State of South Australia v Collins

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Application for Judicial Review)

STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v COLLINS

[2018] SASCFC 110

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Bampton)

22 October 2018

PUBLIC SERVICE - BOARDS, TRIBUNALS AND APPEALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS

EDUCATION - SCHOOLS - GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS - TEACHERS' EMPLOYMENT AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE - DISCIPLINARY MATTERS

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - GENERALLY

Application for judicial review.

The second defendant Mr Collins lodged an appeal with the Teachers Appeal Board against decisions by the Education Department not to grant to him an Authority to Teach. The State’s application for summary dismissal for want of jurisdiction was dismissed. The State contends that the South Australian Employment Tribunal (which has succeeded the Teachers Appeal Board) lacks jurisdiction to entertain the appeal.

Mr Collins was employed as a Temporary Teacher pursuant to a one year contract expiring at the end of January 2015. In November 2014 the Education Department commenced an investigation into allegations of misconduct against him, suspended him on full pay and withdrew his 2014 Authority to Teach. In December 2014 he applied for an Authority to Teach for 2015 which was not granted. In January 2015 his employment expired by the effluxion of time and he ceased to be an officer of the teaching service. In October 2015 he applied for an Authority to Teach for 2016. In June and December 2016 the Director-General wrote to him stating that he had engaged in misconduct and would not be granted an Authority to Teach.

Former section 54 of the Education Act 1972 conferred a right of appeal against “any administrative action or decision affecting the officer in relation to which a right of appeal is conferred by the regulations” and regulation 36 of the Education Regulations 2012 (SA) conferred a right of appeal if “a teacher at any time considers that he or she has just cause of complaint against any officer of the Department when that officer is acting in the course of his or her duties”. The State contends that the decisions the subject of the appeal were made after January 2015 when Mr Collins had ceased to be an officer and the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to entertain an appeal against those decisions.

Held by Blue J (Kourakis CJ and Bampton J agreeing):

1. On the proper construction of section 54, it operates to confer a right of appeal upon an appellant affected in his or her capacity as an officer by a decision or administrative action. The question when the appellant is required to be an officer is dictated by the question whether the appellant is affected in his or her capacity as an officer by the decision or action (at [62]).

2. Given the paucity of evidence adduced on judicial review (and before the Tribunal) of the steps taken by Department officers and communications…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of South Australia v Collins and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered an application for judicial review brought by Mr Collins against the State of South Australia. The dispute concerned Mr Collins' right to appeal disciplinary decisions made by the Education Department concerning his employment as a temporary teacher. Mr Collins had been employed on a series of fixed-term contracts and held an Authority to Teach, which was a precondition for his employment. Allegations of misconduct were made against him in late 2014, leading to an investigation and the withdrawal of his Authority to Teach.

The central legal issue before the court was the proper construction and application of section 54 of the relevant Act and regulation 36 of the Education Regulations 2012 (SA). Specifically, the court had to determine whether Mr Collins, having ceased to be employed as a teacher by the Department in January 2015, retained a right to appeal against decisions made in 2016 concerning his prior conduct. The State contended that the right of appeal under section 54 was limited to persons who were officers at the time of the impugned decision.

