NELSON & LOWRIE

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NELSON & LOWRIE [2015] FCCA 1553
Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Children – parenting orders – contravention of parenting orders – reasonable excuse – whether reasonable excuse established – where one count dismissed – where there is apparent confusion about an order providing for the parties’ children to spend time with each parent during school holidays – where parties directed to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant – application adjourned to allow parties to apply for a further parenting order that varies the primary order.

Legislation:
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s.144

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.70NAC, 70NAF, 70NEA, 70NEB, 70NEC

Applicant: MS NELSON
Respondent: MR LOWRIE
File Number: SYC 5013 of 2008
Judgment of: Judge Scarlett
Hearing date: 2 December 2014
Date of Last Submission: 2 December 2014
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 11 June 2015

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person
Respondent: In person

ORDERS

  1. The Respondent did, on 20 April 2014, without reasonable excuse, contravene Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013.

  2. Count 2 of the Application – Contravention filed on 12 June 2014 alleging a contravention by the Respondent father on 29 May 2014 of Order 17 made on 28 June 2013 is dismissed.

  3. The Applicant and the Respondent are directed to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under the provisions of section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975. In accordance with section 11C of the said Act the Conference is to be reportable.

  4. The Application is adjourned under the provisions of paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975 to allow either or both of the Applicant and the Respondent to apply for a further parenting order that discharges, varies or suspends the primary order.

  5. The Application is adjourned to 16 July 2015 for further mention.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Nelson & Lowrie is approved pursuant to s.121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYC 5013 of 2008

MS NELSON

Applicant

And

MR LOWRIE

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Application

  1. This is an Application by the mother of the parties’ two children to deal with the father for contravention of the Orders made on 28 June 2013. The father denies the allegation and says that, in the alternative, he has a reasonable excuse for the contraventions of the Orders.

The Contraventions Alleged

  1. The Applicant mother claims that the Respondent father contravened the Orders made by this Court on 28 June 2013 in April 2014 and on 29 May 2014.

  2. The Orders claimed to have been contravened are Orders (6)(a)(ii) and (17).

  3. Order (6)(a)(ii) provides that the children will live with the parties as follows:

    (a)     For one half of each of the New South Wales Winter, Spring and Autumn school holidays as agreed and in the absence of agreement:

    …

    (ii)     With the father in the first half and the mother in the second half of the school holiday period in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NELSON & LOWRIE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 1553
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Nelson & Lowrie*, heard by Judge Scarlett, the applicant sought to establish that the respondent had contravened certain orders made on 28 June 2013. The dispute concerned allegations of breaches of parenting orders.

The court was required to determine whether the respondent had contravened specific parenting orders, namely Order (6)(ii) and Order 17, made on 28 June 2013. The court also had to consider whether any such contravention was without reasonable excuse.

Judge Scarlett found that the respondent had contravened Order (6)(ii) on 20 April 2014 without reasonable excuse. However, the court dismissed Count 2 of the application, which alleged a contravention of Order 17 on 29 May 2014. The court then directed the parties to attend a reportable Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under section 11F of the *Family Law Act 1975*. The application was adjourned under paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Act to allow for the possibility of applying for a new parenting order, and was further adjourned for mention on 16 July 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

The Respondent did, on 20 April 2014, without reasonable excuse, contravene Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013.

2.

Count 2 of the Application – Contravention filed on 12 June 2014 alleging a contravention by the Respondent father on 29 May 2014 of Order 17 made on 28 June 2013 is dismissed.

3.

The Applicant and the Respondent are directed to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under the provisions of section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975. In accordance with section 11C of the said Act the Conference is to be reportable.

4.

The Application is adjourned under the provisions of paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975 to allow either or both of the Applicant and the Respondent to apply for a further parenting order that discharges, varies or suspends the primary order.

5.

The Application is adjourned to 16 July 2015 for further mention.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Nelson & Lowrie pertains to a dispute between the Applicant, the mother, and the Respondent, the father, regarding contraventions of parenting orders. The Respondent was alleged to have contravened Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013 on 20 April 2014 without reasonable excuse. Additionally, the Applicant filed a further allegation on 12 June 2014, asserting that the Respondent contravened Order 17 on 29 May 2014. The court dismissed the second allegation but found merit in the first, ordering the parties to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975. This conference, as per section 11C, is reportable. The Application was subsequently adjourned under paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975 to permit either or both parties to apply for a further parenting order that discharges, varies, or suspends the primary order. The case was set for further mention on 16 July 2015.

