Stanford v DePuy International Pty Ltd (No 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Stanford v DePuy International Pty Ltd (No 8) [2024] FCA 35  

File number: NSD 213 of 2011
Judgment of: WIGNEY J
Date of judgment: 1 February 2024 
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceeding – group member settlement scheme previously approved by Court – interlocutory application by administrator of settlement scheme – application seeking approval of payment of administrative costs – certain costs disputed by respondents – where administration costs time costed – whether costs relate to work properly undertaken – whether costs are fair and reasonable – whether any other reason to disallow or discount costs – administrative costs approved in full – costs of application not granted  
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Stanford v DePuy International Ltd (No 6) [2016] FCA 1452

Stanford v DePuy International Ltd (No 7) [2017] FCA 748

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 112
Date of hearing: 15 May 2023
Counsel for applicants: Ms Z Hillman
Solicitors for applicants: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for respondents: Mr R Dick SC with Mr J Entwisle
Solicitors for respondents: Barry Nilsson

ORDERS

NSD 213 of 2011
BETWEEN:

TAMMY STANFORD

First Applicant

JAMIE DUNSMORE

Second Applicant

MAURICE BLACKBURN PTY LTD AND SHINE LAWYERS PTY LIMITED (IN THEIR CAPACITY AS JOINT ADMINISTRATORS OF THE SETTLEMENT SCHEME)

Third Applicant

AND:

DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LTD

First Respondent

JOHNSON & JOHNSON MEDICAL PTY LTD

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

WIGNEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 FEBRUARY 2024

1.Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and, or alternatively, clause 14.1 of the settlement scheme, the administrator pay the following amounts in respect of administration costs that are payable in accordance with clauses 13.1 and 13.2 of the settlement scheme out of the settlement sum:

Clause 13.1 Clause 13.2 Disbursements Total
Maurice Blackburn $1,185,707.60 $110,450.00 $171,214.33 $1,467,371.93
Shine $91,224.20 $216,150.00 $89,505.00 $396,879.20
DBH $8,553.60 $15,950.00 $429.00 $24,932.60
Adelta $6,751.80 $38,720.00 $4,984.11 $50,455.91

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

WIGNEY J:

  1. On 29 June 2016, the Court approved the settlement of this representative proceeding.  The procedural history and terms of that settlement are set out in earlier judgments: see in particular Stanford v DePuy International Ltd (No 6) [2016] FCA 1452 (Stanford No 6).  The proceeding concerned allegedly defective medical devices, known generally as ASR implants, which were used in hip replacement or resurfacing surgery.  The proceeding was settled for a sum of $250 million (plus interest) on 31 March 2016.  The settlement sum was to be paid and applied pursuant to a settlement scheme managed by two joint administrators, Maurice Blackburn Pty Ltd and Shine Lawyers Pty Ltd (collectively the administrators).  Maurice Blackburn and Shine are law firms and had acted for the applicants in the substantive…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stanford v DePuy International Pty Ltd (No 8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stanford v DePuy International Pty Ltd (No 8) involved an interlocutory application by the administrator of a representative proceeding settlement scheme to seek approval for the payment of administrative costs. The primary dispute centred on whether the costs claimed by the administrators were fair, reasonable, and properly incurred under the terms of the settlement scheme. The court had to decide whether the administrative costs claimed were time costed, related to work properly undertaken, and whether there were any grounds to disallow or discount the costs.

The court found that the administrators had carried out the specified administrative work within the terms of the settlement scheme. While the administration costs had exceeded initial estimates, the court held that it was not appropriate to approach the matter with the benefit of hindsight. The court considered that the administrators had provided sufficient information to the court in support of their claims and that the fees charged were fair and reasonable. Consequently, the court approved the full payment of the administrative costs claimed.

In conclusion, the court granted the application for the payment of administrative costs but did not order the costs of the application to be paid. The court found that the respondents' submissions were beneficial and that it was reasonable for them to appear and make submissions, as it ensured there was a contradictor in the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns the approval and payment of administrative costs in the context of a settlement scheme for group members who suffered loss and injury due to ASR implants and their removal. The settlement scheme was approved by the Court, and the administrators periodically approached the Court for updates and approval of payment of administration costs, including general administration costs. As of March 2023, the settlement scheme was nearing its conclusion, with a total of $178.41 million paid to eligible group members and $8.38 million paid to third party lien holders. The administrators sought approval to pay additional administrative costs, which some respondents disputed.

