State Transit Authority of NSW v Chemler

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      STATE TRANSIT AUTHORITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES v CHEMLER [2006]  NSWCA 249

FILE NUMBER(S):
40719/05

HEARING DATE(S):               28 August 2006

DECISION DATE:     08/09/2006

PARTIES:
STATE TRANSIT AUTHORITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES  (Appellant) 
Fritz CHEMLER  (Respondent) 

JUDGMENT OF:       Handley JA Santow JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Workers Compensation Commission

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          WCC509-04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Acting Deputy President Robin Handley

COUNSEL:
G WATSON, SC/ D SANT  (Appellant) 
S GORMLEY, SC/ B McMANAMEY  (Respondent) 

SOLICITORS:
Sparke Helmore  (Appellant) 
Turner Freeman  (Respondent) 

CATCHWORDS:
WORKERS COMPENSATION - Psychological injury –whether any psychological injury suffered by respondent wholly or predominantly caused by disciplinary action taken by appellant – nature of reasons giving rise to error in point of law. 

LEGISLATION CITED:
Workers Compensation Act 1987 s9A(1), s11A(1)
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 s353

DECISION:
Appeal allowed with costs;  see orders at [25]. 

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40719/05
WCC 509/04

HANDLEY JA
SANTOW JA
McCOLL JA

8 SEPTEMBER 2006

STATE TRANSIT AUTHORITY OF NEW SOUTH WALES v CHEMLER

Judgment

  1. HANDLEY JA:  I agree with Santow JA. 

  2. SANTOW JA: 

    INTRODUCTION 

    This appeal is brought by the employer, State Transport Authority of New South Wales (“STA”) pursuant to s353 Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (“WIM”). It is, in terms of s353(1), an appeal “in point of law” from Acting Deputy President Handley’s review, pursuant to s352 WIM, of the decision of the Arbitrator Mr Stephen Lancken. ADP Handley confirmed the decision of the Arbitrator in favour of the worker Mr Chemler.

  3. The appeal principally concerns s11A Workers Compensation Act 1987 (“WCA”). Though s9A is also relevant it is so because of the way in which the Arbitrator reasoned; no reliance was in the end placed on s9A as an independent ground of appeal. Section 9A(1) provides:

    “No compensation is payable under this Act in respect of an injury unless the employment concerned was a substantial contributing factor to the injury.” 

    Section 11A(1) provides:

    “No compensation is payable under this Act in respect of an injury that is a psychological injury if the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the employer with respect to transfer, demotion, promotion, performance appraisal, discipline, retrenchment or dismissal of workers or provision of employment benefits to workers.” 

  4. The appeal to this Court concentrated in argument upon so much of the determination of ADP Handley as dealt with s11A of the WCA. As so refined, the essential ground of appeal was that ADP Handley acknowledged error on the part of the Arbitrator in failing to specifically address s11A WCA when in actuality the Arbitrator did address s11A but in terms which confirmed its application. Yet the Arbitrator still decided for the worker notwithstanding s11A, in terms suggesting that he thought, wrongly, conformance with s9A somehow overrode…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State Transit Authority of NSW v Chemler and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a determination by ADP Handley regarding a workers compensation claim brought by Mr Chemler against the State Transit Authority of NSW (STA). Mr Chemler, a boilermaker and welder, alleged he suffered a psychological injury due to harassment and racial vilification at the STA workplace. The STA contended that any such injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable disciplinary action it had taken against Mr Chemler, relying on section 11A of the *Workers Compensation Act*.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether ADP Handley had erred in law concerning the application of section 11A of the *Workers Compensation Act*. Specifically, the STA argued that ADP Handley had misunderstood the Arbitrator's decision, incorrectly concluding that the Arbitrator had failed to address section 11A when, in fact, the Arbitrator had considered it but erroneously believed compliance with section 9A overrode its application. The STA maintained that ADP Handley's subsequent reasoning, based on this misunderstanding, led to legal error.