The matter before the court pertains to proceedings initiated by the Applicant, Mrs. Nelson, against the Respondent, Mr. Lowrie, under the Family Law Act 1975. This case involves allegations of contraventions of prior court orders concerning parenting arrangements. The proceedings began with a contravention application filed by Mrs. Nelson on 12 June 2014, alleging that Mr. Lowrie had breached an order made on 28 June 2013. Additionally, a further allegation of contravention was made on 20 April 2014, concerning another order dated 28 June 2013. The court dismissed the second count of the contravention application but found merit in the first allegation. Following these findings, the court ordered that both parties must attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant, which is to be reportable under section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975. Moreover, the court adjourned the application under section 70NEB(1)(c) of the Act to permit the parties to seek further parenting orders that could discharge, vary, or suspend the primary order. The matter was subsequently adjourned to 16 July 2015 for further mention.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Respondent father contravened Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013 without reasonable excuse on 20 April 2014.
2. Whether the Respondent father contravened Order 17 made on 28 June 2013 on 29 May 2014 as alleged in Count 2 of the Application filed on 12 June 2014.
3. Whether the Applicant and the Respondent are required to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under the provisions of section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975 and if so, whether the Conference is to be reportable as per section 11C of the said Act.
4. Whether the Application should be adjourned under the provisions of paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975 to allow either or both of the Applicant and the Respondent to apply for a further parenting order that discharges, varies or suspends the primary order.
5. If the Application is to be adjourned, what date should be set for the further mention of the case.

Held
1. The Court concluded that the Respondent father did, on 20 April 2014, without reasonable excuse, contravene Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013.
2. Count 2 of the Application alleging a contravention by the Respondent father on 29 May 2014 of Order 17 made on 28 June 2013 is dismissed.
3. The Applicant and the Respondent are required to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975, and the Conference is to be reportable as per section 11C of the Act.
4. The Application is to be adjourned under paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975 to allow either or both of the Applicant and the Respondent to apply for a further parenting order that discharges, varies or suspends the primary order.
5. If the Application is adjourned, it will be set for further mention on 16 July 2015.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Nelson & Lowrie, the court addressed several critical issues regarding parenting orders and their enforcement. The first issue considered was whether the Respondent father contravened Order (6)(ii) made on 28 June 2013 without reasonable excuse on 20 April 2014. The court meticulously examined the evidence presented to ascertain whether the Respondent's actions constituted a breach of the specified order. The analysis involved understanding the terms of Order (6)(ii) and determining if there was a reasonable justification for the Respondent's actions on the date in question. The court found that the Respondent did indeed contravene the order without reasonable excuse, leading to the affirmation of this contravention in the order.

Turning to the second issue, the court considered whether the Respondent father contravened Order 17 made on 28 June 2013 on 29 May 2014, as alleged in Count 2 of the Application filed on 12 June 2014. The court evaluated the allegations and the evidence provided, focusing on the specific terms of Order 17 and the Respondent's conduct on the specified date. After thorough deliberation, the court dismissed Count 2 of the Application, concluding that the evidence did not substantiate the claim of contravention. The dismissal was based on a detailed assessment of the evidence and the legal standards applicable to determining compliance with the order.

Another significant issue before the court was whether the Applicant and the Respondent were required to attend a Child Dispute Conference with a Family Consultant under the provisions of section 11F of the Family Law Act 1975. The court determined that such a conference was necessary to facilitate a constructive dialogue regarding the child's welfare. Furthermore, in accordance with section 11C of the Act, the court mandated that the conference be reportable, ensuring that the court would be informed of the outcomes and recommendations stemming from the conference. This directive underscores the court's commitment to utilising all available resources to promote the best interests of the child.

The fourth issue pertained to whether the Application should be adjourned under the provisions of paragraph 70NEB(1)(c) of the Family Law Act 1975. This provision allows for the adjournment of proceedings to enable the parties to seek further parenting orders that could potentially discharge, vary, or suspend the primary order. The court found that an adjournment was warranted to allow the Applicant and the Respondent the opportunity to apply for additional orders that might better address the evolving circumstances of the child's welfare. This decision reflects the court's flexibility and responsiveness to the dynamic needs of families in parenting disputes.

Lastly, if the Application was to be adjourned, the court needed to set a date for the further mention of the case. The court decided that the Application should be adjourned to 16 July 2015 for further mention. This date was set to provide sufficient time for the parties to prepare and potentially apply for any new parenting orders, ensuring that the proceedings remain efficient and effective in serving the best interests of the child. The chosen date balanced the need for prompt resolution with the practicalities of allowing the parties to adequately prepare for the next stage of the proceedings.