State Gas Limited v Dome Petroleum Resources Plc

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

State Gas Limited v Dome Petroleum Resources PLC [2019] QCA 307

PARTIES:

STATE GAS LIMITED
ACN 617 322 488
(respondent/applicant)
v
DOME PETROLEUM RESOURCES PLC
ARBN 126 449 527
(appellant/respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 10328 of 2019
SC No 1269 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application to Strike Out

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2019] QSC 231 (Bowskill J)

DELIVERED ON:

Date of Orders: 27 November 2019
Date of Publication of Reasons: 20 December 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 November 2019

JUDGES:

Philippides JA

ORDERS:

Date of Orders: 27 November 2019

1.   The appeal proceeding CA 10328/19 be struck out.

2.   The applications filed by the appellant in proceeding CA 10328/19 are dismissed.

3.    The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal and of each of the interlocutory applications filed in proceeding CA 10328/19 on an indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – OTHER MATTERS – STRIKE OUT – where the applicant (the respondent to the appeal) applied to have the appeal proceedings struck out on the basis that there was no arguable error on the part of the primary judge, and that to require the applicant to meet the appeal would be oppressive – where the applicant and the respondent (the appellant in the appeal) entered into a Joint Operating Agreement to explore for, develop, produce and dispose of petroleum in an area covered by a petroleum lease – where the respondent’s Participating Interest in the joint venture fell below 20 per cent and became mandatorily purchasable by the applicant under the Joint Operating Agreement – where the applicant sought to enforce the purchase of the respondent’s remaining Participating Interest – where, at trial, the primary judge declared, inter alia, that the Joint Operating Agreement was valid and enforceable and that the applicant purchased the respondent’s Participating Interest under it – where the primary judge ordered that the respondent specifically perform the Joint Operating Agreement to effect a transfer to the applicant of its Participating Interest – where the respondent appealed that decision – whether the appeal proceedings should be struck out

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 16(e)

COUNSEL:

G A Thompson QC, with J Hughes, for the respondent/applicant
No appearance for the appellant/respondent

SOLICITORS:

Allens for the respondent/applicant
No appearance for the appellant/respondent

  1. PHILIPPIDES JA:  The present applications arise in relation to an appeal against orders made by Bowskill J on the hearing of a proceeding seeking declarations and other orders for specific performance.  The proceeding concerned an agreement entitled “Petroleum Joint Operating Agreement” and dated 13 February 2017 (the JOA) made between State Gas Limited (State Gas), the plaintiff in the proceeding, and Dome Petroleum Resources Plc (Dome) the defendant.

  2. Bowskill J made orders on 16 September 2019, after a hearing in default of appearance by Dome:

    1.   declaring that:

    (a)the JOA made between State Gas and Dome was valid and enforceable;

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read State Gas Limited v Dome Petroleum Resources Plc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCA 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in State Gas Limited v Dome Petroleum Resources Plc involved the enforcement of a Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) between the parties to explore, develop, produce, and dispose of petroleum. The agreement included a provision that if Dome's Participating Interest fell below 20%, it would be mandatorily purchasable by State Gas. State Gas sought to enforce the purchase, and at trial, the primary judge declared the JOA valid and enforceable, ordering Dome to specifically perform the agreement by transferring its interest to State Gas. Dome appealed this decision, leading to the current proceedings.

The legal issues before the court were whether the appeal proceedings should be struck out on the grounds that there was no arguable error on the part of the primary judge, and that requiring Dome to meet the appeal would be oppressive. Additionally, the court considered whether the evidence adduced at trial was sufficient and whether Dome's decision to not appear at the trial affected the outcome. The court had to determine if the appeal had any prospects of success and whether the costs associated with the appeal should be paid by Dome.

The court found that the appeal had no arguable error and no prospects of success. The primary judge's decision was based on the evidence admitted at the trial, and Dome's decision not to appear did not compel the court to conduct its own investigations. The court also determined that the evidence of Italian legal opinion submitted by Dome was irrelevant and inadmissible as it pertained to issues not raised in the trial. Given these findings, the court concluded that the appeal should be struck out, and the costs of the appeal and interlocutory applications should be paid by Dome on an indemnity basis.

In light of these findings, the court issued orders striking out the appeal proceeding, dismissing the interlocutory applications filed by Dome, and requiring Dome to pay the costs of the appeal and the interlocutory applications on an indemnity basis. These orders reflect the court's determination that the appeal lacked merit and was oppressive to State Gas.

