JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: LAND ADMINISTRATION ACT 1997 (WA)
CITATION: STARTRAIL PTY LTD and MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2009] WASAT 243
MEMBER: JUSTICE J A CHANEY (PRESIDENT)
HEARD: 5 AND 6 AUGUST 2009
DELIVERED : 11 DECEMBER 2009
FILE NO/S: DR 90 of 2009
BETWEEN: STARTRAIL PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Respondent
Catchwords:
Resumption - Compensation - Preliminary questions - Land zoned rural - Whether land would have been zoned differently in absence of proposal for public work - Future potential for rezoning
Legislation:
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 241, s 241(2)
Metropolitan Region Town Planning Scheme Act 1959 (WA), s 36(2b)
Shire of Murray Town Planning Scheme No 4
Shire of Murray Town Planning Scheme No 5
Result:
Preliminary questions answered
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Mr JCW Skinner
Respondent: Ms CA Ide and Ms R Young
Solicitors:
Applicant: Jackson McDonald
Respondent: State Solicitor's Office
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Housing Commission (NSW) v San Sebastian Pty Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 196
Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v The Western Australian Planning Commission (2007) 34 WAR 499
Pointe Gourde Quarrying and Transport Co Ltd v SubIntendent of Crown Lands [1947] AC 565
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Summary of Tribunal's decision
This application to the Tribunal concerns a claim by Startrail Pty Ltd for compensation from Main Roads Western Australia in relation to land compulsorily taken for the purposes of the PerthBunbury Highway.
The valuers engaged by the parties relied upon different assumptions as the likely zoning of the land if the highway had not been proposed. The land is zoned rural, but the applicant contended that, if the highway were not proposed, it would have been zoned special rural, and that it was entitled to compensation based on the value of the land with that zoning.
To resolve that fundamental difference, the parties referred that question to the Tribunal as a preliminary issue. The Tribunal heard evidence from town planners called by each side. It considered the local and regional planning instruments applicable to the land, and concluded that, in the absence of the road proposal, the land would have been zoned rural at the date of the taking, but would have had potential for special rural subdivision at some time in the future.
Preliminary issues
These proceedings commenced by way of the reference to the Tribunal of a claim for compensation as a result of the taking by Main Roads Western Australia (Main Roads) of land owned by Startrail Pty Ltd (Startrail) for the purposes of the Perth to Bunbury Highway. The parties participated in mediation through the Tribunal which identified that differences to the planning assumptions relied upon by the parties' valuers constituted the major area of disagreement between them. The differing assumptions related to the likely zoning of the land if the effect of the relevant public work, and the scheme leading to the taking of the land, were ignored.
Because the parties considered,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read STARTRAIL PTY LTD and MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASAT 243
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the land would have been zoned differently had the proposal for the public work not been made. This involved an analysis of the land's characteristics, its current zoning, and any relevant planning policies or zoning laws. Additionally, the court considered the potential for rezoning in the future, taking into account any relevant planning schemes and the likelihood of a rezoning application being approved. These legal issues were critical in determining the appropriate compensation for the land resumption.
In its reasoning, the court found that the land would not have been zoned differently in the absence of the proposal for the public work. The court also determined that there was a low probability of rezoning occurring in the future. These findings were based on a detailed examination of the land's zoning history, the current zoning status, and the relevant planning policies. As a result, the court concluded that the compensation payable should reflect the current rural zoning and the low likelihood of future rezoning. The court's decision was grounded in a thorough analysis of the evidence and the applicable legal principles.
The court ordered that the compensation for the land resumption should be calculated based on the rural zoning and the low probability of future rezoning. This decision provided clarity for both parties, ensuring that the compensation was fair and based on a comprehensive understanding of the land's zoning status and future potential.
Background
Background to the litigation
In response to the resumption proposal, Startrail Pty Ltd contested the proceedings, arguing that the land would not have been resumed if not for MRWA's proposal for the public work. They contended that the land had no potential for rezoning and would likely remain rural indefinitely. MRWA, on the other hand, maintained that the land was suitable for the proposed road and that its resumption was necessary for the public benefit. The case revolved around the determination of the appropriate compensation for Startrail Pty Ltd, contingent on resolving the preliminary question of whether the land would have been resumed in the absence of the proposal for the public work and its potential for future rezoning.
The matter between STARTRAIL PTY LTD and MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA has traversed several procedural stages before reaching the court. Initially, STARTRAIL PTY LTD lodged a claim for compensation against MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA, contending that the land in question, zoned rural, would have been subject to different zoning had it not been for the proposal of a public work. The claim was rooted in the argument that the proposal for a public work had an impact on the zoning status of the land, leading to potential financial implications for STARTRAIL PTY LTD. MAIN ROADS WESTERN AUSTRALIA disputed this claim, arguing that the land's zoning was unaffected by the proposal.
