the Beach Building group’s web pages included information about a related company described as “BBCG Shipping”. That was said to be an international shipping company specialising in the transport of dry bulk cargoes. This web page referred to various types of cargoes carried on “our Panamax … [and] our Handymax dry bulk carriers” as well as Handysize vessels. During February 2010, Mr Thomson caused Bowen Basin to enter into an agreement with The Griffin Coal Mining Company Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) for the purchase of two cargoes of approximately 42,000 tonnes of coal. Originally the cargoes were to be shipped between 1 and 30 March 2010. The price was USD55.00 per tonne FOB load port. STX negotiated the terms of the charterparty through Anderson da Silva of Sea Corporation Pty Ltd (Sea Corp), a shipbroker based in Perth. But, there is little evidence of what was said in the negotiations for the charterparty. Mr Ahn looked at the web pages of the Beach Building group before he reported to his superiors about whether STX should enter into the charterparty. He saw the prominent role that these pages assigned to Mr Thomson and passed this information on to his superiors. The web pages conveyed to Mr Ahn, as they were calculated to do, that Bowen Basin was a member of a substantial, financially successful group of companies established in 1998 that was involved in a range of activities, including international sales of coal and its transportation by sea. Mr Ahn also made enquiries about Bowen Basin’s credit worthiness through an organisation called Infospectrum and from his own reading of the Beach Building group web pages. There was no direct evidence of what Infospectrum had reported to Mr Ahn, but I infer that it did not reflect adversely on Bowen Basin’s capacity to perform its obligations in a transaction such as the proposed charterparty. Mr Ahn’s other enquiries had not yielded any further information about Bowen Basin’s financial status. Mr da Silva said, and I accept, that if he had had reason to believe that Bowen Basin would not be able to provide the two cargoes and pay the full freight and demurrage contemplated in the proposed charterparty, he and Sea Corp would have recommended to STX that it not proceed with the fixture.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

If STX were allowed to recover damages from Mr Thomson calculated at the rates in the charterparty, it would recover not merely its loss that it had incurred in reliance on the representations, namely the costs of and incurred in pursuing the two charters, but also the anticipated profit that it would have earned had Bowen Basin been able to pay. There was no evidence of a market or alternative charterer from which STX could have earned the rates under the charterparty, or indeed any other rates, during the period it was on foot. It is not possible to assess what STX might have earned had it not relied on the representations I have found, because STX gave no evidence beyond the cost to it of, and relating to, fulfilling its obligations under the charterparty.CONCLUSION The parties should agree the sum for which judgment should be entered in respect of the period 6 to 17 May 2010 consistent with my reasons. I will stand the proceedings to hear the parties on this and the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addition, STX argued that Bowen Basin was not able to perform the charterparty on 12 March 2010 because it had no “disposition to perform” in the sense explained by Mason CJ in Foran v Wight (1989) 168 CLR 385 at 397. It contended that this consequence was evident on 23 April 2010. That was the date it argued in submissions when Bowen Basin defaulted five days after the signing of the bill of lading. I have found that this liability had to be met only five banking days after the bill was released, namely on 5 May 2010 (which was also the date STX had pleaded in its points of claim).CONSIDERATION OF THE MAKING OF THE READY, WILLING AND ABLE REPRESENTATION I find that Bowen Basin was not ready, willing or able, and had no disposition, to perform on the date payment was due, five banking days after the signing and release of the bill (whether that was 5 May or at any time after 16 April, when it had entered into the contract with Loyal Strategic). However, that is not determinative of the issues in relation to the ready, willing and able representation made that was allegedly made almost two months earlier. All of the circumstances, as well as the context, in which conduct occurs must be considered for the purpose of characterising whether a person, in a commercial dealing or negotiation with another, has engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of s 52 of the Act: Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd (2010) 270 ALR 204 at 211 [20] per French CJ and Kiefel J, 224 [91] per Heydon, Crennan and Bell JJ. Silence, common assumptions and practices in a particular industry and the knowledge of the person to whom the conduct in question was directed can be relevant for this purpose: Miller 270 ALR at 211 [20]. The conduct of Bowen Basin and Mr Thomson, that STX alleged gave rise to the ready, willing and able representation, occurred on 12 March 2010 when the charterparty was entered into, or before then. STX relied on Mr Ahn’s state of mind at this time. He said, without objection:“At the time [STX] entered the charterparty with [Bowen Basin] [STX] assumed from the making and execution of the charterparty by [Bowen Basin] and its authorised representative and by the terms of the charterparty that [Bowen Basin] and its controlling mind or manager responsible for the charterparty intended to perform the charterparty according to its terms and that [Bowen Basin] would pay the full freight and demurrage due under the charterparty as arranged and would provide the two cargos required under the charterparty.” (emphasis added) Mr Ahn acknowledged in cross-examination that he had not made the decision that STX enter into the charterparty and could not say what his superiors had assumed at the time. Importantly, Mr Ahn said that he was not responsible for that decision. But, he asserted that his superiors would have made their decision on the basis of his recommendations.