Stevenson Group Investments P/L v Nunn

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Stevenson Group Investments P/L v Nunn & Ors [2011] QPEC 151

PARTIES:

STEVENSON GROUP INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
A.C.N. 101 112 127
(Applicant)

v

GRAHAM NUNN
(Respondent)

and

CODD STENDERS
(
First Respondent)

and

TANGALOOMA PTY LTD
A.C.N. 010 997 707
(Second Respondent)

and

TANGALOOMA ISLAND RESORT PTY LTD
A.C.N. 010 170 902
(
Third Respondent)

and

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(Fourth Respondent)

and

R J and R M LEVER PTY LTD
(Fifth Respondent)

and

HIDEBOURNE PTY LTD
A.C.N. 010 652 436 (TRUSTEE)
(
Twelfth Respondent)

and

TANGALOOMA PHOTO SHOP PTY LTD
A.C.N. 113 674 427
(Seventeenth Respondent)

and

TANGALOOMA MORETON ISLAND RESORT
A.C.N. 122 809 812
(
Eighteenth Respondent)

FILE NO:

1861/2009

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

22/12/11

DELIVERED AT:

BRISBANE

HEARING DATE:

17/10/11 – 18/10/11

JUDGE:

Searles DCJ

ORDER:

1.   On the Application for summary judgment by Respondent, first, second, third, fifth, twelfth and eighteenth Respondents filed 14 July 2011, judgment be entered in their favour; and

2.   Application by the applicant filed 10 August 2011 to amend pleadings dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

Validity of Building Permit- Permit issued before Advice Agency provided with copy Application -  Whether Building Permit Void and of No Legal Effect- Summary Judgment- UCPR 293(2)- Discretionary Considerations .

COUNSEL:

Applicant:
S.Keim SC & D Fahl (Stevenson Group Investments)

Respondents:
D.Kelly SC & M Johnston (Nunn & Ors Tangalooma Resort)
M.Williamson (BCC)

SOLICITORS:

Clinton Mehr Lawyers

Hopgood Ganim Lawyers

Brisbane City Legal Practices

CONTENTS

Nature of Applications
Approach to Judgment
Property the Subject of the Principal Proceeding
Stevenson’s Originating Application (OA)
Nature of Stevenson’s Originating Application Attacking Validity of Building Permit
Stevenson’s grounds for alleging invalidity of Building Permit

Ground 1 – Advice Agency Allegation
Ground 2 - Existing Planning Approval not Generally in Accordance with Original Resort Planning Approval (GIA Point)
Ground 3 - Failure to Impose a Mandatory Condition

Tangalooma Application for Summary Judgment/Strikeout
Tangalooma’s Grounds for Summary Judgment/Strike-Out

Ground 1 – Building Permit is not “Void and of No Legal Effect”
Ground 2 – Absence of any Recognisable Administrative Law Grounds of Challenge
Ground 3 – Discretionary Factors Mitigate Against Stevenson’s Prospects of Success
Ground 4 – Abuse of Process

History of Proceedings
Principles of Summary Judgment

No Real Prospect of Succeeding
Whether there is a need for Trial

Nature of Administrative Decisions and the Concept of a “Void” Decision
Tangalooma’s Submissions re Grounds for Summary Judgment

Ground 1 – Building Permit “Not Void and of No Legal Effect”

Particulars of Stevenson’s Allegations that Building Permit Void and of no Legal Effect :-

(a)  Particulars of Stevenson’s Agency Referral Allegation

(b) Particulars of Stevenson’s allegation re GIA  Allegation

(c).......... Particulars of Stevenson’s Allegations of Failure to Impose Mandatory Condition

Tangalooma’s Ground 1 Argument – Why the Building Permit is not “Void and of no Legal Effect”

Tangalooma’s Response to Advice Agency Allegation

IPA - Section 4.1.5A

Tangalooma’s Response to GIA Application Allegation
Tangalooma’s Response to Failure to Impose Mandatory Condition Allegation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stevenson Group Investments P/L v Nunn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] QPEC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stevenson Group Investments P/L v Nunn, the dispute centred around the validity of a building permit issued by the Respondents to the Applicant. The Applicant sought a declaration that the building permit was void and of no legal effect due to the Respondents not providing a copy of the application to the Advice Agency before issuing the permit. The Respondents applied for summary judgment under Rule 293 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), arguing that the Applicant had no real prospect of success on their claim and that a trial was unnecessary. The court was required to determine whether the permit was indeed void and if the Applicant's claim could proceed to trial.

