Stuart Smith and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

[2015] AATA  343

Division Veterans' Appeals Division

File Number(s)

2013/2138

Re

Stuart Smith

APPLICANT

And

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms A F Cunningham, Senior Member

Date  19 May 2015
Place Hobart

Decision under review varied as follows:

1.   The correct hourly rate to be used for the purposes of calculating the civilian component of the applicant’s NWE as at 29 May 2001 is $15.36.

2.   During the period 29 May 2001 to 30 June 2009 the civilian component of the applicant’s NWE should be adjusted annually, commencing 1 July 2002 by the applicable indexation figure pursuant to section 8 (9B) of the SRC Act.

3.   The applicant is not entitled to any other adjustments to the civilian component of his NWE.

………………………………………….
Ms A F Cunningham, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

Workers Compensation - incapacity payments - calculation normal weekly earnings - increment in a range of salary - indexation rate – decision under review varied

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 19075 (the AAT Act)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation and other Legislation Amendment Act 2009

CASES

Chun v Comcare 209 FCR 399

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v David Perry (2007) FCA 1586

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Regulations 2002

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A F Cunningham, Senior Member

  1. The applicant, Stuart Smith seeks the review of a reviewable decision dated 18th February 2013 regarding the calculation of his incapacity payments for the period 29 May 2001 until 14 June 2012. The reviewable decision revoked an earlier determination and substituted a decision that pursuant to the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act), Mr Smith was entitled to the recalculated incapacity entitlements set out in the decision.

  2. Mr Smith disputes a number of the findings made by the Review Officer in her decision and claims that it is inconsistent with the terms of an order entered by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) by consent on 12 June 2009.

  3. Mr Smith’s claim for compensation arises from an injury to his back suffered during an army reserve exercise when a camouflage net fell on him on 10 November 1992. Liability was accepted for “muscle strain of the lower back” by a determination dated 27 November 1992. The description of his condition was extended to include “mechanical lower back pain” by a decision dated 12 August 2002.

  4. Mr Smith represented himself at the hearing and gave oral evidence. The respondent was represented by David Wilson who tended the T documents pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) and a further document setting out the Statutory Rates under subsections 8 (9 B) and 8 (9 F) of the SRC Act.

    BACKGROUND FACTS

  5. Mr Smith commenced employment as a joiner with Joinery Products Sales Proprietary Limited (Joinery Products) in Devonport Tasmania in 1988. On 25 May 1989 he enlisted in the Army Reserve. He sustained an injury to his back during an Army…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stuart Smith and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 343
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stuart Smith sought a review of a decision made by the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission regarding his entitlement to incapacity payments. The dispute centred on the calculation of Smith's normal weekly earnings (NWE) prior to his injury, specifically whether his salary should be indexed based on potential promotions and increments he might have received had he not been injured. The case was heard and determined in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The legal issues the AAT had to resolve included whether Smith's potential appointment as a foreman with Joinery Products, which he believed would have involved an increment in his salary, should be considered in the calculation of his NWE. The AAT also needed to determine if the Wage Price Index (WPI) should be applied to adjust Smith's NWE annually and whether there was sufficient evidence to support the potential salary increments he claimed he would have received.

The AAT found that the correct hourly rate to be used for calculating Smith's NWE was $15.36. It held that while Smith might have been next in line for a promotion to foreman, there was insufficient evidence to substantiate that he would have received such a promotion. Therefore, the AAT concluded that the provisions regarding increments in a range of salary, wages, or pay did not apply to Smith's case. Consequently, the AAT ruled that Smith's NWE should be indexed annually in accordance with the applicable indexation figure, as per section 8(9B) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act.

The AAT varied the decision under review, specifying that Smith's civilian component of NWE should be adjusted annually from 1 July 2002 onwards by the applicable indexation figure. Smith was not entitled to any other adjustments to the civilian component of his NWE. This decision effectively balanced the need to adjust for inflation against the requirement for concrete evidence of potential salary increments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Decision under review varied as follows:

1. The correct hourly rate to be used for the purposes of calculating the civilian component of the applicant’s NWE as at 29 May 2001 is $15.36.

2. During the period 29 May 2001 to 30 June 2009 the civilian component of the applicant’s NWE should be adjusted annually, commencing 1 July 2002 by the applicable indexation figure pursuant to section 8 (9B) of the SRC Act.

