State of Victoria v Mansfield

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

State of Victoria v Mansfield [2003] FCAFC 154

BANKRUPTCY – whether parking infringement penalties are provable debts – whether the penalties were imposed by an order of a court – whether the Court could stay legal process for the enforcement of parking infringement penalties registered under Pt 2 Sch 7 of the Magistrates’ Court Act 1989 (Vic)

WORDS AND PHRASES – “penalties or fines imposed by a court”

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 60(1) and 82
Magistrates’ Court Act 1989 (Vic), s 99 and Sch 7
Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic), ss 77(2)(b), 86, 87, 89

Storey v Lane (1981) 147 CLR 549 applied
Re Bradbury; ex parte The King; The Official Receiver (1931) 3 ABC 204 considered
Re Curtis; ex parte The Deputy Commissioner of Taxation; The Official Receiver [1951] St R Qd 246 referred to
Cameron v The Secretary of the Department of Justice (unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 28 October 1994) considered
St Kilda City Council v Kenyon (1993) 18 MVR 349 referred to
Zaffiro v Springvale City Council (unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 28 March 1996) referred to
Alpay v Hargreaves (unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, 29 October 1998) referred to
In re Savundra [1973] 3 All ER 406 referred to
R. v Governor of Her Majesty’s Gaol, Coburg; Ex parte Coman [1962] VR 375 considered

Commonwealth of Australia, Report of the Committee Appointed by the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth to Review the Bankruptcy Law of the Commonwealth, Parliamentary Papers Session 1964-65-66, vol XIII
Joint Task Force, Penalty Enforcement by Registration of Infringement Notice; Courts Management Change Program (May 1985)
Legislative Assembly, Parliamentary Debates, Magistrates (Summary Proceedings) (Amendment) Bill 1985
G Webster, “perin Court Fines: Provable in Bankruptcy?” (1998) 72(7) Law Institute Journal 53
Australian Law Reform Commission, Securing Compliance: Civil and Administrative Penalties in Australian Federal Regulation, Discussion Paper 65, April 2002
M Murray, “Fines and Penalties: Provable in Bankruptcy?” (2000) 10(3) New Directions in Bankruptcy 13

STATE OF VICTORIA v MICHELLE MANSFIELD
V 727 of 2002

BLACK CJ, KENNY & DOWNES JJ
18 JULY 2003
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 727 OF 2002

On appeal from a single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

THE STATE OF VICTORIA
Appellant

AND:

MICHELLE MANSFIELD
Respondent

JUDGES:

BLACK CJ, KENNY & DOWNES JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

18 JULY 2003

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The orders made on 27 September 2002 in proceeding V 7014 of 2002 be set aside.

3.The respondent’s application dated 17 May 2002 be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 727 OF 2002

On appeal from a single Judge of the Federal Court of Australia

BETWEEN:

THE STATE OF VICTORIA
Appellant

AND:

MICHELLE MANSFIELD
Respondent

JUDGES:

BLACK CJ, KENNY & DOWNES JJ

DATE:

18 JULY 2003

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Victoria v Mansfield and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCAFC 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State of Victoria appealed against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia in which the Court had held that parking infringement penalties imposed on Ms Michelle Mansfield were provable debts under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) and that the Court had jurisdiction to stay any legal process in respect of these penalties. Ms Mansfield, who had become bankrupt on 29 March 2001, had issued 72 parking infringement notices to her by the Port Phillip City Council under the Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) and the Road Safety (General) Regulations 1999 (SR No 27/1999). The key issues before the Court were whether the infringement penalties were provable debts under the Bankruptcy Act and whether the Court had jurisdiction to stay legal process against Ms Mansfield in respect of the penalties. The Court held that the infringement penalties were statutory liabilities imposed by the Road Safety Act and the General Regulations and were, therefore, provable debts for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act. The Court also held that it had jurisdiction to stay legal process against Ms Mansfield in respect of the penalties.

The Court examined the relevant statutory provisions and noted that under the statutory scheme, the owner of a vehicle becomes liable to pay the penalty for a parking infringement upon receipt of a notice. If the penalty is not paid within 28 days, additional costs are incurred. The Court held that the role of the Magistrates’ Court was to enforce a pre-existing statutory liability in respect of the infringement penalties and costs. Since the pre-existing liabilities for parking infringements were debts to which Ms Mansfield was subject at the date of her bankruptcy, they were provable debts for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act. The Court also held that it had jurisdiction to stay legal process against Ms Mansfield in respect of the penalties under section 60(1)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act.

The appeal was allowed, the orders made on 27 September 2002 were set aside, and the respondent’s application dated 17 May 2002 was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made on 27 September 2002 in proceeding V 7014 of 2002 be set aside.

