State of Tasmania v Stirling

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[2021] TASSC 25

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                State of Tasmania v Stirling [2021] TASSC 25

PARTIES:  STATE OF TASMANIA
  v
  STIRLING, Patricia Joy

FILE NO:  413/2021
DECISION

APPEALED FROM:  The State of Tasmania (Department of Health) v S

[2021] TASWRCT 3

DELIVERED ON:  24 June 2021
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  11 May 2021
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow CJ

CATCHWORDS:

Workers Compensation – Employment related injury, disability or disease – Employment "substantial or significant contributing factor" – "Contributing factor" in relation to disease or disease "due to nature of employment" – Particular cases – Adjustment disorder – Contributing factors incidental to performance of employment duties.

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act1988 (Tas), s 29(1)(b).
University of Tasmania v Cane (1994) 4 Tas R 156, followed.
Aust Dig Workers Compensation [94]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellant:  B R McTaggart SC
             Respondent:  L K Mackey
Solicitors:
             Appellant:  Wallace Wilkinson & Webster
             Respondent:  Ogilvie Jennings

Judgment Number:  [2021] TASSC 25
Number of paragraphs:  37

Serial No 25/2021

File No 413/2021

STATE OF TASMANIA v PATRICIA JOY STIRLING

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  BLOW CJ

24 June 2021

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal, constituted by its Chief Commissioner, Ms A M Clues: State of Tasmania (Department of Health) v S [2021] TASWRCT 3. It concerns a referral pursuant to s 81A of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act"). That section concerns interim payments. The learned Chief Commissioner made a determination that the employer did not have a reasonably arguable case. As a result, the employer remained liable to make continuing weekly payments of compensation, and to pay medical and other expenses, pending a final hearing. The employer has appealed, contending that the learned Chief Commissioner erred in law in making the determination. It contends that the only conclusion open to her was that it did have a reasonably arguable case, that she made a number of specific errors of law, and that she failed to provide adequate reasons for her decision.

  2. This case appears to have arisen out of an unfortunate clash of personalities. It concerns a claim under the Act made by the respondent to this appeal, Patricia Stirling. She is employed as a supervisor in the finance section of the Department of Health. One of her subordinates was a woman whom I will refer to as "Carol". That is a pseudonym, not her real name. She and the respondent worked together in two buildings in Hobart known as the CBA building and the Wellington building. Difficulties between Carol and the respondent led to the respondent taking two days' sick leave on 14 and 15 August 2020, subsequently ceasing work on 1 October 2020, and claiming workers compensation in respect of an adjustment disorder.

  3. The State, as the respondent's employer, disputed liability on the basis that there was no relationship between any incapacity on the part of the respondent and her employment duties.

The legislation

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Tasmania v Stirling and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] TASSC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State of Tasmania, represented by the Department of Justice, has brought an appeal against the decision of the Chief Commissioner of the Tasmanian Workers Compensation Regulator, who found in favour of the respondent, Stirling. Stirling had lodged a claim for workers' compensation, asserting that her employment was a significant factor in her adjustment disorder, which arose from incidents involving a co-worker, Carol. The employer argued that the Chief Commissioner erred in her findings, particularly in relation to the nature and contributing factors of Stirling's disorder.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Chief Commissioner erred in concluding that Stirling's employment was the major or most significant contributing factor to her adjustment disorder. This hinged on whether the disorder arose out of Stirling's employment and whether her employment was a substantial contributing factor to the disorder. The court had to determine if the Chief Commissioner's findings were supported by the evidence and whether the employer had a reasonably arguable case to dispute the claim.

The court considered the evidence presented and the interpretation of relevant sections of the Workers Compensation Act. It held that the Chief Commissioner's findings were supported by the evidence, particularly noting that the injury arose from Stirling's interaction with a co-worker during her employment. The court rejected the employer's argument that Stirling's conduct outside her employment duties could be the major cause of her disorder. The court found that the employer's evidence did not provide a plausible alternative cause inconsistent with the Chief Commissioner's findings, and therefore, the employer's appeal was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal by the State of Tasmania against the Chief Commissioner's determination was dismissed, with the State to pay the respondent's costs. The decision confirmed that Stirling's employment was a significant contributing factor to her adjustment disorder, affirming the Chief Commissioner's findings and upholding the respondent's claim for workers' compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The reasons why the learned Chief Commissioner made a determination favourable to the respondent appear in the following paragraphs of her decision:"24 ... the uncontested evidence is that the worker first became totally incapacitated for work for a period of two days by reason of the injury on 13 August 2020 as a result of the first incident. Based on the only medical evidence which is contained in the initial certificate, the first incident was the cause of the injury and the incapacity for work from 2 October 2020.25 The worker's employment in s25(1)(b) is a reference to the performance each working day of the worker's duties and all that which was reasonably incidental thereto including interaction with fellow employees. See Cane v University of Tasmania [1993] TASSC 98 at [6].26 It was the interaction between the worker and the co-worker that caused the injury and the resultant incapacity for work. The evidence suggests no other cause. As stated by Underwood J in Cane v University of Tasmania (supra) at [8]:'The finding that the stress "arises out of that relationship, an employment relationship" is of necessity, a finding that the employment caused the stress disorder.'27 There is no evidence that it was the application for a restraint order in isolation was [sic] the cause of the worker's incapacity for work. The injury arose as a result of an employment relationship between the worker and the co-worker. It follows from this that the worker's employment was the major or most significant contributing factor to the injury....32 In this case, the employer has not provided evidence of a plausible potential cause that is inconsistent with a finding that the worker's employment was not the major or most significant contributing factor to the injury.Conclusion33 I have reached the view that the employer's evidence does not support an argument to dispute the claim on the basis that the worker's employment was not the major or most significant contributing factor to the worker's injury. The employer's s81A referral is therefore dismissed. ...". The employer contends that it had a reasonably arguable case on the basis that it was reasonably arguable that the respondent's employment did not contribute to her claimed adjustment disorder to the extent of being the major or most significant factor for the purposes of ss 3(2A) and 25(1)(b) of the Act. In more detail, its contentions are to the following effect:· The respondent and Carol had conflicting versions of events. Since the s 81A referral was determined on the basis of documentary evidence alone, it was not open to the learned Chief Commissioner to make findings as to the disputed facts. It was reasonably possible that Carol's version of events would be accepted as wholly truthful and correct at a final hearing. · On Carol's version of events, the claimed adjustment disorder was arguably a consequence of conduct on the part of the respondent that had nothing to do with her employment duties. That alleged conduct included conduct during lunch breaks away from the respondent's workplaces, video recording Carol and her colleagues in their workplaces, and telling lies and defaming Carol in the work environment.· Section 25(1)(b) should be construed as entitling a worker to compensation for a disease only if it both arose out of the worker's employment and arose in the course of the worker's employment. · The claimed adjustment disorder did not arise out of the respondent's employment because it did not arise out of anything she did in service to the employer or incidental to her employment. · The only conclusion reasonably open to the learned Chief Commissioner was that the employer had a reasonably arguable case on the basis that conduct of the respondent that was not within the course of her employment might reasonably be found to have been the major or most significant cause of her claimed adjustment disorder. If so, reaching a contrary conclusion involved an error of law.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.