Orders

Orders of the court

Date of Orders: 27 November 2019

1. The appeal proceeding CA 10328/19 be struck out.

2. The applications filed by the appellant in proceeding CA 10328/19 are dismissed.

3. The appellant is to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal and of each of the interlocutory applications filed in proceeding CA 10328/19 on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The notice of appeal on this ground proceeds upon a misconception. As was made clear to Dome in the email from Bowskill J’s associate of 13 September 2019, the trial procedure in the proceeding before her Honour was not inquisitorial but adversarial and to be determined on the evidence admitted at trial. The deliberate decision by Dome not to appear at the trial did not oblige the Court to undertake its own investigations.Dome’s cross-application to adduce further evidence pursuant to r 766 of the UCPR Dome filed an application seeking to adduce further evidence of an opinion from Italian lawyers. The supporting affidavit of Mr Fucilla stated that, during September 2019, Dome was “urgently seeking to obtain legal advice on both criminal and civil law aspects of the matter”, with a firm of lawyers identified on 30 September 2019 and a legal opinion being provided on 13 October 2019 from Italian lawyers and a translation being requested the following day. The translated opinion concluded, it was said, that the conduct of State Gas reflected in the emails of 24 to 26 November 2018 amounted to offences of fraud under the Italian Criminal Code, “as well as under international law.” It was also stated by Mr Fucilla that the opinion provided was that under Italian Civil Law where a party’s motive for entering into a contract to the detriment of the other party is illegal under Italian criminal law “the contract falls to be cancelled.” It is not clear that Mr Fucilla’s statements reflect the translated brief opinion exhibited to his affidavit. State Gas argued that, by this application, Dome attempted to introduce assertions of fraud according to an Italian expert in circumstances where they were irrelevant and inadmissible. It is clear from the affidavit of Mr Fucilla, that Dome was well aware of the constraints following the directions made by the court as to the adducing of evidence. Mr Fucilla’s affidavit makes it evident that Dome was already alive to the issue of misleading or deceptive conduct, but chose not to pursue it “to afford [State Gas] every opportunity” up to the hearing by the trial judge “to remedy any such irregularities by withdrawing its claim”. Far from it being “inappropriate” for Dome to have commissioned legal opinion before the hearing, as claimed by Mr Fucilla, it was imperative that Dome made every endeavour to obtain all relevant evidence in accordance with the directions made as to the adducing of evidence, and that any difficulty was raised promptly before the hearing. A late application to adduce opinion evidence as to Italian law would not have been likely to have been granted in the circumstances, particularly where that would have raised the need to amend the pleadings and would not have affected the outcome of the trial judge’s decision.Costs Dome should be required to pay the costs of the appeal and of each of the interlocutory applications filed in the appeal on the indemnity basis because the appeal had no prospects of success. In addition, as observed by the primary judge, and set out above, cl 15.3(c) of the JOA provides that “A defaulting Participant must pay or reimburse all reasonable costs and expenses (including legal costs and expenses on a full indemnity basis) incurred by the Operator”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

What follows are my reasons for making those orders.Decision at first instance At a pre-trial hearing conducted by Bowskill J on 3 September 2019, at which Mr Owen appeared by telephone for Dome, her Honour declined to deal with any application by Dome for summary dismissal of State Gas’ claim. Her Honour also refused leave for Dome to call new evidence contrary to previous directions. On 13 September 2019, Mr Owen, on behalf of Dome, sent an email to her Honour’s associate which referred to the events on 3 September 2019 and stated inter alia:[1]“In the light of all these factors, and of their complete confidence in the strength of the defendant’s position, the Directors of the defendant have asked me to advise you and her Honour that they have reluctantly concluded that no purpose would now be served by the defendant attending the trial of this matter, and that it no longer intends to do so.In the circumstances, the defendant relies on her Honour to take fully into account in arriving at her Judgment the matters raised in the pleadings and affidavit evidence on behalf of the defendant and in its proposed opening statement, which the defendant believes are sufficiently persuasive on their own of the correctness of the defendant’s position even without the personal attendance of the Directors of the defendant at the trial. As her Honour is aware, the defendant places particular reliance on the terms of the email of 25 November 2018 at 1.31 p.m. from Ms Snelling of the plaintiff to others within the plaintiff, and on her email to Francesco Fucilla of the defendant on 26 November 2018. Copies of these emails are contained at pages 8 to 10 and 6 & 7 respectively of Exhibit WAF-2 to the affidavit of William Alexander Fucilla sworn on 24 June 2019.The Directors of the defendant have attempted until the latest possible time to comply with her Honour’s request that the defendant should obtain further legal representation. They much regret that their attempt to do so has ultimately been unsuccessful and that they have had to take their decision so shortly before the trial of this matter. The Directors have asked me to express their apologies to her Honour.”[1]Reasons at [12]. Her Honour’s associate responded on 13 September 2019 as follows:[2]“I have referred your email below to Justice Bowskill. She has asked me to respond to you in the following terms. First, to advise you that the trial procedure in this jurisdiction is an adversarial one, not an inquisitorial one. This means that the proceeding will be determined on the basis of evidence admitted at the trial, and the submissions made by each of the parties about the evidence. The fact that affidavits have been filed with the court, by either party, does not result in the content of those affidavits becoming evidence before the court on the trial, in the absence of the party appearing at the trial to tender the affidavit as evidence and, if requested, making the deponent of the affidavit available for cross-examination. You should also be aware that there are rules of court, which may be invoked by the opposing party, which enable judgment to be entered on a party’s claim (or counterclaim) where that party does not appear at the trial. Finally, her Honour has asked me to confirm that you were given leave, by order 6 of Jackson J made on 24 July 2019, to appear for the defendant company at the trial. You remain permitted to appear on behalf of the company, although are required to do so in person.”[2]Reasons at [13].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.