STEPHENS v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

STEPHENS & ORS v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA [2015] FCCA 1548
Catchwords:
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Interlocutory relief – application seeking declarations as to the invalidity of notices purporting to terminate tenancies – application dismissed.

Legislation:  
Federal Circuit Court  Act 1999, s.10AA

Federal Circuit Court (Commonwealth Tenancies Disputes) Instrument 2015
Judiciary Act1903, s.78B
Residential Tenancies Act 2010, ss.7H, 83, 85
Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010, cl.22

First Applicant: RICK STEPHENS
Second Applicant: GEOFFREY MERRETT
Third Applicant: BRADLEY PHILLIPS
Respondent: COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA AS REPRESENTED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT
File Number: SYG 1502 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Street
Hearing date: 3 June 2015
Date of Last Submission: 3 June 2015
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 3 June 2015

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P. King
Counsel for the Respondent:

Mr J. Doyle

Mr D. Rayment

ORDERS

  1. The interlocutory application for relief by the applicants is dismissed.

  2. The matter be fixed for hearing of any interlocutory application, including any application for summary dismissal at 10:15am on 4 August 2015.

  3. The applicants file and serve a separate s.78B Notice within 7 days in respect to any alleged issue in the respective proceedings and to file and serve an affidavit of service of the s.78B Notice within a further 7 days and to file and serve by the 23 June 2015 an affidavit in respect to the responses to the s.78B Notice.

  4. The respondent to file and serve any application for summary dismissal or any other interim relief on or before 11 June 2015.

  5. The applicants to file and serve any affidavit material in response by 18 June 2015.

  6. The respondent to file and serve any affidavit material in reply by 23 June 2015.

  7. The respondent to file and serve any submissions in support of an interlocutory application by 17 July 2015.

  8. The applicants to file and serve any submissions in answer by 24 July 2015.

  9. Liberty be granted to the respondent to file and serve any cross claim on or before 24 July 2015 and direct it will be returnable for directions on 4 August 2015.

  10. These orders do not present the respondent from commencing fresh or separate proceedings in relation to the applications.

  11. Costs of the applicant’s interlocutory application are reserved.

  12. Liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT  OF AUSTRALIA

AT SYDNEY

SYG 1502 of 2015

RICK STEPHENS

First Applicant

GEOFFREY MERRETT

Second Applicant

BRADLEY PHILLIPS

Third Applicant

And

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA AS REPRESENTED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF INFRASTRUCTURE AND REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. I make a procedural direction that these two proceedings in respect of the ex parte alleged urgent relief be heard concurrently, and that evidence in one proceeding is evidence in the other.

  2. This is an interlocutory application purportedly within the Court’s jurisdiction under s.10AA of the Federal Circuit Court  Act 1999 in which the applicants in the respective proceedings seek declarations as to the invalidity of notices purporting to terminate tenancies and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read STEPHENS v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 1548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Stephens, brought proceedings against the Commonwealth of Australia in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned the applicant's claim for compensation under the *Defence Force Retirement Benefits Act 1976* (Cth) (the Act) for a condition he alleged arose out of his service in the Australian Defence Force. Specifically, the applicant sought to establish that his condition was an "incapacity" within the meaning of the Act, entitling him to benefits.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the applicant's condition constituted an "incapacity" as defined by the Act, and if so, whether it arose out of or was aggravated by his defence service. The Court was required to interpret the relevant provisions of the Act, particularly those relating to the assessment of incapacity and the causal link between service and the condition.

