Stephen Moignard and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

[2014] AATA  342

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2012/3591

Re

Stephen Moignard

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member R W Dunne

Date 30 May 2014
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal sets aside the objection decision under review.

.....................[Sgd]...................................................

Senior Member R W Dunne

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION – income tax – failure to lodge taxation returns – default assessment – trustee discretion – assessment of trust income – present entitlement – burden of proof – administrative penalty – objection decision under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 95, 95A, 97, 101 and 167.

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZK, Schedule 1 ss 284-75, 284-220 and 298-20

CASES

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Carey (No 6) (2006) 153 FCR 509

Colonial First State Investments Limited v Commissioner of Taxation (2011) 192 FCR 298
FC of T v Whiting (1943) 68 CLR 199
Taylor v FC of T (1970) 119 CLR 444
Harmer v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 173 CLR 264

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Dalco (1989) 168 CLR 614

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Taxation Ruling IT 328

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R W Dunne

30 May 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of a decision by the respondent to disallow a taxation objection lodged by the applicant against an amended assessment for the 2007/2008 year of income. The taxation objection related to the inclusion in the amended assessment of assessable income of $480,476 pursuant to s 97(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (“ITAA”) following an audit of the applicant’s taxation affairs.

  2. At the hearing, the applicant was self-represented and the respondent was represented by Ms K Clark (of counsel). The Tribunal received into evidence the T documents lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975,[1] together with the following exhibits:

    ·summary of NAB Classic Banking Account for the applicant in the period 25 October 2007 to 30 June 2008;[2]

    ·copy of Business Management Account of Bay Terrace Holdings Pty Ltd in the period 1 November 2007 to 30 June 2008;[3]

    ·letter from the applicant to Mr J Peel at ASIC dated 28 April 2010;[4]

    ·letter from Keating and Company Pty Ltd to Mr J Peel at ASIC dated 22 July 2010, with accompanying documents;[5]

    ·copy of page 4 of signed Deed of Variation;[6] and

    ·copy of email from applicant to Mr Mark Keating dated 28 June 2010, together with additional information.[7]

    [1] Exhibit R1, R2 and R3.

    [2] Exhibit A1.

    [3] Exhibit A2.

    [4] Exhibit A3.

    [5] Exhibit A4.

    [6] Exhibit A5.

    [7] Exhibit A6.

    ISSUES BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

  3. The following issues are before the Tribunal:

    a.Was the respondent correct to include the sum of $480,476 in the applicant’s assessable income for the 2007/2008 year of income pursuant to s 97 of the ITAA?

    b.Was the respondent correct to impose an administrative penalty of 75 percent of the tax shortfall amount in the 2007/2008 year of income for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stephen Moignard and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 342
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Stephen Moignard and the Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant, a vigneron and restaurateur, contested the Commissioner's amended assessment for the 2007/2008 year of income. The applicant objected to the assessment on the grounds that the profit derived from the sale of a Rupert Street property should not be considered as his personal assessable income. The objection was subsequently disallowed by the Commissioner, leading to the applicant seeking review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether the Commissioner was correct in including the sum of $480,476, derived from the sale of the Rupert Street property, in the applicant’s assessable income for the 2007/2008 year of income. The Commissioner argued that the profit should be attributed to the applicant under sections 97 and 101 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA), as the applicant was the trustee of the relevant trusts and had the discretion to apply the trust income for his benefit. The applicant contended that the profit was not properly his assessable income as it was subject to improvements and group trust arrangements.

