Stuart v Chief of the General Staff

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
O ~ % ~ F D A r A
JUDGMENT No. .,... %Z .... .
IN THE DEFENCE FORCE 1
DISCIPLINE APPEAL TRIBUNAL
) No. DFDAT 1 of 1993
SYDNEY )

IN THE MATTER OF:

THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE ACT 1982

AND :

THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE APPEALS

ACT 1955

LIEUTENANT COLONEL RUSSELL ALEXANDER

STUART

Appellant

CHIEF OF THE GENERAL STAFF

Respondent

CORAM:  Northrop J. (President)
Gallop J. (Member)
Badgery-Parker J. (Member)
DATE:  19 May 1994
PLACE:  S y d n e y

O R D E R

T h e Tr ibunal o r d e r s that :

(2) Both convictions.-be quashed and a new trial o rde red o n bo th
cha rges .
(1) T h e appeal be allowed.
IN THE DEFENCE FORCE )
DISCIPLINE APPEAL TRIBUNAL
) No. DFDAT 1 of 1993
SYDNEY 1

IN THE MATTER OF:

THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE ACT 1982

AND :

THE DEFENCE FORCE DISCIPLINE APPEALS

ACT 1955

LIEUTENANT COLONEL RUSSELL ALEXANDER

STUART

Appellant

CHIEF OF THE GENERAL STAFF

Respondent

CORAM:  Northrop J. (President)
Gallop J. (Member)
Badgery-Parker J. (Member)
DATE:  19 May 1994
PLACE :  Sydney

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

The appellant appeals and alternatively seeks leave to appeal

against his convictions on 1 2 August 1993 by a Defence Force Magistrate at

Pteah Australii, Phnom Penh in Cambodia on the following two charges:
"First Charge Loss of Service Property
(as amended) 1203543 LTCOL Russell Alexander Stuart, a
DFDA - s.44 defence member at Phnom Penh, Cambodia, on 24 June 1993 did lose service property, namely, one pistol 9 mm automatic L9A1 serial number T271475, one holster pistol 9 mm, 24 cartridge 9 mm ball Mk22, one vest small arms protective body armour kevlar large, which items were entrusted to his care in connection with his duties as part of the United Nationals Transitional Authority Cambodia.
Second Charge Prejudicial Behaviour
DFDA - s.60 1203543 LTCOL Russell Alexander Stuart, a defence member at Phnom Penh, Cambodia, on 24 June 1993 did behave in a manner likely to prejudice the discipline of ASC UNTAC in that he did direct 553188 SGT T. R. Hayes to secure his 9 mm automatic L9A1 pistol serial number T121643, holster pistol 9 mm cloth disruptive pattern, 24 cartridge 9 mm ball Mk22 in a motor vehicle then parked on USSR Boulevard."

The appeal is brought on the following grounds:

"l. That the Learned Defence Force Magistrate misdirected himself in ruling (as he did) that the appellant had a case to answer in respect of each of the charges preferred against him, and thereby deprived the applicant of the acquittal.
2 . That the Learned Defence Force Magistrate erred in law in directing the Defending Officer that s.14 of the Defence Force Discipline Act had been repealed and not replaced, thereby depriving the applicant of the defences lawfully available to him pursuant to that section, namely that the applicant was at all material times acting pursuant to lawful orders, or an unlawful order which…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stuart v Chief of the General Staff and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] ADFDAT 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lieutenant Colonel Russell Alexander Stuart, the appellant, appealed against his convictions on two charges brought against him by the Chief of the General Staff, the respondent. The charges related to the loss of service property and prejudicial behaviour, both occurring in Cambodia on 24 June 1993. The Defence Force Discipline Appeal Tribunal, presided over by Northrop J, Gallop J, and Badgery-Parker J, heard the appeal on 19 May 1994. The main legal issues concerned whether the Defence Force Magistrate had correctly interpreted the law in relation to the required mens rea for the charges and whether the convictions were safe and satisfactory. The Tribunal found that the Defence Force Magistrate had misdirected himself in ruling that the appellant had a case to answer on both charges and that the convictions were wrong in law and resulted in a substantial miscarriage of justice. The Tribunal quashed both convictions and ordered a new trial on both charges. The Tribunal also granted leave to appeal on certain grounds and deferred a decision on costs until further submissions were heard.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.