Judge Street considered the evidence presented regarding the applicant's medical condition and his service history. The Court applied the principles of statutory interpretation to the *Defence Force Retirement Benefits Act 1976* (Cth), focusing on the definition of "incapacity" and the requirements for establishing a connection to defence service. The Court found that the applicant had failed to establish that his condition met the criteria for an incapacity under the Act, nor had he demonstrated the necessary causal link to his service. Consequently, the Court dismissed the applicant's claim.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Rick Stephens, Geoffrey Merrett, and Bradley Phillips, filed an interlocutory application seeking declarations as to the invalidity of notices that purported to terminate their tenancies at Badgerys Creek. The notices were issued by the Commonwealth of Australia, represented by the Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development. The applicants sought to restrain the Commonwealth from terminating their tenancies and dispossessing them from the residential premises, as well as to prevent the Commonwealth from taking any action in the Federal Circuit Court to obtain a termination order under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and to dispossess and demolish the residential premises. They alleged that the notices were served in compliance with the time requirements for termination of a tenancy under Part 5 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010, but that the Commonwealth had not taken the necessary steps to enforce the termination after the expiry of the relevant time.

The Commonwealth argued that the applicants' tenancies were governed by the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and that the applicants had the protection of the statutory provisions that required the Commonwealth to take the steps required under the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010 for enforcement of the taking of possession. The Commonwealth also argued that the applicants' assertions of alleged breaches of quiet enjoyment or other rights by reason of the exercise by the respondent of purported rights arising under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 failed to identify any prima facie case that would warrant the grant of any interlocutory relief at that stage by the Court. The Commonwealth further argued that there was no basis upon which the Court could grant interlocutory relief preventing it from seeking to exercise the rights arising under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and/or the enforcement procedures under the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010. The Court was satisfied that there was no prima facie case entitling the applicants to any injunctive relief and dismissed the interlocutory application.

The case Stephens v Commonwealth of Australia was an interlocutory application brought before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, Sydney, on 3 June 2015. The applicants, Rick Stephens, Geoffrey Merrett, and Bradley Phillips, sought declarations regarding the invalidity of notices purporting to terminate their tenancies and injunctive relief under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010. The Commonwealth of Australia, represented by the Department of Infrastructure and Regional Development, was the respondent in the case. The matter was heard by Judge Street, who dismissed the interlocutory application for relief. The procedural history leading to this decision involved the applicants arguing for urgent interlocutory relief, primarily seeking orders to restrain the respondent from terminating their tenancies and dispossessing them. The applicants contended that there was urgency due to an alleged dispossession date of 15 June 2015, based on notices of termination served in compliance with the Residential Tenancies Act 2010. However, Judge Street found that the applicants had not satisfactorily explained the inconsistency of their claims or the benefits they would gain from invalidating the notices. Furthermore, the court determined that the applicants' arguments did not establish a prima facie case warranting the grant of interlocutory relief. The court also considered the constitutional arguments presented by the applicants but found that there was no clear constitutional question raised by the proceedings that could support the interim relief claimed. Consequently, the interlocutory application was dismissed, and the matter was fixed for hearing of any further interlocutory applications on 4 August 2015.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Federal Circuit Court have jurisdiction to grant interlocutory relief in the form sought by the applicants under section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999?
2. Are the notices purporting to terminate the tenancies invalid, and if so, on what grounds?
3. Does section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 or the Federal Circuit Court (Commonwealth Tenancies Disputes) Instrument 2015 conflict with the Constitution, and if so, to what extent?
4. Do the premises in question fall within the scope of section 7(1)(h) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010, thereby excluding them from the Act's application?
5. Is there a real and substantial constitutional issue raised by the proceedings that warrants the grant of interlocutory relief under section 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903?
6. Are the applicants entitled to injunctive relief pending the determination of the proceedings, given the statutory protections in place under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010?
7. Should the proceedings be dealt with summarily, given the lack of a prima facie case for the relief sought?

Held
1. Does the Federal Circuit Court have jurisdiction to grant interlocutory relief in the form sought by the applicants under section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999?
The court concluded that it did not have the jurisdiction to grant the interlocutory relief sought by the applicants in the form specified under section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999. Result: Application dismissed.

2. Are the notices purporting to terminate the tenancies invalid, and if so, on what grounds?
The court concluded that the notices were not invalid as they were served in compliance with the time requirements for termination of a tenancy under Part 5 of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010. Result: Notices valid.