3. The applicant is not entitled to any other adjustments to the civilian component of his NWE.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Smith represented himself at the hearing and gave oral evidence. The respondent was represented by David Wilson who tended the T documents pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act) and a further document setting out the Statutory Rates under subsections 8 (9 B) and 8 (9 F) of the SRC Act.BACKGROUND FACTS Mr Smith commenced employment as a joiner with Joinery Products Sales Proprietary Limited (Joinery Products) in Devonport Tasmania in 1988. On 25 May 1989 he enlisted in the Army Reserve. He sustained an injury to his back during an Army Reserve exercise on 10 November 1992 and was discharged from the Army Reserve on 12 July 1996 at his own request. In 1998 Mr Smith ceased employment at Joinery Products and moved to Western Australia where he commenced employment with Ausdrill Limited as a shotfirer’s assistant on a mining site. Mr Smith suffered an aggravation to his injury on 29 October 1998 while pushing his motorbike through a shed door. By a determination dated 18 January 1999, liability to pay incapacity payments was accepted with effect from 5 November 1998. Mr Smith’s employment with Ausdrilll Ltd was terminated on 22 March 1999. Following a reconsideration of a decision denying Mr Smith’s application for permanent impairment, liability was accepted on 29 May 2002 based on a Wage Price Index (WPI) of 10%. In a determination dated 3 August 2000 Mr Smith’s claim that his inability to participate in the Army Reserves should be accommodated in the calculation of his incapacity entitlements, was denied. The basis of the refusal was that Mr Smith had voluntarily left this employment in 1996 which was two years prior to the incident that had caused his incapacity to work and he had continued to be employed in civilian employment. In his decision the Review Officer confirmed that the relevant period for calculating incapacity payments related to employment prior to the date of injury in November 1992. From 17 July 2003 to 3 September 2003 Mr Smith engaged in a work trial with Simplot, working in the laboratory. During this period Mr Smith worked between six hours per week and up to 20 hours per week in the period 21 August 2003 until 27 August 2003. Mr Smith continued the work trial from 10 November 2003 until 24 December 2003. In the period from 20 November 2003 to 26 November 2003 he worked 12 hours, from 27 November 2003 to 3 December 2003 he worked 29 hours and for the following periods he worked between 20 and 21 hours per week. Mr Smith then studied for a Certificate 3 Laboratory Technician qualification through TAFE which he successfully completed in November 2005. In a determination dated 28 March 2006 he was deemed to earn no less than $599.10 gross per week as a Level 1 Laboratory Technician. This determination was affirmed on review. On 1 April 2007 Mr Smith commenced employment with Technical Edge Proprietary Limited working a minimum of 20 hours per week on a permanent part-time basis. On the 1 September 2011 a review of Mr Smith’s entitlement to incapacity payments from 29 May 2001 onwards was conducted. Mr Smith sought a review of the decision. In accordance with section 9 of the SRC Act, the Review Officer determined the relevant period for calculating Mr Smith’s Normal Weekly Earnings (NWE) before the injury on 10 November 1992 was between 26 October 1992 to 9 November 1992.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Initially the index prescribed by regulation 5 of the Safety, Rehabilitation andCompensation Regulations 2002 was the Wage Cost Index (WCI). In 2008 the name of the index was changed to the Wage Price Index (WPI).THE EVIDENCE Mr Smith accepts that for the purposes of calculating the civilian component of his NWE the initial figure is $15.36. However he contends that this amount should be adjusted in accordance with the provisions of the subsection 8 (6) (c) . This provision reads as follows:“(c)the receipt by the employee of an increase in salary, wages or pay by way of an increment in a range of salary, wages or pay applicable to the employee or to his or her office, position or appointment;” It is Mr Smith’s contention that if not for the injury he sustained in the Army Reserve, he would have been appointed as foreman with Joinery Products and earning $33 per hour. Mr Smith contends that he was next in line for the foreman’s position but it was instead filled by Clinton Howe. Mr Wilson on behalf of the respondent, contended that there was no corroborating evidence that Mr Smith would have been appointed foreman. In any event, the appointment to foreman would have constituted a promotion which does not fall within the provisions of section 8 (6) (c) because it does not constitute “an increment in a range of salary, wages or pay”. Mr Wilson contends that on the basis of the documentary material available, there is no evidence that Mr Smith was entitled to any increments within his level of salary during the relevant period. Included in the T documents is correspondence provided by Mr Smith’s former employer, Joinery Products further to his requests for information regarding the rates of pay that he would have received if he was still employed with Joinery Products. In a letter dated 14 August 2008 the Manager of Joinery Products Marcus Kelly advised that the base hourly rate for a qualified joiner as at that date was $22.50 which equated to an annual package of $51,698.70 plus overtime. It was further stated that:“Due to growth of the company and more so the labour shortage I believe that you would have been offered several promotions within the company if you were still there which would obviously involve more money than detailed above. This would be the minimum that you would earn if you were still with Joinery Products. I have two employees still working at Joinery Products that work with you and were in my opinion of similar levels of quality and production to you. The rate detailed above indicates what they currently earn and in my opinion would be the minimum you would have earned without accepting any offers of promotion should they have occurred. I confirm that the pay rate detailed above is equivalent to that of other joiners we currently employ along with similar skills and experience to you.” Further to a request from Mr Smith for more detailed information, Mr Kelly forwarded a letter dated 27 August 2008. This letter listed the then current hourly rates of pay for a joiner level 1 at $18.80 through to the position of foreman at $25 per hour. The hourly rate of $22.50 equated to a joiner level 8. Mr Kelly stated that if Mr Smith had been able to continue in his trade he would have accumulated 20 year’s trade experience and with this amount of experience, skill and productivity, would have been paid more per hour than previously stated. The amount advised was $23.50 per hour which equates to joiner level 10. It was further stated that over time with the retirement of other staff members, Mr Smith would have had the opportunity to apply for other positions and would have been promoted if he had been able to continue in employment if not for his back injury. His estimated salary package would have ranged from approximately $65,000 to $100,000 per annum depending on the position held.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established