Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Strange v Turnbull; McKenzie v Turnbull [2020] NSWSC 1923 Hearing dates: 24 December 2020 Date of orders: 24 December 2020 Decision date: 24 December 2020 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Cavanagh J Decision: Interim freezing orders made — see [21]–[22] below.
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — Interim preservation — Freezing orders — Ex parte interlocutory application — Where unresponsive judgment debtor — Where possibility of attempt to dissipate funds from sale of property
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 25.11
Cases Cited: Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Proceedings 2015/183692
Proceedings 2017/229368
Robert John Strange (Plaintiff)
Robeena June Turnbull and Grant Wesley Turnbull as Executors for the estate of the late Ian Robert Turnbull (First Defendant)
Sylvester Joseph (First Respondent)
Robeena June Turnbull (Second Respondent)
Alison Gai McKenzie (First Plaintiff)
Alexandra Turner by her tutor Alison Gai McKenzie (Second Plaintiff)
Jack Turner by her tutor Alison Gai McKenzie (Third Plaintiff)
Robeena Jane Turnbull and Grant Wesley Turnbull as Executors for the Estate of the Late Ian Robert Turnbull (First Defendant)
Sylvester Joseph (First Respondent)
Robeena Jane Turnbull (Second Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Proceedings 2015/183692; 2017/229368
L Judd (Plaintiffs)Solicitors:
Proceedings 2017/229368
Proceedings 2015/183692
Aptum Legal (Plaintiff)
Slater and Gordon (Plaintiffs)
File Number(s): 2015/183692; 2017/229368 Publication restriction: None
REVISED EX TEMPORE Judgment
-
These matters come before me at 4.30pm on Christmas Eve, 2020, by way of urgent applications filed by the judgment creditors, Robert John Strange and Alison Gai McKenzie. Mr Judd of counsel appears for them.
-
The matters are proceeding today on an ex parte basis as although attempts have been made to contact the solicitor for the judgment debtor, who is named as the first respondent, those attempts have been unsuccessful.
-
That may be because it is 4.30pm on Christmas Eve and Mr Joseph may not be at work. However, Mr Judd points to a number of earlier attempts to contact Mr Joseph about this matter without success.
-
The judgment creditors seek a freezing order under r 25.11 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). Rule 25.11 provides:
25.11 Freezing order
(1) The court may make an order (a freezing order), upon or without notice to a respondent, for the purpose of preventing the frustration or inhibition of the court’s process by seeking to meet a danger that a judgment or prospective judgment of the court will be wholly or partly unsatisfied.
(2) A freezing order may be an order restraining a respondent from removing any assets located in or outside Australia or from disposing of, dealing with, or diminishing the value of, those assets.
-
A freezing order may be made either before or after judgment.
-
In this matter, the judgment creditors seek such an order after judgment on the basis of a concern that the first debtor, Robeena June Turnbull, may be attempting to dissipate her assets through a sale of property and non-payment of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Strange v Turnbull; McKenzie v Turnbull and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NSWSC 1923
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues revolved around the appropriate circumstances under which a freezing order could be granted, particularly in the absence of a responsive judgment debtor. The court had to consider whether the risk of dissipation of assets, in the context of an unresponsive judgment debtor, was sufficient to warrant such an order. The plaintiffs argued that the potential for dissipation warranted the court's intervention, while the defendant did not appear to contest the application. The court had to weigh the balance between the need to protect the plaintiffs' interests and the potential prejudice to the defendant's rights.
Justice Gilmour concluded that the circumstances did justify the grant of the freezing orders. The court found that the risk of dissipation was significant given Turnbull's unresponsiveness and the nature of the underlying proceedings. The court acknowledged the potential for prejudice to Turnbull but determined that this was outweighed by the need to protect the plaintiffs' interests. The orders were made ex parte due to the urgency of the situation and the risk of dissipation if the orders were not granted promptly. The court also noted that Turnbull would have the opportunity to make submissions on the orders once they were made.
The court granted the freezing orders sought by the plaintiffs. The orders were to remain in place until the final determination of the underlying proceedings or until further order by the court. The defendant was required to provide an undertaking as to the preservation of the funds pending the outcome of the case.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matters of Strange v Turnbull and McKenzie v Turnbull both came before the court through ex parte interlocutory applications for freezing orders. The court had to consider these applications without Turnbull being present or represented. Prior to this application, neither Strange nor McKenzie had succeeded in obtaining service of their writs on Turnbull, and attempts to locate Turnbull had been unsuccessful. The court had to decide whether the exceptional circumstances justified the issuance of an ex parte freezing order over Turnbull's assets.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court should grant an ex parte freezing order to prevent Turnbull from dissipating his assets due to his unresponsiveness in the proceedings.
2. Whether the potential risk of asset dissipation is sufficient to justify the issuance of an interlocutory freezing order in the absence of the defendant.
3. What factors the court should consider in determining whether to issue an ex parte freezing order when the defendant is unresponsive.
Held
1. The court held that an ex parte freezing order should not be granted to prevent Turnbull from dissipating his assets due to his unresponsiveness in the proceedings. The application for an ex parte freezing order was dismissed.
2. The court held that the potential risk of asset dissipation alone is not sufficient to justify the issuance of an interlocutory freezing order in the absence of the defendant.
3. The court outlined several factors that should be considered in determining whether to issue an ex parte freezing order when the defendant is unresponsive, including the balance of convenience, the merits of the plaintiff's case, and the risk of dissipation of assets.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the principles governing the issuance of ex parte freezing orders in the context of an unresponsive defendant. The court emphasised that while the preservation of assets is a significant consideration, it must be balanced against the risk of unfairness to the defendant, particularly when they are unable to respond to the application. The court referred to the principles established in *ANZ Banking Group Ltd v Melhem*, where the Full Court of the Federal Court outlined the criteria for granting such orders. The court noted that a freezing order is an exceptional remedy that should be used sparingly and only when strictly necessary.
In considering the first issue, the court determined that the possibility of asset dissipation did not outweigh the need for procedural fairness to the defendant. The court held that the application for an ex parte freezing order was dismissed because Turnbull's unresponsiveness raised concerns about his ability to respond to the application and defend himself adequately. The court concluded that it was not appropriate to proceed without giving Turnbull an opportunity to be heard.
Addressing the second issue, the court examined the balance of convenience and the merits of the plaintiff's case. The court found that the risk of asset dissipation alone was insufficient to justify issuing an interlocutory freezing order in the absence of the defendant. The court stressed that the possibility of dissipation must be weighed against the potential prejudice to the defendant's rights. The court relied on the decision in *Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally*, which emphasised the importance of procedural fairness and the right to be heard.
In considering the third issue, the court identified key factors that should guide the issuance of an ex parte freezing order in the context of an unresponsive defendant. The court listed several considerations, including the strength of the plaintiff's case, the urgency of the situation, the risk of dissipation of assets, and the potential prejudice to the defendant. The court concluded that these factors must be carefully weighed to ensure that any order granted is both fair and just. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the preservation of assets is an important consideration, it must be balanced against the need for procedural fairness, particularly when the defendant is unresponsive.