The AAT found that the sum of $480,476 was not assessable income of the applicant for the 2007/2008 year of income. The Tribunal reasoned that the applicant's assertion regarding the actual profit being approximately $380,000, rather than the $480,476 assessed by the Commissioner, was credible. This was because the difference arose from improvements made to the building prior to sale, which were costs incurred by a group of trusts, not solely attributable to the applicant's personal benefit. As such, the AAT concluded that the Commissioner's assessment was incorrect and set aside the objection decision under review. Consequently, the Tribunal determined that the administrative penalty imposed by the Commissioner was also unjustifiable.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal sets aside the objection decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 5 April 2011, the applicant lodged an objection against the amended assessment for the 2007/2008 year of income which issued on 4 April 2011. Following further requests for information in relation to the objection, on 27 April 2012 the respondent issued a notice of objection decision to the applicant disallowing the objection in full.EVIDENCE OF APPLICANT In giving his evidence, the applicant described himself as a vigneron and restaurateur. He said the RST had changed its name to the HoCT. He said that, when the Rupert Street property was sold, the respondent regarded the profit as income. The respondent would not have done this if the applicant had filed, or been able to file, taxation returns in a timely fashion. However, he said he could not file taxation returns because the original accounting documents, which would enable the returns to be lodged, had been withheld by ASIC. As a result, the respondent proposed that a default assessment would issue. The applicant applied for deferral, which was granted, and the applicant filed the best taxation returns he could. Subsequently, more documents were received from ASIC to enable the applicant to file financial documents which were submitted at objection. As a result, there were discrepancies between the documents filed at audit and those filed at objection. The applicant said that the HoCT was part of a group of trusts and there were costs involved in improving the Rupert Street property for sale. He said the respondent continued to maintain the argument that had been applied when the default assessment issued. The respondent did not know or understand what had actually happened subsequently. In relation to the option, he said it was acquired with the purchase of the business which was operating in a factory on the Rupert Street property. The tenancy in relation to the Rupert Street property had occurred two or three years earlier than the sale of the property. The applicant said he decided to sell the building on the Rupert Street property because it was no longer needed in the business. He had to acquire the property through bridging finance in order to exercise the option, then to sell the building in order to pay back the bridging financier. The bridging finance had been obtained for three months to allow the exercise of the option, together with $300,000 that the applicant held in cash. A new trust was established to hold the building and to exercise the option. The option was exercised and the building sold on the same day (29 June 2007). Wares Printing and Mailhouse Pty Ltd was lessee of the Rupert Street property. As lessee, it had the option to purchase the property, but assigned the option to the applicant as trustee of the RST. The applicant exercised the option in that capacity. When the property was sold, the profit/gain on sale ($902,609.71) was assessed to the applicant entirely in his personal capacity. The applicant said that the profit on sale of the Rupert Street property was only $380,000 (approximately) and this was included in the taxation return of the HoCT/RST for the 2007/2008 year of income. The difference between that amount and the amount arrived at by the respondent represented improvements made to the building on the property, prior to sale, during the tenancy. These improvements were included in the accounts of the HoCT/RST at the time of the objection. He said the improvement costs were the costs of a “group of trusts” and the applicant was the trustee of the group. The group was comprised of two head trusts – the Bay Terrace Holdings Trust and the Secure Portfolio Management Trust. The Bay Terrace Holdings Trust loaned monies through the Secure Portfolio Management Trust in the name of Portfolio Ventures. There was a wine business in the Wine Logistics Trust and a mail house business through Wares Printing and Mailhouse. There was also a graphic design business called Finger Graphics. These subsidiary trusts were financed by the head trusts. The grouping meant that the Bay Terrace Holdings Trust had made loans to the subsidiary trusts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I have found that the sum of $480,476, derived on the sale of the Rupert Street property, was not assessable income of the applicant for the 2007/2008 year of income, it follows that the respondent was not correct to impose an administrative penalty of 75 percent of the shortfall amount or to increase the base penalty amount by 20 percent in the 2007/2008 year of income.DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the objection decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In brief terms, the respondent’s submissions may be summarised as follows:(a)The respondent determined that the net income of the RST as calculated under s 95 of the ITAA for the 2007/2008 year of income consisted of the profit of $480,476 derived on the sale of the Rupert Street property. As all the net proceeds from the sale of the property were transferred to the applicant’s NAB Classic Banking account and to the bank account in the name of Bay Terrace Holdings Pty Ltd (as trustee for the BTH Trust), a company controlled by the applicant, these transactions were an exercise of the trustee’s discretion to pay or apply trust income to or for the applicant’s benefit as a specified beneficiary of the RST for the purposes of s 101 of the ITAA. The respondent was correct to assess the applicant on a total of $480,476 for the 2007/2008 year of income, being the applicant’s share of the net income of the RST, under s 97 of the ITAA. Section 101 of the ITAA will still apply to deem the applicant to be presently entitled to an amount even if the trustee of the RST has not made a declaration, resolution, or other act to distribute an amount to him, providing that an amount has been paid to the applicant’s benefit.(b)In the event that the applicant says that he did not make a valid distribution of the net trust income to himself in the 2007/2008 year of income and the amount involved reverts to the trust fund of the RST, the respondent argues that clauses 3(4) and 3(5) of the trust deed of the RST apply. Clause 3(5) then provides that the net trust income ceases to be part of the trust fund and, pursuant to clauses 4(1) and 4(2) of the trust deed, the net trust income is assessed to the applicant as a specified beneficiary of the RST, in respect of his one-third share of the net trust income, and to the applicant in respect of the remainder of the net trust income for his two minor children also as specified beneficiaries under s 98 of the ITAA.(c)Although the applicant has disclaimed entitlement the net income of the RST, the disclaimer dated 4 April 2011 was not made within a reasonable time of the applicant becoming aware of his entitlement to the trust income, and it is therefore ineffective. CONSIDERATIONWas the respondent correct to include the sum of $480,476 in the applicant’s assessable income for the 2007/2008 year of income pursuant to s 97 of the ITAA? It is clear from much of the material in these proceedings that the applicant has been involved in a dispute (or disputes) with the respondent for a number of years. The disputes have related to his personal taxation affairs and the taxation affairs of related companies and trusts. Analysing certain of the background facts, the applicant set up a wine merchandising business called Wine Logistics during the 2007/2008 year of income and the business commenced through the Wine Logistics Trust. He was trustee of both the Wine Logistics Trust and the RST. In October 2007, he began the process of consolidating his wine-related business interests in the name of the vineyard, the Hundred of Comaum. His plan was that the HoCT would hold the vineyard property at Comaum in the Coonawarra, would own and operate the winery business and would take over the wine merchandising business.