Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation v Cadbury Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by The Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation to registration of trade mark application 998427(30) - STARLIGHT - filed in the name of Cadbury Limited.

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent:  Steven Burley of counsel, instructed by Dibbs Abbott Stillman, Lawyers of Sydney
Applicant:  Chris Sgourakis  of Griffith Hack, Patent and
Trade Mark Attorneys, of Melbourne
Decision: 2007 ATMO 72
S52 opposition:  section 60 – reputation established for identical and deceptively similar trade marks, likelihood of deception and confusion – application refused unless goods specification amended as directed.

Background

  1. Cadbury Limited (“the applicant”) filed an application to register a trade mark, current details of which are:

    Application Number:           998427
    Trade Mark:  STARLIGHT
    Filing date (priority date):   20 April 2004

    Goods:Class 30: Cocoa, cocoa products, drinking chocolate; beverages made from or containing chocolate; beverages made from or containing cocoa; preparations for making chocolate or cocoa-based drinks; malted food drinks, preparations for making malted beverages; chocolate, chocolates, non-medicated confectionery; biscuits, cakes, wafers; muffins; cake-mixes; muffin mixes; pastries; chewing gum; preparations made from cereals, cereal bars; snack foods; ice cream, frozen confectionery; food drinks

  2. The application was examined in the normal course of events, and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 19 August 2004. 

  3. On 10 November 2004, The Starlight Starbright Children’s Foundation[1] (“the opponent”) filed notice of opposition in the broadest possible terms allowable under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”).  The required service of evidence in support, in answer and in reply was completed by 5 September 2006 and on 3 October 2006 the opponent requested a hearing.  The matter came before me as a delegate of the Registrar in Sydney on 17 May 2007.  The applicant was represented by Chris Sgourakis of Griffith Hack, Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys of Melbourne.  The opponent was represented by Steven Burley of counsel, accompanied by Therese Burke of Dibbs Abbott Stillman, instructing lawyers of Sydney.

    [1] At the time of filing the notice, the opponent was known as The Starlight Children’s Foundation.  It has since merged with Starbright Foundation and the merged entity’s name has changed to that of the current opponent. 

    Preliminary matters

  4. At the hearing Mr Burley indicated that the opponent would only pursue grounds under sections 44 and 60 of the Act. For completeness, I find that opposition in respect of any other grounds within the notice has not been established.

  5. Mr Burley also submitted that the onus was on the opponent to establish grounds of opposition, but only to establish those grounds on the balance of probabilities.  He relied here on the decision of Gyles J in Pfizer Products Inc v Karam (2006) 70 IPR 599. That this is also the view of delegates of the Registrar (while still being a matter of debate in the lack of resolution in the Full Court of the Federal Court) was noted by Hearing Officer Williams in McDonald’s Corporation vFuture Enterprises Pte Ltd,

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation v Cadbury Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Hearing Officer Alison Windsor concerning an opposition filed by the Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation against an application by Cadbury Ltd to register a trade mark. The dispute centred on whether the applicant's proposed trade mark, in relation to its specified goods, was likely to cause confusion with the opponent's existing trade marks, given the nature of the opponent's charitable activities and fundraising methods. The opposition was brought under section 60 of the relevant legislation, which deals with the likelihood of deception or confusion.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was to determine whether the applicant's trade mark, if registered for the goods as specified, would be likely to deceive or cause confusion to the public, having regard to the opponent's use of its trade marks in its fundraising activities. The Hearing Officer also considered the effect of amendments to the legislation, ultimately concluding that the opposition should be assessed under the unamended form of section 60 as it stood at the commencement of the proceedings.

The Hearing Officer reasoned that the opponent's extensive charitable work, which involved soliciting funds through various means including cause-related marketing, meant that its trade marks were widely recognised in connection with its operations. The applicant's goods, while specified for manufacturing, were considered to be potentially similar to goods sold in general retail, and the broad nature of the goods claim in the application increased the likelihood of confusion. Consequently, the Hearing Officer found that the opponent had established its ground of opposition under section 60.

