LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: State of Queensland v Pajares [2004] QLAC 0059 PARTIES: State of Queensland
(appellant/respondent)v. Luis James Pajares
(respondent/appellant)FILE NOS: LAC2003/0474 and LAC2003/0472 DIVISION: Land Appeal Court of Queensland PROCEEDING: Appeals from a decision of the Land Court in the matter of determination of compensation consequent upon the resumption of land for National Park Purposes pursuant to the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 ORIGINATING COURT: Land Court of Queensland DELIVERED ON: 20 July 2004 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARD AT: Cairns JUDGE:
MEMBERS:Justice Jones
Mr RE Wenck
Mr RP ScottORDER: 1. To the extent that the State has been successful in having the quantum of the Land Court's determination reduced, and the claimant has been unsuccessful in having it increased, the appeal by the State is allowed and the appeal by the claimant disallowed.
2. Compensation is determined in the amount of $3,419,689 (Three Million Four Hundred and Nineteen Thousand, Six Hundred and Eighty-nine Dollars).
3. The respondent pay interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum on the amount of $3,393,689 from the date of resumption, 19 November 1999, until 13 April 2000, when an advance of $1,830,000 was paid; and on the amount of $1,563,689 from 14 April 2000, until 25 August 2000 (which the parties agreed is the appropriate date that the legal and valuation fees were paid) and then on the amount of $1,589,689 from 26 August 2000 up to the day immediately preceding the date upon which final payment of compensation is made.
CATCHWORDS: Resumption – Determination of compensation – Pointe Gourde and San Sebastian principles – Land taken for National Park purposes – Conservation scheme underlying resumption – Direct relationship between conservation scheme and zoning of land – Whether zoning a step in the resumption process – Characteristics or attributes of land – Effect of zoning on land value – Acquisition of Land Act 1967, Nature Conservation Act 1992.
Resumption – Determination of compensation – Pointe Gourde and San Sebastian principles – Issuing of Interim Conservation Orders (ICOs) – Whether a step in the resumption process – Effect of ICOs on value – Nature Conservation Act 1992.
Valuation – Highest and best use – Development standards for differing uses – Risks associated with realizing highest and best use – Added value of clearing for differing highest and best uses – Consideration of expert advice available to prudent purchaser.
Resumption – Determination of compensation – Special value – None present – Premium classed as severance damage – Original allowance not disturbed.
Resumption – Determination of compensation – Costs in purchase of replacement land – Disallowed – Catered for in severance premium – “double dipping”.
Resumption – Determination of compensation – Professional fees incurred in preparation of claim for compensation – Cut off date – Claimant may serve sequential claims – Date of last claim is cut off date.
Resumption – Determination of compensation – Professional fees incurred in association with making originating…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v Pajares and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] QLAC 59
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the effect of the conservation scheme and zoning on the land's value. It determined that the zoning was a step in the resumption process and thus could be considered in assessing compensation. The court also found that the issuing of Interim Conservation Orders did not constitute a step in the resumption process but did impact the land's value. Regarding severance damages, the court found that no special value was present in the land and classified the premium as severance damage. The court disallowed costs incurred in the purchase of replacement land and professional fees related to the making of the originating application, considering them as costs of the action.
The court concluded that the appeal by the State was allowed to the extent that it reduced the quantum of the Land Court's determination, while the claimant's appeal was disallowed. The court set the compensation amount at $3,419,689 and ordered interest to be paid on various amounts at specified rates from certain dates until final payment. Additionally, the respondent was ordered to pay interest on the amount of $1,589,689 from 26 August 2000 up to the day immediately preceding the date upon which final payment of compensation is made.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. To the extent that the State has been successful in having the quantum of the Land Court's determination reduced, and the claimant has been unsuccessful in having it increased, the appeal by the State is allowed and the appeal by the claimant disallowed.
2. Compensation is determined in the amount of $3,419,689 (Three Million Four Hundred and Nineteen Thousand, Six Hundred and Eighty-nine Dollars).
3. The respondent pay interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum on the amount of $3,393,689 from the date of resumption, 19 November 1999, until 13 April 2000, when an advance of $1,830,000 was paid; and on the amount of $1,563,689 from 14 April 2000, until 25 August 2000 (which the parties agreed is the appropriate date that the legal and valuation fees were paid) and then on the amount of $1,589,689 from 26 August 2000 up to the day immediately preceding the date upon which final payment of compensation is made.