The court reasoned that section 54 of the Act confers a right of appeal on an "officer" against a decision affecting them, provided a right of appeal is conferred by the regulations. Regulation 36, in turn, grants a right of appeal to a "teacher" who has a just cause of complaint against a Department officer, subject to first appealing to the Director-General. It was common ground that the term "teacher" in regulation 36 referred to an "officer" as defined by section 5 of the Act, meaning a teacher holding office in the teaching service. Applying this, the court concluded that the reference to an "officer" in section 54 must be interpreted as a person who held that status at the time the decision under appeal was made. As Mr Collins was no longer an officer of the Department when the 2016 decisions were made, he had no standing to appeal those decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This application raises for consideration the proper construction and application of section 54 of the Act and regulation 36 of the Education Regulations 2012 (SA) (the Regulations).Background In July 2007 Mr Collins commenced employment by the Education Department[2] as a temporary teacher under a fixed term contract. He was appointed as a temporary (contract) teacher pursuant to section 15 of the Act. He was employed by the Education Department as a temporary teacher under a series of fixed term contracts of up to one year’s duration until mid-2012.[2] The Department was at material times generally called the Department for Education and Child Development but its name has changed over time. For ease of reference I refer to it simply as the Education Department. After a series of short term temporary relieving teacher appointments, in January 2014 Mr Collins was again appointed as a part-time temporary teacher from 23 January 2014 to 21 January 2015 pursuant to a letter of appointment dated 3 February 2014. Mr Collins was engaged to work as a preschool teacher at a Children’s Centre in a north-eastern suburb (the School). It was at all times a precondition to Mr Collins obtaining employment with the Department that he hold an Authority to Teach issued by the Department. This precondition applies to all temporary teaching appointments but does not apply to permanent teachers. Teachers who seek an Authority to Teach are required to complete an application towards the end of the calendar year. The criterion for the grant of an Authority to Teach is whether the applicant is suitable for employment within the Department. If granted, an Authority to Teach applies to the following calendar year and the applicant’s details are placed on the Employable Teacher Register for the duration of that calendar year. Principals of schools and directors of preschools have authority to engage only teachers who hold an Authority to Teach and therefore whose names appear in the Employable Teacher Register for the relevant calendar year. On 13 November 2014 allegations of misconduct by Mr Collins at the School were made against him. The Department commenced an investigation. On 17 November 2014 Mr Lovegrove, an officer of the Department, wrote to Mr Collins informing him that he had decided that, pending the investigation, Mr Collins should be suspended from work on full pay. This decision was confirmed by a letter from Mr O’Loughlin, another officer of the Department, dated 22 December 2014. These letters were not tendered before the Board or at the hearing of this action and are not in evidence. Also on 17 November 2014 Mr Mullan, another officer of the Department, wrote to Mr Collins informing him that he had decided that, pending the investigation, Mr Collins’ current Authority to Teach should be withdrawn. This letter is not in evidence. On 8 December 2014 Mr Collins lodged an application for an Authority to Teach for calendar 2015. The application is not in evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 27 September 2017 the Acting Chief Executive wrote to Mr Collins. She referred to her predecessors’ letters of 5 January 2016, 28 June 2016 and 2 December 2016. She maintained the factual findings made about Mr Collins’ conduct but rescinded the findings that this conduct amounted to a contravention of the relevant Professional Conduct Standards and amounted to “misconduct” as defined in section 3 of the Public Sector Act 2009 (SA). It is common ground that the rescission is not relevant to the jurisdictional issue that arises on this application for judicial review.Evidence The hearing and determination of this application for judicial review was referred by a Judge directly to the Full Court pursuant to subrule 201(2) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA). At the hearing the State tendered an affidavit by Helen King, the solicitor for the State in this matter, which exhibited Mr Collins’ notice of appeal,[6] the Director-General’s application for directions and supporting affidavit of Mr McDonald (together with its exhibits), the transcript of the hearing before the Board on 19 May 2017 and the Board’s reasons for decision dated 9 June 2017. [6] The notice of appeal was amended with the permission of the Board granted at the hearing on 19 May 2017. The State also tendered an affidavit by Michael Papps, Director of People and Culture Operations within the Department. Mr Papps exhibited the Acting Chief Executive’s letter dated 27 September 2017 and explained processes within the Department for teaching appointments and Authorities to Teach.Contentions by the parties Section 54 of the Act confers on an officer a right of appeal to the Board against a decision affecting the officer in relation to which a right of appeal is conferred by the regulations. Regulation 36 confers a right of appeal on a teacher who considers that he or she has just cause of complaint against an officer of the Department when that officer is acting in the course of his or her duties provided that the teacher first appeals to the Director-General and is dissatisfied with the Director-General’s determination. It is common ground that the reference in regulation 36 to a “teacher” is a reference to an “officer” within the meaning of section 54 as defined by section 5 of the Act, namely a teacher holding office in the teaching service constituted under Part 3 of the Act.[7][7] In Cusack v Parsons (1988) 48 SASR 364, Jacobs J (with whom Millhouse J agreed) held that the reference to a “teacher” in regulation 111 of the Education Regulations 1976 (SA), which was in the same terms as regulation 36, was to be construed as confined to an officer as defined in section 5 of the Act. Both parties accept the correctness of that decision in this respect. The State contends that on its proper construction the reference in section 54 to an “officer” is a reference to a person who is an officer at the time of the impugned decision the subject of the appeal. As Mr Collins ceased to be an officer in January 2015, he had no right to appeal against decisions made in 2016 when he was no longer an officer.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly the application for judicial review should be dismissed. The appeal should proceed to a hearing before the Tribunal at which evidence relevant to Mr Collins’ standing is adduced together with evidence as to the merits. The Tribunal can then decide both the issue of jurisdiction and the merits on all available evidence.Conclusion I would dismiss the application for judicial review.BAMPTON J: I agree with Blue J and would dismiss the application for judicial review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established