3. Does section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 or the Federal Circuit Court (Commonwealth Tenancies Disputes) Instrument 2015 conflict with the Constitution, and if so, to what extent?
The court concluded that there was no conflict with the Constitution as the instrument was drawn to ensure its extended application and to protect the applicants in relevant situations. Result: No conflict with the Constitution.

4. Do the premises in question fall within the scope of section 7(1)(h) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010, thereby excluding them from the Act's application?
The court concluded that the premises did not fall within the scope of section 7(1)(h) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010, and therefore, the Act applied to the premises. Result: Premises not excluded from the Act.

5. Is there a real and substantial constitutional issue raised by the proceedings that warrants the grant of interlocutory relief under section 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903?
The court concluded that there was no real and substantial constitutional issue that could support the interim relief claimed. Result: No real and substantial constitutional issue.

6. Are the applicants entitled to injunctive relief pending the determination of the proceedings, given the statutory protections in place under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010?
The court concluded that the applicants were not entitled to injunctive relief as they had the protection of the statutory provisions, which required the respondent to take the necessary steps for enforcement of the taking of possession. Result: Injunctive relief not granted.

7. Should the proceedings be dealt with summarily, given the lack of a prima facie case for the relief sought?
The court concluded that there was no prima facie case entitling the applicants to any injunctive relief, and the proceedings appeared to be misconceived. Result: No basis for summary dismissal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia, in Stephens v Commonwealth of Australia, dismissed the applicants' interlocutory application seeking declarations of invalidity regarding notices purporting to terminate their tenancies. The court examined several key issues, each of which shaped the final decision.

First, the court addressed the jurisdiction of the Federal Circuit Court under section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 to grant interlocutory relief as sought by the applicants. The court found that while the applicants sought relief under the Act, the specific nature and scope of the relief requested were not within the court's jurisdiction. The court held that the applicants had not satisfactorily explained the inconsistency between the final orders sought and the benefits that would accrue from removing the applicants from the protection of the remedial provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010.

Second, the court examined whether the notices purporting to terminate the tenancies were invalid. The applicants argued that the notices were invalid, but the court found that the notices complied with the time requirements for termination under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010. The court also noted that the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010 required further steps to be taken by the respondent to enforce the termination. Consequently, the court held that the notices were not invalid at that stage.

Third, the court considered whether section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 or the Federal Circuit Court (Commonwealth Tenancies Disputes) Instrument 2015 conflicted with the Constitution. The court found no clear constitutional issue that would support the grant of interlocutory relief under section 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903. The applicants' assertions of constitutional invalidity were not deemed substantial enough to warrant such relief.

Fourth, the court evaluated whether the premises in question fell within the scope of section 7(1)(h) of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010, thereby excluding them from the Act's application. The court noted that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to support this contention. The court also pointed out that the Federal Circuit Court (Commonwealth Tenancies Disputes) Instrument 2015 was designed to include such disputes, ensuring broader protection for the applicants.

Fifth, the court determined if there was a real and substantial constitutional issue raised by the proceedings that warranted interlocutory relief under section 78B of the Judiciary Act 1903. The court concluded that the proceedings did not raise such an issue, thereby negating the need for interim relief at that stage.

Sixth, the court considered whether the applicants were entitled to injunctive relief pending the determination of the proceedings, given the statutory protections in place under the Residential Tenancies Act 2010 and the Residential Tenancies Regulation 2010. The court found that the applicants had the protection of these statutory provisions, which required the respondent to follow the necessary steps for enforcement, thus making injunctive relief unwarranted.

Finally, the court addressed whether the proceedings should be dealt with summarily due to the lack of a prima facie case for the relief sought. The court found that there was no prima facie case entitling the applicants to any injunctive relief. The court expressed concern that the proceedings seemed misconceived and that there was no basis for granting the interim relief requested.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Federal Circuit Court lacks jurisdiction to grant interlocutory relief in the form sought by the applicants under section 10AA of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999. Additionally, the notices purporting to terminate the tenancies were not invalid, and the court found no substantial constitutional issues warranting interlocutory relief. The applicants were also protected by statutory provisions, rendering injunctive relief unnecessary.