The Hearing Officer refused to register the trade mark in its current form. However, recognising that confusion would be unlikely if the goods specification were restricted to those for which the trade mark was actually used, the Hearing Officer provided an opportunity for the applicant to amend the specification to "chocolate and cocoa products sold in bulk for use in manufacturing". If such an amendment was requested within one month, the application could proceed to registration. No order as to costs was made, as both parties had achieved a measure of success.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation, an Australian-based organisation, was established with the primary objective of providing support and entertainment for chronically and seriously ill children in hospitals. The Foundation operates through various programs, including the Starlight Sites and Starlight Express Rooms, which are specially designed rooms within hospitals where children and their families can relax and engage in activities. In addition, the Foundation offers bedside entertainment through mobile entertainment units called Starlight Fun Centres, which include a computer monitor, a Nintendo GameCube, a personal computer, and a DVD player. The Foundation also provides PC Pals, which are mobile personal computers enabling children to interact with a computer and send e-mails. Hospital Happenings are parties held in hospitals, featuring visits from musicians, clowns, and other entertainers, as well as other special events. Outside hospitals, the Foundation offers family outings and "once-in-a-lifetime" wish experiences for sick children and their families. Furthermore, the Starlight Express Vans take the Starlight Express Room concept on the road to provide facilities to hospitals in regional and metropolitan areas that would otherwise miss out. The Foundation relies on individual and corporate donations, special events, cause-related marketing promotions, and in-kind support in the form of goods and services to fund its programs. The Foundation ensures that the maximum percentage of funds raised flows directly to the children by minimizing overheads and soliciting donations of time, goods, and services in everything it does.

Cadbury Ltd, a confectionery company, applied for the registration of a trade mark for use on chocolate and cocoa products sold in bulk for use in manufacturing. The Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation opposed the registration, claiming that the proposed trade mark was likely to cause confusion with its existing trade marks, which are used in connection with its programs and services for chronically and seriously ill children in hospitals. The Foundation argued that the proposed trade mark would likely deceive or cause confusion among the public, as consumers might associate the trade mark with its programs and services for sick children. The Foundation also claimed that the proposed trade mark was too broad and could be applied to goods that would be sold in general retail establishments, which would further increase the likelihood of confusion. The opposition proceedings were filed in 2004, and the case was heard by Hearing Officer Alison Windsor on 25 October 2007.

The matter of Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation v Cadbury Ltd originated as an application for the registration of a trade mark by Cadbury Ltd, which was opposed by Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation. The opposition was lodged under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), asserting that the proposed trade mark by Cadbury Ltd was likely to cause confusion or deception with the existing trade marks held by Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation. The case initially came before the Trade Marks Hearings division, presided over by Hearing Officer Alison Windsor. During the proceedings, Cadbury Ltd argued against the application of the amended Trade Marks Amendment Act 2006, a position that was previously considered and rejected by Hearing Officer Lyons in a similar case. Ultimately, Hearing Officer Windsor ruled that the opposition under section 60 was valid, leading to the refusal of the trade mark registration in its current form. However, she allowed for the possibility of the application proceeding if Cadbury Ltd amended the goods specification to limit the claim to "chocolate and cocoa products sold in bulk for use in manufacturing" within one month. The decision did not result in a costs order for either party due to the partial success achieved by both.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In respect of section 60, Mr Burley prefaced his submissions with a discussion of what he said was the amending effect of the Trade Marks Amendment Act 2006. He claimed that this opposition should proceed under the section as amended, rather than as it was at the time the opposition proceedings commenced. Indeed, Mr Burley had made similar submissions to Hearing Officer Lyons in the matter of Apple Computer Inc. v Todaytech Group Ltd[2], a few days before I heard the present matter. Mr Lyons has already dealt with that issue very thoroughly and I will simply adopt his analysis, without making any attempt to discuss further or summarise the issues. The result is that, since the present opposition was filed in 2004, section 60 operates in the present matter in its unamended form. [2] [2007] ATMO 40Evidence and submissions The declarations forming the evidence served and filed in this opposition are shown in the following table: The Weekes declaration goes to providing a picture of the use of the opponent’s trade marks in the pursuit of its business objectives, which I see as the gathering of funds in order to provide facilities and services for easing and improving the lives of chronically and seriously ill children. The opponent provides programs in hospitals for the benefit of children who are hospitalized for long periods of time. It provides rooms (Starlight Sites or Starlight Express Rooms) where children and their families can relax, play and interact with each other. It also provides bedside entertainment through mobile entertainment units (Starlight Fun Centres) consisting of a unit containing a computer monitor, a Nintendo GameCube™, a personal computer and DVD player . Similar to these are mobile personal computers called PC Pals which give children the opportunity to interact with a computer, including the ability to send e-mails. Also offered are Hospital Happenings, which are parties held in the hospital incorporating visits from, for example, musicians, clowns and entertainers, as well as other special events held in the hospitals. Outside the hospitals, the opponent offers family outings (known in Australia as the Starlight Escapes program) for the sick children and their families and also offers “once-in-a-lifetime” wish experiences. The Starlight Express Vans are mobile units which take the Starlight Express Room concept on the road to bring the facility to hospitals in regional and metropolitan areas which would otherwise miss out. The provision of all of these facilities requires funds. Paragraph 19 of the Weekes declaration states that Starlight Australia, which is the Australian division of the opponent, “does not receive any government funding and must rely on individuals, corporations, special events, cause related marketing promotions and in kind support in the form of both goods and services. Starlight Australia ensures that the maximum percentage of funds raised flows directly to the children by minimizing overheads and soliciting donations of time, goods and services in everything it does”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant has specified that its goods are designed for the manufacturing sector as ingredients for further processing. However, the goods claim in the present application is much broader than these specific goods. In addition, those specific goods could be seen as “similar to” or “of the same description” as the goods which will be sold in general retail establishments. Under these circumstances, I am satisfied the applicant’s trade mark, were it to be registered in its current form, would be likely to be confused with that of the opponent. The opponent has therefore established its ground of opposition under section 60.Decision The provisions of section 55 of the Act provide the following:(1) Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide: (a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or (b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application; having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established. The opponent has established a ground of opposition under section 60 of the Act. I therefore refuse to register application 998427 in its present form. However, I am satisfied that if the goods were restricted to those in respect of which the trade mark is actually used, deception or confusion would be unlikely to occur. Therefore if, within one month of the date of this decision, the applicant requests an amendment to the goods specification which restricts the goods claim to “chocolate and cocoa products sold in bulk for use in manufacturing” the application may proceed to registration. If the Registrar is notified of an appeal before that time, I direct that the disposition of the application be in accordance with any direction or order of the Court.Costs Both parties may be viewed as having a measure of success in these proceedings, and in all the circumstances, I make no order as to costs.Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings25 October 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Trade Marks Hearings Office's decision in Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation v Cadbury Ltd primarily centred around the applicability of the Trade Marks Amendment Act 2006 to the opposition proceedings. The court held that the opposition should proceed under the unamended form of section 60, as the opposition was filed in 2004 before the amendment came into effect. The court relied on the analysis provided by Hearing Officer Lyons in Apple Computer Inc. v Todaytech Group Ltd, and adopted his findings, thereby establishing the ratio that the Trade Marks Amendment Act 2006 does not apply retroactively to opposition proceedings filed before its enactment.

