SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
State of Queensland v James Thomas O’Brien & Anor [2015] QSC 136
PARTIES:
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(applicant)
v
JAMES THOMAS O’BRIEN
(first respondent)MICHAEL PAUL FALZON
(second respondent)FILE NO/S:
SC No 3879 of 2004
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Mackay
DELIVERED ON:
18 May 2015
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
3 October 2014
JUDGES:
Chief Justice
ORDERS:
The orders of the Court are that:
Pursuant to s 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld), the first respondent and second respondent must each pay to the State of Queensland the sum of $14,051,238.56, being the apportioned value of the proceeds derived from illegal activity. 1.
The second respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application for a proceeds assessment order on the standard basis.2.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY OF STATEMENT OF CO-CONSPIRATOR IN A JOINT CRIMINAL ENTERPRISE – where the first respondent was convicted of unlawfully trafficking in the drugs methylamphetamine and cannabis sativa – where the second respondent was convicted of one count of unlawfully trafficking in the dangerous drug methylamphetamine, and two counts of unlawfully producing methylamphetamine – where an application was made by the State of Queensland for a proceeds assessment order under s 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld) – where the first respondent made certain statements to the police incriminating the second respondent – whether the statements of the first respondent were admissible against the second respondent in confiscation proceedings.
CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – RELIABILITY, CREDIBILITY AND PROBATIVE VALUE OF INCONSISTENT WITNESS STATEMENTS - where the first respondent was convicted of unlawfully trafficking in the drugs methylamphetamine and cannabis sativa – where the second respondent was convicted of one count of unlawfully trafficking in the dangerous drug methylamphetamine, and two counts of unlawfully producing methylamphetamine – where an application was made by the State of Queensland for a proceeds assessment order under s 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld) – where the State of Queensland relied on certain witness statements to establish the existence and duration of the joint criminal enterprise – where there were certain inconsistencies and embellishments in the witness statements – where the chronology, sequence and particulars of their accounts in respect of certain peripheral matters developed over time – whether the witness statements were reliable and credible.
CRIMINAL LAW – PROCEDURE – CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME AND RELATED MATTERS – ASSESSMENT OF BENEFIT - where the first respondent was convicted of unlawfully trafficking in the drugs methylamphetamine and cannabis sativa – where the second respondent was convicted of one count of unlawfully trafficking in the dangerous drug methylamphetamine, and two counts of unlawfully producing methylamphetamine – where an application was made by the State of Queensland for a proceeds assessment order under s 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld) – where hypophosphorous acid was utilised as a precursor to the production…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of Queensland v James Thomas O'Brien and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] QSC 136
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether statements made by one respondent to the police were admissible against the other in the confiscation proceedings. It also needed to assess the reliability and credibility of witness statements, which contained inconsistencies and embellishments, to establish the existence and duration of the joint criminal enterprise. Additionally, the court considered whether the quantity of a chemical precursor used in the production of methylamphetamine could be used to inferentially establish the proceeds derived from the illegal activity. Finally, the court had to decide if the assessed value of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity could be apportioned equally between the respondents, who were co-principals in the joint criminal enterprise.
In its decision, the court found that the statements made by one respondent were admissible against the other in the confiscation proceedings. The court also concluded that despite some inconsistencies, the witness statements were reliable and credible in establishing the joint criminal enterprise. Regarding the chemical precursor, the court accepted that its quantity could be used to inferentially establish the proceeds derived from the illegal activity. Finally, the court determined that the assessed value of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity could be apportioned equally between the respondents. The court ordered that each respondent must pay to the State of Queensland a specified sum, representing the apportioned value of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity. Additionally, the second respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to the application for a proceeds assessment order on the standard basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
The orders of the Court are that:
Pursuant to s 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld), the first respondent and second respondent must each pay to the State of Queensland the sum of $14,051,238.56, being the apportioned value of the proceeds derived from illegal activity. 1.
The second respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application for a proceeds assessment order on the standard basis.2.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as an application for a proceeds assessment order under section 78 of the Criminal Proceeds Confiscation Act 2002 (Qld). The application was made by the State of Queensland following the convictions of the first and second respondents for various drug-related offences. The court heard submissions and evidence from both parties, including the statements made by the first respondent and the witness statements relied upon by the State of Queensland. The court was required to determine the admissibility, reliability, credibility, and probative value of the evidence presented, as well as the benefit and apportionment of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the statements of the first respondent were admissible against the second respondent in the confiscation proceedings.
2. Whether the witness statements were reliable and credible, despite certain inconsistencies and embellishments.
3. Whether the quantity of hypophosphorous acid acquired could be precisely quantified to inferentially establish the proceeds derived from the illegal activity.
4. Whether the assessed value of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity could be apportioned equally between the first and second respondents.
Held
1. The statements of the first respondent were admissible against the second respondent in the confiscation proceedings.
2. The witness statements were reliable and credible, despite certain inconsistencies and embellishments.
3. The quantity of hypophosphorous acid acquired could be precisely quantified to inferentially establish the proceeds derived from the illegal activity.
4. The assessed value of the proceeds derived from the illegal activity could be apportioned equally between the first and second respondents.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the admissibility of the first respondent's statements against the second respondent, noting that the two were co-conspirators in a joint criminal enterprise. The court held that statements made by one conspirator during the course of the conspiracy could be admitted against the other, as they fell under the hearsay exception for statements made by co-conspirators. The court found that the statements were reliable and relevant to establishing the scope of the joint criminal enterprise and were therefore admissible.
Regarding the reliability and credibility of the witness statements, the court observed that despite certain inconsistencies and embellishments, the core narrative remained consistent. The court found that the inconsistencies did not undermine the overall reliability of the statements, as they primarily related to peripheral matters rather than the central facts of the criminal activity. The court relied on the principle that minor inconsistencies do not necessarily render a statement unreliable, provided the witness's overall credibility is not compromised.
The court then addressed the quantification of the hypophosphorous acid acquired, which was a precursor to the production of methylamphetamine. The court accepted that the precise quantity of the chemical precursor could be established, and therefore it could be used to inferentially determine the proceeds derived from the illegal activity. This approach was supported by the fact that the quantity of the precursor was directly linked to the amount of drugs produced and sold.
Lastly, the court considered whether the proceeds derived from the illegal activity could be apportioned equally between the first and second respondents. Given that both were co-principals in the joint criminal enterprise, the court found it appropriate to divide the assessed value of the proceeds equally between them. The court relied on the principle that in cases of joint criminal enterprises, the proceeds should be shared equally among the co-conspirators unless there is evidence to suggest otherwise.