The Court of Appeal found that ADP Handley had indeed fallen into legal error by misapprehending the Arbitrator's approach to section 11A. The Arbitrator had addressed the section but incorrectly concluded that compliance with section 9A superseded its application. ADP Handley's subsequent reasoning, which assumed the Arbitrator had not addressed section 11A at all, was flawed. Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of ADP Handley, and remitted the matter to the Workers Compensation Commission for a rehearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed with costs; see orders at [25].

Background

Background to the litigation

The appeal to this Court concentrated in argument upon so much of the determination of ADP Handley as dealt with s11A of the WCA. As so refined, the essential ground of appeal was that ADP Handley acknowledged error on the part of the Arbitrator in failing to specifically address s11A WCA when in actuality the Arbitrator did address s11A but in terms which confirmed its application. Yet the Arbitrator still decided for the worker notwithstanding s11A, in terms suggesting that he thought, wrongly, conformance with s9A somehow overrode application of s11A. ADP Handley, it was said, fell into legal error concerning the application of s11A. It starts with his failure to appreciate what the Arbitrator did decide and then proceeding to conclude that “had the Arbitrator done so [addressed s11A], he would have found s11A to have no application” (at [47]). SALIENT FACTS The respondent, Mr Chemler, worked as a boilermaker and welder for the appellant STA from March 1981 to early 2003. At the time of his injury he was employed as a body maker in the Waverley depot, having been re-located there in October 1995 (chronology for HREOC Blue, 248). It is there that he alleges his psychological injury arose when he was harassed and racially vilified for being Jewish as well as for his lack of English. The STA rely on the fact that during December 2002/ June 2003 he was disciplined including for leaving work unfinished. He was demoted for three months from a level 4 to level 3 tradesman. He appealed against that demotion to the Transport Appeals Board on 8 January 2003 following a Notice of Punishment dated 17 December 2002 for misconduct essentially alleging poor workmanship; Red, 35, para 33 of ADP Handley’s determination. There had been earlier disciplinary steps, via what were described as a form E1, on 27 June 2001 (Orange, 12), and 10 December 2002 (Blue, 248, chronology for proceedings before HREOC). The last of these E1 notices was just before he left the STA, namely on 6 June 2003. In effect the STA rely for the application of s11A on what it describes as the reasonable disciplinary action which it took in December 2002 contending that, in terms of s11A, that action was the sole or predominant cause of any psychological injury suffered by Mr Chemler. Both before the Arbitrator and ADP Handley Mr Chemler relies on the evidence summarised below, as well as various medical and psychiatric reports of some cogency, to negate that conclusion on causation. On 6 January 2003 and 6 June 2003 Mr Chemler notified the appellant that he was suffering from anxiety, depression and hypertension as a result of what he described as racial harassment, anti-Semitic graffiti and victimisation at work over a number of years. His complaint of racial vilification centred upon the fact that he was Jewish and English was not his first language. There was evidence of an anti-Semitic sign on a piece of sheet metal in the workplace at Waverley, its original text subsequently added to. It appears to have been upon the wall of the body-repairer’s room since about 1997 (Blue, 159 evidence of a non-Jewish co-worker Mr Darbon dated 27 July 2003 where he says “I would think that this sign has been up on the wall of the Body Repairer’s room for about six years” [emphasis added]). Thus it was for most if not all of Mr Chemler’s time there in the body repair shop. It contained writing as follows throughout that time: “Home Sweet HomeDave DarbonAndKeith Abrahams $ Jewish Boys(The “O.T.” Kings)Money Money MoneyIsn’t FunnyIn A Jewish World”(Blue,146)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This conclusion leaves no alternative to a re-hearing. OVERALL CONCLUSION I conclude that the appeal should succeed and propose orders as follows: (1)Appeal allowed. (2)Set aside the decision of ADP Handley and in lieu thereof order: (a)set aside the decision of the Arbitrator, and (b)remit the matter to the Workers Compensation Commission for re-hearing. (3)The respondent to pay the appellant’s costs but to be entitled to a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act. McCOLL JA: I agree with Santow JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established