Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd v Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES SUPREME COURT

CITATION:    Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd v Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd [2005]  NSWSC 1148

CURRENT JURISDICTION:           Equity Division

FILE NUMBER(S):   4998/04

HEARING DATE{S):             3 and 4 November 2005

JUDGMENT DATE:               04/11/2005

PARTIES:
Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd – Plaintiff/Cross Defendant
Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd – Defendant/Cross Claimant

JUDGMENT OF:      Palmer J      

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:             Not Applicable

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):      Not Applicable

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Not Applicable

COUNSEL:
H.J.A. Neal – Plaintiff/Cross Defendant
B.J. Sharpe – Defendant/Cross Claimant

SOLICITORS:
Dick & Williams – Plaintiff/Cross Defendant
JL & Sons – Defendant/Cross Claimant

CATCHWORDS:
LANDLORD AND TENANT – Whether oral agreement that half stipulated rent would be payable until building work completed – whether the lessor, in failing to complete building work, breached implied term of lease.

ACTS CITED:

DECISION:
Plaintiff’s claim for damages upheld;  Defendant’s claim for possession refused.

JUDGMENT:

Ex tempore

Introduction

  1. By a lease dated 1 May 2003 the Defendant leased to the Plaintiff factory and office premises known as 49 Fallon Street, Albury (“the Premises”).  At the time of the lease all building work on the Premises had not been completed.  The Plaintiff says that its Managing Director, Mr Atkinson, made on oral agreement with the Plaintiff's Managing Director, Mr Colquhoun, shortly before the lease was executed to the effect that the rent stated in the lease, namely, $55,000 per year by instalments of $4,583 per month, would not be payable in full because of the unfinished state of the Premises, and that only half of the rent stipulated would be payable until the building work was completed.

  2. The Defendant denies that such an agreement was made.  The Defendant says that at some time after the lease was signed there was an agreement that the Defendant would accept half of the rent stipulated in the lease until such time as the Plaintiff established itself in the Premises and became operational.

  3. The Plaintiff says that building work on the Premises has never been completed, so that the full amount of the stipulated rent has never become payable.  Further, it says that because the Premises remained in an uncompleted and unsatisfactory state in breach of the covenants in the lease it was compelled to seek alternative premises in which to carry on its operations.

  4. In September 2004 the Defendant gave the Plaintiff a demand for possession of the Premises on the ground that it had terminated the lease for the Plaintiff's breach of the covenant to pay the rent in full.  The Plaintiff then commenced proceedings seeking an order restraining the Defendant from retaking possession of the Premises.

  5. The relief which the Plaintiff now claims includes a declaration that there is a binding agreement between the parties that the Defendant would accept half of the rent stipulated in the lease until such time as the Defendant had completed all construction work on the Premises, or a declaration that the Defendant is estopped from resiling from representations to that effect.  Further, the Plaintiff…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd v Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 1148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd sought a declaration and damages from Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd for alleged breaches of a lease agreement concerning a property at 175 Pacific Highway, North Sydney. The central issue was whether an oral agreement existed, whereby the tenant would pay only half the stipulated rent until the landlord completed building work on the premises. The court had to determine if such an agreement was binding and if the landlord's failure to complete the building work constituted a breach of an implied term of the lease.

The court considered whether the alleged oral agreement was sufficiently established and if it could be enforced. The tenants argued that the landlord promised to complete the building work within a certain timeframe and that the rent would be reduced until that work was finished. The landlord denied making such a promise, asserting that the full rent was payable regardless of the state of the premises. The court examined the evidence and testimony to determine if the oral agreement was credible and if it could be enforced as part of the lease terms. The court also assessed whether the landlord's failure to complete the building work within the alleged timeframe amounted to a breach of an implied term of the lease.

The court found that the evidence supported the existence of an oral agreement whereby the tenant would pay half the stipulated rent until the landlord completed the building work. The court held that this agreement was binding and enforceable as it was consistent with the terms of the written lease and the surrounding circumstances. The court further found that the landlord's failure to complete the building work within the agreed timeframe constituted a breach of the implied term to use reasonable endeavours to complete the work. The court awarded the tenants a declaration that the landlord breached the lease and ordered the landlord to pay the tenants damages for the breach.

The court ordered Fallon Street Properties Pty Ltd to pay Steel & Stuff Pty Ltd damages for the breach of the lease agreement, including the unpaid rent and any other relevant costs. The court also granted a declaration that the landlord breached the lease by failing to complete the building work within the agreed timeframe. The tenants were awarded their costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.