3. The respondent’s application dated 17 May 2002 be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Michelle Mansfield, who is the respondent to this appeal, received some 72 parking infringement notices (“infringement notices”) in respect of a motor vehicle registered in her name. The infringement notices were issued to her by an officer of the Port Phillip City Council under the Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) (“the Road Safety Act”) and the Road Safety (General) Regulations 1999 (SR No 27/1999) (“the General Regulations”). The appeal raises the questions (1) whether the respondent’s statutory liabilities for parking infringements were provable debts within the meaning of s 82(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Bankruptcy Act”); and (2) whether it was open to the Court to make an order under s 60(1)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act staying any legal process against the respondent or her property in respect of the non-payment of amounts due in respect of the infringement notices, or in consequence of her failure to comply with the enforcement orders made under cl 5(1) of Sch 7 to the Magistrates’ Court Act 1989 (Vic) (“the Magistrates’ Court Act”).background facts Each of the infringement notices received by the respondent alleged, in substance, that her vehicle had been unlawfully parked in the City of Port Phillip and specified a penalty for the alleged offence (“the infringement penalty”). The infringement notices each informed the respondent that “[p]ayment of the penalty may be made by cash …, money order, or ‘not negotiable’ cheque payable to the Port Phillip City Council”. Each notice informed her that, if she wished to query the notice, she should send “a letter of explanation” to the Port Phillip City Council (“the Council”), or call in at the Council’s offices and “record [her] query in person”. If she paid the penalty within 28 days of the issue of the notice, then, according to the notice “no further proceedings shall be taken” and “no conviction for the infringement recorded”. If she did nothing, then the notice stated that “costs will be added to the penalty and a ‘Courtesy Letter’ issued”. Each notice warned her that if she did not respond after receiving this letter, then “perin court action will be initiated” and, ultimately, an enforcement order “will be issued to recover monies owed adding further costs”. (The term “perin” is an acronym for “Penalty Enforcement by Registration of Infringement Notice”.) The respondent did not pay the infringement penalties specified in the infringement notices. Nor did she query the notices. In due course, the Council sent her the ‘Courtesy Letters’ mentioned in the notices. The letters informed her that payment of the infringement penalties was overdue and that, within 28 days, she must either pay the infringement penalties and costs to the Council; or ask for the matter to be dealt with by a court; or provide a statutory declaration identifying a person other than herself as the driver of the vehicle at the time of the alleged offence. The respondent did not take any action following these letters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Following the presentation by the respondent of a debtor’s petition and acceptance of the petition by the Official Receiver on 29 March 2001, the respondent became a bankrupt from that date. By an application to this Court dated 17 May 2002, she sought an order staying any legal process in respect of her non-payment of the infringement penalties and costs, as well as declaratory relief. On 27 September 2002, a judge of the Court declared that the unpaid penalties or fines and costs payable by her in respect of parking infringements in the City of Port Phillip prior to her bankruptcy on 29 March 2001 were provable debts in her bankruptcy. His Honour ordered that there be a stay of any legal process against her or her property. The State of Victoria appeals against his Honour’s judgment.the decision at first instance At first instance, counsel for Ms Mansfield submitted that if the Road Safety Act, the General Regulations, and the Magistrates’ Court Act were properly construed, then the infringement penalties and costs were debts imposed by statute and provable debts for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act. This was denied by the State of Victoria, which contended that, as a matter of statutory construction, the infringement penalties and costs were debts imposed by orders of the Magistrates’ Court and were not, in consequence, provable debts for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act. In his reasons, the primary judge noted that there were a number of matters that were common ground, including that the amounts owing by Ms Mansfield were in respect of parking infringements as defined in s 3(1) of the Road Safety Act; the amounts of the infringement penalties were determined in accordance with the General Regulations; and the City of Port Phillip was a public authority responsible for collecting and receiving the infringement penalties: see Mansfield v State of Victoria [2002] FCA 1175 (“Mansfield”), at [13] and [16]. After giving careful consideration to the relevant statutory provisions, the primary judge concluded that the role of the Magistrates’ Court was to enforce a pre-existing statutory liability in respect of the infringement penalties and costs. Since the pre-existing liabilities for parking infringements were debts or liabilities to which Ms Mansfield was subject at the date of her bankruptcy, they were provable debts for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Act. His Honour stated, at [20]:Save and except in the case of an owner electing to have the matter dealt with by a court or filing a statutory declaration identifying the driver of the car at the time of the infringement, under the statutory scheme … and the notices required to be given in accordance with the perin procedure:·the owner becomes liable to pay the penalty payable for the parking infringement penalty; and·where there is a failure to pay the penalty within 28 days, the penalty plus the additional costs incurred are payable.In the present case the applicant, who is the owner of the vehicle in respect of which the parking infringements occurred, did not elect to have any of the infringements dealt with by a court nor did she send in a statutory declaration stating that a person other than herself was the driver. Accordingly, in respect of each of the parking infringements, the applicant became liable to the City of Port Phillip to pay the amount of the penalty and the costs incurred prior to the initiation of any court process under the Magistrates Court Act. The amount of the liability was the penalty payable in respect of each infringement plus the costs incurred by the City of Port Phillip. The liability of the applicant to pay the penalty was one which was imposed by the Road Safety Act and the Regulations upon service of the parking infringement notice on the applicant in accordance with that Act and the Regulations.