State of New South Wales v Carr

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: State of New South Wales v Carr [2020] NSWSC 643
Hearing dates: 26 May 2020
Date of orders: 26 May 2020
Decision date: 26 May 2020
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Hamill J
Decision:

Pursuant to s 13(1) of the Crimes (High Risk Offenders) Act 2006 (NSW) the extended supervision order made by Hall J on 14 August 2009 is revoked.

Catchwords: CIVIL LAW – high risk offender – revocation of extended supervision order – 5 year order still in force after 11 years – Aboriginal offender – proud Wiradjuri man – mild intellectual disability – no serious offence in 19 years – where repeated minor breaches result in incarceration – smoking cannabis – breaching curfew – multiple gaol sentences imposed – punitive impact of ESO – protective purpose not served – counterproductive to rehabilitative purpose – failure toppling successes – Steinbeck – change of circumstances – ESO no longer necessary – order revoked
Legislation Cited: Crimes (High Risk Offenders) Act 2006 (NSW), ss 10,13
Crimes (Serious Sex Offenders) Act 2006 (NSW)
Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), s 20
Cases Cited: R v Wilhem [2010] NSWSC 378
State of New South Wales v Bugmy [2017] NSWSC 855
State of New South Wales v Carr [2014] NSWSC 1348
Texts Cited: John Steinbeck, The Grapes of Wrath (William Heinemann Ltd, 1939) chp 25
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: State of New South Wales (Plaintiff)
Darryl Edward Carr (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
D New (Plaintiff)

  Solicitors:
Crown Solicitors Office (Plaintiff)   
R McMillan, Legal Aid Commission (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2009/294569
Publication restriction: Nil

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT (REVISED)

  1. HAMILL J: Darryl Carr is a proud Wiradjuri man. He has ambitions to be an artist, and has strong cultural ties to his community. He has a mild intellectual disability. Mr Carr has spent the vast majority of his adult life in prison. Most of the time he has been locked up is not referrable to any heinous crime he has committed, but has been because he failed to comply with the strictures of an extended supervision order (“ESO”) imposed under the Crimes (High Risk Offenders) Act2006 (NSW) or its predecessor. Some of these breaches involve using illegal drugs, others involve breaches of curfews, schedules of movements and accommodation conditions. These were described by the author of a risk assessment report as “technical” breaches. None involve the commission of violent or sexual offences.

  2. In 2014, when I was asked to make some variations to the conditions of the pre-existing ESO, I suggested that the operation of the ESO in Mr Carr's case had been punitive. [1] By way of one singular example, Mr Carr had been locked up for smoking cannabis, not because anybody charged him with such an offence; such offences are almost never prosecuted,[2] but because his use of drugs, disclosed by compulsory testing, constituted a breach of one of the scores of conditions of his ESO. On other occasions, he has been sentenced to prison…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State of New South Wales v Carr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWSC 643
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of State of New South Wales v Carr, the plaintiff, the State of New South Wales, sought to revoke an extended supervision order (ESO) that had been in place for over 11 years. The defendant, Carr, an Aboriginal man with a mild intellectual disability, had committed no serious offence during this period. The dispute centred on whether the ESO, which was imposed following a 2002 crime, should be revoked due to the changing circumstances of the offender and the punitive impact of the order. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The court was tasked with determining whether the ESO was still necessary given the defendant's lack of serious offending and the punitive consequences of the order. The primary issues involved the purpose of the ESO, whether it served a protective function or had become counterproductive, and whether there had been a change in circumstances warranting revocation. The court considered the defendant's proud Wiradjuri heritage and his overall conduct over the 19 years since the imposition of the ESO.

The court concluded that the ESO had become punitive rather than protective, and had failed to serve its rehabilitative purpose. The repeated minor breaches, such as smoking cannabis and breaching curfew, did not justify the continued incarceration of the defendant. The court found that the successes of the defendant outweighed the failures, and that the ESO was no longer necessary to protect the community. The change in circumstances, including the defendant's conduct and the passage of time, led the court to revoke the ESO, noting that the order had not achieved its intended purpose and had become counterproductive.

The final orders of the court included the revocation of the extended supervision order that had been in place for over 11 years. The court acknowledged the defendant's achievements and the change in circumstances, emphasising that the protective and rehabilitative purposes of the ESO had not been met. The decision highlighted the importance of considering the individual circumstances of the offender and the impact of the order on their rehabilitation and reintegration into society.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established