LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Stewart v Department of Resources [2025] QLC 10
PARTIES:
Diana Pearl Stewart
(appellant)
v
Department of Resources
(respondent)FILE NO:
LAA451-24
PROCEEDING:
Appeal against review decision regarding the purchase price for conversion of tenure under the Land Act 1994
DELIVERED ON:
14 May 2025
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARD ON:
24 March 2025
HEARD AT:
Atherton
MEMBER:
N.D. Loos
ORDERS:
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The unimproved value of Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718, as at 14 April 2022 or 21 April 2022, is determined at Three Hundred and Ninety Thousand Dollars ($390,000).
CATCHWORDS:
VALUATION OF LAND – UNIMPROVED VALUE – METHODS OF ASSESSING – determination of purchase price of lease for conversion purposes under the Land Act 1994 – valuation – unimproved value – where there was a paucity of sales – where sales from different locality employed – whether negative factors of subject land were properly brought to account in assessing unimproved value – internal review decision set aside and substituted
Land Act 1994, ss 170, 426, 429
Land Regulation 2020, ss 1, 9
Alexander & Ors v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority & Ors (2010) 233 FCR 575, cited
BWP Management Ltd v Valuer-General (2019) 40 QLCR 232; [2019] QLAC 4, cited
Commissioner of Succession Duties (SA) v Executor Trustee and Agency Co of South Australia (1947) 74 CLR 358, cited
Gold Coast City Council v Sunland Group Ltd (2019) 1 QR 304, cited
Jensen & Anor v Valuer-General [2024] QLAC 3, cited
Korab & Co Pty Ltd v Department of Natural Resources (1996) 16 QLCR 409; [1996] QLC 37, cited
Moar v Minister for Natural Resources and Minister for Mines and Energy [2004] QLC 67, considered
Valuer-General v Body Corporate for ‘Tennyson Reach’ Community Titles Scheme 39925 (2018) 39 QLCR 302; [2018] QLAC 7, consideredAPPEARANCES:
Mr A Stewart on behalf of the appellant, Mrs D Stewart
Mr P Prasad, In House Legal, for the Department
Introduction
Mr and Mrs Stewart live in Biboohra, near Mareeba. Mrs Stewart leases a parcel of land from the State.[1]
[1]Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718. That lease is due to expire in 2046.
In April 2022, Mrs Stewart applied to have the lease converted to freehold.
The Department of Resources[2] responded to that application about 828 days later, by setting the purchase price for the conversion from leasehold to freehold at $450,000.
[2]Now the Department of Natural Resources and Mines, Manufacturing and Regional and Rural Development.
Mrs Stewart thought that amount too high. She sought an internal review.
The internal review came back at $425,000.
Mrs Stewart appeals that internal review decision.
She says that the correct value is $340,000.
The issues
Mrs Stewart raises the following issues:
(a)the internal review decision was required to state reasons but did not; and
(b)the amount set by the Department is grossly excessive when compared to the comparative sales and valuation data.
Legislation and principles
The process…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Stewart v Department of Resources and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] QLC 10
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the internal review decision did not contain any reasons, which significantly impacted Mrs Stewart, who was self-represented and appeared to be unaware that she could request reasons for the decision. While the Department pointed out that Mrs Stewart could have requested reasons, the court noted that her lack of understanding and the absence of reasons had prejudiced her preparation for the appeal. The court also examined whether the decision was invalid due to the absence of reasons but concluded that, given the lack of detailed submissions on the potential invalidity and its practical effects, it could not determine that the internal review decision was invalid in this instance.
The court determined that the unimproved value of Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718 should be set at Three Hundred and Ninety Thousand Dollars ($390,000) as at 14 April 2022 or 21 April 2022. The appeal was allowed, and the internal review decision was set aside and substituted with the court's determination. The court's decision provided clarity on the valuation process and the importance of providing reasoned decisions in administrative reviews.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. The unimproved value of Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718, as at 14 April 2022 or 21 April 2022, is determined at Three Hundred and Ninety Thousand Dollars ($390,000).
