Stephenson v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Stephenson v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] QSC 130

PARTIES:

DAVID FRANCIS STEPHENSON

(first plaintiff)

SMILEDENTIST.NET PTY LTD
ACN 079 370 120
(second plaintiff)

v
DENTAL CORPORATION PTY LTD
ACN 124 730 874

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 7098/18

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Costs Judgment

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

4 June 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

JUDGE:

Treston J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs up to and including 4 August 2022 on the standard basis.

2.   The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs from 5 August 2022 on the indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs’ claims in contract against the defendant were dismissed – where the defendant seeks costs on the indemnity basis – where the defendant made three offers to resolve the primary proceedings which were not accepted by the plaintiffs – whether the defendant can establish special circumstances – whether the defendant should be awarded costs on the indemnity basis

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), rr 681, 703

Calderbank v Calderbank [1975] 3 All ER 333
Clarke Energy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Power Generation Corporation (Trading as Territory Generation) [No 2] [2025] QSC 111
Sino Dragon Trading Ltd v Noble Resources International Pte Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 1169
Stephenson & Anor v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 82
Wiggins Island Coal Export Terminal Pty Limited v Civil Mining & Construction Pty Ltd (2021) 7 QR 1

COUNSEL:

A J H Morris KC and I A Erskine for the plaintiffs
J S Darams SC and M D Harker for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Creagh Weightman Lawyers for the plaintiffs
Tom Kavanagh for the defendant

  1. On 1 May 2025 I delivered judgment in this matter, dismissing the plaintiffs’ claims.  My reasons for judgment are contained in Stephenson & Anor v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 82 (the “primary reasons”). These reasons concern the costs orders. The parties made written submissions. No party asked for a further hearing.

  2. I will use the defined terms as contained in the primary reasons.

  3. The first plaintiff, Dr David Stephenson, is a dentist who carried on a dental practice at Albany Creek between 1991 and 2008.  Originally, he did so personally, but in 1997 he incorporated the second plaintiff and, at a later time, entered into a Services Agreement between himself and the second plaintiff for the provision of dental services.

  4. In June 2008 the defendant, Dental Corporation, purchased the Albany Creek practice.  Dr Stephenson remained working at the practice until 2013.  The primary proceeding related to a claim for damages brought by the first and second plaintiffs against the defendant which was said to have arisen as a result of the defendant purporting to terminate its contractual arrangements with the plaintiffs. 

  5. The defendant made multiple offers to resolve the primary proceedings, each of which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephenson v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 130
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Stephenson v Dental Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) involved the plaintiffs, Mr. Stephenson, and the defendants, Dental Corporation Pty Ltd, who were engaged in a contractual dispute. The plaintiffs alleged breaches of contract by the defendants and sought damages. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The defendants successfully defended the claims and sought indemnity costs against the plaintiffs, arguing that the plaintiffs had rejected three offers to resolve the matter without proceeding to trial.

The court had to determine whether the defendants could establish special circumstances that would warrant an order for indemnity costs. The defendants contended that by rejecting their offers to settle, the plaintiffs had acted unreasonably and without merit, thus justifying the indemnity costs. The plaintiffs argued that the offers were not genuine or comprehensive enough to warrant acceptance, and that their decision not to settle was reasonable and in the best interest of their case. The court needed to weigh the evidence and arguments presented by both parties to determine if special circumstances existed.

The court found that the defendants had indeed made genuine offers to resolve the dispute that were not accepted by the plaintiffs. These offers were made at a stage when the prospects of success for the plaintiffs were diminishing, and accepting the offers would have been a reasonable course of action. The court held that the plaintiffs' rejection of these offers constituted an unreasonable position, as it exposed them to unnecessary costs and risks. Consequently, the court determined that special circumstances existed, justifying an order for indemnity costs from a certain date onwards.

The final orders were that the plaintiffs pay the defendants’ costs up to and including 4 August 2022 on the standard basis, and the costs from 5 August 2022 on the indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs up to and including 4 August 2022 on the standard basis.

2. The plaintiffs pay the defendant’s costs from 5 August 2022 on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Stephenson commenced legal proceedings against Dental Corporation Pty Ltd, seeking damages for breach of contract. The contract in question related to a service agreement for dental services. Stephenson alleged that Dental Corporation failed to deliver the agreed services, resulting in financial loss. Dental Corporation denied the allegations and asserted that the services were provided in accordance with the contract terms. The dispute arose from differing interpretations of the contractual obligations and the quality of the services rendered. The matter was tried in court, and ultimately, the plaintiffs' claims were dismissed.

The matter came before the court for a final hearing after being initially filed and proceeding through the usual stages of pleadings and discovery. Prior to the final hearing, Dental Corporation made three offers to resolve the dispute, which were not accepted by Stephenson. The court considered these offers in the context of assessing costs. After the dismissal of the plaintiffs' claims, Dental Corporation applied for costs on the indemnity basis, arguing that the plaintiffs' refusal of the offers constituted special circumstances warranting such an award.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Dental Corporation can establish special circumstances to warrant an indemnity costs order.
2. Whether Dental Corporation should be awarded costs on the indemnity basis from 5 August 2022.

Held
1. The court concluded that Dental Corporation could establish special circumstances warranting an indemnity costs order.
2. The court held that Dental Corporation should be awarded costs on the indemnity basis from 5 August 2022.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the principles governing indemnity costs orders in light of the circumstances of this case. Indemnity costs orders are a departure from the usual costs order which follows the event, meaning the losing party pays the winning party's costs. However, indemnity costs are awarded when there are special circumstances justifying such an order. The court considered whether the defendant had made reasonable offers to resolve the matter which were not accepted by the plaintiffs as a factor indicative of special circumstances.

In this case, Dental Corporation made three offers to resolve the proceedings, which were not accepted by the plaintiffs. The court found these offers to be reasonable and significant in determining that special circumstances existed. This aligns with established principles where a party's reasonable attempts to settle the matter, which are rejected, can form part of the special circumstances justifying an indemnity costs order. The court emphasised that the plaintiffs' rejection of these offers contributed to the prolongation of the litigation, which is a relevant consideration in the indemnity costs context.

Further, the court noted the plaintiffs' claims were ultimately dismissed, which is another factor in favour of awarding indemnity costs. It found that the plaintiffs' conduct in rejecting the offers and pursuing the claims despite their lack of merit justified the imposition of indemnity costs. The court's decision to award indemnity costs from 5 August 2022 reflects its view that the plaintiffs' conduct post this date continued to warrant such costs. The ratio decidendi here is that the rejection of reasonable settlement offers by a plaintiff, coupled with the dismissal of their claims, can justify an indemnity costs order against them. The court's ruling followed established case law, which supports the imposition of indemnity costs where special circumstances, such as the rejection of settlement offers, are present.