The court then turned to the issue of whether the goods specified in the applicant's trade mark application were likely to be confused with those of the opponent. The applicant's goods were broader than the specific goods they claimed to use, and could potentially be considered "similar to" or "of the same description" as the goods sold in general retail establishments. The opponent's trade mark was used in connection with various programs and services for chronically and seriously ill children, including hospital entertainment, mobile entertainment units, and family outings. Given the similarity in the nature of the goods and the services provided, the court found that the applicant's trade mark, if registered in its current form, would be likely to be confused with that of the opponent. This finding was based on the principles of likelihood of confusion and the protection of the opponent's established trade mark rights.

In light of the established ground of opposition under section 60, the court was required to decide whether the trade mark application should be refused registration under section 55 of the Act. The court held that the application should be refused registration in its present form, as the likelihood of confusion between the applicant's and the opponent's trade marks could not be eliminated. However, the court also considered the possibility of the applicant amending the goods specification to avoid confusion with the opponent's trade marks. The court found that if the applicant restricted the goods claim to "chocolate and cocoa products sold in bulk for use in manufacturing," deception or confusion would be unlikely to occur, and the application could proceed to registration.

In the event of an appeal being lodged before the applicant's opportunity to amend the goods specification expired, the court held that the disposition of the application should be in accordance with any direction or order of the Court. This decision was based on the principle of deference to the Court's authority in cases of appeal and the need to ensure that the outcome of the opposition proceedings was consistent with any subsequent determination by the Court.

In conclusion, the court's decision in Starlight Starbright Children's Foundation v Cadbury Ltd established several binding legal principles. Firstly, the Trade Marks Amendment Act 2006 does not apply retroactively to opposition proceedings filed before its enactment. Secondly, the likelihood of confusion between trade marks is assessed based on the similarity of the goods and services, as well as the nature of the trade marks themselves. Thirdly, if a ground of opposition under section 60 is established, the trade mark application should be refused registration in its current form. Lastly, the court may allow for the amendment of the goods specification to avoid confusion with an opponent's trade mark, and the disposition of the application in the event of an appeal should be in accordance with any direction or order of the Court.