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was initially reviewed internally by the Department of Resources, but Mrs Stewart was dissatisfied with the outcome. She then appealed this internal review decision to the court. The appeal was heard and the court examined the Department's valuation methodology, the sufficiency of reasons provided, and the procedural correctness of the internal review process. The court also considered the impact of the Department's actions on Mrs Stewart's ability to prepare her case. The appeal resulted in the court setting aside the internal review decision and substituting a new determination of the unimproved value of the land.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the internal review decision invalid due to the absence of reasons and procedural errors?
2. Did the Department of Resources properly account for the negative factors of the subject land in assessing its unimproved value?
3. What is the correct unimproved value of Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718, as at 14 April 2022 or 21 April 2022?
Held
1. The internal review decision was not found to be invalid due to the absence of reasons and procedural errors. While the decision did not include reasons and contained some procedural errors, the court was not persuaded that these rendered the decision invalid.
2. The Department of Resources did not properly account for the negative factors of the subject land in assessing its unimproved value. The court found that the Department failed to adequately consider these factors in their valuation.
3. The correct unimproved value of Lot 299 on Crown Plan NR7718, as at 14 April 2022 or 21 April 2022, is determined to be Three Hundred and Ninety Thousand Dollars ($390,000).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Section 426 of the Act states:426 Decision on reconsideration(1)After reviewing the original decision, the Minister must make a further decision (the review decision) to confirm the original decision, amend the original decision or substitute a new decision.(2)The chief executive must immediately give the applicant notice of the decision.(3) The notice must state—(a)the day the notice is given to the applicant (the review notice day); and(b)if the review decision is not the decision sought by the applicant—(i) the reasons for the decision; and(ii)that the applicant may appeal against the decision to the court within 42 days after the review notice day. The internal review decision is in evidence.[14] It does not contain any reasons. [14]Exhibit 13. Separate from the absence of reasons, Mrs Stewart says the documents provided by the Department with the internal review decision include reference to the wrong Court form, an invitation to direct all future correspondence to an email address that contained a typographical error – so that emails sent to that address went undelivered – and a note that if the figure was not accepted, Mrs Stewart could apply for internal review.[15] As to the last point, the internal review decision was incorrectly inviting another internal review. [15]Transcript 1-48, lines 16 - 32. That the internal review decision offered no reasons and apparently contained errors, had a significant negative impact on Mrs Stewart. It created additional complexity for her and prejudiced the way which she prepared her evidence and arguments for this appeal. The Department pointed out that the Stewarts could have requested reasons for the decision. That is true. I note, though, that Mrs Stewart is self-represented and did not apparently understand that that was something she could do. It would have been better if the obligation in s 426(3)(b)(i) could have been complied with. Member Scott’s decision in Korab appears to support Mrs Stewart’s point about invalidity.[16] More recent decisions of other Courts indicate that whether a decision is invalid for failure to state reasons is a complex question.[17] [16]I think that the Department may have made a mistake in the excerpt of the decision provided in paragraph [5] of its reply submissions. It refers to an incorrect Korab decision and the excerpt stops before reaching the key part. [17]Gold Coast City Council v Sunland Group Ltd (2019) 1 QR 304 at [137] - [164]. See also Alexander & Ors v Australian Community Pharmacy Authority & Ors (2010) 233 FCR 575 at 586 - 595. The case relied on by the Department – Moar v Minister for Natural Resources and Minister for Mines and Energy[18] – does not consider the point in any detail. The Department cited no other cases on the topic. [18][2004] QLC 67 at [7]. Absent any detailed submissions about potential invalidity,[19] I am not able to conclude that the internal review decision in this instance was invalid. [19]And absent submissions about the practical effect of reasons not being requested by Mrs Stewart.