The court examined the criteria for granting summary judgment as outlined in Rule 293, focusing on whether the Applicant had a real prospect of success on their claim and if a trial was necessary. The court considered the meaning of 'no real prospect of success' as interpreted in Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Salcedo, where it was held that the term required a realistic, as opposed to a fanciful, prospect of success. The court also noted the changes introduced by Rule 292 and Rule 293, which aligned with the Civil Procedure Rules in the United Kingdom, emphasising the importance of efficient use of court resources.

After evaluating the Applicant's claims and the Respondents' arguments, the court concluded that the Applicant had no real prospect of success in proving that the building permit was void and of no legal effect. The court found that the Respondents' actions did not render the permit invalid under the circumstances presented. Consequently, the court granted the Respondents' application for summary judgment, dismissing the Applicant's claims and finding no need for a trial. The Applicant's subsequent application to amend their pleadings was also dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that judgment be entered in favour of the Respondents and that the Applicant's application to amend the pleadings be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On the Application for summary judgment by Respondent, first, second, third, fifth, twelfth and eighteenth Respondents filed 14 July 2011, judgment be entered in their favour; and

2. Application by the applicant filed 10 August 2011 to amend pleadings dismissed

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 293 provides:-“293 Summary judgment for defendant1.A defendant may, at any time after filing a notice of intention to defend, apply to the court under this part for judgment against a plaintiff.2. If the court is satisfied:-(a)The plaintiff has no real prospect of succeeding on all or part of the plaintiff’s claim; and (b)There is no need for a trial of the claim or the part of the claim;(c) The court may give judgment for the defendant against the plaintiff for all or part of the complainant’s claim and may make any other order the court considers appropriate.” So there are two elements to be satisfied before Tangalooma is entitled to summary judgment. Firstly, that Stevenson has no real prospect of succeeding on his claim for declaration that the Building Permit is “void and of no legal effect” and secondly, that there is no need for a trial. The meaning of this term was considered in Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Salcedo.[24] Although that case involved an application for summary judgment by a plaintiff under r 292 the wording is identical to r 293 dealing with a defendant’s application for summary judgment.[24][2005] QCA 227. In that case Williams JA, with whom McMurdo P and Atkinson J agreed said:-[25] [25]Ibid, para 10.“[10] On the hearing of the appeal counsel for the appellant referred to Gray v Morris [2004] 2 Qd R 118 and in particular observations by Chesterman J at 126 and 127 the onus was on the applicant for summary judgment to establish that the defence was ‘bound to fail’, ‘one which cannot possibly succeed’, one which had ‘no prospect of success’ and/or one that was ‘hopeless’. Those words were used in the context of reasoning by that learned judge based on the proposition that the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (UCPR) had not affected any substantial change in the approach to summary judgment from that which applied under the former Rules of the Supreme Court.[11] With respect that approach is not correct. Rule 292 and r 293 brought about significant changes in the law and procedure relating to summary judgment. The wording of r 292 and r 293 is clearly based on the drafting used in Part 24 of the Civil Procedure Rules (UK) which came into force in the United Kingdom in 1999. In Swain v Hillman [2001] 1 All E.R. 91 the Court of Appeal had to consider r 24.2, the equivalent of r 292. Lord Woolf M.R. said at 92:-‘No real prospects of succeeding’ do not need any amplification, they speak for themselves. The word ‘real’ distinguishes fanciful prospects of success or ….. they direct the court to the need to see whether there is a ‘realistic’ as opposed to a ‘fanciful finish’ prospect of success.’Later, again speaking of the rule, he said at 94:‘It saves expense; it achieves expedition; it avoids the court’s resources being used up on cases where this serves no purpose, and I would add, generally, that it is in the interests of justice. If a claimant has a case which is bound to fail, then it is in the claimant’s interests to know as soon as possible that that is the position. Likewise if a claimant is bound to succeed, a claimant should know that as soon as possible.’In his reasons at 95, Pill L. J. accepted that the term ‘real’ was used in contradistinction to ‘fanciful’. The third member of the court, Judge L. J., whilst recognising that summary judgment was a ‘serious step’, went on to say at 96:‘This is simple language, not susceptible to much elaboration, even forensically. If there is a real prospect of success, the discretion to give summary judgment does not arise merely because the court concludes that success is improbable.’”