The matter came before the court as an interlocutory application by the administrator of the settlement scheme seeking approval for the payment of administrative costs. This application followed previous proceedings where the settlement scheme had been approved, and the administrators had been granted permission to make periodic applications for the payment of administrative costs. The court was required to determine whether the claimed administrative costs were fair and reasonable, related to work properly undertaken, and if there were any reasons to disallow or discount the costs. The respondents were granted leave to make submissions despite not strictly having standing, as the court found it beneficial to have their input.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In any event, even if the respondents did not, strictly speaking, have standing to appear and oppose the application, I would in any event have granted leave to the respondents to make submissions. That is because there would otherwise have been no contradictor. It was also clear that the Court would be assisted by the respondents’ input in respect of the applications. As events transpired, the Court was assisted by the respondents’ submissions. Supporting evidence In support of its application in respect of the payment of general and administration costs, the administrator relied on two affidavits sworn by Mr Schimmel and an expert report authored by Mr Nicholas. Some reliance was also placed on the administrators’ report prepared by Mr Schimmel in respect of the relevant period. It is unnecessary to deal at length with Mr Schimmel’s evidence concerning the administrative costs. Much of it was responsive to actual or perceived criticisms levelled at him, or the administrators generally, by the respondents in their evidence and submissions. Those criticisms included that: the administration costs had exceeded Mr Atkins’ estimate; that the administrators had not provided an updated estimate of administration costs once it became apparent that the costs exceeded Mr Atkins’ estimate; and that the administrators had failed to provide full and frank information to the Court in support of its administration costs applications. Those criticisms are addressed in more detail later when addressing the question whether the administration costs claimed by the administrator should be paid. In short summary, Mr Schimmel’s evidence was that at the time of the settlement approval application it was not possible to reliably predict the cost of administering the scheme. He considered that the estimate concerning administration costs in Mr Atkin’s cash flow model was no more than, and was never intended to be anything more than, a “crude estimate” of the administration costs. He advised the Court as much in his affidavit which was filed in support of the June 2019 administration costs application. It was for this reason that he did not consider that it was necessary for him to, or that it would assist the Court for him to, “benchmark” the administration costs in fact incurred against Mr Atkins’ estimate. With the benefit of hindsight, and without in any way being critical of Mr Atkins, Mr Schimmel also contended that Mr Atkins’ estimate concerning administration costs was inaccurate and that Mr Atkins should have, but did not, take into account a range of matters that impacted the real cost of administering the scheme. Mr Schimmel took issue with the suggestion that the administrators had not provided sufficient information to the Court in respect of its administration costs applications and referred to the detailed information in the affidavits he had previously sworn in support of the administrators’ applications. He also pointed out that in his affidavit filed in support of the June 2019 costs application, he had estimated that general administration costs for the period April 2019 to March 2024 would be between $2.6 million and $2.9 million. Mr Schimmel’s current estimate is that the total general administration costs as of March 2024 are likely to exceed his June 2019 estimate by $826,500. His evidence was that those additional costs were mostly due to the costs associated with the “top up” payment process, which he had not anticipated in June 2019, as well as the costs of consolidating the administrators’ role.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The fact that those difficulties have been exposed at this late stage of the administration of the settlement scheme does not, however, justify the discounting of the general administrative costs claimed by the administrators. It is not appropriate to approach the current application with twenty-twenty hindsight. For the reasons already given, the administrators are entitled to recover the general administrative costs which are the subject of the current application. The administrators carried out the specified general administrative work within the terms of the settlement scheme and the fees that they have charged for that work were fair and reasonable. CONCLUSION AND DISPOSITION I am satisfied that it is appropriate in all the circumstances to order that the administrator pays the amounts identified in prayer four of the amended interlocutory application dated 12 May 2023, being amounts payable as administrative costs pursuant to clauses 13.1 and 13.2 of the settlement scheme. An order will be made to that effect. I do not propose to make any order in relation to the costs of this application. It was, in all the circumstances, reasonable and appropriate for the respondents to appear and make submissions in respect of the administrator’s application concerning the approval and payment of administrative costs. While the Court has ultimately accepted that it is appropriate to make the order sought by the administrators, the Court was assisted by the respondents’ submissions, particularly in circumstances where, but for their input, there would have been no contradictor. As for the administrator’s costs, it is likely that the administrator will file another, perhaps final, interlocutory application which includes a claim for administration costs. The question whether the costs in respect of this application are claimable as general administration costs pursuant to clause 13.1 of the settlement scheme may well need to be addressed in the context of that application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The administration costs claimed pursuant to clause 13.1 of the settlement scheme will be referred to in these reasons as general administration costs so as to avoid confusion with the costs claimed pursuant to clauses 13.2, 13.3 and 13.4. It should also be emphasised in this context, though it is to an extent stating the obvious, that the amount of the general administration costs paid to the administrators is a matter of some sensitivity and importance. That is because the more money that is paid to the administrators for administration costs, the less that is available to be paid to each of the eligible group members to compensate them for the loss and injury they suffered as a result of their ASR implants and their removal. Finally, it is important to note that clause 14.1 of the settlement scheme relevantly provides that where the administrators consider that “it is appropriate for the Court to give directions regarding an issue concerning the implementation or administration of this Settlement Scheme … the Administrators may approach the Court for directions and in doing so the Administrators are not obligated to notify any of the Group Members”. The current state of the settlement scheme Since settlement, the administrators have approached the Court periodically to provide an update or report on the management of the settlement scheme. The administrators have also periodically sought the Court’s approval in respect of the payment of administration costs, including general administration costs. It is unnecessary for present purposes to detail the reports that have been provided to the Court save as to briefly note the following points in respect of the state of the settlement scheme as of March 2023. The position in respect of administration costs will be dealt with separately. First, as previously noted, the scheme is nearing its conclusion. The effective cut-off date for new claims was 30 June 2023. Only a very small number of new registrations were expected. Second, the administrators have paid a total of $178.41 million to eligible group members out of the available settlement funds. The administrators have also paid $8.38 million to third party holders of liens. The credit balance of the administrator’s bank accounts was $15.45 million. Third, 1,633 eligible group members had received compensation payments. As of February 2023, there were only 14 group members whose claims were ongoing and who had not yet received any payment. Fourth, contrary to the concerns and fears that existed at the time the settlement was approved, the settlement sum will clearly be sufficient to meet all fast track and assessed claims by eligible group members. Indeed, in June 2021, the administrators sought and obtained actuarial advice which enabled them to make “top up” payments to eligible group members. Eligible group members have received 117.5 cents for every dollar of compensation they have been assessed as eligible to receive under the terms of the settlement scheme. Fast track group members have received $9,625 per revision over and above the $55,000 fast track payment. It is anticipated that a further top up payment will be able to be made in the near future.