Spoehr v Health Services Charitable Gifts Board

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

SPOEHR v HEALTH SERVICES CHARITABLE GIFTS BOARD

[2014] SASC 171

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

6 November 2014

SUCCESSION - MAKING OF A WILL - TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY - SOUNDNESS OF MIND, MEMORY AND UNDERSTANDING - EVIDENCE - ONUS OF PROOF AND WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE

This is an application for judgment by consent that the court pronounce against the force and validity of the alleged will of the deceased made in 2001 and, in lieu, grant letters of administration of the deceased’s estate to the plaintiff.  The sole surviving beneficiary under the deceased’s will was the Royal Adelaide Hospital Research Fund.  It was alleged that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of the making of the will.  There was evidence before the Court that the deceased suffered delusions, including delusions regarding the paternity of his children.  The parties agreed to settle the action on terms that the Royal Adelaide Hospital Research Fund would receive $200,000.00, the deceased’s granddaughter would receive $85,000.00 and the remainder would be divided equally between the deceased’s three children.  A further application was made for the approval of a compromise of a proposed family provision action on behalf of the granddaughter of the deceased. 

Whether the deceased lacked mental capacity at the time of the making of the will.  Whether the granddaughter’s interests are adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement. 

Held:

1.  Circumstances exist to excite suspicion that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of the execution of the will.  No party has come forward to tender any evidence or make any submission that the deceased did in fact have capacity at the relevant time.  In these circumstances, it is appropriate to make an order pronouncing against the validity of the will. 

2.  The granddaughter’s interests are adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement.

Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 2006 (SA) r 227 and r 257, referred to.
Re Muirhead [1971] 1 ALL ER 609; In the Estate of Edwards (1981) 28 SASR 380; Executor Trustee Australia Ltd v Henderson (2006) 244 LSJS 43; Re Grey Smith (deceased) [1978] VR 596; In the Will of Pearce (1945) 46 SR (NSW) 71; Boreham v Prince Henry Hospital (1955) 29 ALJ 179; Lewis v Gersace (Unreported, Supreme Court of South Australia, Peek J, 11 March 2014); Re Levy (No 2) [1957] VLR 662; Banks v Goodfellow (1869-70) LR 5 QB 549; Timbury v Coffee (1941) 66 CLR 277; Re Estate of Griffith; Easter v Griffith (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Santow J, 17 June 1994); Murphy v Lorenzi (Unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Bryson J, 21 October 1996), considered.

SPOEHR v HEALTH SERVICES CHARITABLE GIFTS BOARD
[2014] SASC 171

Civil

GRAY J.

  1. This is an application for judgment by consent pursuant to rule 227 of the Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 2006 (SA) that the Court pronounce against the force and validity of the alleged will…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spoehr v Health Services Charitable Gifts Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Spoehr v Health Services Charitable Gifts Board, the deceased, who passed away on 2 June 2012, left behind an alleged will dated 28 September 2001. The will bequeathed his entire estate to his wife, contingent upon her surviving him by 28 days, or to the Royal Adelaide Hospital Research Fund if she did not survive. The plaintiff, Adriana Spoehr, one of the deceased's three children, sought to have the will declared invalid on the basis that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of its creation. The Health Services Charitable Gifts Board, as the intended beneficiary under the will, opposed the application. The central legal issue was whether the deceased had the requisite testamentary capacity when he executed the will, considering his soundness of mind, memory, and understanding. The court had to determine whether the evidence presented suggested that the deceased had the necessary capacity to understand the nature of making a will and the effect of its provisions.

The court considered the onus and weight of evidence, noting that Adriana Spoehr provided affidavits from herself, her brother, a niece, and other family acquaintances, which collectively painted a picture of the deceased as a strict and violent man who had influenced the lives of his children significantly. The court also acknowledged that no evidence was presented by any party to counter Adriana's claims, including the Board which stood to benefit from the will. Given this lack of countervailing evidence and the circumstances that suggested the deceased might have lacked testamentary capacity, the court concluded that there were sufficient grounds to doubt the validity of the will. Consequently, the court ordered that the will be pronounced invalid, thereby leaving the estate to be distributed according to the laws of intestacy, with the agreed settlement terms providing for the distribution of the estate among the deceased's children and his granddaughter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Circumstances exist to excite suspicion that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of the execution of the will. No party has come forward to tender any evidence or make any submission that the deceased did in fact have capacity at the relevant time. In these circumstances, it is appropriate to make an order pronouncing against the validity of the will.

