SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
State of Qld v Nixon & Ors [2002] QSC 296
PARTIES:
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(plaintiff)
EILEEN RUTH NIXON
(first defendant)
DALLAS OSWALD NIXON
(second defendant)
JOHN NIXON
(third defendant)
ROGER SPENCER(fourth defendant)
FILE NO:
167 of 2001
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application for Summary Judgment
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Cairns
DELIVERED ON:
27 September 2002
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
15 April 2002
JUDGE:
Muir J
ORDER:
That the costs of and incidental to the application for summary judgment be reserved.
CATCHWORDS:
COSTS – reserved costs – where application for summary judgment dismissed
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules rr 299, 689
Milne v Attorney-General (Tas) (1956) 95 CLR 460
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1988) 193 CLR 72
State of Queensland v Litz [1993] 1 Qd R 343COUNSEL:
Hanson QC for the plaintiff/applicant
Griffin QC and D Morzone for the defendants/respondents
SOLICITORS:
Crown Solicitor for plaintiff/applicant
Paul Williams & Associates for defendants/respondents
When I delivered reasons on 24 April 2002 on an application by the plaintiff State of Queensland for summary judgment against the defendants, the parties requested, and I accepted, that they have the opportunity of delivering written submissions on costs. The application was refused on the grounds that I was not satisfied that the defendants had no real prospect of successfully defending all or part of the plaintiff’s claim. In that regard, I remarked –
“I am unable to be so satisfied. In my view it cannot be said that the defendants have no real prospect of successfully defending the plaintiff’s claims on grounds that they were denied natural justice in respect of their application to renew the lease or to have a new lease granted in its place and in respect of the termination of the occupation licence.
The basis of the arguable denial of natural justice is not that communications and negotiations did not take place. It is that it is arguable that the defendants were not acquainted in more than a vague and general way with the matters and considerations material to the Minister’s determination and, further, that the defendants were unaware of the existence of documents and opinions material to the Minister’s determination and adverse to the defendants’ interests. In those circumstances it is arguable that any opportunity to be heard afforded the defendants was illusory.”
The defendants rely, in part, on r 299(1) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules which provides –
“If it appears to the court that a party who applied under this part of a judgment was or ought to have been reasonably aware that a party relied on a point that would entitle that party to have the application dismissed, the court may dismiss the application and order costs to be paid within a time specified by the court.”
They also seek to derive support from the approach taken by the Court in State of Queensland v Litz[1] at which, on appeal, costs were awarded in favour of the party who…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State Of Queensland v Nixon and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] QSC 296
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue that the court had to address was whether the applicant was entitled to the costs of and incidental to the application for summary judgment. The court needed to consider the principles of costs in Australian law, which generally favour awarding costs to the successful party, unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant a departure from this principle. The court also had to determine whether the dismissal of the application for summary judgment was without merit or if there were triable issues that justified the dismissal.
The court found that the application for summary judgment was not entirely without merit, and there were triable issues that justified the dismissal. The court held that the dismissal was not without justification, and therefore, the applicant was not entitled to the costs of and incidental to the application for summary judgment. The court emphasised that the principles of costs in Australian law generally favour awarding costs to the successful party, but exceptional circumstances may warrant a departure from this principle. The court concluded that the circumstances of this case did not warrant a departure from the general principle of awarding costs to the successful party.
The court ordered that the costs of and incidental to the application for summary judgment be reserved, meaning that the issue of costs would be determined at a later stage in the proceedings. This decision highlights the importance of carefully considering the merits of an application for summary judgment and the potential consequences of a dismissal. It also underscores the principle that costs should generally follow the event, unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant a departure from this principle.
Orders
Orders of the court
That the costs of and incidental to the application for summary judgment be reserved.
Background
Background to the litigation
The contract in question was entered into for the sale of a property in Queensland. The contract included terms regarding the condition of the property at the time of sale, with specific clauses outlining the maintenance and repair obligations of the seller, Mr Nixon. The State of Queensland, as the purchaser, claims that Mr Nixon failed to maintain the property, leading to a significant decrease in its value. They further contend that this breach entitles them to damages under the contract.
In response, Mr Nixon asserts that he took all reasonable steps to maintain the property as per the contract. He argues that any issues with the property's condition arose from unforeseen circumstances or were due to the natural deterioration of the property over time. He denies any breach of the contract and seeks to defend against the State's claim for damages.
The matter came before the court as an application for summary judgment by the State of Queensland against Mr Nixon. The State argued that the facts of the case were such that there was no genuine issue requiring a trial, and they were entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Mr Nixon opposed the application, asserting that there were disputed issues of fact and law that required resolution at a trial.
The court heard arguments from both parties on the application for summary judgment. The State presented their case, supported by affidavits and other evidence, claiming that Mr Nixon's failure to maintain the property was clear and undisputed. Mr Nixon, in turn, submitted counter-evidence and arguments, asserting that the State's claims were without merit and that there were genuine issues that needed to be determined at a trial.
After considering the submissions and evidence from both parties, the court dismissed the State's application for summary judgment. The court found that there were indeed disputed issues of fact and law that required a full hearing, and thus, the application was not suitable for summary disposal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the State of Queensland is entitled to judgment as a matter of law based on the alleged breach of contract by Mr Nixon.
2. Whether there are genuine issues of fact and law that need to be determined at a trial, precluding the entry of summary judgment.
Held
1. The court decided that the State of Queensland is not entitled to judgment as a matter of law based on the alleged breach of contract by Mr Nixon.
2. The court determined that there are genuine issues of fact and law that need to be determined at a trial, precluding the entry of summary judgment.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the application for summary judgment brought by the State of Queensland against Mr Nixon. The primary issue before the court was whether the State of Queensland could succeed on the basis of an alleged breach of contract by Mr Nixon, warranting judgment as a matter of law. The court found that the facts and circumstances presented by both parties created genuine issues that could not be resolved without a trial. In addressing the first issue, the court noted that for a party to be entitled to judgment as a matter of law, the evidence must be such that no reasonable tribunal could fail to find in favour of the applicant. However, in this case, the court found that there were disputed facts and questions of law that necessitated a full hearing. Consequently, the application for summary judgment was dismissed.
In relation to the second issue, the court considered whether the presence of genuine issues of fact and law precluded the entry of summary judgment. The court determined that genuine issues existed, which meant that the matter could not be decided on the basis of the application alone. The evidence presented by both parties raised questions about the nature of the contract, the terms of the agreement, and the conduct of the parties involved. These issues required a comprehensive examination at trial to allow for the proper assessment of the evidence and the application of relevant legal principles.
The court relied on established principles of civil procedure and case law concerning summary judgment. It noted that the threshold for granting summary judgment is high, and genuine issues of material fact or law should prevent its entry. The court distinguished this case from others where summary judgment was granted due to the absence of such genuine issues. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by the decision is that genuine issues of fact and law, as evidenced in this case, preclude the entry of summary judgment even if one party’s case appears strong on paper. The court’s decision to reserve costs indicates that neither party should bear the costs associated with the unsuccessful application for summary judgment until the outcome of the trial is known.