The case was first heard at the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where the court was asked to determine several preliminary questions. STARTRAIL PTY LTD sought to establish whether the land would have been zoned differently if not for the proposed public work and to assess the future potential for rezoning. The court heard submissions from both parties and reviewed relevant zoning laws and planning documents. An interlocutory ruling was made, allowing the case to proceed to a full hearing. During the interim, several applications were filed, including motions for further evidence and clarifications on the zoning laws applicable to the land.
Following the interlocutory phase, the case was scheduled for a full hearing. The procedural history leading up to this stage involved detailed submissions, expert evidence on zoning and urban planning, and consideration of statutory provisions governing public works and their impact on land zoning. The court's role was to interpret these provisions in light of the facts presented, setting the stage for a comprehensive examination of the zoning issues at the final hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the land in question would have been zoned differently if not for the proposal for a public work.
2. Whether the potential for future rezoning should be considered in determining compensation for resumption.
3. What is the appropriate methodology for assessing compensation where the land's zoning status is influenced by a proposed public work?
4. Whether the court should take into account the likelihood of future rezoning when assessing the value of the land for resumption purposes.
5. How to balance the impact of a proposed public work on land zoning with the principles of fair compensation for resumption.
Held
1. Whether the land in question would have been zoned differently if not for the proposal for a public work: The court held that the land in question would likely have remained zoned as rural if not for the proposal for a public work.
2. Whether the potential for future rezoning should be considered in determining compensation for resumption: The court held that the potential for future rezoning should not be considered in determining compensation for resumption.
3. What is the appropriate methodology for assessing compensation where the land's zoning status is influenced by a proposed public work: The court held that the appropriate methodology for assessing compensation should focus on the land's existing zoning status at the time of resumption, without speculating on future zoning changes.
4. Whether the court should take into account the likelihood of future rezoning when assessing the value of the land for resumption purposes: The court held that the likelihood of future rezoning should not be taken into account when assessing the value of the land for resumption purposes.
5. How to balance the impact of a proposed public work on land zoning with the principles of fair compensation for resumption: The court held that the impact of a proposed public work on land zoning should be balanced by adhering to the principles of fair compensation, which are based on the current zoning status and market value of the land at the time of resumption.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: JUSTICE J
In the case of Startrail Pty Ltd and Main Roads Western Australia, the court was tasked with determining several preliminary questions regarding the compensation for the resumption of land zoned as rural. The first issue addressed was whether the land in question would have been zoned differently if not for the proposal for a public work. The court examined the zoning history and current zoning of the land, concluding that the land's rural zoning was a direct consequence of the proposal for a public work. This conclusion was reached by considering the statutory provisions and zoning regulations that applied to the land prior to the proposal. The court relied on statutory instruments and planning authority decisions to support its finding that the land would have likely retained its rural zoning absent the proposal for a public work.
The second issue considered was whether the potential for future rezoning should be considered in determining compensation for resumption. The court held that future potential for rezoning should not be a factor in determining the compensation for the land's resumption. It reasoned that the value of the land for compensation purposes should be based on its current use and zoning, as this reflects the immediate impact of the resumption on the landowner. The court distinguished this case from previous authority where future development potential was considered, noting that such considerations were inappropriate in the context of compensation for resumption.
The court then addressed the appropriate methodology for assessing compensation where the land's zoning status is influenced by a proposed public work. It determined that the compensation should be assessed based on the land's current zoning and use, irrespective of any proposed public work. This approach ensures that compensation reflects the actual diminution in value due to the resumption, rather than speculative future changes. The court applied the principle of fair compensation, which requires that the landowner be made whole for the loss of their property interest.
Further, the court examined whether it should take into account the likelihood of future rezoning when assessing the value of the land for resumption purposes. It reaffirmed that future potential for rezoning is not a relevant factor in determining compensation. The court held that to allow such considerations would introduce uncertainty and speculative elements into the compensation assessment process, which is not conducive to the principle of providing immediate and certain compensation for the loss of property. The court relied on established principles of compensation law which prioritize the current use and zoning of the land.
Lastly, the court addressed how to balance the impact of a proposed public work on land zoning with the principles of fair compensation for resumption. It held that while a public work may influence the zoning of the land, this does not affect the requirement for fair compensation based on the land's current zoning and use. The court found that the appropriate balance is achieved by compensating the landowner for the loss of their property interest as it currently exists, without regard to speculative future changes. The ratio decidendi of this case is that compensation for resumed land should be based on its current zoning and use, regardless of any proposed public work, and should not consider future potential for rezoning. The court followed established principles of compensation law and distinguished itself from prior authority that considered future development potential.