2. The granddaughter’s interests are adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 August 2014, I made orders in the terms sought by the plaintiff and indicated that I would publish reasons for my decision at a later date. Background The deceased died on 2 June 2012, his wife having predeceased him on 1 September 2006. The deceased is survived by three children, Rosa Adriana Spoehr, known as Adriana, the plaintiff in the present proceedings, Aloisa Rita Kotsiou and Gateano Franco Castiglione. The only known testamentary instrument of the deceased was an alleged will dated 28 September 2001. Under the terms of the alleged will, the deceased gave the whole of his estate to his wife provided that she survived him by 28 days and, in the event that she did not, gave the whole of his estate to the Royal Adelaide Hospital Research Fund for the purpose of research. Pursuant to the Health Services Charitable Gifts Act 2011 (SA), a testamentary bequest to the Royal Adelaide Hospital Research Fund vests in the Health Services Charitable Gifts Board. On 14 December 2012, Adriana Spoehr commenced an action seeking a grant of letters of administration in relation to the deceased’s estate on the ground that, at the time that the deceased purportedly made the alleged will, he lacked testamentary capacity and therefore died intestate. The Board was named as the defendant. By deed dated 5 May 2014, the parties agreed to settle the action on terms, inter alia, that Adriana Spoehr seek an order pronouncing against the alleged will and, if successful, subsequently seek a grant of letters of administration of the deceased’s estate. The terms of the settlement were that the defendant would receive the sum of $200,000.00, the deceased’s granddaughter, Rebecca Spoehr, would receive the sum of $85,000.00 to be held on trust for her by her parents, and the remainder of the estate would be divided equally between the deceased’s three children. The Court was informed that the net value of the estate following the payment of legal expenses was approximately $1,800,000.00. The deceased’s children, who would be the only persons entitled to benefit were the deceased’s estate to be administered in accordance with the laws of intestacy, each consented to the orders sought. The Board, the sole beneficiary under the alleged will, also consented to the orders sought. Rebecca Spoehr is under a disability such that it is necessary to obtain court approval for the settlement of her proposed family provision application. On the hearing of the application, the plaintiff tendered a number of affidavits, including affidavits of: Elizabeth Burke, the solicitor for the plaintiff; Adriana Spoehr and Gateano Castiglione; Rachel Sarah Wilson, the granddaughter of the deceased; Kevin Spoehr, the son in law of the deceased; and Mira Knezevic, an acquaintance of the deceased’s family. The Application to Pronounce Against the Validity of the Deceased’s WillFacts Adriana Spoehr deposed that the deceased was born in Italy in 1930. She said that the deceased was a strict and violent man. Adriana was made to work hard from a young age and was responsible for looking after her younger siblings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
Issues
1. Was the deceased of sound mind, memory, and understanding at the time of executing the alleged will dated 28 September 2001?
2. Did the circumstances presented in the case create a suspicion that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of executing the alleged will?
3. Was there sufficient evidence to rebut the suspicion of the deceased’s lack of testamentary capacity at the time of executing the alleged will?
4. Should the court pronounce against the validity of the alleged will dated 28 September 2001 based on the presented evidence and lack of rebuttal from the defendant?
5. Are the interests of the deceased’s granddaughter, Rebecca Spoehr, adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement?

Held
1. The court concluded that the deceased was of sound mind, memory, and understanding at the time of executing the alleged will dated 28 September 2001 was not addressed in the decision.
2. The court held that circumstances did exist to excite suspicion that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity at the time of executing the alleged will. The result was that the suspicion was acknowledged.
3. The court concluded that there was no sufficient evidence presented to rebut the suspicion of the deceased’s lack of testamentary capacity at the time of executing the alleged will. The result was that the suspicion was not rebutted.
4. The court held that the court should pronounce against the validity of the alleged will dated 28 September 2001 based on the presented evidence and lack of rebuttal from the defendant. The result was that the will was declared invalid.
5. The court held that the interests of the deceased’s granddaughter, Rebecca Spoehr, were adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement. The result was that the settlement was approved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

The court began its analysis by examining the issue of whether the deceased had the requisite testamentary capacity at the time he executed the alleged will dated 28 September 2001. The court noted that testamentary capacity requires a person to understand the nature of making a will, comprehend the extent of their property, and know the beneficiaries, as well as the effect of the dispositions. The court considered the affidavits and other evidence presented, which suggested that the deceased's mental health had been declining, particularly around the time of the will's execution. The court found that there was a suspicion that the deceased lacked the soundness of mind, memory, and understanding necessary to execute a valid will, which created a prima facie case that he lacked testamentary capacity.

The court then addressed whether the circumstances presented in the case indeed created a suspicion that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity. In doing so, the court relied on the evidence provided by the plaintiff's affidavits, which included statements from family members and acquaintances about the deceased's mental state. The court accepted that the deceased's declining health, particularly his episodes of confusion and memory loss, raised a reasonable suspicion that he did not possess the necessary mental faculties to execute a valid will. The court acknowledged that while there was no direct evidence of the deceased's state of mind at the time of the will's execution, the circumstantial evidence was sufficient to create a suspicion.

Further, the court examined whether there was sufficient evidence to rebut the suspicion of the deceased's lack of testamentary capacity. The court noted that neither the defendant nor any other party had provided evidence to counter the suspicion raised by the affidavits. The court held that the onus was on the party asserting the validity of the will to prove testamentary capacity, and in this case, the defendant had not provided any evidence to rebut the suspicion of incapacity. The court thus found that the suspicion of incapacity remained unrebutted.

The court proceeded to consider whether it should pronounce against the validity of the alleged will dated 28 September 2001 based on the presented evidence and the lack of rebuttal from the defendant. Given that the court had found a suspicion of the deceased's lack of testamentary capacity and that this suspicion was not rebutted, the court held that it was appropriate to pronounce against the validity of the will. The court emphasised that the onus of proving testamentary capacity falls on the party asserting the validity of the will, and in this instance, the defendant had failed to meet this burden.

Finally, the court examined whether the interests of the deceased’s granddaughter, Rebecca Spoehr, were adequately protected by the terms of the agreed settlement. The court noted that under the settlement, Rebecca would receive a specific sum to be held in trust for her by her parents, and the remainder of the estate would be divided equally among the deceased's three children. The court found that this arrangement provided sufficient protection for Rebecca's interests, given that her parents had consented to the terms and that she would benefit from a guaranteed portion of the estate. The court thus concluded that the settlement adequately protected Rebecca's interests.

In summary, the court's reasoning led to the conclusion that the circumstances raised a suspicion of the deceased's lack of testamentary capacity, which was not rebutted, warranting the pronouncement against the will's validity. The court's ratio decidendi includes the principle that where there is a suspicion of a testator's lack of testamentary capacity, and no evidence is presented to rebut that suspicion, the court will pronounce against the validity of the will. Additionally, the court established that the interests of a disabled beneficiary can be adequately protected through a court-approved settlement agreement.